Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To object to this punishment ?

111 replies

School99 · 25/11/2023 13:22

My son is doing his GCSEs at local secondary school. They give lunchtime / break time / afterschool detentions for misbehaviour (ranging from not wearing a tie to constantly talking /disrupting class) which I support.
They also do a thing called internal exclusion which is where pupil has to sit in a different room all day with no lessons and nothing to do. My son has been told he has to do this on Monday for what I think is not a serious offence. Apart from thinking the punishment is not appropriate for the crime, I actually think this punishment is not at all appropriate in any circumstances- surely missing out on lessons when doing GCSEs is just setting them up to fail ? How is that teaching them to behave according to the school rules ?? I would object less if they were isolated but got their normal work given to them but they don’t even do that. I’m not really happy about the punishment - is this standard across all secondary schools ? I’m thinking of contacting the school to voice my views/objections but not sure if there’s any point ??

OP posts:
GettinChillyHereFFS · 26/11/2023 09:31

EarringsandLipstick · 26/11/2023 09:12

It works because it takes disruptive pupils out of the classroom.

But it doesn't, presumably, address the behaviour of the disruptive child?

I'm obviously not familiar with the situations and not meaning to be argumentative. I assume we have similarly disruptive children in Ireland (I haven't come across it in my DC's schools or heard about it but assume it happens, obviously) and perhaps this is used & I haven't heard about it.

I just am concerned about isolating an already challenging student - how does it address the behavioural issues?

It doesn't. Reading this thread, I remember getting this as punishment. It was just an inconvenience, did nothing for my behaviour. We thought it was funny. People would get hall passes and come and see you.

EarringsandLipstick · 26/11/2023 09:30

menopausalmare · 26/11/2023 09:28

EarringsandLipstick, if your child was on the receiving end of bullying I think you'd be pretty quick to support inclusion.

Except a PP's example is not anything to do with bullying?

If bullying was involved it's exclusion I'd seek, rather than this practice.

Longma · 26/11/2023 09:30

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

Passepartoute · 26/11/2023 09:30

There are now some quite strict rules around the use of removal or isolation which many schools don't follow - https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/651d42d86a6955001278b2af/Behaviour_in_schools_guidance.pdf

Have a look and ask some detailed questions about what they are doing to comply, including asking for copies of the relevant statistics.

EarringsandLipstick · 26/11/2023 09:29

DD3's school have a 2-strike policy on low level disruption. Their name is written on the board if they are disruptive (including dropping pens, rocking on chairs, etc) then Hubbed after that.

Thanks for explaining the system.

That's awful. When PP spoke of disruption I expected it on a much more significant level and understood.

This is annoying behaviour of course - in my DC's school this merits 'points' on their online system that parents can see. Most parents check this & don't like seeing the 'points' & address with their DC.

The school will follow up with further consequences if it continues, including contacting the parents.

I cannot see how a day in silence, in solitary conditions, addresses this kind of behaviour.

Most likely the kids who engage in low-level disruption will respond poorly, rather than with maturity or a depth of understanding, to this punishment.

menopausalmare · 26/11/2023 09:28

EarringsandLipstick, if your child was on the receiving end of bullying I think you'd be pretty quick to support inclusion.

Lougle · 26/11/2023 09:18

In DD3's school it's called the 'hub'. 'Hubbed' students are contained in a static unit and copy text from random textbooks. They sit in silence and are not allowed to look at other students. They are escorted for their lunch after other pupils have returned from lunch to their classes.

A hub period is one full day. So if they are given a red card in period 5, they would spend period 5,6 of the first day and periods 1,2,3,4 of the following day in the hub.

DD3's school have a 2-strike policy on low level disruption. Their name is written on the board if they are disruptive (including dropping pens, rocking on chairs, etc) then Hubbed after that.

I'm not sure that it's effective. I am regularly at the school and see at least 15-20 kids with red cards at registration time. They have an R&R space for the kids who are too disruptive for 'don't cope' with the hub and they are often mixed with the kids who can't cope with classes and aren't disruptive. It makes kids with SEN very uncomfortable and they often end up refusing to go there.

FloralScented · 26/11/2023 09:17

@School99 what did he say he did? Did he tell you or school tell you? Just interested to know what is considered not serious.

ACynicalDad · 26/11/2023 09:17

If it was really minor I expect you would have said what the issue was. It can also be the straw that breaks the camels' back. If you think he's being treated unfairly ask them for a meeting and maybe to wait until the meeting before the punishment is carried out. But if he's been bad you do him more favours backing school up. Remember you are only hearing his side. And if he is a prat in class and isn't focusing a day out of class and you backing school up may make the rest of his GCSE course way more effective than it might have otherwise been if he keeps behaving badly, even at a low level. If he is disrupting other's learning even more reason to keep him out of class for a day.

feathermucker · 26/11/2023 09:15

Of course he'll be doing work.

What was the offence that you don't agree that this is an appropriate punishment for?

Maxus · 26/11/2023 09:15

EarringsandLipstick · 26/11/2023 09:12

It works because it takes disruptive pupils out of the classroom.

But it doesn't, presumably, address the behaviour of the disruptive child?

I'm obviously not familiar with the situations and not meaning to be argumentative. I assume we have similarly disruptive children in Ireland (I haven't come across it in my DC's schools or heard about it but assume it happens, obviously) and perhaps this is used & I haven't heard about it.

I just am concerned about isolating an already challenging student - how does it address the behavioural issues?

As I said before between years 7-10 kids get all the guidance they kids concerning disruptive behaviour, if they are still disruptive by year 11 the teachers quiet rightly need them removing so they can concentrate on the rest of the class.

EarringsandLipstick · 26/11/2023 09:13

@Maxus

I suppose that's fair enough. Sad to hear.

It must happen here but I wonder if to a less extent?

EarringsandLipstick · 26/11/2023 09:12

It works because it takes disruptive pupils out of the classroom.

But it doesn't, presumably, address the behaviour of the disruptive child?

I'm obviously not familiar with the situations and not meaning to be argumentative. I assume we have similarly disruptive children in Ireland (I haven't come across it in my DC's schools or heard about it but assume it happens, obviously) and perhaps this is used & I haven't heard about it.

I just am concerned about isolating an already challenging student - how does it address the behavioural issues?

Maxus · 26/11/2023 09:11

EarringsandLipstick · 26/11/2023 09:07

There would be the usual sanctions of detention, meeting with parents, suspension ultimately.

There's challenging behaviour in Irish schools of course, but the idea of isolating students is not considered suitable.

I see the point about the break for others but it seems really counter-intuitive in terms of addressing the actual issues.

Most of the disruptive kids in my child's school have had between years 7-10 have had many interventions and guidance around their behaviour, I'm sorry but if they don't get it by year 11 the rest of the class has to come first

EdithStourton · 26/11/2023 09:09

Intelligenthair · 26/11/2023 09:04

I think it’s really bad that he’s missing lessons in Y11 due to his poor behaviour, but it’s him I’d be reading the riot act to, not the school.

Absolutely.
I work in a school and parents who constantly second guess what is going on, complain when their child is sanctioned and so on do not help anyone - including their child.

Yes, if you have a one-off issue, speak to the teacher or the head, but usually if little Johnny misses break or is put in detention there is a good reason for it.

Maxus · 26/11/2023 09:08

EarringsandLipstick · 26/11/2023 08:58

Once again, I'm so glad that the disciplinary processes that are used in the UK are not used in Ireland.

I don't agree that there's any useful purpose served by a student sitting in isolation, with work to do or not (and I agree with PP that there is likely work given).

I wonder if there's any evidence that this is a successful approach to remedying behavioural issues?

It works because it takes disruptive pupils out of the classroom. By year 11 the majority of kids just want to get their heads down at get good grades. Why should they be prevented to do this by one disruptive pupil eating up all the teachers time?

EarringsandLipstick · 26/11/2023 09:07

Intelligenthair · 26/11/2023 09:04

I think it’s really bad that he’s missing lessons in Y11 due to his poor behaviour, but it’s him I’d be reading the riot act to, not the school.

Yes, of course this

EarringsandLipstick · 26/11/2023 09:07

There would be the usual sanctions of detention, meeting with parents, suspension ultimately.

There's challenging behaviour in Irish schools of course, but the idea of isolating students is not considered suitable.

I see the point about the break for others but it seems really counter-intuitive in terms of addressing the actual issues.

Intelligenthair · 26/11/2023 09:04

I think it’s really bad that he’s missing lessons in Y11 due to his poor behaviour, but it’s him I’d be reading the riot act to, not the school.

spanieleyes · 26/11/2023 09:03

There may not be but at least it gives the other pupils, and staff, a break!

TeenDivided · 26/11/2023 09:03

EarringsandLipstick · 26/11/2023 08:58

Once again, I'm so glad that the disciplinary processes that are used in the UK are not used in Ireland.

I don't agree that there's any useful purpose served by a student sitting in isolation, with work to do or not (and I agree with PP that there is likely work given).

I wonder if there's any evidence that this is a successful approach to remedying behavioural issues?

It serves a useful purpose of getting a disruptive pupil out of the classroom so others can get on with their learning.

What happens in Ireland?

EarringsandLipstick · 26/11/2023 08:58

Once again, I'm so glad that the disciplinary processes that are used in the UK are not used in Ireland.

I don't agree that there's any useful purpose served by a student sitting in isolation, with work to do or not (and I agree with PP that there is likely work given).

I wonder if there's any evidence that this is a successful approach to remedying behavioural issues?

ComfyBoobs · 26/11/2023 08:42

Even if (which I really doubt is the case!) your son isn’t being set work, I’d expect him to get off his arse to find a useful way to spend his time - reading ahead in the textbooks, past papers etc. The fact that he’s expecting to sit there all day, not learning, speaks volumes.

Marchitectmummy · 26/11/2023 07:34

State schools are limited now in what punishments they can consider. The one you are describing is one for the most serious offences. So if your son has done something the school thinks warrants it, then yes it's needed.

Perhaps be frustrated with your son rather than the school, he could have chosen not to do whatever it was and then not be punished.

Maxus · 26/11/2023 07:29

Tell your child that whatever they did is unacceptable. Why should the teacher spend time setting work? They have the rest of the class to teach and frankly in year 11 the other kids will be more than happy the disruptive child is finally removed. It's year 11 for every child not just your child and frankly they will be annoyed at your child for taking up the teachers time. When your child is disruptive their actions affect everyone else's GCSE, think about that for a second Its year 11 by now your child should have realised the school rules.