Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this government are at war with disabled people and always have been?

259 replies

MyopicBunny · 24/11/2023 20:20

I am assuming that the part of their UC that will be cut is the disabled element? Most people can’t even get this at all if you are disabled. The rules to receive it in the first place are extremely strict.

Why us nobody talking about this? Has our society now become brainwashed with the idea that it’s acceptable to call disabled people with significant needs benefit scroungers?

Why is it the most vulnerable being shat on from a great height, over and over??

OP posts:
Disillusioned11 · 25/11/2023 00:58

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 25/11/2023 00:46

First paragraph - Right, so if I'm understanding you correctly, your beef with PIP claimants and so on, is that these benefits are not contributions based. So how do you expect someone disabled to "contribute" to benefits which are 1. awarded on qualifying criterion, not contributions in the first place, and 2. when they are incapable of contributing because they are incapable of independently earning?

Are you seriously suggesting that disability benefits should also be strictly contributions based?

2nd paragraph - Well its no real surprise that in countries where they ascertain the number of disabled people by tallying the number of disability claimants those two numbers happen to marry up, is it?

Presumably you also believe there are absolutely no disabled people in these countries who do not claim benefit. Like, not a single one. After all, by your "logic", if they're not claiming disability benefit, they're can't possibly be disabled.

It's not "1 in 4 according to me", it's 24% of the UK population according to the DWP's own figures. But of course, because you don't see 1 in 4 people in a wheelchair you obviously know better...

The reasons for our disabled population being so high are numerous, and it's an onerous discussion I really don't have the inclination to get into on here, but suffice to say we are a hugely unhealthy country by comparison to most of our near neighbours, typical UK lifestyles are less conducive to long life and good health, and our general societal attitudes to things like economy, mental health provision, tax and spend, and the fact wealth is centred and hoarded in small parts of the country is also a significant factor in why the UK churns out people with a huge preponderance of poor mental and physical health. You can't even totally discount the impact of climate. Look at the Scandi countries and their issues with depressive illnesses. It's no different in the north of the UK, although I would not expect someone who has spent their entire life in the South or South East of England, for arguments sake, to have any inkling of that because in terms of average temps and sunlight it truly is a different world altogether. Then there's the UK's obsession with alcohol, chronic drug usage that spiralled out of control under Thatcherism and is still killing people in their 60's and 70's who have never recovered from that period.

The UK is not the same as any other country you might care to mention, so like for like comparisons are impossible, and serve no worthwhile purpose.

You seem insistent on claiming things I have not said. For the final time, I haven’t made any comment one way or the other regarding PIP claimants other than to say when 1:20 people claim it or approximately 1:5 disabled people receive it (& it’s meant for the most severe disabilities where people can not work at all) it’s not really statistically correct claim its a ‘hard to get’ benefit. You made a comparison with state pension which I pointed out is a completely different benefit as it is contribution based and so of course some people will feel differently.

As for the uk in comparison to other countries, I think it is interesting to look at similarities and difference but you also don’t get to pick the statistics you like only. Because there may well be figures that support % disability vs sunlight or even Maggie Thatcher if you like …. Please feel free to share but the statistic I find interesting is the close correlation between % of people with disability and benefits paid. (Norway seems to buck this trend somewhat- I wonder why?)

To think that this government are at war with disabled people and always have been?
Kerantli · 25/11/2023 00:49

It took me 2 attempts to get a WCA, the first time I was deemed "fit to work" despite the fact I fell into the wall on the way into the interveiw room from loss of balance while using a walking stick that the interviewer saw happen.
I need to be supervised by my partner when I'm in the shower, when I was able to cook and when I leave the flat. My partner does 99% of my care on his own with very little breathing room for him to take care of his own disabilites (Autism and ADHD).

What employer would want to hire me if I need so much supervision when at home?
And these mythical entry level work from home jobs? I have no qualifications, my highest grade I got was a D at GCSE level, had to drop out of college so no A-levels.
I'd need any job to be flexible enough for when pain levels get so high I can't lift my head, never mind get out of bed.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 25/11/2023 00:46

Disillusioned11 · 25/11/2023 00:23

Sorry if my point wasn’t clear but I believe you stated that people don’t complain regarding entitlement of state of state pension. I was simply pointing out that people tend to not complain about people receiving a benefit when they perceive that those people have actually contributed and paid into it for as I was corrected 35 years of payments in fact.

As I stated my social group and my observation of the people around me and the 10,000 plus people I’ve dealt with through work is not that 1 in 5 (or 4 according to you) is disabled. Amazing really? A quarter of the population is disabled. I wonder why it’s so very high in the uk in comparison with other countries. It’s a strange phenomenon that where in countries where statistics exist the percentage of disabled people directly correlates with the amount of benefits paid to them. Google it.

First paragraph - Right, so if I'm understanding you correctly, your beef with PIP claimants and so on, is that these benefits are not contributions based. So how do you expect someone disabled to "contribute" to benefits which are 1. awarded on qualifying criterion, not contributions in the first place, and 2. when they are incapable of contributing because they are incapable of independently earning?

Are you seriously suggesting that disability benefits should also be strictly contributions based?

2nd paragraph - Well its no real surprise that in countries where they ascertain the number of disabled people by tallying the number of disability claimants those two numbers happen to marry up, is it?

Presumably you also believe there are absolutely no disabled people in these countries who do not claim benefit. Like, not a single one. After all, by your "logic", if they're not claiming disability benefit, they're can't possibly be disabled.

It's not "1 in 4 according to me", it's 24% of the UK population according to the DWP's own figures. But of course, because you don't see 1 in 4 people in a wheelchair you obviously know better...

The reasons for our disabled population being so high are numerous, and it's an onerous discussion I really don't have the inclination to get into on here, but suffice to say we are a hugely unhealthy country by comparison to most of our near neighbours, typical UK lifestyles are less conducive to long life and good health, and our general societal attitudes to things like economy, mental health provision, tax and spend, and the fact wealth is centred and hoarded in small parts of the country is also a significant factor in why the UK churns out people with a huge preponderance of poor mental and physical health. You can't even totally discount the impact of climate. Look at the Scandi countries and their issues with depressive illnesses. It's no different in the north of the UK, although I would not expect someone who has spent their entire life in the South or South East of England, for arguments sake, to have any inkling of that because in terms of average temps and sunlight it truly is a different world altogether. Then there's the UK's obsession with alcohol, chronic drug usage that spiralled out of control under Thatcherism and is still killing people in their 60's and 70's who have never recovered from that period.

The UK is not the same as any other country you might care to mention, so like for like comparisons are impossible, and serve no worthwhile purpose.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 25/11/2023 00:44

I know there aren't nearly as many lords and ladies as there are disabled people, but if every penny of taxpayers' money really counts (except when they clearly show that it doesn't), the government could do a lot worse than seek to sanction all of the lazy ones who turn up to sign in and get their generous daily fee, with the taxi still waiting outside with the engine running; or those who do stay there for a while, but just sit reading their paper or having a nap.

TooBigForMyBoots · 25/11/2023 00:31

Disillusioned11 · 24/11/2023 23:25

“PIP (which is not mean tested, is not an out of work benefits, and is notoriously hard to get).”

1 in 20 people in England receive PIP … so is not “hard to get”

That's 5%. I can easily see how we could have 5% of the population in need of and in receipt of PIP.

What % of the population do you think have severe disability @Disillusioned11?

Tina221 · 25/11/2023 00:28

JaceLancs · 25/11/2023 00:10

It’s actually harder to get PIP if you work and/or drive despite the motability scheme
so makes no sense that they are trying to join up wca and pip
To everyone who questions benefits for those with disabilities - why? Do disabled or ill people not deserve the same opportunities in life as you?
There is so much ignorance about the hidden costs of being disabled - have you looked at the price of aids, special diets, continence products etc? financial assessment and contribution rates for needing someone to help you with personal care? It’s not free!!!

You have said everything I wanted to say, thank you.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 25/11/2023 00:25

Far too many people - including in the government - believe that there's a clearly-defined binary of groups: (1) the people who are so severely disabled that they can't do a single thing for themselves; and (2) everybody else who is completely fit and well save for the odd annoying cold or tickly cough every now and again

God yes, this.

Still clear just from this thread alone that for some people, absence of a visible wheelchair or an iron lung = no possibility of disability.

Disillusioned11 · 25/11/2023 00:23

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 25/11/2023 00:09

As pointed out, it's 35. Regardless, the fact Pensions are dependent on NI contributions is immaterial to the point, which is that entitlement should go hand in hand with ease of access, so I'm puzzled at the assertion that benefits should be "difficult" to get, because you either qualify or you do not.

1 in 20 claiming PIP is an indication that at least 1 in 20 qualify for PIP. I say "at least", because like with most benefits, there will be plenty who do qualify but do not claim or have never applied.

To address some earlier points -

Your social circle is not particularly relevant because we're talking about a State, and small sample sizes will very rarely be representative of the whole. If you draw conclusions about the entire UK based on the people you know and socialise with, what am I supposed to make of the fact that the majority of the people I work with, socialise with, my family, my partner, and I myself are all disabled? That's a quirk of circumstance, and is no more relevant to the macro picture than your own small group. Anecdotal observations aren't particularly relevant when they are based on tiny samples. So yes, almost by default your "area" and social circle are highly likely to be atypical and unrepresentative, as is mine.

It's actually closer to 1 in 4 people who are officially considered disabled in any case, and huge numbers of those will be claiming no benefits whatsoever, so I have reservations about your claim that 1 in 5 people in the UK are claiming disability related benefits.

Sorry if my point wasn’t clear but I believe you stated that people don’t complain regarding entitlement of state of state pension. I was simply pointing out that people tend to not complain about people receiving a benefit when they perceive that those people have actually contributed and paid into it for as I was corrected 35 years of payments in fact.

As I stated my social group and my observation of the people around me and the 10,000 plus people I’ve dealt with through work is not that 1 in 5 (or 4 according to you) is disabled. Amazing really? A quarter of the population is disabled. I wonder why it’s so very high in the uk in comparison with other countries. It’s a strange phenomenon that where in countries where statistics exist the percentage of disabled people directly correlates with the amount of benefits paid to them. Google it.

XenoBitch · 25/11/2023 00:22

My FB feed threw up an ad for my local police force, and how inclusive they are... so if you are disabled, then they might have role for you.
I had a look... nothing is suitable for someone with no experience in anything, no qualifications, no references, maybe have a police record due to MH etc.

TooBigForMyBoots · 25/11/2023 00:21

CroftonWillow · 24/11/2023 21:09

Like everything I'm sure there's many factors that play into the figures and if I was conducting the review would try to look at the data 'in the round'. I'm sure it's not straightforward.

Unfortunately this government is incapable of looking at things in the round. See also pledges to lock up more prisoners for longer when the prison system is at breaking point, judges are being told to reduce custodial sentences and the UK is exploring sending prisoners abroad!Shock

We have the most incompetent government ever. All they do is tell lies, talk shite and fight amongst themselves while the country goes down. All they have left is dehumanising, degrading rhetoric.Hmm

Don't get sucked in.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 25/11/2023 00:20

It’s actually harder to get PIP if you work and/or drive despite the motability scheme
so makes no sense that they are trying to join up wca and pip
To everyone who questions benefits for those with disabilities - why? Do disabled or ill people not deserve the same opportunities in life as you?

Yes, it's especially nasty to be trying to encourage/force people to be more independent in the knowledge that you will then use that against them to 'prove' that they are lazy liars.

Far too many people - including in the government - believe that there's a clearly-defined binary of groups: (1) the people who are so severely disabled that they can't do a single thing for themselves; and (2) everybody else who is completely fit and well save for the odd annoying cold or tickly cough every now and again.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 25/11/2023 00:11

MyopicBunny · 24/11/2023 23:58

Carer's allowance pays this, I believe if you're in receipt of it.

Most, if not all active benefit claims see your "Insurance stamp" paid for the duration. ESA certainly used to, and even if you do not qualify for a payment due to spousal income or such, provided your claim is contiguous DWP continues to "pay" your NI contribution to State Pension.

JaceLancs · 25/11/2023 00:10

It’s actually harder to get PIP if you work and/or drive despite the motability scheme
so makes no sense that they are trying to join up wca and pip
To everyone who questions benefits for those with disabilities - why? Do disabled or ill people not deserve the same opportunities in life as you?
There is so much ignorance about the hidden costs of being disabled - have you looked at the price of aids, special diets, continence products etc? financial assessment and contribution rates for needing someone to help you with personal care? It’s not free!!!

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 25/11/2023 00:09

Disillusioned11 · 24/11/2023 23:46

State pensions are a contribution based benefit… you have to contribute - 25 years of NI payments I believe - to get the full benefit.

Edited

As pointed out, it's 35. Regardless, the fact Pensions are dependent on NI contributions is immaterial to the point, which is that entitlement should go hand in hand with ease of access, so I'm puzzled at the assertion that benefits should be "difficult" to get, because you either qualify or you do not.

1 in 20 claiming PIP is an indication that at least 1 in 20 qualify for PIP. I say "at least", because like with most benefits, there will be plenty who do qualify but do not claim or have never applied.

To address some earlier points -

Your social circle is not particularly relevant because we're talking about a State, and small sample sizes will very rarely be representative of the whole. If you draw conclusions about the entire UK based on the people you know and socialise with, what am I supposed to make of the fact that the majority of the people I work with, socialise with, my family, my partner, and I myself are all disabled? That's a quirk of circumstance, and is no more relevant to the macro picture than your own small group. Anecdotal observations aren't particularly relevant when they are based on tiny samples. So yes, almost by default your "area" and social circle are highly likely to be atypical and unrepresentative, as is mine.

It's actually closer to 1 in 4 people who are officially considered disabled in any case, and huge numbers of those will be claiming no benefits whatsoever, so I have reservations about your claim that 1 in 5 people in the UK are claiming disability related benefits.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 25/11/2023 00:06

How will they need to job hunt 8 hours a day? If they are only able to apply for work from home jobs and there are few available it's not going to take long to find them online and apply. Probably a few minutes a day.

Have you ever applied for a job yourself? Did it only take you a few minutes to submit an application? Really?

I know the 'we don't receive enough taxes to fund this' claims are pure lies. There are so many unnecessary things that the government unquestioningly shovels money out to pay for - there's never any shortage of money for wars and aggressive military actions. As Tony Benn said, if we have the money to kill people, we have the money to help people.

Adam hills said he spoke to Penny Mordaunt when he visited the HOC and she reassured him...
Nothing will happen until 2025.
Those already disabled and on pip/ limited capability will not have anything to worry about.
It's more aimed at those who have sat and home and not worked or attempted to try after 18 months.

We may have a different government by then.

Do you really not understand that we are talking about the actual livelihood and continued ability to exist of a great many disabled and vulnerable people here? It's not just them wanting to close down your local golf club, meaning that you might end up getting a little bit bored on Sunday afternoons.

Just because people are disabled, that doesn't make them dim simpletons who are somehow unable to realise or care that they will still need to survive after 2025 - a little over a year away.

If you were told that there were plans to make your job industry illegal, bulldoze your house, take away your driving licence and close all of the food shops within a 20-mile radius, would you find that 'reassuring' if it wasn't going to happen for at least 13 months?

Willyoujustbequiet · 25/11/2023 00:04

ElevenSeven · 24/11/2023 22:06

People with disabilities, yes.

Adults with anxiety, fuck no. I’m not working every day god sends so a grown adult can stay home and feel anxious or have depression, and do nothing long term.

I’m glad they want to change some of it.

Staggeringly ignorant comment.

MyopicBunny · 24/11/2023 23:58

Disillusioned11 · 24/11/2023 23:46

State pensions are a contribution based benefit… you have to contribute - 25 years of NI payments I believe - to get the full benefit.

Edited

Carer's allowance pays this, I believe if you're in receipt of it.

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 24/11/2023 23:56

ambley · 24/11/2023 23:51

That's not great. I don't know how people manage on the basic amount. They're not managing in my experience.

Exactly.
I have a friend who is on the ESA version of LCW, but it does come with extra money (but not as much as support/LCWRA). That extra was stopped in 2017.
I remember sending a panic ridden message to my work coach about being awarded LCW and still expected to live on £70 a week... and for how long? My friend has been in her group for years and has cut her cloth so to speak (but is also on PIP, I am not).

ambley · 24/11/2023 23:51

XenoBitch · 24/11/2023 21:11

I think we can expect a lot more people to be awarded LCW rather than LCWRA as they are removing the ' serious risk' descriptor

No extra money in LCW though, so many people will be plunged into deeper poverty, which in turn has an effect on health.

That's not great. I don't know how people manage on the basic amount. They're not managing in my experience.

ambley · 24/11/2023 23:49

I didn't know about this. Though universal credit sounds like a dreadful thing to navigate.

I've been looking for working from home jobs. None allow complete remote working, requiring some time in the office, and all have said that a period of training, completely in the office, is required for the first 3-6 months. Though to be fair a sales/customer service based role only required two weeks initial training then two days a week in the office, three remote.

Babyroobs · 24/11/2023 23:49

Disillusioned11 · 24/11/2023 23:46

State pensions are a contribution based benefit… you have to contribute - 25 years of NI payments I believe - to get the full benefit.

Edited

35 I think.

Disillusioned11 · 24/11/2023 23:46

State pensions are a contribution based benefit… you have to contribute - 25 years of NI payments I believe - to get the full benefit.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 24/11/2023 23:44

Babyroobs · 24/11/2023 23:30

Presumably a lot of those could be on DLA or Attendance Allowance or are we just talking about 10.4 million working age disabled people?

Well the jist of my point is that when you consider 24% of the entire population is considered disabled, the fact that only 1 in 20, or 5%, have been awarded PIP doesn't exactly back up the argument that it's an "easy" benefit to get.

The only relevant figure will be the number of claims v's the number of eventual awards, but even then, that only tells you about people who are actually bothering to claim, and ignores all of those who likely would be eligible for an award but don't bother applying for one reason or another.

Anyway, I'm unsure what the problem with a benefit that is "easy" to get supposedly is, since surely if you are eligible and in need the process should be as fair and straightforward as possible. State Pensions are a benefit, and they are fairly "easy" to get once you become eligible, yet I don't hear the same people moaning and whining about the perceived injustice of that.

Disillusioned11 · 24/11/2023 23:41

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 24/11/2023 23:28

2.8 million PIP claimants, yet 10.4 million disabled people.

If it's easy to be awarded PIP, why is the number of claimants not far higher?

Because having a disability and having a disability so severe that means you can not work are two different things?

10.4 million people are disabled … out of a total population of 55 millions. So 1 in every 5 people in this country claim disability benefit.
I guess I must live in a very atypical area and my social circle must be very atypical because 1 in every 5 people aren’t disabled and 1 in every 20 so much so that they are unable to work.

XenoBitch · 24/11/2023 23:39

Disillusioned11 · 24/11/2023 23:25

“PIP (which is not mean tested, is not an out of work benefits, and is notoriously hard to get).”

1 in 20 people in England receive PIP … so is not “hard to get”

Have you tried to claim it?
I have known so many people who have tried to claim...mountains of evidence, and they get turned down. Yes, many get it after tribunal, but many give up at the first hurdle as it is demoralising and difficult.
Also, the assessors are known to lie. There are many accounts you can read about people who were told they could walk ok (when they were in a wheelchair), made good eye contact (assessment was over the phone), were laughing and joking (assessment was actually paused due to claimant having a panic attack) etc it goes on.
I have never applied as my MH team were worried it would put me at significant risk of harming myself.