Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this government are at war with disabled people and always have been?

259 replies

MyopicBunny · 24/11/2023 20:20

I am assuming that the part of their UC that will be cut is the disabled element? Most people can’t even get this at all if you are disabled. The rules to receive it in the first place are extremely strict.

Why us nobody talking about this? Has our society now become brainwashed with the idea that it’s acceptable to call disabled people with significant needs benefit scroungers?

Why is it the most vulnerable being shat on from a great height, over and over??

OP posts:
TigerRag · 25/11/2023 09:55

SuspiciousSue · 25/11/2023 08:52

Why is it so bad to be told to find work that they can do from home? I’ve got epilepsy and work full time. Part of my reasonable adjustment is that I work full time from home due to tiredness caused by medication and the need to have privacy if I were to have a seizure. Also, probably 75% of the time, I can continue working after a seizure with a short break. If it’s slightly worse, I might have a lie down and then finish early. Being at home allows that.

I’m on epilepsy forums where people refuse point blank to even look for work. I get it if you’re having 20 tonic clonic seizures a day. When I have those, I’m like a zombie. But if you can find something suitable then just do it 🤷‍♀️ It’s possible.

Where are all these entry level work from home jobs? I googled out of curiosity and it was either a pip assessor or translator.

Ladybees · 25/11/2023 09:49

SuspiciousSue · 25/11/2023 08:52

Why is it so bad to be told to find work that they can do from home? I’ve got epilepsy and work full time. Part of my reasonable adjustment is that I work full time from home due to tiredness caused by medication and the need to have privacy if I were to have a seizure. Also, probably 75% of the time, I can continue working after a seizure with a short break. If it’s slightly worse, I might have a lie down and then finish early. Being at home allows that.

I’m on epilepsy forums where people refuse point blank to even look for work. I get it if you’re having 20 tonic clonic seizures a day. When I have those, I’m like a zombie. But if you can find something suitable then just do it 🤷‍♀️ It’s possible.

The reason it's so bad is largely because the government won't actually provide any help with preparing for, finding, or keeping those jobs. Particularly the preparation stage which might involve time training/getting qualifications etc. If their aim was to get disabled people into work this is what they'd focus on.

Instead they will just say that people should be able to do some mythical work from home job (or job where other reasonable adjustments can be made) and remove their benefit entitlement on that basis, whether they can find one of these jobs or not. Plunging people into dire poverty on top of their existing issues, pushing them even further from the workplace, worsening their health issues.

It's NOT about getting disabled people to work, it's about getting disabled people off benefits.

I should point out that Universal Credit (which replaced all previous out-of-work benefits including disability-related ones) can be claimed whilst in work, with earnings reducing benefit in such a way you're almost always better off working. This is a lifeline for disabled people who can only manage part-time work. Cutting UC for disabled claimants will affect these people who are clearly trying their best to work.

Out of interest (and somewhat taking notes for my own situation!) how did you get your work from home job? Has it always been WFH or did you attend a workplace initially to prove yourself before WFH was granted? What qualifications did you need - and how did support yourself financially whilst getting these? How did you get references - were they from jobs working outside the home? How did you convince employers to see past large gaps on your CV and jobs lost due to your epilepsy? If there were no lost jobs - why not? Did you manage to work for long enough that you couldn't easily be dismissed, did you have jobs that had flexible hours or where it wasn't a huge problem if you needed time off sick?
What I'm trying to understand is how a disabled person can go about getting past all these barriers and find a suitable job - I suspect it's a lot easier if you become disabled later on in life with a good work history and/or already in a job where adjustments can be made.

JaniceJanice · 25/11/2023 09:45

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 24/11/2023 22:53

It's not just a phenomenon linked to the Covid timeline.

Around 10 years ago it was enormously difficult to be awarded DLA for purely mental health reasons. Approximately 80% of all rejected applications were eventually awarded once they had been pursued through mandatory reconsideration and then Tribunal. These were only the rejected application that were actually challenged though, not ALL rejected applications. So the long and short of it is that the majority of people who absolutely should have been awarded DLA were not, and at best, they'd end up on JSA and be subject to the strictures that come with that.

Over the years, increased exposure of just how unfit for purpose the Capability assessments were, and scrutiny of the processes used by ATOS served to temper somewhat the DWP's thirst for finding people fit for work who clearly were not. Of course, this pressure for "targets" came from Government, which is in itself utterly beyond ridicule. The idea that you must find people perfectly fit for work lest doing otherwise takes you over a completely arbitrary threshold. Complete and utter nonsense to begin with.

So the reality is that this picture of a vastly increased number of disability-related claimants is a bit misleading, because we're not "more ill", the Government was just getting away with finding many more ill and unfit for work people fit for work, until the nonsense of how they were going about this was laid bare for the scandal it was and they rowed back from it.

The numbers claiming these benefits now are a fairer reflection of reality, and more akin to where they always should have been, not some sort of indicator that vast numbers of people are "at it". Of course, the Tories don't care about that, and would far rather have the public blaming the unfortunate for their own misfortune, rather that question why we have a society that creates huge numbers of mentally ill people who are incapable of work.

Very true.

So many people don’t understand the nuance of statistics and think ‘number up=X’ and ‘number down =Y’ and don’t realise (or care to realise) that there are a number of factors affecting statistics.

My brother is one such statistic- 10 years ago he was beaten unconscious with a crowbar on the street-

he was left with a traumatic brain injury that caused major memory loss. He lives alone- He can’t use a cooker for example because he will forget that the hob is on and cause a fire. He can’t drive safely or take journeys outside the couple of streets round his house because he gets lost and can’t get home. He can’t remember appointments, times, peoples names etc.

Basically he can’t function beyond going to the corner shop for a ready meal and microwaving it or popping two doors down to his friends house.

When was he awarded PIP and finally found unable to work and awarded the benefit the government now wants to cut? 2 weeks ago. It’s taken 10 years for the assessors to accept that someone who basically has dementia can’t get up and off to work on the bus on their own, and accept that no one will employ someone who can’t even remember that they have a job, never mind do said job.

LizzieW1969 · 25/11/2023 09:43

XenoBitch · 24/11/2023 23:39

Have you tried to claim it?
I have known so many people who have tried to claim...mountains of evidence, and they get turned down. Yes, many get it after tribunal, but many give up at the first hurdle as it is demoralising and difficult.
Also, the assessors are known to lie. There are many accounts you can read about people who were told they could walk ok (when they were in a wheelchair), made good eye contact (assessment was over the phone), were laughing and joking (assessment was actually paused due to claimant having a panic attack) etc it goes on.
I have never applied as my MH team were worried it would put me at significant risk of harming myself.

Yes, my DB (56) was turned down for PIP a few years ago, despite having suffered from severe MH issues for 30 years and having no hope of getting a job. He was only awarded it on appeal, which wouldn’t have happened if my DM hadn’t made it happen for him.

RosaGallica · 25/11/2023 09:25

This government are at war with the working British people and always have been. Full stop. Unfortunately so have all governments for the last 50 years, and yet another u-turn from the New New Labour government this morning does not engender confidence that the trend will change. Over my life I have seen a country that at least tried to be democratic and meritocratic, and practice the values of freedom of speech, freedom of information, inclusivity, equality and informed consent to the rule of law be utterly destroyed. In its place are the values of exploitation to make money for the wealthy, and the values of aggression and the politics of social and wealth connection. We are back in the days of Imperium.

Zebedee55 · 25/11/2023 09:20

FelicityFlops · 24/11/2023 21:38

Please explain to me why any government should be responsible for disabled people.

I don't know - perhaps for the same reasons the government/taxpayer take "responsibility" for health, with the NHS, state education, benefits generally, pensions and a variety of other things.

Its called collective responsibility for those needing help and support.

HTH.🙄

ffsrainagain · 25/11/2023 09:19

Whilst I agree with you OP that these changes are terrifying (as someone who receives LCWRA and PIP) they are not set to come in until after the next election so may never happen.... fingers crossed this useless lot get booted out of office!

irishmurdoch · 25/11/2023 09:18

It's another way to kick disabled people. Govt knows full well there are not thousands of unfilled remote working jobs that disabled people can suddenly decide to do. If these jobs existed, there would be fierce competition for them, for example from parents looking for flexibility.

JaniceJanice · 25/11/2023 09:10

Disillusioned11 · 25/11/2023 00:23

Sorry if my point wasn’t clear but I believe you stated that people don’t complain regarding entitlement of state of state pension. I was simply pointing out that people tend to not complain about people receiving a benefit when they perceive that those people have actually contributed and paid into it for as I was corrected 35 years of payments in fact.

As I stated my social group and my observation of the people around me and the 10,000 plus people I’ve dealt with through work is not that 1 in 5 (or 4 according to you) is disabled. Amazing really? A quarter of the population is disabled. I wonder why it’s so very high in the uk in comparison with other countries. It’s a strange phenomenon that where in countries where statistics exist the percentage of disabled people directly correlates with the amount of benefits paid to them. Google it.

I don’t think you understand how statistics work.

If ‘number of disabled people’ is ascertained by looking at ‘number of people claiming disability benefits’ then clearly those two figures will always correlate- they will rise and fall together.

in other countries ‘number of disabled people’ is ascertained by some other thing, say ‘number of people in care home’ or ‘number of people on medication’, then those numbers will correlate.

This doesn’t prove causation- this statistical analysis does not show that we have more disabled people because we give disability benefits, it just shows how we happen to have measured the data. It doesn’t show any causation at all.

sollenwir · 25/11/2023 09:03

XenoBitch · 24/11/2023 20:24

YANBU, but then a lot of people wont talk about it as it wont affect them.

It will affect me, and I am bloody terrified.

It won't affect me directly, currently at least (but who knows what our future might bring?). It still really bothers me though, that the most vulnerable (and potentially financially struggling) are targets yet again.

sollenwir · 25/11/2023 09:01

GirrlCrush · 24/11/2023 20:22

Yabu to assume we have all seen /read/know about whatever it is you are talking about!

When watching news events I've been more concerned when seeing footage from Gaza lately

YABU to assume we all only care about the same things as you.

Babyroobs · 25/11/2023 08:59

SuspiciousSue · 25/11/2023 08:52

Why is it so bad to be told to find work that they can do from home? I’ve got epilepsy and work full time. Part of my reasonable adjustment is that I work full time from home due to tiredness caused by medication and the need to have privacy if I were to have a seizure. Also, probably 75% of the time, I can continue working after a seizure with a short break. If it’s slightly worse, I might have a lie down and then finish early. Being at home allows that.

I’m on epilepsy forums where people refuse point blank to even look for work. I get it if you’re having 20 tonic clonic seizures a day. When I have those, I’m like a zombie. But if you can find something suitable then just do it 🤷‍♀️ It’s possible.

Yes my brother is the same, works a lot from home as epilepsy medication makes him tir easily and he can't drive. He gets a free bus/ train pass for when he does need to go into the office. He has always worked from aged 16 although his seizures are fairly well controlled.

SuspiciousSue · 25/11/2023 08:52

Why is it so bad to be told to find work that they can do from home? I’ve got epilepsy and work full time. Part of my reasonable adjustment is that I work full time from home due to tiredness caused by medication and the need to have privacy if I were to have a seizure. Also, probably 75% of the time, I can continue working after a seizure with a short break. If it’s slightly worse, I might have a lie down and then finish early. Being at home allows that.

I’m on epilepsy forums where people refuse point blank to even look for work. I get it if you’re having 20 tonic clonic seizures a day. When I have those, I’m like a zombie. But if you can find something suitable then just do it 🤷‍♀️ It’s possible.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 25/11/2023 08:39

TigerRag · 25/11/2023 07:45

Disabled students allowance is only for people in higher education. You can't get it for GCSE, A Levels and courses that are the same level.

Yes, perhaps I should have been clearer. Not having appropriate support earlier is such a barrier to higher education. So many students are amazed at what they can achieve with the appropriate support. You do not need any qualifications to study with The Open University but it can affect benefits. It is worth investigating though depending on circumstances.

TigerRag · 25/11/2023 07:45

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 25/11/2023 06:56

I do not in anyway intend this post to be saying that disabled people who cannot work should be made to. I do however want to highlight two benefits which are helpful - Disabled Student Allowance and Access to Work. Both schemes seem to be really positive in how they are applied. The assessments are supportive. The number of possible adaptions are extensive and there is training in place to help you use the technology and equipment provided.

For a person starting a job the costs from an access to work assessment are fully met, for existing employees it is shared with the employer.

It can include physical equipment (chairs, computer etc.), software such as for dictation or apps to help with managing anxiety such as brain in hand.

If you are disabled and working or studying or planning to do either then I strongly recommend putting an application in.

Disabled students allowance is only for people in higher education. You can't get it for GCSE, A Levels and courses that are the same level.

Hellokittymania · 25/11/2023 07:39

Whoever mentioned about the attitudes from other people with disabilities, looking down on other people, yes, sadly, this is very very common, and very true, and sometimes it’s also like a hierarchy. I am severely visually impaired, and have been since birth, I know other people who lose service in later on in life end Have a bias towards people who were born blind, it’s even worse if the person has another disability on top of blindness. Just because you can do something, it doesn’t mean everybody else will be able to do that same thing. Yes, I can do some things, in some cases better than even people who don’t have a disability, yet I struggle with other things. There was a possibility that I could have worked from home, I live in Greece, but I would have had to move to another city, and passed things like a typing test. I use dictation when I’m sending emails, writing, messages, etc. I could just about past the typing test in English, but not in the language that I wanted to apply for. No matter how much I tried, I was really struggling. In my case, I also have to worry about the technology, being user-friendly with voiceover, since I can’t read quickly enough with large print to be able to handle things if I’m doing something like customer service. It’s a difficult one. I try my best, with everything, but there are definitely challenges.

IClaudine · 25/11/2023 07:20

Just to add 99% of SREL claimants are awarded PIP. So even 1% of people who are at the end of life and expected to die within a short time are turned down for PIP.

Simonjt · 25/11/2023 07:19

When we lived in the UK my husband was refused PIP, he has arthrogryposis and has extremely limited use of his hands and arms. His assessor put some wild lies in his report, if he had lied and successfully claimed PIP he would be done for benefit fraud, so why doesn’t the same apply for assessors? If I lied on official documents in any job I have had I would have been sacked, in my main career I would have been rightly reported to the regulatory body.

Where we live now his application was accepted, all he needed was a note from his doctor naming his condition, so no huge booklet with hundreds of questions. He also received a visit at home to see if he needed any adaptions and one at work to do the same.

IClaudine · 25/11/2023 07:03

Since 2013 there have been 6.4 million claims for PIP. 2.9 million of those were turned down. So almost half. That rather disproves @Disillusioned11 claim that it is "easy to get"?

Also, those stats show that since 2017 39% of new PIP claims were succesful ( Again, that doesn't exactly indicate an "easy"to get benefit?

For those people being transferred from DLA to PIP, the award rate is 69%. I guess the other 31% were miraculously cured of their disability. Either that or PIP is more difficult to get than DLA.

https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/personal-independence-payment-statistics-to-october-2022/personal-independence-payment-official-statistics-to-october-2022

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 25/11/2023 06:57

Oh and you do not need to be on any other disability benefits in order to qualify.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 25/11/2023 06:56

I do not in anyway intend this post to be saying that disabled people who cannot work should be made to. I do however want to highlight two benefits which are helpful - Disabled Student Allowance and Access to Work. Both schemes seem to be really positive in how they are applied. The assessments are supportive. The number of possible adaptions are extensive and there is training in place to help you use the technology and equipment provided.

For a person starting a job the costs from an access to work assessment are fully met, for existing employees it is shared with the employer.

It can include physical equipment (chairs, computer etc.), software such as for dictation or apps to help with managing anxiety such as brain in hand.

If you are disabled and working or studying or planning to do either then I strongly recommend putting an application in.

IClaudine · 25/11/2023 06:53

For the final time, I haven’t made any comment one way or the other regarding PIP claimants other than to say when 1:20 people claim it or approximately 1:5 disabled people receive it (& it’s meant for the most severe disabilities where people can not work at all) it’s not really statistically correct claim its a ‘hard to get’ benefit

You don't understand PIP do you @Disillusioned11 ?

It is not meant for the "most severe disabilities where people can not work at all". It is designed to meet the extra
costs of day to day living that disabled people incur. It is not linked to ability to work. Hence many people on PIP work.

As for PIP being "easy to get". It is not. Have a look at the stats,and how many cases end up going to appeal.

Many people with "mild" disabilities will qualify for the lower rates of PIP (though will no doubt had to have fought for it), which will perhaps account for the figure of 1 in 5 (if that is correct).

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 06:46

Disillusioned11 · 24/11/2023 23:46

State pensions are a contribution based benefit… you have to contribute - 25 years of NI payments I believe - to get the full benefit.

Edited

A) contributions are paid by the state in many situations, such as caring for children/others or being in receipt of benefits
B) Pension Credit is paid to those who have insufficient contributions anyway
C) 35 years now

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 25/11/2023 01:21

@Disillusioned11

Two things -

  1. You can not make claims about something being easy or difficult to get without qualifying exactly how you measure "easy" and "difficult". Pure numbers of claimants alone tell us absolutely nothing, because even if we agree on the 1 in 20 figure, 1 in 20 tells us zilch about how easy or otherwise those 1 in 20 found the process, it tells us nothing about the other 19 who are not claiming PIP, and it tells us nothing about how many of the 19 perhaps should be claiming PIP but have not, or indeed, should be awarded PIP. Again, the only figure of relevance here is the number of claims v's the number of successful awards, and since we don't have that, it's impossible to draw any conclusion at all about how easy or otherwise it is to be awarded PIP. For all you know, 19 in 20 people might have applied for PIP and 18 of those rejected, which objectively would seem to make it enormously "difficult" to be awarded PIP.
  2. As above, a correlation between disabled numbers and total spend doesn't tell us anything unless we also know how these figures, especially the %, are arrived at. On the face of it, the only thing you can conclude is that Spain, for example, reports a far lower rate of disability in its population than Switzerland does. What you can not say with any certainty is that there is a lower incidence in one country than another, because you do not know exactly how each country is arriving at its own figure, so there is every chance you care comparing two figures that have been arrived at using completely differing methodology. Put more simply, you can not guarantee that Spain calculates it's number of disabled using the exact same criterion as Switzerland, so you can not compare the two figures and draw any meaningful conclusions.

This is why you can not look at Germany, for example, and use the German figure to determine what % of the UK population "should" be disabled. Even if you used the exact same methodology and criterion to ascertain the disabled populations of both the UK and Germany, you can still expect a discrepancy because you are not comparing two identical nations. Life in Germany will differ from life in the UK in a multitude of ways, and for a multitude of reasons, so you can not make hard and fast assertions about one based on what you know about the other.

Your table might be "interesting", but it's of little relevance to the UK until you ensure that every figure is calculated in the exact same way. Even then, as I've already pointed out, you can't draw any firm conclusions about anything, because you should still expect a natural variance from one country to the next, especially so if you are comparing say, a Northern European country with an industrial past, to a Mediterranean one with an agrarian economy.

JimmyGrimble · 25/11/2023 01:00

My son is about to be assessed for PIP, we were informed of this by text at 10pm a couple of days ago. He is an outwardly fit and healthy 26 year old. He had never worked. He is bright and outgoing, has GCSE’s and A Levels. I suspect that he will appear fit for work. He has schizophrenia, schizoaffective disorder with bipolar and non organic psychosis and has been held on section since December 2022.