Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To object to this punishment ?

111 replies

School99 · 25/11/2023 13:22

My son is doing his GCSEs at local secondary school. They give lunchtime / break time / afterschool detentions for misbehaviour (ranging from not wearing a tie to constantly talking /disrupting class) which I support.
They also do a thing called internal exclusion which is where pupil has to sit in a different room all day with no lessons and nothing to do. My son has been told he has to do this on Monday for what I think is not a serious offence. Apart from thinking the punishment is not appropriate for the crime, I actually think this punishment is not at all appropriate in any circumstances- surely missing out on lessons when doing GCSEs is just setting them up to fail ? How is that teaching them to behave according to the school rules ?? I would object less if they were isolated but got their normal work given to them but they don’t even do that. I’m not really happy about the punishment - is this standard across all secondary schools ? I’m thinking of contacting the school to voice my views/objections but not sure if there’s any point ??

OP posts:
Lougle · 26/11/2023 11:11

@cansu the trouble is that behaviour policies often do sound reasonable. Unfortunately, individual teachers then apply those polices and there comes the inconsistency. The terms on the policy are so vague that it is for the teacher to interpret and action.

This child may not have any SEN but the general discussion was about internal exclusion, which disproportionately (IMO) applies to boys and children with SEN.

cansu · 26/11/2023 11:04

In any case I am not sure why we are talking about kids with adhd or asd. The student in question is not said to have either of these conditions so far.

cansu · 26/11/2023 11:02

Lougle
Imagine what lessons would like without consequences. I know many kids with autism and adhd thrive when there are clear rules and consequences. Yes there should be adaptations for individual students but most of the things on the referral to the hub list do not appear that unreasonable. Kids do not feel safe and able to learn in classes where kids are swearing, shouting at the teacher and refusing to follow instructions. Referral to the hub means taking the child out of the lesson where they are clearly not accessing learning to another place where they can calm themselves. How is that bad for them or for their peers?

luckylavender · 26/11/2023 10:50

More teacher bashing. We have no idea unless we know what he did. And even then there will be other versions of the truth.

Elfandwellbeing · 26/11/2023 10:49

Yabu to start a conflict with the school so close to him leaving anyway.

You signed up the school contract when you enrolled him, yabu.
Rules are rules. Stop teaching him they don’t apply to him.

Ohwhatfuckeryisthis · 26/11/2023 10:46

Whatever he’s done, he’s gcse, he will have a ton of revision guides, notes, flash cards etc. He’s got a day of revision, make sure he goes prepared.

Lougle · 26/11/2023 10:43

cansu · 26/11/2023 10:10

All schools clearly state their behaviour policy when you join. Schools without consequences would be fairly awful places to try and learn in. Most people expect consequences to be severe when their child has been wronged in some way and lenient when their child has done something wrong! Schools use internal isolation as step before fixed term exclusions. They also allow schools to discipline kids who don't attend detentions or who won't follow teacher instructions. As a previous poster explained unless the OP chose a school who gives isolations for dropping a pen - most unlikely! Her ds has done something wrong and she should be supporting the school. Maybe it is just a troll given she has not come back on the thread.

Our school is the school you mention. We didn't 'choose' it. There is precisely one school we are eligible for given our location. If you live in our area, you go to this school, or private. It isn't a 'bad school', but I would argue that the HT has 'independent school' aspirations and at this year's certificate evening he referred to someone 'scraping a pass in their GCSEs', knowing that there would be students in the room that had worked extremely hard to achieve a 4, or indeed failed a GCSE or two.

Although dropping a pen isn't written, it was given as an example at the parent presentation we attended. Imagine a child with ADHD or ASD, then look at the sanction list.

To object to this punishment ?
Maxus · 26/11/2023 10:41

I object the pupils wrecking the learning of my year 11 child in their most important year. If they carnt behave by year 11 they deserve to be removed. Why should all the other suffer due to one pupil. Good luck applying for colleges, they look at the behaviour records.

zingally · 26/11/2023 10:31

You've very carefully not mentioned what he actually did.

In my experience, internal exclusion like that is for pretty serious misbehaviour, or low-level behaviour that hasn't responded to the less serious punishments.

If he misses a day of learning due to his own choices, that's a him problem.

cansu · 26/11/2023 10:10

All schools clearly state their behaviour policy when you join. Schools without consequences would be fairly awful places to try and learn in. Most people expect consequences to be severe when their child has been wronged in some way and lenient when their child has done something wrong! Schools use internal isolation as step before fixed term exclusions. They also allow schools to discipline kids who don't attend detentions or who won't follow teacher instructions. As a previous poster explained unless the OP chose a school who gives isolations for dropping a pen - most unlikely! Her ds has done something wrong and she should be supporting the school. Maybe it is just a troll given she has not come back on the thread.

Lougle · 26/11/2023 09:56

Fusterclucked · 26/11/2023 09:43

It is a way of teaching them what prison is like, excluded from society, unable to progress in life, lots of time alone to reflect on their sins.

For dropping a pen? for waving at a fellow student as they enter the class slightly late? For turning in their chair when they should be listening to the teacher? For zoning out and not knowing what to do, so asking a fellow student?

These are all examples of 'low level disruption' that can lead to the Hub at DD3's school.

I have no concerns about my children. One was so dysregulated by being there that she had to leave and is now on an EOTAS package from the Local Authority, and my other DD is being very well accommodated by the SEN team, although out of school because she can't cope with it. However, that's my point, really. Both girls refused to go to classes, left classes part way through, etc., but because they display their SEN in quite a polite and passive way, they will never even get a behaviour point, let alone a detention or the Hub. Other children may have exactly the same needs, but because they displace their anxiety and display behaviours that are seen as 'low level disruption', they get Hubbed.

Some children are Hubbed, refuse to go back to school, then go back to school and because they have additional needs can't comply with the behaviour code and get Hubbed again. So their whole education is reduced to about 20% of school time.

I was a SEN school governor for over 10 years, across primary and secondary special schools, and mainstream infant schools. I would love to get in to DD3's school and analyse the Hub statistics. I bet it would show a disproportionate rate of boys and children with SEN being Hubbed. They advertised for governors recently but I can't bring myself to apply because I know that such analysis wouldn't be welcome by the HT and the SEN governor should already be asking those questions.

FieldInWhichFucksAreGrownIsBarren · 26/11/2023 09:55

Would you look at that, just the original post omitting what the punishment is actually for then no reply to the many posts asking what he did. Perhaps not such a minor infringement...
Students are given work to do, can you imagine how hard it would be to control the room for staff if they were simply left to their own devices?
Your son can revise and also perhaps reflect on why he's in there so it doesn't occur again.

BoohooWoohoo · 26/11/2023 09:49

If they don’t give work (I think they do but there’s no repercussions for not doing it), then he should take some revision in. Past papers are available to print out in the exam board websites and nobody is going to object if he gets on with that kind of work.
Unless your child goes to an insanely strict school like Michaela (in which case you picked the school so must bear some responsibility ), your son is at an age where he is responsible for his behaviour and will know what is acceptable or not. Internal exclusion is a pretty serious consequence and you should be mad at him more than the school who are probably seeing this as their last straw. The other students in the classroom will have a break from your son for the day.

Fusterclucked · 26/11/2023 09:46

EarringsandLipstick · 26/11/2023 09:45

For rocking on a chair? 😳😳😳😳

I’m not agreeing with it, just pointing out the thinking behind the punishment

EarringsandLipstick · 26/11/2023 09:45

Fusterclucked · 26/11/2023 09:43

It is a way of teaching them what prison is like, excluded from society, unable to progress in life, lots of time alone to reflect on their sins.

For rocking on a chair? 😳😳😳😳

EarringsandLipstick · 26/11/2023 09:44

otherwise they may just go to external exclusion and make it your problem.

See, that's what I'd expect the school to do?

And it's what ours do. If there's any significant issue we get a call from the class tutor.

If it breaches their code of conduct eg any physical aggression / fighting, it's a suspension.

Of course this becomes, rightly, the parents' problem.

Fusterclucked · 26/11/2023 09:43

It is a way of teaching them what prison is like, excluded from society, unable to progress in life, lots of time alone to reflect on their sins.

Ohtobetwentytwo · 26/11/2023 09:42

I think you should treas carefully before complaining about how they do internal exclusion, otherwise they may just go to external exclusion and make it your problem.

RudsyFarmer · 26/11/2023 09:42

Well what did he do this time and does he have a pattern of poor behaviour?

I honestly think as parents we are doing our kids a disservice for adult life if we allow poor behaviour to go unpunished because it’s not ‘that bad’. If your son has an issue with the defiance for example, how is he going to cope in a work environment? Is he going to end up being someone that can’t cope with orders and just quits constantly.

That would be how I’d be viewing this. Is this a one off? Is this a pattern? Is this teaching him anything? Is my reaction to this going to help him learn or entrench the behaviour? Only you can answer that.

Ohtobetwentytwo · 26/11/2023 09:40

I'd support the school and if he says he has no work then I'd expect him to make it up on a weekend. Until hed logged enough hours of work he wouldnt be getting leisure time.

EarringsandLipstick · 26/11/2023 09:36

The kids who make a genuine mistake, get Hubbed and never get Hubbed again, didn't need to be Hubbed in the first place and a 1 hour detention would have got the message across in the first place. The kids who are repeatedly Hubbed are the kids who have very little control over their behaviour, and no amount of 'inclusion' is going to change that

That seems to make total sense.

EarringsandLipstick · 26/11/2023 09:36

My issue is that most of the kids that are 'included' will have additional needs of some sort. They just don't display them in a socially acceptable way.

That was my thought, too.

The disruptive kids in my DC schools fit this category. My experience is the teachers manage it well, with some latitude and some consequences and a great deal of care. The other students too seem to have some understanding.

However, these students are in the minority, and I recognise if there were many more, trying to teach might be impossible.

Again, from an outside perspective, the pressures on teachers in the UK (curriculum, paperwork, discipline) seem immense (not saying it's a walk in the park here either).

Lougle · 26/11/2023 09:32

menopausalmare · 26/11/2023 09:28

EarringsandLipstick, if your child was on the receiving end of bullying I think you'd be pretty quick to support inclusion.

It's not inclusion though, is it? That's a word that is used to make it sound better than 'internal exclusion'.

My issue is that most of the kids that are 'included' will have additional needs of some sort. They just don't display them in a socially acceptable way.

The kids who make a genuine mistake, get Hubbed and never get Hubbed again, didn't need to be Hubbed in the first place and a 1 hour detention would have got the message across in the first place. The kids who are repeatedly Hubbed are the kids who have very little control over their behaviour, and no amount of 'inclusion' is going to change that.

cryinglaughing · 26/11/2023 09:32

He will get work, for sure.

What did he do?
What punishment do you think he should get?

cansu · 26/11/2023 09:32

What did he do ?
Yes he will get work.
I suggest you ask if he can also take his revision folder.
He has the chance to do lots of work in complete silence. Why would this be setting him up to fail??