Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I shouldn’t have to stop my run to walk past a horse?

715 replies

Famousperson2023 · 25/11/2023 05:44

This has happened twice now. Out for a run and the horse riders have asked me to stop running while I go past their horse!!

I’ll put this in context- daughter rides, I used to ride. When passing a horse or pony I’ll go wide and slow, or stop and wait at a passing place on narrow roads (often while the riders amble up at a slow walk deep in conversation with their fellow riders, 3 abreast….and without a hint of thank you). When I’m out with our dog I’ll make sure she is on the lead while we pass. but being asked to stop and walk???

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Snowflakeslayer · 27/11/2023 09:15

All over the road and stinking, yes. It’s no different to any other excrement. It’s disgusting, and horse riders who think it’s acceptable are just as disgusting.

Fizbosshoes · 27/11/2023 09:15

I was reminded of this thread yesterday as I was out running and came across 2 horses.i stopped to walk for maybe 30 seconds max. I was out for over an hour and a half so adding 15 seconds (assuming I walked half as slow as I ran) was neither here not there. And the horses had santa hats on which made me smile!

Homebaby · 27/11/2023 09:14

This thread is frightening. The amount of people who don't seem to think they should be looking out for others aswell as themselves is staggering. Is this a sign of the way that society is going?

Malarandras · 27/11/2023 09:04

Here’s the thing folks - a horse is big, animal and can do you a serious damage. If you’re determined to take the risk of spooking it because ‘you have a right to be there’ well that’s up to you. But you’ll be the first to complain if you’re injured won’t you? I tend to go prioritise self-preservation over my ‘right’ to be anywhere. I guess everyone isn’t so sensible.

margotrose · 27/11/2023 09:01

Snowflakeslayer · 27/11/2023 08:47

Exactly, all horse riders should be made to do this immediately. It’s disgusting how they are allowed to leave their filth all over the roads.

Yeah, digested grass is just disgusting isn't it 😂

Conkered · 27/11/2023 08:56

@goldbar A horse and rider need 2m space and passing at less than 10mph to mitigate risk to all. That's indisputable. Ignorance is not a defence I'm afraid. Nor is "I had headphones in and was distracted by checking my app for my run time."

Getting bored of posting it, but....

[Riders] should respect your safety, but you [pedestrian] should take care not to obstruct or endanger them. Always remain aware of your [pedestrian] environment and avoid unnecessary distractions.

Why do you think 2m and such a low speed is specified? What might happen when that space/speed is not adhered to?

How about horse people take responsibility for do their best to manage their side of the risk, and people on foot take some responsibility for being aware of the environment they are entering into and take appropriate precautions. Such as not to potentially startle half a tonne of horse that has very likely recently become startled by some other idiot's ignorance?

Otherwise you are quite literally giving the majority of horses a life of misery/death sentence since they are then unable to get the exercise they need and are confined to going round in circles for the rest of their lives.

We then may as well go the whole hog and tarmac over bridleways to avoid trip hazards (we're almost at that stage so that cyclists can use them, making them less suitable for horses) and ban all domesticated species/farm machinery from the countryside where there are footpaths and bridleways, incase there's an accident involving them?

What about making bridleways just for those with bridles and those okay with the risk/willing to respect them (like the majority of users) and footpaths just for people on foot who are not okay with it?

Snowflakeslayer · 27/11/2023 08:47

Exactly, all horse riders should be made to do this immediately. It’s disgusting how they are allowed to leave their filth all over the roads.

Nomoremudplease68 · 27/11/2023 08:40

Snowflakeslayer · 27/11/2023 06:37

In the middle of the road? How is that good for Roses? Seriously!

Its very simple:

  1. Take a shovel and bucket
  2. Scoop
  3. Carry to garden
  4. Put on compost heap
  5. Apply to roses 12 months later
  6. Appreciate blooms
Worldgonecrazy · 27/11/2023 08:39

Happy to stop and walk for horses and dogs when out running. It has a minimal effect on me, and makes life easier for dog and horse owners alike. Even the most bomb proof horse and non-chasing dog can react in an unpredictable manner.

Pamcakey · 27/11/2023 08:37

This is one of the most ridiculous arguments I’ve ever heard.

Running and riding are both leisure activities. The right to do either does not trump either.
Therefore common sense would suggest safety trumps.

Animals are unpredictable by nature. The best trained horse in the world can still spook when it hears a noise coming up behind it in its blind spot.
Walking past when a rider asks you to do so makes both parties safer.

I mean, I feel you probably wouldn’t be too impressed if you were running on a bridleway and I came galloping past? In the same vein, in that scenario, I would walk past. It may be annoying for me - I compete and my horses need to be fit and there’s limited places to do fast work with them, however, that doesn’t mean I have the right to endanger or frighten someone by thundering past them. It goes both ways.

Nomoremudplease68 · 27/11/2023 08:37

Goldbar · 27/11/2023 01:58

If we should generally assume that riders aren't in control of their horses, then I'm afraid I agree with the poster above that maybe horses shouldn't be allowed on public land for the protection of the general public. But I'm sure this isn't what you meant to say.

Tbh I'm not sure why horses should be treated so differently from children, dogs, cars etc. Parents who aren't in control of their children and let them pose a danger to others are rightly criticised, likewise dog owners. And drivers who can't control their cars are told that they shouldn't be on the road.

Goldbar I’m afraid that your ignorance about horses is shining through in this post. They are prey animals with totally different temperaments to dogs. They have eyes on the side of their head and so have a vision blind spot behind them which means they can spook sometimes if they don’t see you approaching from the rear. This rider was trying to make things safer for you. Their intention was good.

Passepartoute · 27/11/2023 08:31

Goldbar · 27/11/2023 00:37

Or who are surprised that there are so many riders willing to put others in dangerous situations.

Where do you get that from? The complaint seems to be about riders trying to make other road users safe.

Hippyhippybake · 27/11/2023 08:11

Absolutely Bodger, it is this sort of complete arsehole behaviour which is making our society a worse place to live. It is so depressing to see so many on here unwilling to make a tiny adjustment to their own behaviour in order to obtain a better outcome for everyone. Fortunately IRL I continue to be cheered up by the kindness and generosity of strangers.

@sunglassesonthetable love the image of grumpy faced mumsnetters railing about these things, I'm sure it happens!

BodgerSparkins · 27/11/2023 07:31

This thread reminds me of the day I, as a teen, was horribly lost and distressed on a country path. Was it my fault I was lost? Yes. I tried to flag down a passing runner to ask if he could look at the map with me, his absolutely incredulous response 'I'm running! ' and he kept going. Did he every right to? Yes, he did. Would it have been nice for him to stop a moment and help even though he didn't have to? Yes.

I know it's different circumstances before any awfully wise person wishes to point that out, but honestly, if running and timing yourself is it not acceptable to just deduct a few seconds from your time at the end? Especially with wearables this is easy to do, to see how long you slowed or stopped?

It is sad reading how people don't even want to accept a moment's inconvenience because they should not 'have to', though that's pretty evident in some of the driving I witness on the roads as a pedestrian most days.

Even police horses have to be gradually acclimatised to the modern world, which is busy and largely given over to the car rather than foot traffic (runners included). We are all, by our reliance on cars because public transport is so shoddy, squashed into ever decreasing spaces. A little patience under the less than ideal circumstances goes a long way.

A rider up thread pointed out that they adjust their behaviour on bridleways for walkers, runners, children, people with dogs. Other people just as entitled to be there. Slowing their pace, stopping to let people stroke their horse etc. We're all just trying to get along, or should be.

sunglassesonthetable · 27/11/2023 06:58

Tbh I'm not sure why horses should be treated so differently from children, dogs, cars etc. Parents who aren't in control of their children and let them pose a danger to others are rightly criticised, likewise dog owners. And drivers who can't control their cars are told that they shouldn't be on the road.

What if you see a deer in the road and have to slow down? Are you annoyed at the land owner for not being in control?

What about a flock of pheasants? Are you annoyed at the game keeper for not being in control and you have to slow?

What about a farmer moving cattle on the road, best not to run right up and spook them, but you're saying farmer is not 'confidently in control'.

From your pov I have no idea why any of this allowed.

sunglassesonthetable · 27/11/2023 06:44

*Similarly, a rider who gets themselves into a position where they can’t confidently control their horse in a public place is at fault.
*
It's not ' a position' it's a standard precaution.

Accepting that there is always a risk ( horse could get spooked ) is NOT THE SAME as not being confidently in control.

People who are confidently in control, swimmers go into the sea all the time but are still aware of the element of risk ( weather could change )

I don't know why you keep talking about "fault". There is no fault knowing your horse has the potential to spook. Just as there is no fault knowing the sea could turn.

Snowflakeslayer · 27/11/2023 06:37

In the middle of the road? How is that good for Roses? Seriously!

Sayitaintso33 · 27/11/2023 05:15

Catsmere · 27/11/2023 00:33

Full of people who seem to think horses are machines with an off switch.

"A beggar on horseback lashes a beggar on foot"

Shouldbehoovering · 27/11/2023 05:00

Those saying the onus is on the rider - that is EXACTLY why they are asking you to walk… to minimise risk….

Even the safest horse can be spooked. That might have happened on the ride before you met the horse but the horses adrenaline will still be high and therefore more likely to react. Only the rider knows what is going on with the horse. In the absence of being able to assess risk yourself, I would listen to what is being asked of you.

Dibbydoos · 27/11/2023 03:57

@Famousperson2023 Yabu. If you scare the horse you, the horse and/ or the rider might get injured or die. Is it worth the risk?

Popsy09 · 27/11/2023 03:37

Please,please, please just walk past. A rider wouldn’t ask you to unless they feel their horse tense up or know their horse will react. It’s pretty scary feeling a horse tense up, not knowing what may happen next. Riders often don’t have anywhere else to ride. They don’t all have fancy yards, indoor/ outdoor schools with miles of off-road hacking. They just the want to get out in same way that cyclists, runners, bikers and walkers want to. Can’t we all just enjoy being outdoors and be kind and considerate to each other. Horses are flight animals and even the best behaved ones can have their unpredictable moments. And if you meet a rude rider that’s just them, the next one might be lovely but really need you to walk. That’s life; some folk are nice, some not so.. which one are you?

Goldbar · 27/11/2023 01:58

Catsmere · 27/11/2023 01:27

You're still talking as if a rider can control even the most placid horse fully, in all circumstances, and shouldn't be allowed out if something happens to startle the horse. And all this bad grace unless they're apologetic when they do take the responsible measures - advising runners to slow down as they approach from behind - I mean, wtf? What's so precious about seconds of a runner's time? If you're (general you) in that much of a hurry and can't cope with slowing down for a moment, maybe you, the runner, are the one who shouldn't be out.

If we should generally assume that riders aren't in control of their horses, then I'm afraid I agree with the poster above that maybe horses shouldn't be allowed on public land for the protection of the general public. But I'm sure this isn't what you meant to say.

Tbh I'm not sure why horses should be treated so differently from children, dogs, cars etc. Parents who aren't in control of their children and let them pose a danger to others are rightly criticised, likewise dog owners. And drivers who can't control their cars are told that they shouldn't be on the road.

MeinKraft · 27/11/2023 01:57

Goldbar · 26/11/2023 23:29

I find this thread so odd. It's like a parallel universe.

It seems to me so self-evidently obvious that you should take responsibility for an animal under your control not harming others that I'm wondering if I'm missing something. And that this responsibility is not discharged by a hurried warning demanding that those around you change their behaviour to avoid the danger that you have created.

Of course, if you put others in danger, you should of course warn them so they can take steps to avoid it. But then to blame them if they fail for whatever reason to avoid the danger you yourself have knowingly created... honestly, I'm gobsmacked that some people think this is OK.

I find it like a parallel universe too but from an opposite POV. I am not horsey, don't know many people who are. But I have enough awareness of animals and safety and common decency to know you approach horses slowly and give them plenty of room. How do people not know this? I can't imagine a world where someone has cause to run around country roads, fields and paths and doesn't know that you shouldn't spook a horse...because it will potentially harm the horse/rider/you/anything nearby that gets caught in its path especially if it runs onto a main road. You don't just run past and say fuck it, that's not my responsibility if the horse bolts. It's about caring for your community and everyone in it.

Nomoremudplease68 · 27/11/2023 01:54

However, if they were apologetic, I’d probably accept with a good grace that we all make mistakes now and then.

Wow. I generally try not to be rude to people on Mumsnet, or when out riding, but are you aware how supercilious this makes you sound?

I’d like to know how you would react to someone actually being impolite as opposed to someone trying to make the situation safer for you and them.

Catsmere · 27/11/2023 01:27

You're still talking as if a rider can control even the most placid horse fully, in all circumstances, and shouldn't be allowed out if something happens to startle the horse. And all this bad grace unless they're apologetic when they do take the responsible measures - advising runners to slow down as they approach from behind - I mean, wtf? What's so precious about seconds of a runner's time? If you're (general you) in that much of a hurry and can't cope with slowing down for a moment, maybe you, the runner, are the one who shouldn't be out.