Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think blocking is childish?

109 replies

TheAlchemistElixa · 24/11/2023 23:44

I’m consistently surprised (and sometimes a bit appalled) at how many threads here are answered with “just block!”, “block and delete” even over the most innocuous friendship issues, or a man not having been in touch for a mere week etc.

I understand cutting out someone completely irrevocably toxic, abusive or harassing…but since when did we all decide that we just cover our ears and close our eyes and shout “lallalala, I can’t hear you!” like a six year old child at all our minor issues?

id be absolutely devastated if someone just blocked me for an infraction that could and should have been talked about instead.

Has it really become ok to just stop communicating with someone rather than having tricky conversations? have the people advising others to just block and delete actually done it to someone themselves, or is it just something they say to other people to do because it seems an easy solution?

I’m mystified by it.

OP posts:
SuspiciousSue · 26/11/2023 14:03

Sometimes, someone does something that on the face of it seems really small and petty. However, it’s actually just the straw that broke the camel’s back and you have to walk away.

Mellowautumnmists · 26/11/2023 13:25

@Thepeopleversuswork exactly this!

Mellowautumnmists · 26/11/2023 13:24

I'm in a WhatsApp group of "friends" and we meet up at least once a year if we can. After the last such meet up one member deleted and blocked me on facebook, and I really have no idea why. She continues to engage with me in the WhatsApp group (?!?!) but has chosen to ignore my direct question re whether she had deleted her facebook account. She is still active on FB (I have an Admin account for a group I am in so could see her profile).

What will happen at our next get together remains to be seen - will she offer to make everyone else a cup of tea but not me; will she buy everyone else a glass of wine, but not me; will she hug and kiss everyone else as they arrive, but not me.......

If she has an issue with something I've done or said then that's fine, but I'd rather she spoke to me about it. And most certainly didn't try and act as if nothing was wrong within the WhatsApp group. Just bizarre and childish.

Thepeopleversuswork · 26/11/2023 13:15

I completely agree OP. There’s absolutely a place for blocking: if someone has been abusive or is harassing you or has been incredibly unkind.

But you do quite routinely see people on here advising posters to block friends who have stood them up for a lunch or who don’t agree with their politics.

It’s very childish but also unbelievably self destructive. If you actually blocked someone because they had missed a couple of nights out you would come across as unhinged. It’s also bad for people’s communication skills and basic resilience to make them feel it’s acceptable to digitally storm off every time they have a difference of opinion. Grown up friendships can accommodate a bit of wear and tear, there’s simply nothing to be gained by this flouncing.

TurquoiseHexagonSun · 26/11/2023 13:13

OP, I wholeheartedly agree! I once posted a similar thread and got ripped, though, so I'm not surprised by the YABUs on here.

fishshop · 26/11/2023 13:11

You are exaggerating hugely. I have never seen it used in the way that you describe.

“block and delete” has never been used for family members or long standing friends who you are pissed off. That’s “go NC”.

so yeah- YABU because your post’s basis is completely untrue

Block and delete is for toxic exs and OLD situationships that aren’t going anywhere, and you don’t want the agg of them popping up for a shag 2 months down the line with their bullshit. Is also a good way method of invoking a physical boundary. This is particularly important if you have low self esteem or pickme tendencies and literally can’t be trusted, or clown yourself pretending you need closure when you are just hoping he changes his mind. Nothing childish about it.

sollenwir · 26/11/2023 13:05

Fairygoblin · 26/11/2023 00:07

YADNBU It's the equivalent of flouncing which is overly dramatic. There's people I've dropped from my life with good reason but have never felt the urge to 'block' ceremoniously. And yes OP you are right that many posters suggest blocking friends and family over relatively trivial issues.

It's the opposite of flouncing IMHO.

sollenwir · 26/11/2023 13:05

No, I don't think that ensuring someone has no access to my online life is remotely childish.

Mycatmax · 26/11/2023 12:59

YABU

Blocking is just about self preservation and a response to unwanted contact.

I am old enough to have had a social life before mobile phones/internet. If you didn't want to hear from someone, you just didn't answer their calls (trickier before caller display!) and eventually they would get the message and fuck off.

I don't think twice about blocking toxic ex, the plumber who couldn't accept I didn't want a date, an ex friend who was just an emotional vampire. Why would I?

To me it's childish to keep entertaining people you would rather avoid as it smacks of poor boundaries.

CatMadam · 26/11/2023 12:58

GirlsAloudReturnMadeMyYEAR · 25/11/2023 23:58

Yanbu! It's so tacky and embarrassing when people block ex's, looks a bit unhinged. My friend does this and thinks it's a power move but she just looks nuts lol

I don’t see what’s ’unhinged’ or ‘nuts’ about blocking an ex- it just seems practical to me! Theyre no longer part of your life, usually for good reason- why not block
them?

Dontcallmescarface · 26/11/2023 12:47

The daft thing is, blocking someone doesn't have the desired effect. They want the enemy to realise their calls and texts are blocked but when you text a blocked number (at least on android) it just sends the message into a void so you never get the 'can't send' or 'blocked' message anyway. Your enemy will have no idea about your silly power move.

It had the desired effect for me...I'm no longer "piggy-in-the-middle" in their ridiculous spat. They know they are blocked because the last message I sent either of them was "that's it I'm blocking the pair of you as I can't be doing with either of you right now". Also they are not my "enemies" they are 2 people I love dearly, but don't like ATM.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 26/11/2023 12:27

After my first ex dumped me (the day after he said he loved me and we were informally engaged) I eventually couldn’t stand seeing him on my social media so I blocked him after I think three months of break-up. Five year relationship and he’d cheated.
I then got blocked by my third ex so he could get off with one of my best friends without me knowing. He dumped me after two years in the middle of a conversation by ringing off. Never heard from him again. THAT was childish.
I generally think as long as you give good warning that it might happen, it’s an acceptable final outcome for really unbearable behaviour, when you may need to protect yourself as well. Ghosting on the other hand is just immature, hurtful and wrong.

Aquamarine1029 · 26/11/2023 12:25

Scarletttulips · 26/11/2023 12:18

The daft thing is, blocking someone doesn't have the desired effect. They want the enemy to realise their calls and texts are blocked but when you text a blocked number (at least on android) it just sends the message into a void so you never get the 'can't send' or 'blocked' message anyway. Your enemy will have no idea about your silly power move.

It’s not a power move it’s a self preservation move - why should the receiver have to read messages they don’t want and didn’t ask for and are likely to me horrid anyway?

Exactly. Blocking someone isn't a "power move." It's about making the decision to remove an unwanted person from your life. I don't owe anyone an explanation as to why I don't want their toxic bullshit in my life. With a simple tap of a button, any drama and unwanted nonsense disappears. More women should block unnecessary, negative people from their lives, in my opinion. Far too many people keep allowing themselves to be distressed and burdened by toxic people just for the sake of being "nice."

Scarletttulips · 26/11/2023 12:18

The daft thing is, blocking someone doesn't have the desired effect. They want the enemy to realise their calls and texts are blocked but when you text a blocked number (at least on android) it just sends the message into a void so you never get the 'can't send' or 'blocked' message anyway. Your enemy will have no idea about your silly power move.

It’s not a power move it’s a self preservation move - why should the receiver have to read messages they don’t want and didn’t ask for and are likely to me horrid anyway?

StockpotSoup · 26/11/2023 12:15

I’m torn. On one hand, I see posts on here from people who’ve tried to sort out a minor argument only to find they’ve been blocked and I think “FFS, bloody drama queens”. It’s a move people make to get noticed.

On the other hand, I’m very glad the technology exists. In the days of landlines only, it would have been a nightmare if I’d had to stop someone from trying to contact me. Essentially you had to prove you were getting nuisance calls, and even then the solution was likely to be a number change. When a now very much ex-friend behaved in a way I knew I could never forgive, it was very liberating to press a few buttons and know it was over. (Getting her to stop pestering mutual friends and acquaintances was a lot harder, but that’s a whole other issue!)

Gettingbysomehow · 26/11/2023 12:13

It's absolutely pathetic. I was married for 20 years when my husband ran off with another woman, I did everything for him because he was always out of work, gave him a home, took care of him. We were so close.
When he went, very suddenly without any warning, he blocked me on everything and destroyed all evidence of our relationship so mutual friends told me including wedding photos, events we went to, special times. He blocked me 7 years ago and I haven't heard from him since. Why? Surely our shared experiences meant something? Apparently not.
I'm disgusted with him, he should know better at his age. I would be content with being distant friends, I had no beef with him but no I've just been deleted out of his life.
It's a vile and sick thing to do.
Unless of course you have been abused or stalked or something.

JFT · 26/11/2023 12:13

TheAlchemistElixa · 26/11/2023 08:24

But in those instances where you just let something fizzle and then blocked rather than explaining….isn’t that just the ghosting that you have found so hurtful to be on the receiving end yourself? It’s certainly a version of it.

Not in my case no. I was in fully engaged relationships with these two people I mention and they switched and ghosted. Both of them were quite unstable and highly narc, I think they did a Narc silent treatment on me, unsure. But it was painful and hurtful at the time.

Ywlala92 · 26/11/2023 12:06

Reasons I would block:
Stop me messaging someone toxic I want to cut out of my life
Stop someone who I no longer want in my life contacting me

Reasons I personally wouldn't block:
Havjng a tiff and want to piss someone off / let them cook down, knowing I will in the near future unblock. I would just mute the convo for that and approach it when I'm ready.

hotcandle · 26/11/2023 12:05

Ficklebricks · 26/11/2023 08:39

The daft thing is, blocking someone doesn't have the desired effect. They want the enemy to realise their calls and texts are blocked but when you text a blocked number (at least on android) it just sends the message into a void so you never get the 'can't send' or 'blocked' message anyway. Your enemy will have no idea about your silly power move.

We may all be blocked by someone and never realise it, we may just assume they're not picking up the phone as they're busy!

Of course it has the desired effect. Whatever message the blocked person sends isn't delivered. That's the whole point.

Who cares whether the person doesn't realise their blocked? They can send all the messages they want, the receiver doesn't have to deal with them.

Sapphire387 · 26/11/2023 10:46

I have blocked -

Ex-fiancé who really messed me around and hurt me. He kept trying to be 'friendly' and then started messing with my head saying he still loved me, etc. For my own sanity, I needed to be sure I wouldn't keep receiving random messages from him.

Former 'friend' who always had some drama and wanted help but it was very one-sided and they never asked me about my life.

My in-laws. Long story but basically two of them started a massive argument with my DH over something stupid last year while we were going through a stressful time (ectopic pregnancy). The rest of them all gossip, it's like living in Eastenders and very enmeshed. DH is supportive of me doing this - I just can't have them in my space, looking at my social media etc (there's a lot more to the story).

In short, I block people when interacting with them causes me a lot of stress.

Tsc2011 · 26/11/2023 10:26

I’ve blocked a couple of people in the past but only when it was really needed (an abusive narcissistic ex bf who wouldn’t leave me alone and a threatening family member who would get drunk and text abuse to us in the night).

I don’t mind admitting that someone blocked me this week (explained in my recent post on “parents”). It was a little frustrating because I didn’t get to respond to an abusive message from them but, ultimately, they look incredibly childish and it is a bit of a relief to have an excuse not to engage with them anymore. I’ve been purposefully avoiding this woman for the last 6-12 months so, although I unfortunately will see her at school pick-ups etc, I have an excuse not to engage with her.

She’s a very needy person so it’ll be interesting to see what happens over the next few years as her message and behaviour (witnessed by half the school parents) was incredibly offensive and our children will potentially (We’re hoping to move) be at a very small village school together for the next 5 years.

IndecentFeminist · 26/11/2023 09:35

I've only blocked one person, but she was/is truly toxic and her aggressive communications made me very stressed and uncomfortable. I still see her regularly but we don't speak, which is far better all round.

LauraRacĥ4 · 26/11/2023 09:34

I've blocked an ex who really hurt me. Not for him though - for me. I wanted to remove the temptation to spy and move on.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 26/11/2023 09:00

You can't imagine it because you've never been subjected to the same level of bat shittery as others on here. If everyone behaved appropriately, could resolve conflict, understood and respected other people's boundaries then blocking wouldn't be necessary.

Topseyt123 · 26/11/2023 08:53

I block spammers. Apart from that I have only ever blocked one extremely toxic woman who I had come to know via my adult DD. It is the mother of a close friend of DD's, who I also sort of knew.

This woman had turned very toxic and abusive on both DD and I, and took to phoning us at home to insult us and dole out her bilge. Blocked, and will never be unblocked as far as I am concerned.

Blocking has its uses. It is a last resort for me, but has been very effective. It's a tool I will use rarely but wouldn't want to be without.

Swipe left for the next trending thread