Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

... to expect my 5 year old to do something she doesn't wany to?

158 replies

letloz · 25/11/2023 10:45

I was in alone with the 5 (nearly 6) year old today. Quite fancied going to a second hand clothing sale in the centre of town- DD wasn't keen. I can understand she wouldn't get much out of it, but I explained we'd only be there half an hour, gave examples of all the MANY things we are doing this weekend for her benefit (going to legoland tomorrow, made pancakes and played video games with her this morning) and how it would be nice for her to do something for someone else, even offered a cafe trip. Still refused to go. I found myself turning off all the screens and refusing to play with her, ad if she wouldn't do something nice to me, why should I do more nice things for her? It felt like a bit of an adult sulk, but really wasn't/am not sure how else to approach the situation. If it had been something non negotiable, like a medical appt, obviously I would have put my foot down more, but I'm more disappointed that she was unwilling to put someone else's wishes before her own for a change. Or AIBU to expect this of a 5 year old?

OP posts:
liveforsummer · 25/11/2023 16:24

'We are going in to town now' was all you needed to say here. No negotiation necessary. I can't believe you didn't go on your 5 year olds say so!

Heronwatcher · 25/11/2023 16:21

I can’t believe you negotiated! My kids of a similar age get told, we’re going to xyz in 10 minutes. If they get into a strop (rare) I say they can stay at home on their own and start putting my shoes on- they usually get ready pretty quickly after that. Once you start a negotiation with a 5yr old it’s a slippery slope.

Spirallingdownwards · 25/11/2023 16:15

letloz · 25/11/2023 12:39

OK, I get the general gist here is 'tell her she's going', but what when she then flat out says no? (Which she has done in the past)

She isn't asked a question. She doesn't get to say no.

It's shoes on we are going out.

MumofSpud · 25/11/2023 16:06

scorpiogirly · 25/11/2023 11:12

With my daughter who is also 5, it's a case of "right come on, we've got to pop out'. These outings recently usually consist of trawling around what she likes to call boring shops like Wickes or B&Q.

I still call B and Q etc boring - and when I went with my mother recently I may have had a bit of a strop in the nails aisle (boring boring boring)
I am 51Blush

Cherrysoup · 25/11/2023 16:05

You tell a 5 year old, you certainly don’t ask her opinion! What would happen if she didn’t want to go to school? Would she just be allowed to stay at home?

MumofSpud · 25/11/2023 16:03

The reason she said no is because that is how you've brought her up - giving her a choice so she will only do the things she wants - at school this will be a nightmare

You are obviously NOT a bad parent at all (great activities / giving your DD a voice) but you are in the process of making a rod for your own back!

Not too late to change it up though! Good Luck!

Orangeandgold · 25/11/2023 15:19

Even as teens I don’t think our children react to “you do something nice for mummy because mummy does so much for you”. That thinking doesn’t work. It doesn’t work much for adults either - it’s just an unwritten code.

When my DD was younger the conversations were more like “We are going shopping today, what do you want to bring? scooter or walk// book or toy// tuna or egg”

I was told that children want to feel in control but you give them choices of things that they can control - whilst still being the parent and being in control (hope that makes sense!)

Personally at that age I would spend many weekends going out - whether it was a fun trip to a museum or theme park or doing groceries or a family event. I wouldn’t let my DD take over or change our plans unless the place I was going was not child friendly or one of us were ill or exhausted etc.

5 year olds do not reason with adults. At the end of the day you can talk about the one thing she loved from going out with you today (e.g. my DD once didn’t want to go to the panto. I took her anyway. At the end I asked her to share her favourite part and her face lit up as she explained her fav scene).

However prior and whilst we are still getting out the only negotiation would be given them a choice of what they want to bring with them. OR if there is a park nearby you can say “we will ply in the park for 30 mins”.

twinklystar23 · 25/11/2023 15:03

Your reaction to punish her for making the "Wrong choice" would have been confusing and likely have made her feel insecure. As at 5 she wouldn't have made the connection between saying no and your reaction. Clear messages and if needs be consequences need to be communicated to children at this age.

Punishing her with not going to legoland would be unfair as in this scenario she has not done anything wrong, she made a choice offered to her. Again it would be confusing and upsetting for this to be withdrawn.

Mmmm19 · 25/11/2023 14:37

Op ignore the posters who can’t admit/see they aren’t perfect parents all the time. I’d have also gone for the - we are doing x for me and then we could do y for you in town. But I’ve also made the mistake of asking when I only wanted one answer! I am still figuring things out but if they said no / kick up a fuss for a long time I say we won’t have time to do your things as there won’t be time or i’ll have to go another time and it will mean we miss y etc - I am hoping this counts as a natural consequence….

remindersofhim · 25/11/2023 14:37

YANBU.

And then when she says no? My go to would be 'OK, then we're not doing x that you wanted to do', but I didn't really think it was ideal to resort to that either.

Why is it not ideal? She says no she gets a consequence, personally I wouldn't not take her to an activity as that would only punish you too and result in another boring day stuck in the house but I'd take away screen time or something else she cares about. What you did today was fine, I definitely don't think you're a bad mother!

whatwasIgoingtosay · 25/11/2023 14:35

"I wasn't looking for a diatribe of abuse of how I was the world's worst mother, and my daughter is fcked.*"
Really and truly, you haven't had a diatribe of abuse and no one has said your daughter is fucked. The vast majority of posters have simply said that 5 year olds don't get to negotiate whether or not they go out and some have even given you sensible advice on how to manage that. If you can follow that advice in future, I'm sure your life will be easier.

Viviennemary · 25/11/2023 14:32

Stop allowing her to choose when it isn't appropriate. She is five. And needs to do what you say. Or else you are storing up problems for the future.

TheIsleOfTheLost · 25/11/2023 14:19

I haven't read every comment, but the ones I have read don't say you are the worst mother ever. It seems like you are having the same reaction to people here saying something you don't like as when your child said something you didn't like and stropping off.

The advice is quite reasonable. If it's something you are set on doing, don't ask her if she wants to first. If you don't mind, that's when you give the choice. Asking her and then telling her she is selfish for having a different opinion is never going to end well.

Cornettoninja · 25/11/2023 14:15

It's not fair to put it in terms of being 'disappointed that she was unwilling to put someone else's wishes before her own for a change'

I think you’ve picked up on the bit that’s probably influenced a lot of answers here. This is a really unreasonable expectation of a 5 year old. If it doesn’t come naturally (which is rare) to people then having enough empathy and intellectual willpower to justify putting someone else’s needs first is very much a learned skill. Part of learning that is doing things you don’t necessarily like because they need to be done. As the parent you decide what falls into that category of ‘need’. Shopping isn’t always a need but if the parent has a need to do something pleasant for themselves then that counts.

TinkerTiger · 25/11/2023 14:10

Cornettoninja · 25/11/2023 13:10

Fwiw @letloz i don’t think anyone has tried to be cruel to you, I think they’re trying to illustrate how a 5 year old is likely to perceive it. Absolutely I can see why you’d find that hurtful or a bit too close to the bone but I really don’t think it’s been offered up with the intention of upsetting or shaming you. It can be helpful to understand it all a bit more at times

I think there’s a book recommended here, how to speak so kids will listen. Haven’t read it myself (and my dd is 50/50 on whether she listens to me Grin) but it might be worth investigating. The upshot is that we have learned a lot of social rules and things like being nice and/or fair. Dc aren’t automatically being disobedient or mean because they haven’t learnt the same rules we have. Sometimes parenting in a way you don’t find instinctually comfortable isn’t helpful overall and leads to situations being managed in a way you yourself aren’t completely happy about and doesn’t lead to future behaviour being any different.

It's a great book, I recommend.

Middleagedmeangirls · 25/11/2023 14:08

You are being unreasonable to expect a 5 year old to put an adults feelings before their own. That's why, if there is something an adult needs/wants to do (and it's not age inappropriate) you don't ask a 5 year old, you tell them. If they are reluctant you can acknowledge and discuss their feelings but they still have to do as they are told.

You would also be unreasonable to announce tomorrow that you don't feel like going to Legoland. That would be spite not discipline. And it's too far off from today's events for her to understand the connection.

Talk to your daughter now. Tell her you are really sad that and disappointed didn't get to go to the sale and you hope there will be another one soon. She will probably be amazed to discover that adults have feelings and feel sorry. That's all it needs for now. Then for the next couple of weeks insist she does some slightly less pleasurable things with you using some of the excellent
parenting techniques suggested on here.

ToWhitToWhoo · 25/11/2023 14:06

It's not U to expect her to do something she doesn't like. Everyone has to do things that they don't like. However, it's unfair to give her a choice and then punish her with an 'adult sulk' for making a choice you don't like. Either you just take her where you wish, with no room for argument, or if you do give her a choice, you accept her decision. It's not fair to put it in terms of being 'disappointed that she was unwilling to put someone else's wishes before her own for a change'- that is treating her as someone much older. Best just to say 'We're going to town!' and not leave room for debate or bargaining.

IncompleteSenten · 25/11/2023 14:02

My husband has always been a bugger for asking the kids question that implies they can actually say no and then telling them to do it because he wasn't really giving them a choice.

I can't count how many times I said to him (privately) ffs, if you are telling not asking then don't bloody start with would you like to go out, do you want to put your shoes on, would you like dinner, do you want to ... then start ordering them to do it anyway if they take your question at face value and believe they have the option to refuse! They're adults now and I still haven't managed to drill that blindingly obvious thing through his bloody head.

It's very important to not make children feel they don't have the right to say no when they are asked if they want to do something.

When we are telling them, we should tell them. Not pretend they have a choice they don't have.

If we ask them and they say no, we have to respect that otherwise what are we teaching them about their right to say no?

In this situation I would have said please put your shoes on, we need to go to the shops. After that, we can do X.

If she said no then that's when you tell her that you weren't asking. That this is somewhere you need to go and to put her shoes on.

If she still won't comply that's when you put consequences in place such as removal of screen time.

But you don't ask someone a question about whether they want to do something if you can't accept their answer may be no and respect that.

uninterestingusernamealert · 25/11/2023 13:59

Cornettoninja · 25/11/2023 13:39

Oh, that brings back memories - my dad used to do something similar. IIRC it was "This is not a democracy, this is a dictatorship and I am the dictator!" And yes, it made us laugh, my dad was a big softie

I had an uncle who would say ‘I do not negotiate with terrorists’ Grin

DH and I regularly use war speak when dealing with ours. 'We don't negotiate with terrorists!' and also 'divide and conquer?' when they need separating, particularly in the hour before bedtime! Grin

uninterestingusernamealert · 25/11/2023 13:56

letloz · 25/11/2023 12:39

OK, I get the general gist here is 'tell her she's going', but what when she then flat out says no? (Which she has done in the past)

Shoes on, coat on, door open, out!

If she won't put her stuff on, then do it for her.

If she throws a wobbler, still do it for her, then scoop her up and put her in the car. Ignoring whining and yelling.

'We're going'

My five year old is stubbornly wilful and currently would do nothing that wasn't playing if she had her way. She will flat out dead eye me and say 'No Mummy, I am NOT coming to Tesco it's boring!' Ahem, yes you are kiddo, move it!

She would rule the house if I let her, and she would likely be a nightmare in five years time!

None of this 'I'm not playing with you' rubbish - at five years old they're too little to understand the message you're trying to convey. Their brains just aren't mature enough. At five, they understand 'Mum is in charge' even if they don't like it. Approaching it as you have all the think is that Mum is being horrible and they don't understand why.

Cappuccino17 · 25/11/2023 13:54

I don't think the sulk is the way to go about it. 5 year olds can still be quite selfish and are still learning about giving etc
Now if she really didn't want to go to a second hand store that does not mean she has done something bad. Forcing her would be a wrong move. She needs to gain an understanding through you about the reasons for helping and going. Get her involved. Not sure if i understood but if you are donating things get her to help you bag things up and she can hand it over to the lady at the store and i usually end of with imagine how many people you can make smile through giving all these things? The cafe idea would definitely have bribed my daughter not sure what happened there with yours maybe she reallllly didn't want to come.
I think restricting her from things because you want something to be your way is not the way to go. Restricting things because of bad behaviour is fine. 2 very different things.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 25/11/2023 13:49

How much do you actually want to go to Legoland yourself?

Maray1967 · 25/11/2023 13:48

Lucytheloose · 25/11/2023 13:35

You take her. It won't be pleasant and there may be some yelling, but if you let her call the shots at 5, she will be unmanageable at 10 or 15.

Agreed. Mine knew very well that when I said we needed to go out, we went. But I didn’t make them go round shops any longer than necessary. Ten minutes at the most in each shop, 3 or 4 shops max, small treat after for good behaviour eg cake, ice cream.

A 5 year old is old enough in my experience to understand that sometimes we need to do what we don’t want to do. Mine certainly did.

Canwehaveaminute · 25/11/2023 13:48

I've 3 kids and they've never said 'no' when ive said were going somewhere. Maybe a moan or a groan but they know they have to go if I say were going.

I think that children can pick up on our confidence. If deep down we feel like we are the boss, everything about us communicates that and the child can't spent any chinks in our armour.

It sounds like you felt you lost some kind of control over the situation and you tried to regain it with the emotional blackmail. Is this something you faced as a child? Sometimes these habits can be hard not to repeat.

I think you would really enjoy researching Janet Lansbury. She is great at showing how to be a strong confident parent without using emotional manipulation. Her philosophy is very refreshing (and children should do things that they aren't interested in, in small doses-its good for them to know that other people are important too).

Ffsnotaconference · 25/11/2023 13:43

letloz · 25/11/2023 13:01

As a side point- I came on here looking for advice cos I knew I hadn't handled the situation well. I wasn't looking for a diatribe of abuse of how I was the world's worst mother, and my daughter is f*cked. I am taking on board the message behind these posts and appreciate the people who have done so in a neutral way, but the tone of the majority of these posts have just made me feel like an utterly failure. Why is it ok to be so much more cruel anonymously on here than you would be to someone in real life? Ironic considering one of the main thing people are stating is to be kind.

Where’s the abuse?

Where is the cruelty?

and who stating ‘to be kind’ as a main thing? People are telling you to understand you daughter doesn’t have and can’t be excepted to be on the same level as you emotionally.

Are you really comparing people (adults) critiquing your (another adult) parenting style, which you asked them to do, in a way you don’t like to ignoring a 5 because she won’t simply just enjoy things that you do?

Swipe left for the next trending thread