Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To object to this punishment ?

111 replies

School99 · 25/11/2023 13:22

My son is doing his GCSEs at local secondary school. They give lunchtime / break time / afterschool detentions for misbehaviour (ranging from not wearing a tie to constantly talking /disrupting class) which I support.
They also do a thing called internal exclusion which is where pupil has to sit in a different room all day with no lessons and nothing to do. My son has been told he has to do this on Monday for what I think is not a serious offence. Apart from thinking the punishment is not appropriate for the crime, I actually think this punishment is not at all appropriate in any circumstances- surely missing out on lessons when doing GCSEs is just setting them up to fail ? How is that teaching them to behave according to the school rules ?? I would object less if they were isolated but got their normal work given to them but they don’t even do that. I’m not really happy about the punishment - is this standard across all secondary schools ? I’m thinking of contacting the school to voice my views/objections but not sure if there’s any point ??

OP posts:
Cosyblankets · 26/11/2023 07:22

PegasusReturns · 26/11/2023 07:12

I’d be asking what work he is going to be set and is there an opportunity to catch up on the lessons he will miss

I'd he asking him to behave

Usernamechange1234 · 26/11/2023 07:18

I’d support the school and pull your child up for his poor behaviour that led to a quite serious consequence. Honestly, you will be doing him a favour supporting the school in teaching your child that actions have consequences.

menopausalmare · 26/11/2023 07:16

Internal inclusion is an alternative to exclusion and is standard in schools.
Work is provided and they work in silence away from the other students. Some schools stagger inclusion from 1-7pm which students dislike.
It sends a strong message that bullying/ swearing/ rudeness/ truancy/ dodging detentions/ vaping is not tolerated.
Whatever your child did, the school deem inclusion necessary.
Support the school , don't undermine them.

PegasusReturns · 26/11/2023 07:12

I’d be asking what work he is going to be set and is there an opportunity to catch up on the lessons he will miss

LolaSmiles · 26/11/2023 07:10

It might be that the final incident wasn't a serious issue, but it's part of a pattern of issues.

I know a few schools will use internal exclusion for repeated patterns of behaviour that disrupt learning because it's still persistent disruption.

Or a student ends up in internal isolation not for the original issue, but for the events that followed. For example, the student does something that's outside expectations, the teacher challenges it, but instead of doing what they should, the student argues back, refuses to follow instructions, disrupts the class. They aren't in internal exclusion for the first issue. They're in there for the defiance and disruptive behaviour that followed.

It would be interesting to find out what the behaviour was.

spanieleyes · 26/11/2023 07:01

Rather than object to the punishment, try objecting to the behaviours.

Mumofoneandone · 25/11/2023 15:18

Check the school discipline policy to gain some extra info. Maybe contact the school to find out what has really led to the exclusion.
Really need to support the school.....

dizzydizzydizzy · 25/11/2023 15:10

Yes, you are probably being U. as PPs have said, in most secondary schools this is for more serious issues. The school almost certainly has a clear policy on sanctions. Without knowing the nature of your son's misdemeanor, it's impossible to say for sure whether it's fair or not.

Daphnis156 · 25/11/2023 15:00

Your child did not follow rules and is being sanctioned.
Unless there is some serious misconduct by the teachers, you need not be involved; in addition your child may be lying to you about what the offence was.
You might have a better influence by punishing the child yourself in addition to the school, then you could set a task and see it was completed.

caringcarer · 25/11/2023 15:00

He could take in his Science text books and read them and make a few revision cards. No teacher would say stop working on Science GCSE'S to sit doing nothing.

alfagirl73 · 25/11/2023 14:51

I would assume he would at least be allowed to read/revise - so if no other work is given, I would encourage him to use it as focused revision time. Assuming he has books/access to materials related to the subjects he is studying, he could also read ahead - it may be that he quickly grasps whatever concepts/topics were to be covered in the lessons he will miss - perhaps make notes so he can research the topics himself. At least then when he returns to class he may only have to ask a few questions to fill in the gaps. I don't know what he's alleged to have done but I would've thought at the very least, any decent teachers would likely be impressed if he used the time like that and used his own initiative/motivation to minimise the educational impact of the isolation period. Also an opportunity to develop self-study/research skills.

Badgrief · 25/11/2023 14:49

Maybe voice your concerns to your son and support the school. How much work do you think it would be (and who should do it) to get the lessons from each of the teachers he should have on Monday? Part of his punishment is catching up on the work he will miss! That is his responsibility. Supervising children in detention or internal isolation is a pain for teachers.

Cherrysoup · 25/11/2023 14:48

It’s a legal obligation to give work for external exclusion, not sure about internal. I’m sure he’ll be given work, probably textbook/worksheets.

How about you teach your ds to behave rather than complain about a standard school punishment? One of mine was caught smoking in the toilets and was-rightfully, imo-internally excluded recently. Awful example to the younger kids who share bathroom facilities.

ttcat37 · 25/11/2023 14:44

Impossible to comment without knowing what he’s actually done to get the punishment

dapsnotplimsolls · 25/11/2023 14:44

FloofCloud · 25/11/2023 14:41

Some school rules are stupid but need to know what he did

I'll be amazed if we find out.

FloofCloud · 25/11/2023 14:41

Some school rules are stupid but need to know what he did

BreadBag · 25/11/2023 14:35

dapsnotplimsolls · 25/11/2023 14:26

He can revise.

It's a pain in the arse setting work for kids who are working in isolation - they can rarely do the same tasks as the rest of the class.

I've got a folder full of independent tasks linked to topics (Collected over time) for the specific purpose.
I just pull one out and send it over, if I don't have anything when I put something together I pop it in the folder I also have one with lessons I've left for cover teachers which are often also suitable. It's been a real time saver.
Edited for clarity.

dapsnotplimsolls · 25/11/2023 14:26

He can revise.

It's a pain in the arse setting work for kids who are working in isolation - they can rarely do the same tasks as the rest of the class.

LIZS · 25/11/2023 14:18

Why do you think it is minor? He can spend the time going over last week's lesson and revising.

Bluevelvetsofa · 25/11/2023 14:17

Yes, it is normal in secondary schools to have a day’s isolation as a punishment.
Yes, work is set, although whether it’s done is a different matter.
Yes, it is a shame that he’s missing lessons in his GCSE year. Do you think he will consider his actions in the future and avoid this sanction?

No one here can say whether the sanction is appropriate, since you haven’t said what happened to cause it. However, it isn’t done lightly, so I’d guess that there had been previous sanctions, or your son had ignored attempts to moderate his behaviour.

By all means voice your objections. You might find out exactly what happened. You might not like it though.

MrMucker · 25/11/2023 14:14

There was an ofsted report published this last week about how parents are increasingly willing to challenge school rules, and it was impressed on parents to remember that they themselves sign up to a schools' policies.
Whatever it is he has done wrong, you shouldn't be questioning the punishment in terms of whether it's a good one, you should be looking at the school policy and seeing if they've breeched it.
In the case of an internal exclusion, in my experience it's not something that's just pulled out of a hat, and is always heavily documented in terms of "why". I fear if you challenge the internal exclusion you'll end up embarrassed .

Instead you should be challenging your child on whatever it is they did.

TheresaCrowd · 25/11/2023 14:05

unvillage · 25/11/2023 13:59

What did he do?

I'm loving how the OP tells us all they don't think it's a serious offence, but omitted what it was from the opening post 🤣🤣

BreadBag · 25/11/2023 14:00

Yeah, that's not how it works.
I'm a teacher we set work as close to the class lesson as possible but not necessarily the same for internal exclusions. This also applies to first 5 days of external exclusion, including permanent exclusion. This is a legal requirement.
Most often the children who have been given these consequences do not engage with that work. Hence the expectation amongst them that no work is set/done.

unvillage · 25/11/2023 13:59

What did he do?

Octavia64 · 25/11/2023 13:58

Most schools have work available in isolation - textbooks etc.

In some cases the teacher will be asked to provide work, sometimes students will do coursework/reversion etc depending on how old they are/where they are in their gcse courses

He will have stuff to do,

Being out of lessons is the point,