Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel uncomfortable at the amount he has spent

318 replies

JonnaMam · 25/11/2023 03:30

I started seeing a man in February, we both have children they are 18 (he has twins b/g and I have a son). We took things really slow, we are both widows/widowers (met through a support group), didn't want to impose on them. In September they all left for uni, we did a lunch with them all before.
My son has been home a couple of times and spent time with my partner and I.
We spoke to all the kids and agreed we will spent Christmas together, he has a guest room which will be my sons room for the week.
I have picked up a couple of bits for my son, but I don't go all out anymore.

Well my partner has bought all the kids a whole new suite of technology from apple. He wanted to do it before they went to uni, but was waiting for his bonus.
He has bought them each a MacBook Pro, Ipad Pro, Iphone 15 Pro, Apple Watch, Airpods and Airpods Pro (why on earth both I don't know). He's spent little less than £20,000 and said we can still get them a few more bits.

I don't earn nearly as much as he does, to me £20,000 is a deposit on a house (my house is barely worth more than £120,000 these days), It makes me very uncomfortable.
AIBU to say he should return what is for my son? It isn't my business what he gets his kids, but he barely knows my son and it is so much money!!

OP posts:
Itsmehi222 · 25/11/2023 08:00

How would you feel if his children opened all those presents and your son has nothing? Or how would your son feel? At 18, I might be quite embarrassed if I was him and they had significantly so much more then me.

Peoples incomes and expenses can be drastically different, I think it’s so nice he’s considered your son and his feelings. I’m not sure why you’re so upset by it, is it because you’re unable to do it yourself?

He can afford it and he wants to, perhaps it’s just not that much to him. A lot of men wouldn’t give a shit and exclude your son. He sounds thoughtful and kind.

EarringsandLipstick · 25/11/2023 07:59

He will likely feel good that he has purchased them

I mean, as long as he feels good, that's the main thing 🙄

mrssunshinexxx · 25/11/2023 07:58

I think it's really generous that he's including your son I take this that he really wants him to feel included. If there are no red flags and your relationship is great I would just say a very big thank you and hopefully your son will to!

CantFindTheBeat · 25/11/2023 07:58

Pleasegotobed · 25/11/2023 03:41

That is no where near 20k of tech OP.. is there something he’s bought that you haven’t posted?

I bet it is. All those items for 3 people.

Emeraldrings · 25/11/2023 07:58

I thought it was going to be that he'd got all that just for his kids and yours would be left out but he's included your son which is really nice.
It's a lot but I bet your son will appreciate it. Maybe you can tell your partner you don't spend that much normally but you appreciate him treating your son like his own children.

Spirallingdownwards · 25/11/2023 07:57

EarringsandLipstick · 25/11/2023 07:49

This has to be one of the daftest responses I've seen

So many assumptions about the cost & affordability.

And then - he knows it's for life and because you haven't said otherwise he assumes you feel the same? Dear. God.

The assumptions about affordability are based on the OP saying he is well off and his wife has passed. Anyone sensible with their finances would have insurance covering mortgage and life assurance. It is not therefore that much of a jump to assume he did.

I am not saying he knows it is for life but that I did so PERHAPS he feels like this.

Yours us one of the grumpiest responses I have seen. Dear God yourself 🤣

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 07:55

ActDottie · 25/11/2023 07:52

Yes it’s a lot but he’s treating your son the same as his kids which is lovely

Is it lovely for an adult child who has lost his father?

It runs counter to all advice on how to merge families.

TrishyLou1111 · 25/11/2023 07:54

JonnaMam · 25/11/2023 03:30

I started seeing a man in February, we both have children they are 18 (he has twins b/g and I have a son). We took things really slow, we are both widows/widowers (met through a support group), didn't want to impose on them. In September they all left for uni, we did a lunch with them all before.
My son has been home a couple of times and spent time with my partner and I.
We spoke to all the kids and agreed we will spent Christmas together, he has a guest room which will be my sons room for the week.
I have picked up a couple of bits for my son, but I don't go all out anymore.

Well my partner has bought all the kids a whole new suite of technology from apple. He wanted to do it before they went to uni, but was waiting for his bonus.
He has bought them each a MacBook Pro, Ipad Pro, Iphone 15 Pro, Apple Watch, Airpods and Airpods Pro (why on earth both I don't know). He's spent little less than £20,000 and said we can still get them a few more bits.

I don't earn nearly as much as he does, to me £20,000 is a deposit on a house (my house is barely worth more than £120,000 these days), It makes me very uncomfortable.
AIBU to say he should return what is for my son? It isn't my business what he gets his kids, but he barely knows my son and it is so much money!!

He sounds very generous, OP.

It is lovely he has included your son, too. Yes, it's extravagant, but they are all useful for university students, and I personally think it's very thoughtful.

Maybe say something like

That is a lot of money, and you really didn't need to do that, but thank you so much. He will love them.

Don't offend by telling him to return. He will likely feel good that he has purchased them.

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 07:54

EarringsandLipstick · 25/11/2023 07:48

Some of these answers 🤦🏻‍♀️

Of course it's problematic, on multiple levels.

It's way too much money, for well,anyone someone in his position - mum's boyfriend.

It's completely outside the norms for what OP would usually gift

It's a whole heap of tech, some duplicated - does DS even want these items?

It may well be done with good intentions, but it's still making certain assumptions about the relationship & how serious it is.

I would absolutely be talking to him, explaining your concerns & limiting these gifts - just the AirPods are an amazing gift.

I agree.

He's steamrolled the entire tone of the Christmas, it's really very weird.

Many of my twat detectors are going off:
-unilateral decisions
-excessive largesse
-symmetry of gift despite relationship difference
-overstepping boundaries

EveryKneeShallBow · 25/11/2023 07:53

wideawakeinthemiddleofthenightagain · 25/11/2023 05:53

I'm surprised at everyone saying how lovely this is as I was expecting a load of people saying "red flags".
Personally, I'd be really uncomfortable with this.
That's £6.5k that he has spent on your son. Lots of people have said that it's "setting them up for Uni presents" but all of the DC have been at Uni for a term so must have had enough tech to manage until then.
I'm also slightly suspicious of someone whose bonus means they have this much cash to burn in November but couldn't have bought it in September. How well does he manage cash?
I'm also not sure about the whole idea of all spending Christmas week together. I imagine Christmas must be an emotional time for you all and this is your first Christmas of knowing each other. How do the gifts play into this? Will you put up with behaviour you wouldn't usually do knowing the cost of the presents? What about your son? How will his DC feel seeing that he's got your son the same as they've got.
What on earth has he got you for Christmas?

@wideawakeinthemiddleofthenightagain has said exactly what I was thinking. This makes me uncomfortable, let alone you.

EarringsandLipstick · 25/11/2023 07:52

namethisbird · 25/11/2023 07:51

What a lovely, kind and generous man you have OP.
Take a moment to read through some of the multiple posts on here from women who have chosen partners who don’t treat their children well or refuse to contribute as they don’t want to provide for their child.
Then you may see how lucky you are to have a partner who has thought about including your son in his lovely generous gifts
Dont put your son at a detriment just because you feel uncomfortable. Apple tech will be useful for him for university.

Are you serious?

You can be 'lovely & thoughtful' for less than £6k - for your girlfriend's son, in a new relationship.

The idea he has to do it because he is doing it for his own DC is nuts.

ActDottie · 25/11/2023 07:52

Yes it’s a lot but he’s treating your son the same as his kids which is lovely

EarringsandLipstick · 25/11/2023 07:51

LOL at the PPs claiming an 18 year old will feel awkward about receiving a tonne of Apple products

Why LOL?

I have teens. Sure they'd like some of these items. Not a whole heap of them.

One has just got a new phone following a relative's upgrade - they don't need a new phone, it would be pointless.

Gifts aren't about 'loads of expensive stuff'. They should be about what someone needs or wants, or will see as valuable to them.

namethisbird · 25/11/2023 07:51

What a lovely, kind and generous man you have OP.
Take a moment to read through some of the multiple posts on here from women who have chosen partners who don’t treat their children well or refuse to contribute as they don’t want to provide for their child.
Then you may see how lucky you are to have a partner who has thought about including your son in his lovely generous gifts
Dont put your son at a detriment just because you feel uncomfortable. Apple tech will be useful for him for university.

EarringsandLipstick · 25/11/2023 07:49

Spirallingdownwards · 25/11/2023 07:45

He is well off, his wife has passed, his mortgage has presumably been paid off by insurance, he may have had other insurance pay out too and it may be his chance to do a one off gesture for the kids at the time where decent tech may be useful to them. Perhaps Apple did him a deal buying that much at once. He may have even used his kids student numbers to get the apple student discount so he wouldn't have paid full retail price anyway.

By all means have a conversation with him but it is a 10 month relationship and I know I knew within 3 months that I was going to be with my husband. Perhaps he feels the same and you haven't indicated otherwise so he assumes you do too.

Edited

This has to be one of the daftest responses I've seen

So many assumptions about the cost & affordability.

And then - he knows it's for life and because you haven't said otherwise he assumes you feel the same? Dear. God.

Peablockfeathers · 25/11/2023 07:49

He is well off, his wife has passed, his mortgage has presumably been paid off by insurance, he may have had other insurance pay out too

This was my thought too, he probably has money and is happy to spend it on stuff he knows will be well recieved (LOL at the PPs claiming an 18 year old will feel awkward about receiving a tonne of Apple products).

The crux is that it's probably too soon to be mixing Christmasses but it is different as they're a bit older and live away, they're not small children. I suspect he just thought it would be hideously savage to have Xmas together and to have his children open a tonne of expensive gifts and for your son to be sat watching. Unless there are other red flags it seems thoughtful to me.

CurlewKate · 25/11/2023 07:48

@JonnaMam I would be uncomfortable too- apart from anything else what's he going to give you! And I think your son might find it difficult to get so much from a virtual stranger. If I were you l, I would give him a heads up. I know it will spoil the the surprise, and he'll have to pretend he didn't know. But I don't think it's fair not to warn him.

EarringsandLipstick · 25/11/2023 07:48

Some of these answers 🤦🏻‍♀️

Of course it's problematic, on multiple levels.

It's way too much money, for well,anyone someone in his position - mum's boyfriend.

It's completely outside the norms for what OP would usually gift

It's a whole heap of tech, some duplicated - does DS even want these items?

It may well be done with good intentions, but it's still making certain assumptions about the relationship & how serious it is.

I would absolutely be talking to him, explaining your concerns & limiting these gifts - just the AirPods are an amazing gift.

Spirallingdownwards · 25/11/2023 07:45

He is well off, his wife has passed, his mortgage has presumably been paid off by insurance, he may have had other insurance pay out too and it may be his chance to do a one off gesture for the kids at the time where decent tech may be useful to them. Perhaps Apple did him a deal buying that much at once. He may have even used his kids student numbers to get the apple student discount so he wouldn't have paid full retail price anyway.

By all means have a conversation with him but it is a 10 month relationship and I know I knew within 3 months that I was going to be with my husband. Perhaps he feels the same and you haven't indicated otherwise so he assumes you do too.

BlackFridayDiscoCunt · 25/11/2023 07:43

I would feel very uncomfortable about this on every possible count.

He's a relatively new boyfriend and isn't playing a step-parent role in your son's life, so this all seems excessive to me.

Losing a parent is bad enough without someone else's parent steaming in. I have experience of this and if I were the son in this scenario I would feel very weird and wrong and overwhelmed by receiving gifts of this value from a man I'd only met a few times and who means nothing to me. I'd also find it weird if I were one of the man's own children. How come he's treating a young man he barely knows in the same way as he's treating them?

In the OP's position, I'd have wanted to have discussed it together before he did this (and I'd probably have said no, as it sets up expectations and also highlights the disparity in income and, possibly, priorities).

I actually think it's too soon to be playing at blended families over Christmas. I would say that there's no need to 'blend families' at all when all the children are technically adults. It might be nice to spend the day together, but this is all too much, too soon.

Daisygivemeyouranswerdo · 25/11/2023 07:43

It sounds like he wants all DC to have the same exciting things to open for Christmas, I would say this is very kind and thoughtful but can also see why you might feel uncomfortable a little bit. Perhaps have the conversation about it around how much you’d normally spend and how generous it is but that you’d like to chat it over.

As you have both lost spouses (and the children’s other parent?) he might be doing all he can for that reason. Uni is a big milestone, especially as a young person who has lost a parent too. Perhaps he feels he wants to bridge a gap (even if you feel there isn’t one!)

I wonder if he’s paying back in kind, in his own way? Did you support his DC or him during the Uni transition, emotionally etc?

I think it’s ok he wants to treat all the kids the same in terms of presents, it shows character. As long this is a general pattern of thoughtful and generous behaviour

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 07:40

FlamingoQueen · 25/11/2023 07:34

It is a bit over the top, but £20k for him is probably like ‘us’ spending £100.
However, I think it is lovely that he has included your son in this. He sounds genuinely lovely and thoughtful.
For now, I would say to enjoy it! Don’t feel bad that someone wants to spend some money on you all.

You think he has an income 200 times the average?? If so, he would have been able to afford these gifts in summer as he wanted rather than waiting for his bonus.

FrustratedCustom · 25/11/2023 07:38

As a different point, I think that’s way too overwhelming a number of tech gifts for anyone. There isn’t time to appreciate each one. I genuinely wouldn’t like to receive all that in one go. Maybe due to the hassle of packaging removal and setting up ;-)

Does your son want this stuff? Does he prefer Microsoft laptops to Apple products?

It just feels too much to me to get at once. For any of his kids.

sep135 · 25/11/2023 07:35

We're well off and try to give the kids nice presents but their main gift would be one of those items.

It would make me uncomfortable. Firstly because it seems excessive and sets a precedent that you won't be able to match (and makes it harder next time as they have everything). I also think it's important that kids understand the value of money and not have everything given to them on a plate.

I can also sense possible tension going forward if you're being careful with money and, if you were living together, you'd rather use the money on a bigger house or car etc than extreme amounts of presents.

FlamingoQueen · 25/11/2023 07:34

It is a bit over the top, but £20k for him is probably like ‘us’ spending £100.
However, I think it is lovely that he has included your son in this. He sounds genuinely lovely and thoughtful.
For now, I would say to enjoy it! Don’t feel bad that someone wants to spend some money on you all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread