Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell DH that MIL has got me a Christmas present i will have to get rid of?

282 replies

haribosmarties · 25/11/2023 14:48

Or does that seem ungrateful? Its only a low cost item. Should I just pretend to like it?
DH told me the ILs were asking about gifts for us so I told him a brand of toiletries I like of which you can buy various gift sets between a tenner and twenty quid.
I borrowed DH phone whilst we were out and as I was using it a txt message came in from MIL saying she had forgotten what he'd said and just bought a Dove body set for me and would that be ok?
I handed back the phone to my DH without mentioning seeing the message.
Issue is I have eczema and altho its not severe it does flair up with random things.. Dove shower cream, soap and body wash are amongst those things. Ive tried using them before.

So now I dont know whether just to pretend to like the gift when I open it or to tell my DH that I saw the text and its not suitable.
I know these seems like a petty issue but my relationship with MIL has never been great... I mean we've never actively fallen out... but basically she doesnt like me anyway I can tell, and we have very little to do with each other.. I get the sense she thinks I'm high maintenance.. saying something about this gift might add to that.
My DH won't have any advice, he'd probably just tell her to change the gift because interpersonal dynamics go over his head quite often unless people are actively shouting at each other. He also hasnt mentioned the text to me which makes me think he's just replied 'that's fine' and forgotten about it

YANBU= just tell your husband to answer the text saying its not ok and she should change it for something else

YABU = dont say anything. It doesnt really matter, just give it away to someone.

Yes I know I probably should have said something as soon as I saw the text but I just didn't. I struggle with being thought of as difficult so my first response to anything like that is to freeze and then think about it carefully.

OP posts:
DoIReallyNeedToDoThis · 26/11/2023 18:47

This sort of thing is why we stopped doing presents.

PIL would spend about £20 or stuff that went straight from the car to the charity shop. I suggested only edible gifts the next year, got stuff I couldn’t eat (vegetarian). So then suggested we just stop because it’s a waste of money to buy stuff that the recipient can’t use.

It’s been a blissful 15 years.

Hadenough2021 · 26/11/2023 18:41

Blimey. I think you need a hobby.

pollymere · 26/11/2023 18:40

You will get one every. Single. Year. If you accept it as is. Your DH or you on his phone need to say "Oh no! Unfortunately Dove brings her out in a really nasty rash 😞. Her favourite is [...]. Sorry I should have told you in a text. Hope it's not too late to exchange it."

Gettingolderandgrumpier60 · 26/11/2023 18:36

My MIL bought me Eternity perfume every year (despite the fact I told her I didn’t like it, I had when I was 18). I just kept donating it to raffles etc.

Middleagedspreadisreal · 26/11/2023 18:30

If you liked your MIL & got on with her, what would you do?

AmazingSnakeHead · 26/11/2023 18:04

Smile, thank, straight to charity.

SqueakyRadish · 26/11/2023 17:55

Surprised so many people are saying let it go.

I would agree with that if it was a case of just being given it. But in this case the MIL has literally asked if it'll be ok!?

I would mention that the text came through,
So all he has to do is say "hi mum, unfortunately Dove really aggravates DWs skin. She is fine with X,y,z"

dcthatsme · 26/11/2023 17:45

Really not worth falling out / offending someone over a crappy gift. They keep charity shops going.

melj1213 · 26/11/2023 14:19

Needmorelego · 26/11/2023 12:40

Out of curiosity....
If all those "just smile and say thanks and then pass on" people found out that whatever gift they gave to their MIL is just dumped in a charity shop pile minutes after being given - wouldn't you all be just a little bit miffed?
Your money and the time you spent shopping just discarded in seconds.
That's why in my family we do wish lists - and they get followed.
I find this all ironic as Mumsnet is full of the "I hate pointless tat" people.
No wonder the world is drowning in "stuff".

Not only that but the MiL has asked ahead of time to check it's OK ... So there was an opportunity (that the OPs DH has taken) to say "Sorry that's not going to work"

She may not have worded it perfectly but the fact that MiL was messaging her son to make sure the item she bought was suitable shows she has at least some concern for wanting to get something the OP could use.

I am all for "smile and accept an unwanted gift graciously" in the moment of recieving said gift but I don't understand the people who have an opportunity to prevent an issue ahead of time but choose not to take it ... Why?

Surely it is better to be honest and get something you actually need/want/can use than just smile and say nothing, knowing the other person is wasting their money on something you will never use? How hurt would you feel if you found out that half the people you buy gifts for just open them, smile, say thanks and then "chuck it on a pile to donate"? I would definitely stop buying people gifts if they weren't being appreciated, whether it cost £5 or £500, it's the thought, meaning and intention behind it that counts and the OPs MIL clearly wants to get something she will use, or she wouldn't have bothered to check with the OPs DH, she'd have just bought it regardless.

If I want to donate to charity I do so to charities I choose to support and in addition to buying gifts for family/friends. If you're just going to donate the gift I buy you then I'd rather you say up front and I'll just save the time, money and effort of buying something and instead add that money to my own donations.

Needmorelego · 26/11/2023 12:40

Out of curiosity....
If all those "just smile and say thanks and then pass on" people found out that whatever gift they gave to their MIL is just dumped in a charity shop pile minutes after being given - wouldn't you all be just a little bit miffed?
Your money and the time you spent shopping just discarded in seconds.
That's why in my family we do wish lists - and they get followed.
I find this all ironic as Mumsnet is full of the "I hate pointless tat" people.
No wonder the world is drowning in "stuff".

TheChosenTwo · 26/11/2023 12:33

Accept, smile, say thanks, chuck in a pile to donate to someone who can make use of it/leave out at the end of the drive for someone to take/put in the box of donations at the supermarket etc etc.
It’s a cheap gift set, it’s not like mil has wasted hundreds of pounds on something and missed the mark.

Needmorelego · 26/11/2023 12:31

@Anon0mum the husband has already spoken to his mother apparently.

Anon0mum · 26/11/2023 12:29

I would accept the gift and say thank you. I would then have a conversation with DH afterwards and say “I didn’t want to be rude but I can’t use this, because of my skin. So what I’m going to is donate it so it doesn’t go to waste.”
Then either drop it into conversation later on that it causes a flare up or get DH to tell
her at some point you can’t use xx

stitchinguru · 26/11/2023 12:23

@Needmorelego
Exactly that - I can’t believe how many people have joined the Dovegate debate…
It really beggars belief.

Needmorelego · 26/11/2023 12:20

@stitchinguru sorry for your loss 💐
I understand Christmas must be incredibly hard for you.
But I think it's everyone else that's making it a big issue.
It takes one simple sentence to the MIL so she isn't wasting her money.

stitchinguru · 26/11/2023 12:16

@Needmorelego @OhNoOhNo
Please…. Stop trying to justify the need to make this a big issue - It’s a toiletry set, FFS!
It’s SO trivial. Unwrap, smile, give it away. Simple.
Apologies, but I lost my eldest son aged 24 on Christmas Day 2019 to Sudden Adult Death Syndrome. I have absolutely zero patience for this kind of ridiculous selfishness!

MyDHhasADHD · 26/11/2023 11:43

I think this might be related to cost? A dove gift set is significantly cheaper than a body shop one. Maybe the mil didn't want to spend that much on op's gift?

I would accept it this year of she's already bought it & next year if she asks your dh again choose something you're not allergic to - vouchers sound perfect

VimtoVimto · 26/11/2023 11:38

To be fair to your MIL I’ve been in two branches of Bodyshop in the last week trying to get a specific gift set I’d seen online and both of them had sold out.

zingally · 26/11/2023 11:08

I think, unless someone has actually expressed an enjoyment for a particular brand, those sorts of body sets are token gifts designed for people to give to others, who they either don't know very well, or feel like they have to give "something".
They are of the "mindless but better than nothing" variety.

Frankly, it's not worth the agro of speaking up about it. Smile and say thank you, then re-gift/donate at the earliest opportunity. And mentally knock her down a similar amount with the amount of care/effort you put into her gifts. I did it some years ago with my BIL and it's intensely freeing.
He always made a fuss about presents, never giving any idea what he wanted, and saying "just get me something you think I'll like". So one year I got him a gift certificate to a new steak restaurant in town. He looked at it, sneered, and said "I don't want to do that" and gave it back to me!
Since then he gets the token wall calendar and some chocolates. He pulls a 6 figure salary, and I do well to pull 30k. I figure he can bog all the way off.

Needmorelego · 26/11/2023 10:01

@clpsmum @Zanatdy if you read a few posts up you will see the OPs husband has spoken to his mother. Issue is probably solved. MIL probably said "oh thanks for letting me know".
Why do people keep thinking this would be "drama"?
I would have thought a simple telling someone BEFORE this gift is given that it's unsuitable is considerably less "drama" than an awkward moment when you are dropping the unsuitable gift off at a charity shop or wherever and you bump into MIL there.
If I was the MIL I would be more annoyed that no one bothered to tell me it's unsuitable.
How much money, time and products are wasted every year because people keep being so polite and doing the "smile and wave" act rather than just opening their mouths and speaking.

Zanatdy · 26/11/2023 09:31

I’d just act grateful and regift. Definitely not worth any drama

clpsmum · 26/11/2023 09:26

Laiste · 25/11/2023 14:50

It's not worth the agro. Just unwrap it and say thanks and then re-gift it.

This

Needmorelego · 26/11/2023 09:00

@stitchinguru it's not about it being "cheap" Dove products - the OP can't use it due to her eczema. MIL could have bought some hand crafted by fairies toiletries containing unicorn tears from Harrods - they would still be unsuitable if they cause skin problems.
@haribosmarties glad to hear your husband spoke to her.
I really don't understand all this just "smile and be grateful" nonsense when all it takes is just talking to each other and being honest.

OhNoOhNo · 26/11/2023 06:26

stitchinguru · 26/11/2023 02:52

Could someone PLEASE explain to me why a Dove gift set has generated so much interest???
That’s the biggest issue in all this!

Maybe because MIL was told Body Shop stuff and instead bought a Dove set that costs £3.25. I have the set, I like it, but it’s not what OP has asked for.

JMSA · 26/11/2023 05:18

So many petty responses on here.

I'd have just asked your husband to type back that you're allergic. It's absolutely no big deal.

Swipe left for the next trending thread