Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this government are at war with disabled people and always have been?

259 replies

MyopicBunny · 24/11/2023 20:20

I am assuming that the part of their UC that will be cut is the disabled element? Most people can’t even get this at all if you are disabled. The rules to receive it in the first place are extremely strict.

Why us nobody talking about this? Has our society now become brainwashed with the idea that it’s acceptable to call disabled people with significant needs benefit scroungers?

Why is it the most vulnerable being shat on from a great height, over and over??

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 24/11/2023 22:54

nationallampoons · 24/11/2023 22:51

I'm worried about my mum. She's either all of her life and was signed off last year. She's had knee replacements and is waiting for a new hip. She's got a crumbling spine and skin cancer

She's unable to leave her flat without help. She's petrified

Is she getting PIP ? I honestly don't think that this group of people need to be worried. I think these proposals have cause scaremongering unecessarily.

MyopicBunny · 24/11/2023 22:54

Zepherine · 24/11/2023 22:50

The Government have been telling civil servants to get back in the office. Where are all those WFH jobs that untrained people without transferable skills with chronic health problems, disabilities and mental heath conditions are going to be able to do?

Yes you have anxiety and depression so of course you can WFH .Of course, nobody cares that you are actually unable to get out of bed because your condition is crippling. That your medication makes you slow and fatigued and you can’t concentrate. That your anxiety is so severe you can’t even make a decision about what to wear that day. You are going to be marvellous in your new WFH job that doesn’t actually exist.

So you’ve got mobility problems? No problem. You can work at home at a computer for 8 hours a day. Never mind that sitting in one position is so excruciatingly painful that you can’t do it for very long and you might well be a bit out of it on pain killers so liable to make mistakes and that the pain makes you irritable and depressed. Never mind that you will need specialist equipment to even sit at a desk, if you can sit that is. Of course you will manage to use a laptop with your fingers stiff and swollen with arthritis or shoulders that are so painful you can’t even get your clothes on properly in the morning.

Your employers are going to love you when you take days off to attend numerous health related appointments, hospital visits, scans, xrays and regular blood tests, or psychiatric appointments along with visits to the GP or maybe a weekly therapist. The appointments that take all morning because of your disability it takes ages to get ready and go anywhere and you have to sit waiting in outpatients for more than an hour and then you have to sit and wait for your blood tests because the NHS has been starved of funds and there aren’t enough staff and then you have to wait in Pharmacy for another 45 minutes, if you are lucky, to collect your medication. After that you still need to get home and have lunch because you are human and need to eat and it could be 3pm by then and you are far to exhausted to work the rest of the day and the following day because of the knock on affect of doing too much, which is a thing for people with certain conditions. Rinse and repeat for the different consultants you are under for your varied conditions. Your employer is going to love you when your condition flares up and you are off work AGAIN for another few weeks, or you need surgery or a course of physio therapy AGAIN.

These are only some of things people with health conditions and disabilities have to deal with. There are dozens of different conditions and scenarios but all of them difficult to manage and keep on top of. This government hasn’t got a clue and I don’t think Labour will be much better, sadly.

Edited

Well I agree that Labour isn't perfect but they certainly did things better than this lot, who have created nasty mindsets like some of those on this thread.

New Labour did a lot of progressive things. The first thing the Tories did was to shut all the Sure Start centres. They do not care about a level playing field and they do not want to enable social mobility.

OP posts:
XDownwiththissortofthingX · 24/11/2023 22:53

It's not just a phenomenon linked to the Covid timeline.

Around 10 years ago it was enormously difficult to be awarded DLA for purely mental health reasons. Approximately 80% of all rejected applications were eventually awarded once they had been pursued through mandatory reconsideration and then Tribunal. These were only the rejected application that were actually challenged though, not ALL rejected applications. So the long and short of it is that the majority of people who absolutely should have been awarded DLA were not, and at best, they'd end up on JSA and be subject to the strictures that come with that.

Over the years, increased exposure of just how unfit for purpose the Capability assessments were, and scrutiny of the processes used by ATOS served to temper somewhat the DWP's thirst for finding people fit for work who clearly were not. Of course, this pressure for "targets" came from Government, which is in itself utterly beyond ridicule. The idea that you must find people perfectly fit for work lest doing otherwise takes you over a completely arbitrary threshold. Complete and utter nonsense to begin with.

So the reality is that this picture of a vastly increased number of disability-related claimants is a bit misleading, because we're not "more ill", the Government was just getting away with finding many more ill and unfit for work people fit for work, until the nonsense of how they were going about this was laid bare for the scandal it was and they rowed back from it.

The numbers claiming these benefits now are a fairer reflection of reality, and more akin to where they always should have been, not some sort of indicator that vast numbers of people are "at it". Of course, the Tories don't care about that, and would far rather have the public blaming the unfortunate for their own misfortune, rather that question why we have a society that creates huge numbers of mentally ill people who are incapable of work.

RedHelenB · 24/11/2023 22:52

MyopicBunny · 24/11/2023 20:35

@Overthebow people don't get disability benefits in the first place unless they have extremely significant needs. How can you just suddenly work from home if you never did in the first place?

This isn't a benefit I personally get even though I do have a disability but my daughter does get it. She is severely autistic and needs 2:1 24 hour a day care. She is non verbal.

Tbf , your dd will never be expected to work , even by the harshest of govts.

ChatBFP · 24/11/2023 22:51

@Babyroobs

Agreed. I'm not sure that the messaging is right, because those people are not lazy and that is what the "sanctioning those who refuse" line is straying into. But it is correct to say that those people do need to be helped back into work so far as possible and should not be encouraged to see not working permanently as the "cure", for a whole host of reasons.

My relative with social anxiety absolutely could work. I can think of many many things she could and would be able to do well. Whether there is a WFH job that only has the bits that wouldn't cause her anxiety to start with, or whether she would have the necessary support to work through the anxious bits without triggering panic attacks, that is another question.

nationallampoons · 24/11/2023 22:51

I'm worried about my mum. She's either all of her life and was signed off last year. She's had knee replacements and is waiting for a new hip. She's got a crumbling spine and skin cancer

She's unable to leave her flat without help. She's petrified

Zepherine · 24/11/2023 22:50

The Government have been telling civil servants to get back in the office. Where are all those WFH jobs that untrained people without transferable skills with chronic health problems, disabilities and mental heath conditions are going to be able to do?

Yes you have anxiety and depression so of course you can WFH .Of course, nobody cares that you are actually unable to get out of bed because your condition is crippling. That your medication makes you slow and fatigued and you can’t concentrate. That your anxiety is so severe you can’t even make a decision about what to wear that day. You are going to be marvellous in your new WFH job that doesn’t actually exist.

So you’ve got mobility problems? No problem. You can work at home at a computer for 8 hours a day. Never mind that sitting in one position is so excruciatingly painful that you can’t do it for very long and you might well be a bit out of it on pain killers so liable to make mistakes and that the pain makes you irritable and depressed. Never mind that you will need specialist equipment to even sit at a desk, if you can sit that is. Of course you will manage to use a laptop with your fingers stiff and swollen with arthritis or shoulders that are so painful you can’t even get your clothes on properly in the morning.

Your employers are going to love you when you take days off to attend numerous health related appointments, hospital visits, scans, xrays and regular blood tests, or psychiatric appointments along with visits to the GP or maybe a weekly therapist. The appointments that take all morning because of your disability it takes ages to get ready and go anywhere and you have to sit waiting in outpatients for more than an hour and then you have to sit and wait for your blood tests because the NHS has been starved of funds and there aren’t enough staff and then you have to wait in Pharmacy for another 45 minutes, if you are lucky, to collect your medication. After that you still need to get home and have lunch because you are human and need to eat and it could be 3pm by then and you are far to exhausted to work the rest of the day and the following day because of the knock on affect of doing too much, which is a thing for people with certain conditions. Rinse and repeat for the different consultants you are under for your varied conditions. Your employer is going to love you when your condition flares up and you are off work AGAIN for another few weeks, or you need surgery or a course of physio therapy AGAIN.

These are only some of things people with health conditions and disabilities have to deal with. There are dozens of different conditions and scenarios but all of them difficult to manage and keep on top of. This government hasn’t got a clue and I don’t think Labour will be much better, sadly.

MyopicBunny · 24/11/2023 22:49

Yes @XenoBitch - I thought exactly the same thing about David Cameron. I really doubt he needed the money(!) but he presumably claimed it because it was his child's right to do so. And that's all anyone does who has a disabled child.

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 24/11/2023 22:47

IClaudine · 24/11/2023 22:38

I am really not trying to be cruel, just the opposite in fact!

Perhaps I am wrong, but the implication seems to be that the blogger is somehow doing something wrong and I very much doubt they are. Especially as PIP is not means tested, so mentioning the family's income is totally irrelevant.

Wasn't David Cameron claiming DLA/PIP for one of his children?
You are right, it is not means tested and not about someone's inability to work.
Even if someone does not need the money that comes from claiming it, having an active claim opens other gateways to further support.

topnoddy · 24/11/2023 22:46

Only 2 words sum this up
TORY SCUM

IClaudine · 24/11/2023 22:46

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 24/11/2023 22:29

This isn't even about cutting the Benefits bill or saving public money, because any savings made by forcing people into work who aren't fit for it, or simply stopping their claims, will be completely outweighed by the cost of administration. All significant changes to benefits are inevitably a shitshow that costs far more than they save, this will be no different.

The unfortunate thing is that their will be real people's lives destroyed by this nonsense, but don't for none minute think that it's being driven by an honest belief that it will cut spending, because it wont, and the Government understands that fine and well.

This is pure soundbite populism of the worst sort, intended to raise the hackles of the sort of people who form their entire world view from the complete shite they read in rags like the Mail, shite that is fully intended to pander to their already existing prejudices and misconceptions about issues like disability, and what your typical benefit claimant might look like. It buys the Government a few kudos points with the ignorant because they are perceived to be tough on "scroungers", even though the bulk of the people this will affect are no such thing, and it won't achieve it's stated purpose in the first place.

Human casualties of course, but this government, and the sort of ignorant muppets who take things like this on face value couldn't care less about other human beings if it means they get to revel in their own ignorance for a bit.

Absolutely this.

IClaudine · 24/11/2023 22:43

IClaudine · 24/11/2023 22:38

I am really not trying to be cruel, just the opposite in fact!

Perhaps I am wrong, but the implication seems to be that the blogger is somehow doing something wrong and I very much doubt they are. Especially as PIP is not means tested, so mentioning the family's income is totally irrelevant.

Stomacharmeleon actually, having given it a bit more thought, you might be right. Linking to it here might send some of the nastier elements on MN over to that blog.

Babyroobs · 24/11/2023 22:39

ChatBFP · 24/11/2023 22:37

I think the issue is that there has been a massive, massive increase in those claiming they can't work due to ill health since the pandemic. Many are, for example, MH or back pain related. Some could work in another field, but cannot work in previous one etc. I'd be fine with encouraging them back into work if they had good support through the DWP and/or healthcare.

I don't think it is actually in the interests of most people to not work at all if they could work, especially if they are otherwise low on human interactions and relationships. Quite how these jobs appear is a different and difficult matter though.

Yes massive rise in mh disorders since covid and also in teens/ young people. Also long covid is a real problem for many.

ChatBFP · 24/11/2023 22:38

(And obviously taking away someone's money to sanction them for not finding suitable work on the basis of a thin assessment by the DWP has the potential for inhumane results)

IClaudine · 24/11/2023 22:38

Stomacharmeleon · 24/11/2023 22:29

@IClaudine that seems a bit cruel can't you just google it?

I am really not trying to be cruel, just the opposite in fact!

Perhaps I am wrong, but the implication seems to be that the blogger is somehow doing something wrong and I very much doubt they are. Especially as PIP is not means tested, so mentioning the family's income is totally irrelevant.

MyopicBunny · 24/11/2023 22:37

I'm actually shocked that anyone thinks that anxiety disorder is 'sitting at home thinking about your feelings'.

It's not my job to educate the ignorant but I will explain one of my adult daughter's situation. She's the only one of my children who is NT. She's a talented young designer who almost had to give it all up due to debilitating anxiety. Her anxiety was so bad that she lost all of her creative talent. She was woken up in the night by painful panic attacks which caused extreme pain in her chest. She was so, so unhappy and lost herself. We were all incredibly worried about her.

Luckily, she is now on medication and is back to her old, happy self but we had to really push for this medication for her because doctors were against prescribing it for her. Medication sadly isn't going to solve everyone's anxiety though. I'm thankful that there has been a relatively easy solution to make her well again. I remember the day I knew she was feeling better because I realised she was humming.

OP posts:
ChatBFP · 24/11/2023 22:37

I think the issue is that there has been a massive, massive increase in those claiming they can't work due to ill health since the pandemic. Many are, for example, MH or back pain related. Some could work in another field, but cannot work in previous one etc. I'd be fine with encouraging them back into work if they had good support through the DWP and/or healthcare.

I don't think it is actually in the interests of most people to not work at all if they could work, especially if they are otherwise low on human interactions and relationships. Quite how these jobs appear is a different and difficult matter though.

Spendonsend · 24/11/2023 22:31

FelicityFlops · 24/11/2023 21:38

Please explain to me why any government should be responsible for disabled people.

I'm interested what you think the purpose of government is? I know some people believe health, social care and education are outside the remit of government, but they have been part of government in the uk for longer than my lifetime.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 24/11/2023 22:29

This isn't even about cutting the Benefits bill or saving public money, because any savings made by forcing people into work who aren't fit for it, or simply stopping their claims, will be completely outweighed by the cost of administration. All significant changes to benefits are inevitably a shitshow that costs far more than they save, this will be no different.

The unfortunate thing is that their will be real people's lives destroyed by this nonsense, but don't for none minute think that it's being driven by an honest belief that it will cut spending, because it wont, and the Government understands that fine and well.

This is pure soundbite populism of the worst sort, intended to raise the hackles of the sort of people who form their entire world view from the complete shite they read in rags like the Mail, shite that is fully intended to pander to their already existing prejudices and misconceptions about issues like disability, and what your typical benefit claimant might look like. It buys the Government a few kudos points with the ignorant because they are perceived to be tough on "scroungers", even though the bulk of the people this will affect are no such thing, and it won't achieve it's stated purpose in the first place.

Human casualties of course, but this government, and the sort of ignorant muppets who take things like this on face value couldn't care less about other human beings if it means they get to revel in their own ignorance for a bit.

Stomacharmeleon · 24/11/2023 22:29

@IClaudine that seems a bit cruel can't you just google it?

ilovesooty · 24/11/2023 22:29

NettleTea · 24/11/2023 22:24

there is some real evil and hard cruelty on this thread

There certainly is.

Stomacharmeleon · 24/11/2023 22:28

They are discussing it on 'the last leg'.

IClaudine · 24/11/2023 22:25

Lifesd · 24/11/2023 22:04

@MyopicBunny i totally agree and I don’t want to sound as if I’m bashing - I’m not, I come on here and read horrific posts about people not being able to get the right support and I look at my friends who have sons who age receiving it and they are both on upwards of 50k individually - both sons have their own help in schools and the mum has a blog about travelling with the kids and their disabilities and I’m not saying it’s wrong but when I read on her people can’t access PIP etc it makes me question the system

Can you link to the blog?

NettleTea · 24/11/2023 22:24

there is some real evil and hard cruelty on this thread

Morphingirl · 24/11/2023 22:24

I don't agree with it as a disabled person who does work but also gets pip. While it doesn't help the length your claim is open with DWP from the day you applied is back paid after a successful tribunal . BUT it doesn't help if you have pip and lose it as suddenly it becomes very hard to get a blue badge and you lose a lot .