Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that 4 boys should not be a deal breaker

205 replies

ItsCagain · 25/11/2023 09:30

We have 4 boys 15 13 11 6. i can’t help but feel so jealous at people who go to Christmas markets with their kids. We can barely go out for dinner without them killing each other or be so difficult you just want to leave. This morning i saw some pic of a friend with their son and daughter last night and it makes me so sad that we can’t do that anymore with ours or at least not without complete despair

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
toomanyleggings · 29/11/2023 12:56

We’ve got three ( 2 girls and a boy), there’s lots of arguing whenever we go anywhere tbh. The girls are actually worse than the boy

EarthyMangold · 29/11/2023 12:55

But the boot is on the other foot now....

For example, packing for school camp (5 days every year from age 8 in this country, it's a fairly routine thing) I go through the list provided, send my son to gather the required item, show him how to fold/pack them, he puts them in the bag and we're done in 15 minutes. My friend with a daughter in the same class spends more than a week negotiating which clothes, how much new stuff she needs, whether or not she can pack various things that are not on the list, not to mention which bag or suitcase she is going to take...

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 29/11/2023 12:51

Regardless of whether they're boys or girls, I'm not sure that I would expect that 4 children with such a spread of ages would all want to go on happy family days out together. Surely when you make the choice to have a big family like this, you recognise that some compromises will need to be made and that your lifestyle will be a bit different from that of people with fewer kids?

crackofdoom · 29/11/2023 12:49

It changes sometimes. DS2, while not into crafts as a toddler, now loves loom bands/ Hama beads/ drawing and modelling now he is 8. In fact, he keeps nagging me to sit down and make a pomander with him at the moment. This is taking a little readjustment, as DS1 has always been a "typical boy" and largely disinterested.

ManateeFair · 29/11/2023 12:48

I'm not quite sure what you're asking here. Are you suggesting that the reason you can't do stuff as a family is because your children are all boys? Or just because having four kids in that age range things makes things difficult?

The fact that your kids don't get on and/or behave like arseholes is absolutely nothing to do with them being boys. You could easily have a mix of boys and girls, or all girls, and have exactly the same problem. My brother and I couldn't be in the back of the car together for 10 minutes without some kind of furious row breaking out. My sister once hit my brother in the face with a plimsoll.

I also think that the age range of your kids is probably an issue for family days out. A 15-year-old generally doesn't get a huge amount of enjoyment from the company of younger kids, for instance. When I was 15, my friends had younger brothers in the 11-13 age bracket and we basically LOATHED them and considered them horrible little embarrassing pests.

EarthyMangold · 29/11/2023 12:46

It can be difficult actually when they’re little, as a “boy mum” to be friends with “girl mums” - they don’t understand why your child won’t sit quietly doing crafts!

Oh yes!!! My dear, kind friend who kept giving my lads colouring books and fimo and effing Hama beads for birthday presents because they were what her same aged daughters loved (and created beautiful things with) and I was too embarrassed to say "unless I keep them in the boxes and re-gift ASAP these will only ever be used as missiles in my house.. "

Whyohwhywyoming · 29/11/2023 12:40

EarthyMangold · 29/11/2023 12:38

Also a quick Google of polls by parents shows that on the whole, boys are actually seen as easier to raise than girls.

As a sweeping generalisation, based entirely on anecdotal observation, I think girls tend to be "easier" in the early years - less destructive, more likely to engage in peaceful play, craft etc, quicker to catch social cues, potty train etc BUT from around age 7 onwards boys are "easier" - less complicated, clearer on what they want, more easily satisfied, less likely to complain.

Possibly this is why new mothers are concerned about having boys - if you've only seen under 3s close up, the girls often do seem a lot more civilized. However, if you spend some time around 7-10 year olds, the boys are often a lot more relaxed and friendly.

Obviously exceptions exist (plenty of them) but I find this to be broadly true so far (I have 4 boys, my eldest is nearly 12, youngest is nearly 5) and 3 of my closest friends have daughters around the same age. And I don't know about the teen years yet....

It can be difficult actually when they’re little, as a “boy mum” to be friends with “girl mums” - they don’t understand why your child won’t sit quietly doing crafts!

Whyohwhywyoming · 29/11/2023 12:38

I have two boys, both ND, both teen, and they have barely spoken to each other for at least a year. When you get, they fought horribly, so this feels like an improvement.

they have very different personalities and would not choose to be friends. One is ASD and likes planned out activities knowing exactly what is happening and not deviating, one is adhd, hyper fixates, thrives on chaos. I have settled for 2 or three days a year doing something they both really like (theme park / cinema with gallery tickets where you get extras) and we can do a fairly decent impression of a happy day as long as I manage their needs.

EarthyMangold · 29/11/2023 12:38

Also a quick Google of polls by parents shows that on the whole, boys are actually seen as easier to raise than girls.

As a sweeping generalisation, based entirely on anecdotal observation, I think girls tend to be "easier" in the early years - less destructive, more likely to engage in peaceful play, craft etc, quicker to catch social cues, potty train etc BUT from around age 7 onwards boys are "easier" - less complicated, clearer on what they want, more easily satisfied, less likely to complain.

Possibly this is why new mothers are concerned about having boys - if you've only seen under 3s close up, the girls often do seem a lot more civilized. However, if you spend some time around 7-10 year olds, the boys are often a lot more relaxed and friendly.

Obviously exceptions exist (plenty of them) but I find this to be broadly true so far (I have 4 boys, my eldest is nearly 12, youngest is nearly 5) and 3 of my closest friends have daughters around the same age. And I don't know about the teen years yet....

Satsscores · 29/11/2023 08:27

Amyalexandrer · 29/11/2023 08:18

I understand where you're coming from but there are also studies that show that women and girls are more likely to perpetrate indirect and verbal aggression and digital/social media aggression. Whilst we all try to steer clear of gender stereotypes, there is a reason they exist. Girls being nasty to one another at school is a noticeable issue and one a lot of us have personal experience with, and can also play out at home.

Like you said at a 'societal level' there is an issue with criminality in boys, such as gang violence and assault etc. but how often is your average family on Mumsnet impacted by this? Most posters claiming their boys are hard work are referring to petty arguments amongst siblings, wrestling, talking back, general difficult behaviour.

I'd say in your average loving family environment, there is no reason to believe that boys will be 'more hard work' in terms of behaviour than girls.
The challenges may be different, but a lot of it is personality dependent.

Also a quick Google of polls by parents shows that on the whole, boys are actually seen as easier to raise than girls.

Amyalexandrer · 29/11/2023 08:18

Summermeadowflowers · 28/11/2023 04:02

And, I hesitate to write this but bear with me.

I have a son (nearly 3) I love dearly, a lovely husband, my brother is lovely, my dad was too, as is FIL. I don’t want to sound anti men at all.

But, if I can speak generally for a moment - there’s a lot of ‘well I have girls and … the problem is four kids, not four boys …’ and this is always the case on threads about boy children being hard work or similar. I do understand we don’t want things to become a self fulfilling prophecy.

However, even a brief look at statistics do indicate big differences. Boys are far more likely to be permanently excluded and suspended from school. There are far more male prisoners than female, and they are more likely to have committed a violent or sexual offence.

How much of that is caused by the environment around boys and men and how much is innate, I don’t know. But I don’t think we do our sons any favours to ignore that and claim girls are somehow just as bad -
that might be true on an individual level but on a societal level, it isn’t. I don’t necessarily have the answers, but denying the question certainly isn’t it.

I understand where you're coming from but there are also studies that show that women and girls are more likely to perpetrate indirect and verbal aggression and digital/social media aggression. Whilst we all try to steer clear of gender stereotypes, there is a reason they exist. Girls being nasty to one another at school is a noticeable issue and one a lot of us have personal experience with, and can also play out at home.

Like you said at a 'societal level' there is an issue with criminality in boys, such as gang violence and assault etc. but how often is your average family on Mumsnet impacted by this? Most posters claiming their boys are hard work are referring to petty arguments amongst siblings, wrestling, talking back, general difficult behaviour.

I'd say in your average loving family environment, there is no reason to believe that boys will be 'more hard work' in terms of behaviour than girls.
The challenges may be different, but a lot of it is personality dependent.

AnnieG5 · 29/11/2023 07:17

I am 48 years old and just thought - for the first time ever - that it might be nice to go to a Christmas market. Definitely for old people…

ChristmasShopping23 · 28/11/2023 09:08

I am realistic these days about what we can do as a family. I refuse to take my dc to a restaurant any more after too many times where it was a disaster with everybody moody and at least one person storming off and then me footing the bill for something that no one enjoyed.

I’ve got girls btw but I do take the point that a pp made about more boys/young men in PRU and prisons although both my darling daughters did end up in a PRU.

Santibbz · 28/11/2023 08:37

I have 4 children, 13, 5, 3 and 1. I most certainly don’t post when my 5 year old and 3 year old are at each others throats. Or when my 1 year old is trying to escape in every direction and then screams when you put him in a pram/high chair. My middle two will attempt to start something but stop when I squash it as they understand we will be going home if they carry on. So it’s not always sunshine and rainbows but nobody ever sees that part of it, definitely don’t compare your family to other families you see on social media. My 13 SD is done with all of us so her face is 😐 no matter where we are 😂

lizzy8230 · 28/11/2023 08:35

@ItsCagain

See, the thing that jumps out at me is that when your first three boys were 9,7 and 5, all settled in school, you had a newborn. That's going to be a big age gap right the way through childhood and teenage years tbh. When the eldest becomes an adult, you'll still have one in primary school. It's a stretch to believe there are really that many activities and outings they can all enjoy together. I wouldn't have thought a Christmas market is an attractive proposition to many kids to be fair.

I know there are no guarantees that siblings will get along well, even twins, but at least with close ages they're more likely to be at he same stage and it's more likely to find family activities which work.

A 15 year old is at the stage of wanting to hang out with friends and be more independent, whereas your youngest at 6 is still very much at the age of needing constant supervision and being with mum and dad.

Your best bet really is to accept that whole family activities aren't likely to happen, so do things with them separately or perhaps the older three and then different activities for the 6 year old.

Wilfman · 28/11/2023 07:55

Growing up as one of 4 boys I would say this is reality. Kids of different ages, interests and perspectives.

Summermeadowflowers · 28/11/2023 04:02

And, I hesitate to write this but bear with me.

I have a son (nearly 3) I love dearly, a lovely husband, my brother is lovely, my dad was too, as is FIL. I don’t want to sound anti men at all.

But, if I can speak generally for a moment - there’s a lot of ‘well I have girls and … the problem is four kids, not four boys …’ and this is always the case on threads about boy children being hard work or similar. I do understand we don’t want things to become a self fulfilling prophecy.

However, even a brief look at statistics do indicate big differences. Boys are far more likely to be permanently excluded and suspended from school. There are far more male prisoners than female, and they are more likely to have committed a violent or sexual offence.

How much of that is caused by the environment around boys and men and how much is innate, I don’t know. But I don’t think we do our sons any favours to ignore that and claim girls are somehow just as bad -
that might be true on an individual level but on a societal level, it isn’t. I don’t necessarily have the answers, but denying the question certainly isn’t it.

Summermeadowflowers · 28/11/2023 03:44

@T1Dmama Why do kids fight with their siblings so much these days?

Er, sibling rivalry is the cause of the first recorded murder, if the Old Testament is to be believed! I don’t think it’s down to ‘these days’ at all.

Op, to be honest and at the risk of sounding like the grinch, I think Christmas is partly to do with it - combined with dark days, a hell of a long term at school, little chance to burn off energy, cooped up indoors more than normal and the build up makes for cranky kids of all ages. It will come right.

caringcarer · 28/11/2023 03:24

Could you take them out 2 at a time. My sister had 3 boys who squabbled a lot and a DD. She took them out 2 at a time leaving other 2 at home with her DH. He sometimes took 2 out as well leaving the other 2 at home with my sister. As they got older their behaviour improved but when she had 4 under 9 it was hard.

Mere1 · 28/11/2023 03:13

We have identical female twins. On a beach in Menorca, a total stranger came up to us to say she had thought twins always got on well together til she’d watched ours fighting as they played! We were later complimented on their immaculate table manners in a restaurant. They are as they are. Enjoy them. They grow up.

SkiingIsHeaven · 28/11/2023 02:51

I have one of each young adults now and they still embarrass me and tear strips off each other when we go out.

GrannyRose15 · 28/11/2023 01:13

This too will pass.

Bamboobzled · 28/11/2023 01:08

I have three boys OP. Can't take them anywhere without someone fighting someone. Can't imagine 4! Can feel your pain though as its hard work and exhausting. I also have a middle child who I suspect is on the spectrum and so cries over things like noise, crowds etc and is then ganged up on by the other two who don't understand that he's not trying to annoy them, it's just how he feels. I fought with my two brothers like cats and dogs though and now as adults we are all close. So despite the battles they can take you out all together when they are adults and treat you to a calm lunch hopefully!

BlueGrey1 · 28/11/2023 00:20

Would bribing them every once in a while work, maybe say we will go to McDonalds after if ye don’t fight, This might get them out of the habit of fighting

I will probably be slated for saying the above though

Cupcakekiller · 27/11/2023 23:19

I don't think 15 and 13 year olds need "memorable" family days out at that age. I have a ten year gap between my boy and girl and wouldn't have forced him into family Xmas activities at those ages beyond a meal out.