Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this government are at war with disabled people and always have been?

259 replies

MyopicBunny · 24/11/2023 20:20

I am assuming that the part of their UC that will be cut is the disabled element? Most people can’t even get this at all if you are disabled. The rules to receive it in the first place are extremely strict.

Why us nobody talking about this? Has our society now become brainwashed with the idea that it’s acceptable to call disabled people with significant needs benefit scroungers?

Why is it the most vulnerable being shat on from a great height, over and over??

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 26/11/2023 12:08

sashh · 26/11/2023 09:20

What planet do you live on?

I've paid NI from being 16.

I also paid into a pension.

The amount of benefit I receive is reduced by the amount of my pension, so I'm actually spending my pension to subsidise my benefits and your tax bill.

I have no family within 100 miles of me.

A little research will make it quite apparent what the views of this poster are. There's little point in engaging with her. Posts by someone who refers to mental health issues by putting them in inverted commas really aren't
worth anyone's time.

Puppydog23 · 26/11/2023 09:24

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

sashh · 26/11/2023 09:20

yellowspanner · 25/11/2023 22:36

So many people claim to have 'mental health issues'. It's only in the last ten years that this has happened and the increase coincided with the increase availability of benefits.
People no longer expect families to help and support. It's all down to 'the government".
No wonder the country is broke.
Where do you think all the money is coming from? A magic money tree!

What planet do you live on?

I've paid NI from being 16.

I also paid into a pension.

The amount of benefit I receive is reduced by the amount of my pension, so I'm actually spending my pension to subsidise my benefits and your tax bill.

I have no family within 100 miles of me.

Iamblocked2 · 26/11/2023 09:16

I have to say I find it terrifying. DC is physically able but has other issues (autism and severe learning difficulties). I wonder what sort of WFH they are expected to do and who on earth would employ them

Locutus2000 · 26/11/2023 09:04

yellowspanner · 25/11/2023 22:20

I don't see why I should work dammed hard all my life and pay taxes so someone with 'anxiety' or 'depression' can stay at home and be funded.
It's simply not fair.
It's like a 'glass back'. Can't be unproven.

Can't be unproven.

Best err on the side of caution then.

JaniceJanice · 26/11/2023 09:02

yellowspanner · 25/11/2023 22:36

So many people claim to have 'mental health issues'. It's only in the last ten years that this has happened and the increase coincided with the increase availability of benefits.
People no longer expect families to help and support. It's all down to 'the government".
No wonder the country is broke.
Where do you think all the money is coming from? A magic money tree!

Clearly you missed the discussion of what the statistics actually show. I suggest you go back and actually read the thread.

TigerRag · 26/11/2023 07:17

yellowspanner · 25/11/2023 22:36

So many people claim to have 'mental health issues'. It's only in the last ten years that this has happened and the increase coincided with the increase availability of benefits.
People no longer expect families to help and support. It's all down to 'the government".
No wonder the country is broke.
Where do you think all the money is coming from? A magic money tree!

You're obviously aware that you can't just claim you have a mental health condition and you get benefits on your say so? You need evidence. I was actually told my evidence (for a different condition) was rubbish. It was a letter from my consultant stating what he'd diagnosed me with.

sashh · 26/11/2023 06:38

Yes.

I've been saying for years it is like living in 1930s Germany.

Currently they are taking £50 a month of my UC for an 'over payment' from 2019. But in 2019 they didn't actually pay me anything.

They also take my pension of £ for £ because it is 'unearned income', if I could work I could keep the same amount.

I got that pension from working and paying in, so in effect I get less money because I did work, and make contributions and I also pain NI.

I'm terrified.

Duckingella · 26/11/2023 01:33

You can get PIP and still work as the two aren't mutually exclusive:I'm assuming they are talking about those physically unable to work and on ESA.

Unless someone has transferable skills or training or even a degree then the only work from home opportunities will be call centre type work;not everyone has good people skills or can use a computer well enough to be able to do this.

My brother who's autistic has really poor people skills,zero patience,crappy sleep patterns,no self motivation,poor organisational skills and poor coping skills so work is out of the question especially WFH.

As for my mum who's unable to leave the house without a carer due to a physical disability;well she's in constant pain;on pain meds that make give her brain fog,she's unable to read and write properly and struggles to even use apps on her phone;she has no useable computer skills.

It's absolutely ludicrous.

catskittens · 26/11/2023 00:20

Babyroobs · 24/11/2023 21:03

From what I have concluded from reading the report on the proposals.
A lot more people are being awarded the LCWRA element of UC than was originally anticipated so they are changing the descriptors. People are awarded LCWRA then stay on it for years and haven't been being re-assessed as the system is overwhelmed. So they are changing the descriptors so that only the most seriously mentally ill people will be awarded LCWRA. they are also changing some of the mobility descriptors. I think basically rather than so many people being put on LCWRA, people with say anxiety and depression will be offered more talking therapy and unless you have major psychosis etc, they will likely now be put in the LCW group rather than LCWRA so will have to take some steps to returning to work rather than having no work commitments. Those on PIP will have a health element added to UC rather than also having to be assessed for work capability. so this cuts down the number of assessments people have to go through for two different benefits.
Those who already have LCWRA will not be re- assessed unless their condition changes, or it was awarded due to pregnancy ( and therefore short term) or was awarded because they were having cancer treatment for a period of time which will end ( people receiving cancer treatment are automatically awarded LCWRA without assessment currently so I don't think this will change).
From 2025 all new claims will be subject to the new changes.
I think we can expect a lot more people to be awarded LCW rather than LCWRA as they are removing the ' serious risk' descriptor.

what would happen if you are on ESA support group and migrate after 31st december 2024 do you get re assed or like now take your award with you and get tran protection

ambley · 25/11/2023 22:56

And where will these completely remote jobs come from? They don't exist, or far far from the numbers needed. There's big competition for the hybrid jobs too.

Baconisdelicious · 25/11/2023 22:48

on principle the idea of supporting disabled people to access jobs they can do such as wfh which happens widely rather than write them off as unable to work at all is a good thing?

It's really not a good thing that it is assumed all people with disabilities need is to be able to work from home. It ignores the complexities of individual conditions and assumes that disabled people don't need anything to access work other than a chair in their own kitchen and a laptop. It sees disabled people as one big, homogeneous group with nothing much at all to overcome. It ignores the fact employers don't want to employ people who regularly need the afternoon off for hospital appointments (think chemo, dialysis, blood transfusion....).

It is terrifying.

pointythings · 25/11/2023 22:44

yellowspanner · 25/11/2023 22:36

So many people claim to have 'mental health issues'. It's only in the last ten years that this has happened and the increase coincided with the increase availability of benefits.
People no longer expect families to help and support. It's all down to 'the government".
No wonder the country is broke.
Where do you think all the money is coming from? A magic money tree!

Evidence for your statements, please? Prevalence data for rates of mental ill health is available, so please link to that.

When did the 'increase in the availability of benefits' happen in the past 10 years under a Tory government? I'd like some evidence for this statement too.

This government certainly seems to have had a magic money tree to shake for giving bungs to their mates...

Stomacharmeleon · 25/11/2023 22:42

It isn't due to happen until 2025
We will have a change of government before then.

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 22:42

yellowspanner · 25/11/2023 22:36

So many people claim to have 'mental health issues'. It's only in the last ten years that this has happened and the increase coincided with the increase availability of benefits.
People no longer expect families to help and support. It's all down to 'the government".
No wonder the country is broke.
Where do you think all the money is coming from? A magic money tree!

OK, this post is full of what is known in the business as 'alternative facts'.

Benefits are far less available now than previously. The assessments are more stringent, the awards less permanent, the checks more constant and the investigations for fraud more persistent.

There has been an increase in mental health diagnoses for two reasons. Firstly an increase in incidence of mental health illness. Secondly an increased awareness.

Denial of mental health illness is usually based on prejudice.

manybiscuits · 25/11/2023 22:38

I think that's more likely what they'll do @pointythings

Considering the bad reputation of some of the people administering UC and the inefficiencies involved, and even tiny things made sanctionable, apparently. I'm not surprised people are afraid of what might be in store.

yellowspanner · 25/11/2023 22:36

So many people claim to have 'mental health issues'. It's only in the last ten years that this has happened and the increase coincided with the increase availability of benefits.
People no longer expect families to help and support. It's all down to 'the government".
No wonder the country is broke.
Where do you think all the money is coming from? A magic money tree!

JaniceJanice · 25/11/2023 22:32

yellowspanner · 25/11/2023 22:20

I don't see why I should work dammed hard all my life and pay taxes so someone with 'anxiety' or 'depression' can stay at home and be funded.
It's simply not fair.
It's like a 'glass back'. Can't be unproven.

You best hope you never become disabled or ill then…

pointythings · 25/11/2023 22:30

@yellowspanner if the government were indeed going to help people find work, that would be great. But they aren't. They're going to punish people for not finding work by taking their money away and pushing them deeper into poverty.

If they wanted to help people into work, they would be:

  • Investing large amounts of money into funding excellent physical and mental health services so that people with health issues didn't have to spend years on waiting lists getting worse and worse
  • Investing large amounts of money in helping people with disabilities access training of all kinds to upskill them and equip them for work
  • Push through legislation enabling employers to employ disabled people and people with health conditions so that they would be able to stay in work even if their health issues meant they couldn't attend work as reliably as people without those conditions - this could be through flexible working, job shares and tax incentives

But they are not doing that. They're just saying 'well, they can work from home or we'll take their benefits away'. Which will just push more people back onto hospital waiting lists and cost the taxpayer money. It's typical short term ill thought through bullshit that Tory voters will just lap up because they are unwilling or unable to see the complexities of the problem.

happytobee · 25/11/2023 22:29

They are cracking down on those who are disabled or say they are disabled yet could still work and not be funded to stay at home. This is not being aimed at people with disabilities who are unable to work.
The issue is you can’t prove whether people have or have not got many disabilities and mental health issues and the figure for those claiming benefits has sky rocketed

yellowspanner · 25/11/2023 22:29

No they are not XenoBitch.
They are insisting that those that are able to work , do work.
That is extremely reasonable.
Why are they my responsibility?

XenoBitch · 25/11/2023 22:27

yellowspanner · 25/11/2023 22:22

The Government are going to help these people to find work
What is so wrong with that? .
Why does it have to be at home?

They are not going to help them... they are going to threaten them with poverty.

yellowspanner · 25/11/2023 22:22

The Government are going to help these people to find work
What is so wrong with that? .
Why does it have to be at home?

yellowspanner · 25/11/2023 22:20

I don't see why I should work dammed hard all my life and pay taxes so someone with 'anxiety' or 'depression' can stay at home and be funded.
It's simply not fair.
It's like a 'glass back'. Can't be unproven.

JaniceJanice · 25/11/2023 10:11

@FelicityFlops because we live in a society where we all do things for each other, otherwise it doesn’t function.

I presume you mean ‘I work and pay income tax therefore I am entitled to take from the state- disabled people who are unable to work don’t pay income tax (although they do pay all other types of tax, and may well have paid income tax in the past) therefore they don’t deserve to take from the state’

So, able bodied person A works and pays income tax (and vat, national insurance, possibly inheritance tax, council tax etc). Person A

is born in a hospital (£££ from the state),

goes to school (£££ from the state),

drives on roads (£££ from the state)

goes to the park (£££ from the state)

goes to the leisure centre (£££ from the state)

benefits from the police and legal system (£££ from the state)

has kids born in a hospital (£££ from the state)

has subsides child care (£££ from the state)

they go to school (£££ from the state)

takes them to feed the ducks in the park (£££ from the state)

and so on.

The money person A pays in income tax no where near covers her cost to the state. It only works because everyone pays what they can so that everyone benefits.

Disabled person B pays council tax, vat, inheritance, national insurance etc. Maybe doesn’t have kids? Maybe was privately educated etc… could well turn out to be a smaller net cost to the state than person A.

So, it’s a pointless argument (because you have no idea who is a net contributor or net cost to the state overall), and it’s a shitty point of view because able bodied people are not of more value morally, ethically, socially or in any other way than disabled people.

We all contribute what we can and take what we need. Sometimes people take the piss with this… corporations not paying taxes for example, criminals stealing from other people as another example- but the principle remains the same despite these anomalies.