Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this government are at war with disabled people and always have been?

259 replies

MyopicBunny · 24/11/2023 20:20

I am assuming that the part of their UC that will be cut is the disabled element? Most people can’t even get this at all if you are disabled. The rules to receive it in the first place are extremely strict.

Why us nobody talking about this? Has our society now become brainwashed with the idea that it’s acceptable to call disabled people with significant needs benefit scroungers?

Why is it the most vulnerable being shat on from a great height, over and over??

OP posts:
Babyroobs · 24/11/2023 23:30

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 24/11/2023 23:28

2.8 million PIP claimants, yet 10.4 million disabled people.

If it's easy to be awarded PIP, why is the number of claimants not far higher?

Presumably a lot of those could be on DLA or Attendance Allowance or are we just talking about 10.4 million working age disabled people?

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 24/11/2023 23:28

Disillusioned11 · 24/11/2023 23:25

“PIP (which is not mean tested, is not an out of work benefits, and is notoriously hard to get).”

1 in 20 people in England receive PIP … so is not “hard to get”

2.8 million PIP claimants, yet 10.4 million disabled people.

If it's easy to be awarded PIP, why is the number of claimants not far higher?

SemperIdem · 24/11/2023 23:26

GirrlCrush · 24/11/2023 20:22

Yabu to assume we have all seen /read/know about whatever it is you are talking about!

When watching news events I've been more concerned when seeing footage from Gaza lately

Not everyone is capable of only caring about one thing at a time.

Disillusioned11 · 24/11/2023 23:25

XenoBitch · 24/11/2023 20:37

The "you must WFH" stuff is just one thing (plus where are these mythical entry level WFH jobs? And the mythical employers who will take on people who have been out the work force for years and have no transferable skills or experience)

There are plans to scrap the WCA and the higher rate of UC that disabled people get. The only people who will be able to claim it will be those on PIP (which is not mean tested, is not an out of work benefits, and is notoriously hard to get).

Whether someone is fit to work will be determined by work coaches, which are not medically trained at all.

“PIP (which is not mean tested, is not an out of work benefits, and is notoriously hard to get).”

1 in 20 people in England receive PIP … so is not “hard to get”

XenoBitch · 24/11/2023 23:21

ChatBFP · 24/11/2023 22:51

@Babyroobs

Agreed. I'm not sure that the messaging is right, because those people are not lazy and that is what the "sanctioning those who refuse" line is straying into. But it is correct to say that those people do need to be helped back into work so far as possible and should not be encouraged to see not working permanently as the "cure", for a whole host of reasons.

My relative with social anxiety absolutely could work. I can think of many many things she could and would be able to do well. Whether there is a WFH job that only has the bits that wouldn't cause her anxiety to start with, or whether she would have the necessary support to work through the anxious bits without triggering panic attacks, that is another question.

You need to pass an interview to get the job though. Even if your relative was keen to actually do the job, would she pass the interview stage?

Interviews are about selling yourself etc. Someone with anxiety will struggle with that... also someone with ASD due to maybe lack of eye contact etc. It is sad, because many people with such conditions look great on paper for particular jobs... but the hurdles set to get the job to begin with sets them up for failure.

MyopicBunny · 24/11/2023 23:18

Lots of disabled people who could potentially work want to. Sadly, many employers are not keen on employing disabled people.

Yep, a family member has MS. He tells nobody about it, certainly not any of his employers. When he has a relapse, he has to take time off work and just hope that his employers don't run out of patience and sack him.

OP posts:
XDownwiththissortofthingX · 24/11/2023 23:17

Babyroobs · 24/11/2023 23:05

Exactly this. I wish people would stop panicking.

I think it's perfectly understandable that people who have no income besides their benefits, a have personal experience of being brutalised repeatedly by DWP and their assessments and application processes, and fear for their ability to prove they genuinely are incapable of work might be plunged into a panic.

Yes, there is an election due, but the great British public saw fit to elect a complete an utter charlatan who was patently unfit for office in 2019, so nobody can guarantee that it will not happen again.

Polling suggests it's unlikely, but polling has frequently been proven wrong in the past, so I wouldn't go cashing in my chips that everything is just going to turn out hunky dory just yet.

Also of note is the fact that Starmer and Reeves have more or less stated they don't think these changes go far enough, so it's not as if a change to the Red Tories is guaranteed to render this moot in any case.

Zepherine · 24/11/2023 23:17

Stomacharmeleon · 24/11/2023 23:03

Adam hills said he spoke to Penny Mordaunt when he visited the HOC and she reassured him...
Nothing will happen until 2025.
Those already disabled and on pip/ limited capability will not have anything to worry about.
It's more aimed at those who have sat and home and not worked or attempted to try after 18 months.

We may have a different government by then.

There is always this narrative that people are sitting at home taking the piss. Actually, there are more people who are denied health benefits or don’t claim their entitlement. And it is an entitlement. What happens when you get seriously with a long term condition? I don’t mean you specifically, Stomacharmeleon, but any one of us.

As for it not coming in until 2025, what about caring about the people who will have to face even more barriers and financial loss? Removing benefits from someone who has nothing else is going to end up costing society in the long term, whether it be through poor health, the need for even more food banks, homelessness and so on. What happens if they have children? Do they get taken into care costing the state even more? It’s nasty rhetoric design to inflame the right. Just like Braverman and look how that turned out.

MyopicBunny · 24/11/2023 23:15

Benibidibici · 24/11/2023 23:08

I don't love the underlying vibe here (not a tory voter)

But I do struggle with the sheer percentage of people these days who are apparently unable to do any labour at all. As a society i feel like we're getting something so wrong if so many people can't cope, struggling with depression, anxiety etc.

For the vast majority of people, work helps mental health and improves their life. A life on disability benefits is not a great life. I can understand wanting to support people to find work they can manage that might help. The onus needs to be on employers to be as flexible as possible to accommodate.

The problem is not that people with disabilities are useless. It is that we live in a world which is designed for people who are not disabled and therefore meeting the needs of anyone different is often a task that nobody will do had can't be bothered to, anyway.

OP posts:
IClaudine · 24/11/2023 23:14

yellowspanner · 24/11/2023 23:10

I don't see the problem with helping those who can work getting employment. The welfare bill is enormous in the UK. Surely all those that can work should work rather than depend on others for welfare

Lots of disabled people who could potentially work want to. Sadly, many employers are not keen on employing disabled people.

Benibidibici · 24/11/2023 23:12

Tell me what wfh job a deaf person brought up in mainstream school, worked in the land of the hearing, can no longer use a phone, and has mental health issues do from home? BTW I used to be a top earner

My job and lots of office jobs could accomodate someone who can only communicate in writing. There's also lots of software available now to hear whats said in a meet and transcribe it immediately on screen, there's also voice software if you wanted it.

Are any of your mental health issues worsened by not being able to work?

yellowspanner · 24/11/2023 23:10

I don't see the problem with helping those who can work getting employment. The welfare bill is enormous in the UK. Surely all those that can work should work rather than depend on others for welfare

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 24/11/2023 23:09

ChatBFP · 24/11/2023 22:56

@XDownwiththissortofthingX

We do have a higher proportion of people claiming (since the pandemic) than equivalent EU countries though. Probably this is about our health service failing people.

Yes, that's to be expected considering what a shambles our government made of handling the pandemic, but the point I'm making is that changes in the landscape re "disability" benefits were well underway prior to 2020, and it's not solely a consequence of Covid 19.

There was a distinct change in how CWA were carried out between 2010 and 2017, the time period where I attended the bulk of the ones I sat in on, and a corresponding increase in the number of people I worked with being awarded benefit without having to undergo appeal and tribunal.

I think what we're seeing is a particularly vicious, venal government railing against the fact their immediate predecessors (Cameron & Co) were actually concerned about the optics of the whole ATOS farce, whereas the current incumbents do not care, hence the nastiness, spite, and cruelty.

Benibidibici · 24/11/2023 23:08

I don't love the underlying vibe here (not a tory voter)

But I do struggle with the sheer percentage of people these days who are apparently unable to do any labour at all. As a society i feel like we're getting something so wrong if so many people can't cope, struggling with depression, anxiety etc.

For the vast majority of people, work helps mental health and improves their life. A life on disability benefits is not a great life. I can understand wanting to support people to find work they can manage that might help. The onus needs to be on employers to be as flexible as possible to accommodate.

Babyroobs · 24/11/2023 23:05

Stomacharmeleon · 24/11/2023 23:03

Adam hills said he spoke to Penny Mordaunt when he visited the HOC and she reassured him...
Nothing will happen until 2025.
Those already disabled and on pip/ limited capability will not have anything to worry about.
It's more aimed at those who have sat and home and not worked or attempted to try after 18 months.

We may have a different government by then.

Exactly this. I wish people would stop panicking.

Stomacharmeleon · 24/11/2023 23:03

Adam hills said he spoke to Penny Mordaunt when he visited the HOC and she reassured him...
Nothing will happen until 2025.
Those already disabled and on pip/ limited capability will not have anything to worry about.
It's more aimed at those who have sat and home and not worked or attempted to try after 18 months.

We may have a different government by then.

CluelessHamster · 24/11/2023 23:03

Yep. I have hated the lot of them since we were one of the first lucky postcodes to change from DLA to PIP and my autistic 16 year old, who previously qualified for lower rate both care and mobility - a fair assessment - suddenly scored zero points. And there was me thinking you couldn't cure autism but the Tories somehow managed it! This also meant we lost the disability element of tax credits so, in total, lost out on about 3k a year.

I never liked them anyway but I will never forgive them for the stress and upset caused by the assessment (the assessors pants must have burst into flames when she wrote her report) and subsequent failed appeal after which my son refused to apply again as it was so traumatic for him.

We were ok and he never went without but so many people had it worse.

I hate them all.

DementedPanda · 24/11/2023 23:02

And people with anxiety and depression who have worked in high pressure jobs, overcoming obstacles in their way who can no longer work due to disability getting worse? Due to disability having no confidence and severe anxiety/panic attacks and depression? They have paid into the system too. Don't they deserve to be protected? Tell me what wfh job a deaf person brought up in mainstream school, worked in the land of the hearing, can no longer use a phone, and has mental health issues do from home? BTW I used to be a top earner

Keepingittogetherstepbystep · 24/11/2023 23:01

MyopicBunny · 24/11/2023 20:43

Exactly, the PIP assessments are already unfair. The assessors tell lies about people being able to walk across a car park when they couldn't. Most people only get PIP on appeal when doctors are the one who decide if you're eligible (much fairer).

I read a report on a personal that said they'd been seen waking across the car park. That person was dropped off and picked up at the door so that was a blatant lie on the report.

The irony is don't most wfh jobs insist you have a dedicated quite area. I'm assuming whoever is making these decisions has never spent much time in a disabled person's home. Wheren't most of the forced to move because of the bedroom tax if they lived in social housing. Those I private renting are probably scared to pick up the post notifying them of unaffordable rent increases or section 21.

I reckon they are readying for a June election.

Babyroobs · 24/11/2023 23:01

Babyroobs · 24/11/2023 22:58

And if she has already been awarded LCWRA on ESA or UC then she won't have any further assessments from 2025 unless her condition improves for example she gets her hip replacement and it significantly improves her mobility ( likely as that's why joints are replaced ). in this case she would need to report that her condition has improved and may be re-assessed.

Sorry just saw regarding her spinal problems which are not likely to improve so very unlikely she would be re-assessed. Please try to tell her not to worry !

funbags3 · 24/11/2023 23:01

Will those with learning disabilities be made to work from home? What kind of jobs are available if you've never worked before?

Babyroobs · 24/11/2023 22:58

Babyroobs · 24/11/2023 22:54

Is she getting PIP ? I honestly don't think that this group of people need to be worried. I think these proposals have cause scaremongering unecessarily.

And if she has already been awarded LCWRA on ESA or UC then she won't have any further assessments from 2025 unless her condition improves for example she gets her hip replacement and it significantly improves her mobility ( likely as that's why joints are replaced ). in this case she would need to report that her condition has improved and may be re-assessed.

Astridastro · 24/11/2023 22:58

My DD is an adult with anxiety, she has not left the house in 2 years, she had to leave school in her final year before completing her final exams, she now has OCD as well. She won’t even apply for any benefits because of the likes of people on this thread as she doesn’t look unwell, even applying gives her panic attacks and anxiety. We are extremely fortunate in that as a family we can still adopted to feed and house her. Her life is a living hell and there is nothing she would like more than to have the normal life of a teenager and be working or at uni/college.

As for myself, I have spent all night in bed in pain from working today, I have had to cut back my hours from full time to part time as I physically cannot cope anymore. I already get ADP and I don’t know how long I will be able to keep working. I am absolutely terrified of not being able to work due to ill health. It give me great anxiety.

I also look after children with severe and complex needs and some of the comments on here about disabled people are disgusting. Their parents are their carers, they cannot work themselves due to their care duties so need the CDPs in order to live. I don’t grudge them a penny, it’s a 24/7 job the only respite is when they are at school. Some never get a full nights sleep. Maybe the Government want to go back in time and lock them up in hospitals, chained to beds until they die and are buried in the hospital cemeteries? No autism in those days! That’s what a lot of the old folks say “there was none of this autism in my day?” that’s because everyone was locked away?!

ChatBFP · 24/11/2023 22:56

@XDownwiththissortofthingX

We do have a higher proportion of people claiming (since the pandemic) than equivalent EU countries though. Probably this is about our health service failing people.

MyOtherNameToday · 24/11/2023 22:56

I'm angry about this for several reasons but the truth is that the piss takers are the ones who have brought this about. This includes the piss takers in government who have cut health and care services to the bone.

But there are individuals who are so blatantly taking the piss that they have helped create this situation.

I had a perfectly normal life until I was hospitalised with severe, sudden neurological symptoms. I have an incurable progressive neurological condition. Having worked all my life I assumed there was a safety net there, I just hadn't needed it before.

The whole process of applying for these benefits was utterly degrading. My PIP was awarded at the highest rate first time and the assessor was lovely and was frankly embarrassed by the whole thing. The vibe I got was very much: you have the kind of severe illness that these benefits were designed for and I am so sorry that I am asking these degrading questions because some absolute piss takers have forced us to make this a punitive process.

The irony is that very ill people don't have the energy to fight this system - the piss takers have the time and energy along with the brass neck to do it.