Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask advice on how to deal with know it all group member at university?

32 replies

gpproj · 24/11/2023 21:58

I'm currently retraining and studying for a healthcare degree, I'm in my first year (so around 2 months in). I already have a degree and master's (first class and distinction - only mentioning to provide context of my academic background).

I'm currently in a group with 4 other students, they are all 18/19 and straight out of sixth form (again just saying to provide context). It's been a bit of a nightmare (2 of them just don't turn up for meetings despite texting and emailing them).

However, I'm having a difficult time with one of them who is taking the project in a bit of a wrong direction. She is trying to pigeonhole her analysis into basic points covered in a-levels (e.g. the kind of buzz words you mention to get marks in a-level exams like saying something is 'reductionist'). She will say things like she is happy to do all the analysis as she is 'very confident' with it as she did it at a-levels. I've been reading her section and I feel like it isn't really relevant (e.g. she's critiquing a vague part of a theory we're using, rather than critiquing its ability to be applied to the topic in question - if that makes sense). I have tried to gently mention these things to her, but she does this thing where she will interrupt me and start talking over me by trying to say what I'm saying, like I said

'I think we need to include some analysis of the topic and-'
'Include analysis of the topic, yes we need to include that'

I can't get a word in edgeways.

AIBU to keep trying or should I let her do her best? I know I'm a mature student so I'm not expecting my group to approach the work in the same way I would, and it's still a new subject to me so I'm still new to it all too, although it does have some similarities to my previous degree.

OP posts:
Merryoldgoat · 24/11/2023 22:14

Why do you have to work in a group? Is it compulsory? I’d hate that OP - what a complete pain.

theduchessofspork · 24/11/2023 22:10

If it’s going to impact on your marks then you just need to explain to her why you think she’s wrong. You can’t get a word in edgeways because you aren’t asserting yourself - you’re talking about ‘a bit of a wrong direction’ or being mean by calling her a know it all. You aren’t a child - just be polite, firm and clear. If she talks over you tell her to let you finish.

If it’s not impacting on you ignore her.

burnoutbabe · 24/11/2023 22:10

I'd just hope it didn't count towards anything and smile and ket them at it.

(Having done second degree then masters at 47)

When it counts choose better teams. Identify the keeno's.

PermanentTemporary · 24/11/2023 22:10

Have you split the work into different sections? I think at this stage I'd just do my section and give only very gentle feedback if asked, as positive as possible.

I did a healthcare degree as a mature student and it's not easy as an 18 year old to have us oldsters there. If the degree is properly set up, this piece of work won't represent any of your marks, and dven if it did, you'd be separately marked. I'd say dial it right down.

JustJoinedRightNow · 24/11/2023 22:06

How should she know how to handle this??

WhoNeedsFriends · 24/11/2023 22:01

You're a mature student you should know how to handle this.

gpproj · 24/11/2023 21:58

Reading this back I feel bad for writing 'know it all' in the title, that's unkind of me.

OP posts: