Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a 10yo too young?

55 replies

nosoworried · 25/11/2023 05:31

After looking for ages for a job, I have managed to find one, but that means I can not pick up my 10yo (Y6) from school. We have about 5 bus stops (10mins) to our home with about 15 mins walk to a bus stop from school. My 10yo finished 10mins earlier then my older child in Y9.
AINBU to think that it is ok for a younger child to wait for their older sibling by the school (both schools are 3 mins walk) and for them both to travel home together? Older sibling is ok with that (reluctantly, naturally!)
Dad will get home after an hour after children.
I have been SAHM (but running my own little business on the side) for as long as they were born, so, naturally, hyperventilating to let them out of my sight.
We live on the outskirts of London.

OP posts:
tiggergoesbounce · 25/11/2023 07:41

I dont think kids should be responsible for their siblings, also i dont think its faie that they potentially miss out on things in their life to care for their sibling.

If you think your younger one can take responsibility for themselves and could easily get themselves home then i think it would be fine, but waiting around in the rain and cold doesn't sound great.

cariadlet · 25/11/2023 07:36

I let my dd go home on her own in year 6.
5 minutes walk from school to bus stop, 20 minutes bus ride, 10 minutes walk the other end.

The only problem was one day when she couldn't open the front door (the lock is awkward) so went next-door and asked if she could wait there until I got home.
Worth talking through what your dc would do in various scenarios.

One rainy afternoon my dd was spotted at the bus stop and offered a lift home by an adult she knows but refused because I had drummed into her that you don't go with any adult, even one you know, without checking with the adult who is responsible for you at the time.

That's something I would emphasise after cases like that of poor little April Jones (she thought her murderer was safe to go with because it was her friend's dad).

Desecratedcoconut · 25/11/2023 07:23

Yeah, our y5 and y6s can just go home by themselves, but owing to the catchment area, most primary school kids are in walking distance of home.

Unless this is a trip your kid can do on their own then I would be cautious. What happens if your older kid gets waylaid, needs to take an after school class, gets a detention? I think the logistics get tricky and potential for things to go wrong.

Benibidibici · 25/11/2023 07:18

Nb our school the y6 would be allowed to just go home themselves.

If you want them to go together, id have the y6 walk to the y9s school to meet up as if it finishes 10 mins later there'll be lots of people milling around.

Kittenkitty · 25/11/2023 07:15

I’m not being rude but it’s a question none of us can answer. As we don’t know the school and the surrounding area. There is nobody by my kids school 10 mins after pick up so they’d be quite vulnerable there alone. I also think a child stood waiting is more vulnerable than a moving child. My kids school also have an after school club which I’d use.
Do you know any school Mums? Maybe speak to them about solutions.

Benibidibici · 25/11/2023 07:15

socialising, hobbies, clubs, sports etc after school occasionally ie once or twice a week are so important for so many reasons

Why can't they just do it a bit later? Its only an hour and then their dad is home.

Benibidibici · 25/11/2023 07:13

Tbh I'd either put the year 6 in childcare or wait until they are in year 7 to get a job that's out of school hours.

Oh dfod. Its completely normal to work full time with primary aged kids, its called "keeping a roof over their head". Most year 6s will be fuming at being sent to an asc when they could go home with an older sibling.

bitchatty · 25/11/2023 07:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Benibidibici · 25/11/2023 07:10

I don't think it's very fair on a y9 child to have to go and collect a younger sibling every day. They will want to hang out with friends unless they have urgent homework.

What has happened to the world? Why can't a 14 year old be given some small responsibilities within the family? Wants come after needs. When i was a child (90s) it was absolutely a given that secondary age kids would walk younger siblings home from school. Few kids hung out after school, you had homework, jobs, chores at home, sports practise, music etc and it was common to have to be home minding younger siblings.

We ask too little of teenagers these days, it makes for spoiled youngsters who aren't used to pitching in and doing things for others.

Autieangel · 25/11/2023 07:07

Tbh I'd either put the year 6 in childcare or wait until they are in year 7 to get a job that's out of school hours.

I worked from home until mine were 12 and 14 .

sashh · 25/11/2023 06:58

Make sure they both have a phone to tell each other if one will be late.

Check your eldest's schools policy on things like detentions, you don't want a same day detention.

Check with the youngest's school, they may be able to wait in reception.

cornflakesandtea · 25/11/2023 06:53

Would the secondary school be okay with your 10yo waiting inside reception? At least he'll be safe and dry while waiting for his sibling and there'll be adults around who can help in an emergency.

CasperGutman · 25/11/2023 06:48

Plenty of Y6 kids round here get themselves home from school with no problem. It's a 'nice' area with plenty of people around. They mostly walk with groups of friends, but not all of them all the time, of course. My Y7 DS (who is in some ways a bit 'younger' than his classmates) gets himself home with no issues. It's a 25 minute walk.

I don't think it's out of the question to ask a Y6 child to make their own way home. I'd probably prefer the idea of him heading home than waiting for his sibling, somehow. A child travelling seems somehow less vulnerable than one hanging around on the street. If he waits at the primary school he could be there for 20 minutes quite routinely, even without anything going particularly wrong - 10 mins until the end of the secondary school day, another 3-5 for the walk, older child's teacher takes an extra 2 mins letting them out or he needs to speak to someone after school or forgot something in a different classroom etc. That's a long time to be hanging around alone on the street, in the dark at this time of year. And does the Y9 never have activities after school?

It probably depends on the child, and on the journey. Will he be in a busy area with plenty of people around? Are there safe pavements to walk? Is it well lit? Is he familiar with the journey, including catching the bus, or as he only travelled that way passively in the back of a car?

SwedishSchnauzer · 25/11/2023 06:26

Yes I think this is fine, there may even be other children that he can walk with to the big school and your eldest can coordinate the rest. Year 6 is a good age to take steps of independence.

do a practice run with him after school.

Vaguely chat about what to do in different situations - illness, lost pass, bag left on bus, weirdos approaching him, late out of school, missed bus, no busses, missing the bus stop, extreme weather

Mummyoflittledragon · 25/11/2023 06:23

That sounds fine to me. Kids will still be hanging around at school so your youngest can effectively stay on school property. Only one more month to the shortest day. You need a contingency for if something happens and your teen doesn’t turn up.

MortifiedSeptember · 25/11/2023 06:22

I used to pick my brothers and sisters from school when I was in year 9. It was fine, but I finished before them and I was the one waiting 10min.
It wasn't hardship for me and I enjoyed it. The odd days I couldn't make it, dm friend picked them up. I was old enough and I knew if I needed to do something something else I would need to tell dm in advance.

Newuser75 · 25/11/2023 06:17

I'd trust my 10 year old to do this providing the older one agreed and they both had phones in case of a change of plan or wherever.

I'd also make sure the 10 year old knew how to get home by himself in case of an emergency.

PuttingDownRoots · 25/11/2023 06:12

The biggest flaw in your plan would be the yr9 not appearing for whatever reason. Would your younger child know what to do?

bitchatty · 25/11/2023 06:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Iamblocked2 · 25/11/2023 06:00

I would let the y6 child to make their own way home. it's getting ready for high school and a good step towards a bit more independence. If that isn't an option (special needs or so), use an after school club? I don't think it's fair to put the onus for collection on the older sibling.

christmasdodedodedo · 25/11/2023 06:00

christmasdodedodedo · 25/11/2023 05:37

For me there are too many moments in the whole process where something could go wrong and it isn't fair for the 10 year old to have that responsibility. They're both just that bit too young still.

Sorry, probably not what you need to hear.

Ah, I've read it wrong. In Scotland so we don't have Y9 so thought that was a 9 year old.

Yes, that seems more manageable as long as older sibling complies

YireosDodeAver · 25/11/2023 05:52

I don't think it's very fair on a y9 child to have to go and collect a younger sibling every day. They will want to hang out with friends unless they have urgent homework.
I think you need a wraparound care/after school club for the 10yo to go to until DH is available an hour later.

DoAWheelie · 25/11/2023 05:48

christmasdodedodedo · 25/11/2023 05:37

For me there are too many moments in the whole process where something could go wrong and it isn't fair for the 10 year old to have that responsibility. They're both just that bit too young still.

Sorry, probably not what you need to hear.

They are 10 and 13/14, not 9 and 10 years old as you seem to have read. The 10 year old is the younger sibling not the older.

Mothership4two · 25/11/2023 05:46

So 10 year old walks 3 minutes to meet 13 year old, they walk 15 minutes together to bus stop which takes 10 minutes to reach your home. If you think they are both sensible enough to stick with this and the 10 year old is happy to do this then I would be OK with it. I don't live in London though, but you know the areas. I would probably get them to do a couple of trial runs first and go over emergency back up plans with them.

DoAWheelie · 25/11/2023 05:46

I traveled home a similar distance alone from year 5 onwards. Let myself in with a key and then watched an episode of the Pokémon anime before my parents got home. With a 13-14 year old with them they should be fine.

Maybe ask the younger ones teacher if they could keep an eye out to make sure they wait for their sibling for the first couple of weeks while they get used to the new arrangement.