Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think blocking is childish?

109 replies

TheAlchemistElixa · 24/11/2023 23:44

I’m consistently surprised (and sometimes a bit appalled) at how many threads here are answered with “just block!”, “block and delete” even over the most innocuous friendship issues, or a man not having been in touch for a mere week etc.

I understand cutting out someone completely irrevocably toxic, abusive or harassing…but since when did we all decide that we just cover our ears and close our eyes and shout “lallalala, I can’t hear you!” like a six year old child at all our minor issues?

id be absolutely devastated if someone just blocked me for an infraction that could and should have been talked about instead.

Has it really become ok to just stop communicating with someone rather than having tricky conversations? have the people advising others to just block and delete actually done it to someone themselves, or is it just something they say to other people to do because it seems an easy solution?

I’m mystified by it.

OP posts:
Mazuslongtoenail · 26/11/2023 08:51

I do wonder when I read those threads if everyone is blocking people in reality. If so it’s quite far from world where I’ve never been blocked or considered blocking anyone, ever.

Dontcallmescarface · 26/11/2023 08:49

TheAlchemistElixa · 26/11/2023 08:19

See, that’s one of the examples I find difficult to understand. You haven’t fallen out with either of your siblings, yet you’ve used blocking as a way to silence both of them in your life - presumably without them knowing?&

so they are left just shouting into the wind (which I understand is your intention) when they are trying to get some sort of support/help/understanding/backup from you about an issue which is tricky for them.

While I absolutely think you’re right to not want to be involved, and while I hear you that you’ve told them this and they are still trying to involve you, I just can’t comprehend wanting to “mute” anyone I care about, however annoying they might be. I expect they might find it very hurtful, too? I would if it were me.

Also, what if they want to get in touch with you about something non-drama related? You’d presumably miss that message as well, and they wouldn’t know why.

Other people’s drama can be really draining and pointless, I do understand your reasons for wanting no part of it, but I can’t make that leap to understand blocking family like that. Sorry.

Edited

If support/help/understanding/backup was needed then they would get that, but it isn't. It is literally both of them saying how horrible the other is and expecting me to take their side, which after 4 days of that nonsense (and me telling them it was nonsense), I said I wasn't going to listen to it anymore and that they can sort it out between themselves and if they continued to carry on trying to drag me into it then I would block the pair of them . They carried on involving me, so I've blocked them both. They both have partners and 1 of them has adult DC so if there was anything I needed to know then either their DP/DW or DC would have been in touch.

Oh and they never get in touch unless it is drama related.

AlltheFs · 26/11/2023 08:49

Ficklebricks · 26/11/2023 08:39

The daft thing is, blocking someone doesn't have the desired effect. They want the enemy to realise their calls and texts are blocked but when you text a blocked number (at least on android) it just sends the message into a void so you never get the 'can't send' or 'blocked' message anyway. Your enemy will have no idea about your silly power move.

We may all be blocked by someone and never realise it, we may just assume they're not picking up the phone as they're busy!

What are you on about? There is no blocked message. It’s bloody obvious if you are blocked on Whatsapp, but anyone still in the dark ages and using text you can still see if messages were delivered on either platform and calls are obvious too as the way they go to voicemail. I also block on socials so it’s a complete blocking on all channels.

But I don’t give a shit if MIL knows I have blocked her or not. I block and delete her so I can’t contact her primarily, but also so I don’t see her crappy messages. Blocking very much has the desired effect!

Ficklebricks · 26/11/2023 08:39

The daft thing is, blocking someone doesn't have the desired effect. They want the enemy to realise their calls and texts are blocked but when you text a blocked number (at least on android) it just sends the message into a void so you never get the 'can't send' or 'blocked' message anyway. Your enemy will have no idea about your silly power move.

We may all be blocked by someone and never realise it, we may just assume they're not picking up the phone as they're busy!

TheAlchemistElixa · 26/11/2023 08:24

JFT · 26/11/2023 01:40

Same here. And I sometimes say why as kindly as I can and other times let it fizzle out then block because I don't want to hear again from someone.

I've been ghosted tho by people I was in intimate relationships with, twice now, over the last 5 years and that was really painful. I would never ghost someone in those circs and was shocked if they had an issue so serious they were contemplating ending the friendship that they would have discussed it. Also why they didn't just pull back a bit and give breathing space if they had wanted. V odd ghosting is.

But in those instances where you just let something fizzle and then blocked rather than explaining….isn’t that just the ghosting that you have found so hurtful to be on the receiving end yourself? It’s certainly a version of it.

OP posts:
TheAlchemistElixa · 26/11/2023 08:19

Dontcallmescarface · 26/11/2023 00:49

I have blocked both my siblings at the moment. They have had some sort of disagreement and, despite me saying I don't want to get involved, they have both sent me messages bitching about each other. It's the closest thing I can get to banging their heads together. I'll give it a week or so then unblock them.

See, that’s one of the examples I find difficult to understand. You haven’t fallen out with either of your siblings, yet you’ve used blocking as a way to silence both of them in your life - presumably without them knowing?&

so they are left just shouting into the wind (which I understand is your intention) when they are trying to get some sort of support/help/understanding/backup from you about an issue which is tricky for them.

While I absolutely think you’re right to not want to be involved, and while I hear you that you’ve told them this and they are still trying to involve you, I just can’t comprehend wanting to “mute” anyone I care about, however annoying they might be. I expect they might find it very hurtful, too? I would if it were me.

Also, what if they want to get in touch with you about something non-drama related? You’d presumably miss that message as well, and they wouldn’t know why.

Other people’s drama can be really draining and pointless, I do understand your reasons for wanting no part of it, but I can’t make that leap to understand blocking family like that. Sorry.

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 26/11/2023 03:09

I see quite a few people suggest it for interactions with people you have no real relationship with (OLD, or school mum you talk to in passing, etc.) who have stepped out of line, and for family and friends where it’s an ongoing difficult relationship that doesn’t seem to be getting any better and a series of nasty/inappropriate messages. But (other than the occasional oddball, who you’ll always get on the Internet, and friends who say the wrong thing when OP’s had a miscarriage), I don’t really see it suggested for good relationships where one thing has gone wrong in a way that’s out of character.

It does all seem a bit odd to me. The only people I’ve ever blocked are spammers. I don’t know if that’s because I’m lucky in who I meet (I don’t OLD), if I give off vibes that somehow discourage poor comments, or if I have good communication skills and/or a really thick skin. I am happy to have a clear conversation, verging on the blunt if less direct communication isn’t picked up on, but that is so vanishingly rare I can’t remember the last time it happened. I am always a bit surprised by the drama some people have to put up with.

Inthetropics · 26/11/2023 02:55

I sometimes think fondly of the days of yore in which one could stop contact with an ex-partner, or a former friend who's done something unforgivable by just... living and avoiding the odd call (on the landline). It was also easier to deal with those days in which it felt very tempting to reach out to an ex-partner in a moment of weakness a week after a difficult breakup. People had to call you or go to your home/work/school to meet you so it was easier to avoid them. It was easier to avoid people who kept pushing for contact when you had already told them you didn't wish to talk to them. Not so easy to deal with many situations when everyone is on Instagram, Facebook, Whats app, etc.

Mouse82 · 26/11/2023 02:31

.

To think blocking is childish?
aretred · 26/11/2023 01:54

I think blocking is sensible and a good way to assert your boundaries. Any individual should be able to control who contacts them and choose not to be contacted if they wish, regardless of their relationship. Nobody has the right to your time, whoever they are.

Personally I tend to mute rather than block, as I am never sure if others can see whether I've blocked or not, but I'm never tempted to respond and so I'm able to still stop contact without needing to block. But it's a useful tool for those who would just end up in conflict because they can't stop themselves replying.

BlueEyedPeanut · 26/11/2023 01:45

If you are completely done with someone and no longer want them in your life, why would you leave a way open for them to contact you? That seems kind of pointless because it means you might have to waste time on them again in the future.

hotcandle · 26/11/2023 01:41

I disagree. I have several people blocked on social media, WhatsApp and messages. Sometimes for the smallest of reasons.

The way I think of it is, it's my phone and my social media. I don't have to receive anyone's messages or calls and frankly I don't worry one jot about the other person's right to reply or whether or not they know they're blocked.

I also mute a lot of people on Instagram and Facebook that I can't unfriend for other reasons. In a world where I'm so easily contactable and everyone's lives are flashing up on screen, it's refreshing to put a impenetrable barrier up when I want too.

JFT · 26/11/2023 01:40

Headshoulderscheeseontoast · 26/11/2023 00:52

I only block people who I never want to hear from again, that's what it was invented for.

Same here. And I sometimes say why as kindly as I can and other times let it fizzle out then block because I don't want to hear again from someone.

I've been ghosted tho by people I was in intimate relationships with, twice now, over the last 5 years and that was really painful. I would never ghost someone in those circs and was shocked if they had an issue so serious they were contemplating ending the friendship that they would have discussed it. Also why they didn't just pull back a bit and give breathing space if they had wanted. V odd ghosting is.

Coolstorysis · 26/11/2023 01:32

Black mirror foresaw this with White Christmas, actually it foresaw a lot of things, must rewatch lol

It's just a sign of the times, there is a cohort of people 100% involved and only board with mainstream media and the current "thing" another one utterly opposed to that and most people in the middle who just muddle through.

Society has become utterly divided and atomised, some would say that's by design.

MidnightOnceMore · 26/11/2023 01:31

I think it is fine to block people if them contacting you is causing stress.

These days we are so bloody contactable, it is draining. Therefore you have to be able to block/mute/switch things off.

I think those who don't get this are either absolute doormats/saints or have no experience of what it is like to receive too much unhealthy contact from difficult people.

That said, I also don't answer the door Grin

shropshire11 · 26/11/2023 01:27

Agree It’s one thing to cut yourself off from threatening people, but to use it as a first resort simply to assert control over others - to permanently remove their right to reply - is immature.

MintGreenPolo · 26/11/2023 01:23

I don’t agree. I blocked my ex as he doesn’t see our children and will often message me at 2/3/4/5am random messages (unrelated to them) so blocked.

Creepy2023 · 26/11/2023 01:22

I have an ex with BPD who blocks myself, close friends and family every few days on and off during symptoms. Probably blocked me at least 70 times during the three year relationship.

I never used to block people, though blocked a few men last spring and found it gave a firm boundary. Never unblocked.

I mean married coworkers who tried it on etc. I felt zero guilt.

herownworstenemy · 26/11/2023 01:18

YABU. Its my phone, my computer, if I don't want someone intruding on my life then blocking ensures this without drama or any anxiety that the phone ringing or pinging might be them, and I can relax and go about life undisturbed. By all means don't block and get bogged down in the back and forth of calls and messages if you want, but for those of us who grew up before mobile phones when we weren't instantly and permanently contactable blocking is freedom from drama, it doesn't add to it quite the opposite.

Headshoulderscheeseontoast · 26/11/2023 00:52

I only block people who I never want to hear from again, that's what it was invented for.

Dontcallmescarface · 26/11/2023 00:49

I have blocked both my siblings at the moment. They have had some sort of disagreement and, despite me saying I don't want to get involved, they have both sent me messages bitching about each other. It's the closest thing I can get to banging their heads together. I'll give it a week or so then unblock them.

ManchesterLu · 26/11/2023 00:48

Sometimes I decide life's too short, and my peace of mind is too important. Blocking when you're sure somebody serves no further purpose in your life can be brilliantly freeing.

AlltheFs · 26/11/2023 00:46

I block frequently- my MIL is currently blocked. We have always had a difficult relationship and DH is very low contact with her as she’s a narcissist and was a fairly appalling parent. She did something this year to DH that is unforgivable. I blocked and deleted her so that I can’t engage with her as I know that this time I will lose my shit and I don’t want to. I just want to pretend she doesn’t exist.

I also blocked my batshit anti vax cousin and wife during Covid. I just couldn’t stand to be associated with them and the absolute bilge they posted. They live in Australia anyway and we aren’t close but I do not want them in my life. Unblocked I wouldn’t be able to stop myself rising to their nonsense. Blocked on all channels I can be blissfully unaware of their existence.

R4R1 · 26/11/2023 00:41

My wife and I block each other on a weekly basis.

pocketblocket · 26/11/2023 00:34

I have been known to block those kind of inconsistent people who go quiet/cold for months and months and months on end. Then reappear, feign interest and disappear again.

I take friendships as I find them, and for me that's reciprocal. If you're someone who never makes the effort to contact me first, often leaves me on read, then pops up out of the blue after a year because you want something and you think that that's perfectly respectful then yes, you might find that I have blocked you.

Suits me.