Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To object to this punishment ?

111 replies

School99 · 25/11/2023 13:22

My son is doing his GCSEs at local secondary school. They give lunchtime / break time / afterschool detentions for misbehaviour (ranging from not wearing a tie to constantly talking /disrupting class) which I support.
They also do a thing called internal exclusion which is where pupil has to sit in a different room all day with no lessons and nothing to do. My son has been told he has to do this on Monday for what I think is not a serious offence. Apart from thinking the punishment is not appropriate for the crime, I actually think this punishment is not at all appropriate in any circumstances- surely missing out on lessons when doing GCSEs is just setting them up to fail ? How is that teaching them to behave according to the school rules ?? I would object less if they were isolated but got their normal work given to them but they don’t even do that. I’m not really happy about the punishment - is this standard across all secondary schools ? I’m thinking of contacting the school to voice my views/objections but not sure if there’s any point ??

OP posts:
FloralScented · 25/11/2023 13:56

surely missing out on lessons when doing GCSEs is just setting them up to fail ? but this impacts him so he learns not to do whatever it was he did. Just because you don't consider what he did to be serious doesn't mean he didn't break the school rules. You can't just be punished for fun so what exactly did he do?

He is in his 5th year of being at the school. He knows the rules, he broke them, he gets punished. I know when Ds was in year 11 those put in isolation were allowed to look at their revision stuff. Ds was glad when people were put in isolation because it meant his teacher could actually teach instead of doing behaviour management.

cardibach · 25/11/2023 13:54

What was the offence? You say you do think it’s serious but don’t say what it is. Is that because you think it actually was reasonably serious?
He’ll be given stuff to do. It probably won’t be what his class are doing because that needs the teacher, but revision or some reading on the topic they are covering. Depending on the offence it may be work around that and the causes of it. Apart from anything else supervising teenagers with literally nothing to do would be a nightmare. School wouldn’t do that to its staff…

Seashor · 25/11/2023 13:50

What he has told you he has done and what he has done will be poles apart.
He committed the crime and this the consequence, he knew that it would be. He needs to suck it up, lesson learnt.

clary · 25/11/2023 13:45

Yeh I imagine he will be given work to do. This used to happen where I taught. We would be asked for work for anyone in inclusion. Not always easy to offer something appropriate tho (as the lesson needs them to be there IYSWIM). But I would at very least send a text book and some revision work. They never did it tho.

What did he do OP? tbh it must be something reasonably serious. In my old school it would be for swearing at a teacher, that kind of thing.

Summerbay23 · 25/11/2023 13:44

I suppose it depends on what he did? If it was disrupting the class then I think it’s right that he’s pulled out for his punishment (why should the other kids be disrupted?). If it was a uniform violation then possibly a lunchtime detention is more appropriate.

if it’s about the work I would just gently inquire as to what he’s being asked to do.

TheresaCrowd · 25/11/2023 13:38

I don't believe they give them nothing to do so they're just sitting there twiddling their thumbs.

They probably won't be given anything special as why should the teacher be put out?

But they'll definitely have books etc.

NunsKnickers · 25/11/2023 13:37

What did he do?

Octavia64 · 25/11/2023 13:36

Internal exclusion/isolation is standard at secondary schools.

Most schools give it for either a serious incident or refusal to attend previous punishments eg detention.

madnessitellyou · 25/11/2023 13:33

He will get work to do but no, it might not be his 'normal' work. In my school we give out generic work for isolation or we'd be having to essentially plan a whole other lesson for a child who can't meet expectations. Where does "not a very serious offence" start and end?

It's not ideal for a y11 to miss classes, but maybe this'll be an absolute one-off.

Lilylula · 25/11/2023 13:28

I think you'll find he is given work but doesn't do it on his own.

You may feel the sanction is disproportionate but perhaps he is undermining the learning of other children?

I would work with the school, not against them.

TeenDivided · 25/11/2023 13:26

Not giving work to do sounds crazy to me. Are you sure??