Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I shouldn’t have to stop my run to walk past a horse?

715 replies

Famousperson2023 · 25/11/2023 05:44

This has happened twice now. Out for a run and the horse riders have asked me to stop running while I go past their horse!!

I’ll put this in context- daughter rides, I used to ride. When passing a horse or pony I’ll go wide and slow, or stop and wait at a passing place on narrow roads (often while the riders amble up at a slow walk deep in conversation with their fellow riders, 3 abreast….and without a hint of thank you). When I’m out with our dog I’ll make sure she is on the lead while we pass. but being asked to stop and walk???

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
LakieLady · 26/11/2023 12:18

Cloudysky81 · 25/11/2023 22:08

I’m amazed so many people come across horses whilst running. I’ve lived in a variety of places across the UK and never have. Presumably it’s more trail running?

I would be annoyed if I had to stop though, I know nothing about horses, so probably would as they seem quite dangerous.

I've seen horses being walked along the roads in Croydon, where I grew up. There was a stables near my old school, which has probably closed now to make way for housing, but my niece used to ride out from a stables near her home on the outskirts of the borough.

I live in Sussex now, a few miles from Brighton, and it's not uncommon to see horses being ridden along the high street.

Pelham678 · 26/11/2023 11:15

napody · 26/11/2023 10:15

Couldn't you dismount and stand still with them for a moment?

Because clearly it's so much easier for a rider to dismount and stand there then have to remount to facilitate a runner, which might happen countless times, than the runner to just walk for ten seconds. And you talk about entitlement. 🙄

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 26/11/2023 11:05

Also, why should runners who can easily walk for ten or fifteen seconds take priority over riders, who as just discussed will have a LOT more inconvenience from having to dismount.

margotrose · 26/11/2023 10:44

napody · 26/11/2023 10:15

Couldn't you dismount and stand still with them for a moment?

You could, but it would be a lot more dangerous.

You have much more control over a horse while you're on it than you do if you're standing next to it. Horses can weigh up to a ton in weight (if not more) - a human on the ground would have absolutely no chance of controlling one if it decided to rear or bolt. They would also be at serious risk of injury. A kick to the head from a horse can kill you.

There's also the issue of getting back on again safely if there's nothing nearby to use as a mounting block.

thenightsky · 26/11/2023 10:38

Couldn't you dismount and stand still with them for a moment?

Its a hundred times easier to control a frightened horse when you are sat on top, it really is. Plus remounting again has its own issues such as the horse wheeling around in the road and bouncing about whilst you've got only one foot in a stirrup so you're hopping.

napody · 26/11/2023 10:24

I don't know, that was why I was asking!

It just seems like such a risk to rely on being able to control your environment (and everyone in it) to such an extent. If I were running, I'd do as requested, but be irritated at the sense of entitlement.

MeinKraft · 26/11/2023 10:19

@napody do you think that if you dismount and stand with the horse that will stop it bolting if it gets spooked?

backinthebox · 26/11/2023 10:17

@Tomasinabombadil I do know that group, I am not in it. I am already quite busy with various horse access groups, but often the PWAS posts are shared in the access group pages. I think there is a range of levels of evangelism in some groups that I don’t always align myself with.

napody · 26/11/2023 10:15

Homebaby · 25/11/2023 06:37

I'll start by saying that I always thank drivers who slow down in a car or wait for me to pass. However, passing wide and slow is in the highway code and shouldn't need a pat on the back, plus I'd have thought that waiting in a safe place is just common decency? While I agree that a thank you takes virtually zero effort you are after all just following the law and being a considerate driver?
As regards them asking you to walk past them, if they've felt the need to ask then it's most likely for a reason. I ride some who I know are unpredictable so I'll always ask for people to be more cautious when passing me be it in a car or on foot when I'm on them. Some horses can whip round or bolt in the blink of an eye without even an experienced rider able to do anything about it. The way I see it is that I'm keeping myself, the horse and you and your passengers safe. You will get to your destination far quicker without a trip to a and e thrown in to the mix.
Unfortunately most riders don't have the luxury of private land to ride on. Believe me, we would all rather not have to ride in public places but it's not always possible so we have to rely on people being sensible when we meet. And after all, we are as entitled as you are to be in that public place.

Couldn't you dismount and stand still with them for a moment?

backinthebox · 26/11/2023 10:13

category12 · 26/11/2023 09:58

Shouting is not great around horses. 😂

Just take a moment to say hello and walk past. It's a minor inconvenience.

I disagree. A shouted ‘hello, just passing’ is much better than running up quickly and quietly in the horse’s blind spot and then popping into view at the very last minute, triggering the bit of the horse’s brain (even a well trained one’s) that stores the genetic memory of mountain lions jumping out on them. If they hear a human voice behind, even if they cannot see it, they are aware there is a human there and nothing to be afraid of. This applies particularly to cyclists, but also to runners.

My horses, most horses for that matter, are kept in fields and large barns where the standard form of human communication is to bellow at each other in order to hear each other over a distance. The fact that humans are noisy creatures is not scary to them. Horses are not afraid of a shouted greeting or informative shout that a runner or cyclist is passing them.

A shout is perfectly fine. (A scream, a shout accompanied by flapping arms, etc, less so, but those are completely different to a quick polite shout.)

ACynicalDad · 26/11/2023 10:08

It's a training run not a race and the rider knows their horse. I'd walk for a few seconds.

Tomasinabombadil · 26/11/2023 10:02

@backinthebox
“Pass Wide & Slow”
It’s a group dedicated to raising awareness for all road users of the Highway Code legislation stating that horses should only be passed (when it is safe to do so) at a width of no less than 2 metres & no more than 10mph.
Also refers to off road, bridleways & country tracks with cyclists, runners, dog walkers etc., passing horses & riders.
They encourage riders to wear hi-viz & cameras to record bad behaviour especially from drivers & report to their local police force.

To think I shouldn’t have to stop my run to walk past a horse?
category12 · 26/11/2023 09:58

Shouting is not great around horses. 😂

Just take a moment to say hello and walk past. It's a minor inconvenience.

MissingMoominMamma · 26/11/2023 09:55

If you shout and slow down a bit, it shouldn’t be a problem.

I wish runners would shout when approaching people or dogs from behind too. It can startle when you appear from nowhere at speed.

Conkered · 26/11/2023 09:35

If you're too close and/or fast and the horse spins there's a high risk you're going to get squashed or kicked, either in the moment or by the loose horse, if the rider has come off and it panics. If a loose horse then gets onto a highway and causes an accident there's a risk to others not involved in the original incident!

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 26/11/2023 09:25

I’m slightly baffled at the number of posts insisting that it’s for the runner’s safety and I agree that it would be less reasonable to ride on the road if horses responded to surprise runners with aggression. They don’t unless for some reason you’re running past a wild/undomesticated stallion with babies to protect. They might catch people by accident while they’re panicking, but often they’ll actually make an effort not to run over or hit people. The main danger if a horse spooks is to the rider - a fall off a 16hh horse onto tarmac is no joke and people get horrific injuries from it - and the secondary danger is to the horse, which could get tangled up in the reins, bolt and fall (also not a joke if you’re a frightened creature which weighs about 500kg, crashing onto your bony knees on a road) and multiple other problems.
Also, all these people saying horses should be trained before they go on the road - how exactly are you proposing they be trained? It’s like saying cyclists should be taught the rules of the road before they cycle on it - yes, they should, but you’ll find some angry motorists who would be intensely frustrated if they had to slow down for learner cyclists as it were. I had a mare who was so bombproof she once stood very calmly while a lorry loaded with hay passed us closely enough to squash my leg. I didn’t train her but I imagine that when she was younger that took hours of careful exposure to traffic and there’s no way you can get that without some consideration from road users. ALL road users.

Conkered · 26/11/2023 09:09

Great post @backinthebox

It's also worth remembering that should there be an accident involving a horse, the owner will likely be facing expensive veterinary costs. To the run of the mill struggling horse owner (the teachers/office workers/nurses/hair dressers without plums in their mouths) these can be quite crippling! It's like having an extra child but with no NHS back up or welfare safety net.

I had a good contingency fund and insurance when I bought my horse and which got blown in the first 3 years, all due to things beyond my control and a huge amount of bad luck.

To make an insurance claim the owner/rider will need to explain in detail everything they've done to minimise risks. If you've carefully done all of that, then as mentioned above you have a horse in rehab that has to be retrained/brought back into work slowly, the risks from re-injury and exclusions from insurance for the same issue after a year has passed can be very stressful to manage. Should a member of the public get hurt, they will also likely be facing a public liability claim. So this might relate somewhat to why horse riders may seem bossy over a seemingly minor thing - it's not personal or because they are up themselves, it's often because of full awareness of the realities that make preventing injury or accident vital. Their (and their horse's) stakes in the need for a safe outcome are often higher than you realise.

backinthebox · 26/11/2023 08:12

@Tomasinabombadil not a member of that group, I don’t know what it is.

@TwoShades1 @Famousperson2023 and anyone else still wondering - I do sort of agree that if a running person is going to really upset the horse then it probably needs more training before being put in that situation.

I shouldn’t need to explain this in this much detail, but I will, and I hope it explains to you and all the ‘well if the horse is not trained it shouldn’t be there’s.

My horse is very brave. He has had a considerable amount of training. He has performed in front of cheering crowds of up to 10000 people, in main arenas round the UK and abroad. He has taken part in parades, carrying a flag, walked past air horns being blown. He has stood quietly and calmly and gazed at the humans around him, those cheering, those running at him, and never moved a muscle. But he is currently injured, and is not able to keep up the amount of ridden work and training he has been used to all his life. After some time off completely, he is now allowed to be walked out. He is excited at this prospect, but it is important to keep him calm, as we want him to recover, not relapse his injury.

It doesn’t take much to get him a bit overexcited. In normal times I would just tell him to get over himself and calm down. But it is essential to his recovery to stay calm. If some jogger who could not spare 10 seconds of their life to slow down past my horse when I politely asked them to felt it was necessary to keep up
their pace because they once met a poorly behaved rider elsewhere, then yes - I would feel perfectly entitled to call them a fuckwit.

But there is more!

Periodically, we get new horses in. I like the same sensible sort, the sort you could ride into the pub beer garden and enjoy a pint without it spilling your drink. Because of what I do with my horses, all of them will eventually be called on to perform in front of a busy crowd. So although I have bought a calm horse, when they move house it can take a while for a horse to settle. It doesn’t mean the horse is not calm, or well trained, but it does mean we might ask a little from the people we meet (nothing that would inconvenience them or cause them harm, just perhaps to pass us a little wider or slower) until we know the horse better and the horse knows and puts its trust in us.

Sometimes my children will be on these horses that need a little more space, a little bit less excitement. All of us are perfectly entitled to enjoyed a peaceful and pleasant ride, just as runners are entitled to a peaceful and pleasant run. Sometimes, in sharing space, rider, runner or both has to make a small adjustment to path and speed. I will always stop my horse and stand to the side to allow a runner past, I won’t even ask them to slow down. I normally just smile and say hello as they run past. But if, for any reason, I felt my horse begin to tighten up,,I would politely suggest to the runner they pass us at walk. I wouldn’t consider this to be a rude request. I’m baffled that anyone would interpret it as a rude request!

I take part in events at a high level that bring me into public spaces and into contact with other users of them. I’ve managed to win national titles whilst still also managing to stand aside for a few seconds to let a mountain biker or dog walker pass. I’m pretty sure I have never lost a competition because I waited politely for a member of the public to pass me, and I’m pretty sure that your average jogger is not going to scupper their training regime because they had to break pace for a few seconds for a horse.

I’ll continue to smile and greet runners as I stand aside for them, and assume that most of them are quite happy to be sharing the fresh air and lovely countryside with other users. Only a few are entitled knobs who think no one else should have the temerity to interrupt their activities.

JMSA · 26/11/2023 04:54

How does it hurt you, to stop running for one minute? You're being petty.

SamphireAndSalmon · 26/11/2023 04:29

dontgochangingagain · 26/11/2023 02:40

Maybe the horse gets spooked easily.

It sounds like the rider is being sensible and just looking out for everyone so no accidents occur.

Surely it's better than not saying anything and the horse then kicked out or bolted.

Yep

Catsmere · 26/11/2023 02:59

wesurecouldstandgladioli · 25/11/2023 14:54

They want OP to stop whilst they go on.

They should stop the fuck down.

As has been pointed out multiple times on this thread, that's increasing the risk to horse, rider and runner, not decreasing it.

Asking a runner to pause for a minute or two so the riders can move past them seems entirely reasonable to me.

Catsmere · 26/11/2023 02:49

AlwaysGinPlease · 25/11/2023 14:27

I wonder if the anti horse wankers are also the anti dog wankers? 🤔

Oh yes, they crop up on the same threads.

dontgochangingagain · 26/11/2023 02:40

Maybe the horse gets spooked easily.

It sounds like the rider is being sensible and just looking out for everyone so no accidents occur.

Surely it's better than not saying anything and the horse then kicked out or bolted.

TwoShades1 · 26/11/2023 01:53

I do sort of agree that if a running person is going to really upset the horse then it probably needs more training before being put in that situation. Especially as not everyone will be polite and things can still happen unexpectedly. But as a horse person surely you would feel really bad if of you caused a terrible accident and the rider/horse were badly hurt?

Kittylala · 26/11/2023 01:26

It doesn't hurt to be respectful when sharing the road x

Swipe left for the next trending thread