Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

... to expect my 5 year old to do something she doesn't wany to?

158 replies

letloz · 25/11/2023 10:45

I was in alone with the 5 (nearly 6) year old today. Quite fancied going to a second hand clothing sale in the centre of town- DD wasn't keen. I can understand she wouldn't get much out of it, but I explained we'd only be there half an hour, gave examples of all the MANY things we are doing this weekend for her benefit (going to legoland tomorrow, made pancakes and played video games with her this morning) and how it would be nice for her to do something for someone else, even offered a cafe trip. Still refused to go. I found myself turning off all the screens and refusing to play with her, ad if she wouldn't do something nice to me, why should I do more nice things for her? It felt like a bit of an adult sulk, but really wasn't/am not sure how else to approach the situation. If it had been something non negotiable, like a medical appt, obviously I would have put my foot down more, but I'm more disappointed that she was unwilling to put someone else's wishes before her own for a change. Or AIBU to expect this of a 5 year old?

OP posts:
spriots · 25/11/2023 13:42

I get that it's frustrating to ask for advice and then have people just tell you you're doing it wrong.

Some suggestions that work for me with mine below - but I really do recommend that you think about your existing strategies and what already works when you need to get her out for things like school/appointments as you will already have some approaches that already work.

  • Don't ask questions or negotiate unless you really don't mind what she chooses - it is unfair to offer a choice and then guilt trip her if she chooses the wrong one. Just announce that this is the plan for the day.
  • Routine helps, we have a rhythm to the weekend, some bits are kid focused and some are adult focused
  • Timeouts work on the older one
  • Joking him out of it works better on the younger one

I recommend the book how to talk so little kids will listen

Cornettoninja · 25/11/2023 13:39

Oh, that brings back memories - my dad used to do something similar. IIRC it was "This is not a democracy, this is a dictatorship and I am the dictator!" And yes, it made us laugh, my dad was a big softie

I had an uncle who would say ‘I do not negotiate with terrorists’ Grin

Goldbar · 25/11/2023 13:39

Cornettoninja · 25/11/2023 13:34

That’s great but it’s not the same scenario for a single parent or parent that finds themselves without any on tap childcare for whatever reason. I wouldn’t book a sitter for a shopping trip and wouldn’t expect anyone else to either. It doesn’t harm a child to go even if they are a bit bored.

Completely agree. My 6yo spends lots of time in places they'd rather not be. Most recently in hospital for 3 hours as we waited for their baby sibling to be checked over. You make it as fun as you can, you take something to do and offer a hot chocolate and a playground trip afterwards, but doing boring stuff is part of family life.

WhereYouLeftIt · 25/11/2023 13:37

Goldbar · 25/11/2023 13:12

"This is not a democracy. I'm in charge. Shift, now, otherwise sharks will start biting your bottom."

Or something of that sort. I say this to my 6yo and they find it funny, and then they move.

Oh, that brings back memories - my dad used to do something similar. IIRC it was "This is not a democracy, this is a dictatorship and I am the dictator!" And yes, it made us laugh, my dad was a big softie.

I agree with everyone else, you do not negotiate with a five year old. You are the adult, you are in charge. It sounds as if you have maybe made a rod for your own back.

You now need to wean her off having an effective veto. I would go with @billy1966's way of giving her the illusion of choice -

"Coat and shoes, or jacket and boots?
Eggs and toast or beans and waffles?"

But never giving her the choice of going or not going. She'll kick up the first few times, but - persevere. Be firm, be consistent - DO NOT BUDGE A MILLIMETRE! She has to learn that kicking off does not get her anything. Consistency is your friend.

OhNaffOffYouWazzock · 25/11/2023 13:36

letloz · 25/11/2023 12:39

OK, I get the general gist here is 'tell her she's going', but what when she then flat out says no? (Which she has done in the past)

You just say "sorry you don't want to come/think it's boring/would rather stay at home, but we're going". It's a non negotiable like brushing your teeth, wearing a seat belt and taking your medicine.

If I'd have stayed in every time my children didn't want to go out we'd have either starved to death or the older ones would still be waiting at the school gates for me to collect them.

Lucytheloose · 25/11/2023 13:35

letloz · 25/11/2023 12:39

OK, I get the general gist here is 'tell her she's going', but what when she then flat out says no? (Which she has done in the past)

You take her. It won't be pleasant and there may be some yelling, but if you let her call the shots at 5, she will be unmanageable at 10 or 15.

Cornettoninja · 25/11/2023 13:34

Canisaysomething · 25/11/2023 13:28

It’s unrealistic to expect a 5 year old to go to a 2nd hand clothing sale. I don’t expect my DH would want to go either. For children and adults, compromises are needed. I would persuade a child or adult to go based on the fact we would probably also do something they wanted to do whilst we were out as well. “Do what I want to do and come with me” isn’t a particular effective approach for children or adults of any age.

That’s great but it’s not the same scenario for a single parent or parent that finds themselves without any on tap childcare for whatever reason. I wouldn’t book a sitter for a shopping trip and wouldn’t expect anyone else to either. It doesn’t harm a child to go even if they are a bit bored.

NoTouch · 25/11/2023 13:34

If you have let her rule the roost until now she is going to say no because she thinks she always has a choice.

Tell her she is going, shoes on now, if she says no then she gets a firm warning then consequences. No begging, pleading, negotiation and follow through every. single. time.

She needs to learn the world doesn't revolve around her. That means she doesn't only go where she wants, doesn't always get her favourite food, etc. It will initially be hard changing, but will be worth it for both of you. Kids feel more secure when they have firm boundaries from their parents.

Make sure she knows the difference between boundaries with her parents/trusted adults and adults she doesn't know well.

Bournetilly · 25/11/2023 13:32

Until she’s old enough to stay on her own she doesn’t get a choice (unless there’s someone else able to look after her). Just tell her you are going. It’s not like she’s not done/ doing anything she enjoys all weekend.

Lucytheloose · 25/11/2023 13:30

You can't expect much in the way of empathy and fairness from a five-year-old, which is why you don't give them a veto.

Notimeforaname · 25/11/2023 13:29

People aren't being cruel. They are telling you what they think because you asked.

What you have done is allowed your child to make a decision, then punished and scolded the child for making the "wrong decision ".
I'd say that's closer to cruel than anything else on this thread..

Mycatmax · 25/11/2023 13:29

What do mean “if she says no!” You haven’t asked her a question, that’s the whole point.

If you say “right, we’re off to the shops in five minutes “ and she says “I don’t want to go” you just say “never mind, we will make it fun and do xyz when we get back” or any other jolly shizz you can make up.

As PP have said, what would/do you do if she says she doesn’t want to go to school?

It will be harder for you to enforce these boundaries as she’s got used to being in charge, but don’t beat yourself up. We’ve all fucked up parenting in one way or another, I know I have! Just keep at it and she will adapt.

Canisaysomething · 25/11/2023 13:28

It’s unrealistic to expect a 5 year old to go to a 2nd hand clothing sale. I don’t expect my DH would want to go either. For children and adults, compromises are needed. I would persuade a child or adult to go based on the fact we would probably also do something they wanted to do whilst we were out as well. “Do what I want to do and come with me” isn’t a particular effective approach for children or adults of any age.

OneCup · 25/11/2023 13:26

Yes I agree with PP. 'do you want to make pancakes before or after going to X?'

billy1966 · 25/11/2023 13:21

A parenting trick that I found affective when mine were very small was to give them two choices that suited me in things like this, or food.

Coat and shoes, or jacket and boots?
Eggs and toast or beans and waffles?

Shop and super market or shop and a hot chocolate?

It worked well with 3 year olds.

Jellycatspyjamas · 25/11/2023 13:17

*In this situation tomorrow morning I'd not be getting up and getting ready for legoland and just announcing "I just don't fancy going"

Yes she'll be disappointed. But she'll learn bloody darn quick that compromise and making sacrifices works both ways.*

Please don’t do this, she’s too young to have the psychological processes to make that link, it’s unfair to try and teach her a lesson she’s too young to learn. Instead stop asking her to do things that aren’t negotiable - including things you want/need to do that are inconvenient for her.

billy1966 · 25/11/2023 13:15

There wouldn't have been ANY discussion here, it would be absolutely happening.

There is no choice in this situation.

itsgettingweird · 25/11/2023 13:13

Agree not negotiating.

In this situation tomorrow morning I'd not be getting up and getting ready for legoland and just announcing "I just don't fancy going"

Yes she'll be disappointed. But she'll learn bloody darn quick that compromise and making sacrifices works both ways.

Goldbar · 25/11/2023 13:12

letloz · 25/11/2023 12:39

OK, I get the general gist here is 'tell her she's going', but what when she then flat out says no? (Which she has done in the past)

"This is not a democracy. I'm in charge. Shift, now, otherwise sharks will start biting your bottom."

Or something of that sort. I say this to my 6yo and they find it funny, and then they move.

Jellycatspyjamas · 25/11/2023 13:10

OK, I get the general gist here is 'tell her she's going', but what when she then flat out says no? (Which she has done in the past)

I’d tell her I wasn’t asking her, she needs to get her shoes and coat on and be ready to go. She’s going to say “no” to a lot of things, you need to hold your authority as her parent because she’s not old enough to chose every aspect of her life, and shouldn’t be controlling aspects of yours.

Cornettoninja · 25/11/2023 13:10

Fwiw @letloz i don’t think anyone has tried to be cruel to you, I think they’re trying to illustrate how a 5 year old is likely to perceive it. Absolutely I can see why you’d find that hurtful or a bit too close to the bone but I really don’t think it’s been offered up with the intention of upsetting or shaming you. It can be helpful to understand it all a bit more at times

I think there’s a book recommended here, how to speak so kids will listen. Haven’t read it myself (and my dd is 50/50 on whether she listens to me Grin) but it might be worth investigating. The upshot is that we have learned a lot of social rules and things like being nice and/or fair. Dc aren’t automatically being disobedient or mean because they haven’t learnt the same rules we have. Sometimes parenting in a way you don’t find instinctually comfortable isn’t helpful overall and leads to situations being managed in a way you yourself aren’t completely happy about and doesn’t lead to future behaviour being any different.

penjil · 25/11/2023 13:03

"Screen off, shoes on, we're going into town".

What a 5 year old wants isn't relevant. You are the adult. You make the choices.

SusanKennedyshouldLTB · 25/11/2023 13:03

ThePineapplePrincess · 25/11/2023 12:59

“Oh that’s a shame you don’t want to. Come on, we’re going.”

You are being awfully cruel when you said “right well if you won’t do what I want you can’t do what you want”. You can’t talk to a child like that.

This. You dont negotiate.

YomAsalYomBasal · 25/11/2023 13:01

No need for all that, just tell her you're going.

letloz · 25/11/2023 13:01

As a side point- I came on here looking for advice cos I knew I hadn't handled the situation well. I wasn't looking for a diatribe of abuse of how I was the world's worst mother, and my daughter is f*cked. I am taking on board the message behind these posts and appreciate the people who have done so in a neutral way, but the tone of the majority of these posts have just made me feel like an utterly failure. Why is it ok to be so much more cruel anonymously on here than you would be to someone in real life? Ironic considering one of the main thing people are stating is to be kind.

OP posts: