Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not letting my child ride/scooter without helmet, but I seem to be the only one AIBU?

113 replies

WearTheHelmet · 24/11/2023 20:14

DD is 9, Year 5.

She likes to ride her bike or scooter but has recently refused if I make her wear her helmet. Like as in if I offer it she’ll say “Can I do it without my helmet?” and when I say no she says “Then I’m not going to be the only one doing it with one so no”.

I’ve noticed on the school run, Key Stage 1 and younger (so Years 2 and below) all wear helmets but once they get to year 3/Key Stage 2 they seem to stop, I haven’t seen anyone else in DDs year/class wearing one for years.

I always think it’s safer and part of the school run is along a fast B road where the cars ignore the 20 mile an hour zone around school times and drive down at 50+ (there have been a couple of fatal accidents along the road involving pedestrians, none involving children but still it’s a risk).

So AIBU? And if not how do I persuade DD it’s in her interests to use her helmet?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NameChange30 · 26/11/2023 23:23

No helmet, no wheels for us, too.

I'm in my late 30s and I remember not wearing a helmet when I was a teen and cycled to school - my mum did try and get me to wear a helmet, but I remember thinking they weren't cool. I cycled around everywhere as a uni student and have a feeling I didn't wear a helmet then either Blush However, I have become more sensible as I've got older, and now I have children, I always wear a helmet - partly because I want to be a good example to them and also because I'm painfully aware that they need me not to die or have a life-changing injury! I couldn't care less about being cool now.

I really hope my kids will be confident enough in themselves to wear helmets without caring whether they're cool or not. Hopefully it'll just be habit by the time I have less say in the matter!

mollyfolk · 26/11/2023 23:06

I think people aren’t convinced they make as much difference as they do. If your on wheels and you fall and hit your head you could get a brain injury or worse so it - no helmet no wheels in our house too. Mine don’t need convincing after seeing my son bounce his head of the ground one day - the shattered helmet could have been his head.

PurpleNebula84 · 26/11/2023 21:47

ThePoetsWife · 25/11/2023 09:08

Head injuries are often not fixable - you are being very silly and irresponsible

Think @farmfoodsqueen got the trifecta there "always watching" "boys will be boys" "all part of growing up"... Only missing "it never did me any harm" lol

Georgeandzippyzoo · 25/11/2023 18:41

wineandmaltesershappyme · 25/11/2023 11:02

She doesn't go very fast on the scooter or do tricks.
She goes faster on her bike.

It doesn't really matter. A fall from a scooter can be as catastrophic as a fall from a bike. Not worth the risk.

JanglingJack · 25/11/2023 17:46

Haven't read full thread but YANBU

DD was taking part in scooter club at primary on the playground (Helmets essential). Her scooter hit a stone, stopped and she went over handle bars.
She was scraped with grazes, down top of her face (helmet took impact) came loose, all down her shoulders then back of arms.
If she hadn't had helmet, it would have been a lot worse.
Apparently she went in to shock and they gave her lemonade. The club was run by headteacher who didn't call me but looked very sheepish telling me after school 😡

Georgeandzippyzoo · 25/11/2023 17:40

No helmet?
No bikes/scooter/skates/skateboard.

My friend goes allover the world cycling with her husband. She brought his helmet in to school one day and the kids were guessing where he'd had an accident. Helmet was trashed and had he not been wearing it he would be dead. He was coming out of their path at very low speed and slipped off the kerb. Freak accident that could have killed him.

A bike is not more dangerous than a scooter because its the fall that's the issue.

DGPP · 25/11/2023 17:22

No helmet then no bike or scooter here. It’s your job to keep them safe. Show you DD some crash injuries and hopefully she will get it

ismu · 25/11/2023 17:20

Rule 59 of the Highway Code suggests you should wear a helmet although it's not compulsory.
But it's just a general attitude now that telling people what they should do to keep safe, well or to respect others is somehow taking away their freedom.
Just one of the joys that covid brought us

Runssometimes · 25/11/2023 11:16

ismu · 25/11/2023 10:05

There are a serious number of adult cyclists who won't wear a helmet because rOOLz are for foOLz.

I think this attitude is being passed on and that's what people are seeing, because helmets have been a thing for over thirty years.

What roolz though? There’s no law. A polystyrene helmet isn’t much use if you’re crushed under a truck. I’m a regular cyclist and always wear a helmet as when I’ve come off it’s either the surface of the road/track/path or a pedestrian hopping out or doing something unexpected. I’ve had concussion from avoiding a pedestrian jumping out in front of me, helmet completely busted, torn clothes, bruising all down my back but could have been so much worse.

My kid at age 4 clipped the edge of a manhole cover on a cycle path (why are they there? He didn’t have the experience to avoid it yet. I was right there he flipped straight over, eyes rolled up in his head. Terrifying. Helmet was dented and after he got checked out in A&E turned out he’d had a shock but wasn’t even concussed.

Helmets have always been non negotiable in our house on scooters, skateboards, skiing. Bikes. Basically anything where you’re liable to fall at some speed. Kid in secondary school now and still wears it. But I respect the right of grown adults to choose not to. Not a risk I’d take myself.

But as a parent I will make sure my child wears protection while he builds up the skills and experience he needs to make his own personal safety decisions. Until then I choose. No lid? You’re walking.

InaBarbieWorld · 25/11/2023 11:06

Always insisted on a helmet with scooter and bike. Was a non negotiable. DS skidded on an ash type car park, frictions burns, holes in clothes and a cracked helmet- he was 10 and absolutely fine. Hate to think about no helmet xx

Lochness1975 · 25/11/2023 11:04

Ds18 was 3 when he came off his bike, completely smashed the front part of his helmet in, luckily no injuries, but dread to think what would have happened if he didn’t have one on.

wineandmaltesershappyme · 25/11/2023 11:02

She doesn't go very fast on the scooter or do tricks.
She goes faster on her bike.

Mycatmax · 25/11/2023 11:00

My DS would be dead if he hadn’t been wearing a helmet when he had a bad skateboarding accident.

He broke his arm but would have been fatal if helmet (completely cracked) hadn’t protected him.

rainbowunicorn · 25/11/2023 10:58

wineandmaltesershappyme · 24/11/2023 22:49

Mines 7, wearing a helmet with a bike is a must, we stopped wearing it with the scooter though when she was 6. Same for her friends.

I don't understand the logic here, a six or 7ot 8 year old is likely to be going much faster and trying to do more tricks etc on a scooter so much more likely to sustain a serious injury if they come off than a 4 or 5 year old.

rainbowunicorn · 25/11/2023 10:55

farmfoodsqueen · 24/11/2023 21:30

@Rogue1001MNer don't you dare suggest I don't parent my DS, he's my life and I never take my eyes off him for a second when he's riding outside. Worst case scenario and he breaks a bone, obviously it would be awful but at the same time boys will be boys and get into scrapes. It's part of growing up

Allowing a 6 year old to dictate that they won't wear a helmet when they have no understanding of the consequences is not parenting. Your eyes are not going to prevent an accident from happening. All you having eyes on him will do is allow you to see him have the accident. Worst case scenario is not a broken bone. It is death from a head injury.

PTSDBarbiegirl · 25/11/2023 10:11

I probably wouldn’t for scooter. I also wouldn’t want them riding a bike along a dangerous B road, I’d take dc elsewhere with helmet and bike.

ismu · 25/11/2023 10:05

There are a serious number of adult cyclists who won't wear a helmet because rOOLz are for foOLz.

I think this attitude is being passed on and that's what people are seeing, because helmets have been a thing for over thirty years.

rainbowunicorn · 25/11/2023 10:02

farmfoodsqueen · 24/11/2023 20:49

Hmm I dunno... my DS (6) flat out refuses to wear a helmet so there's not much I can do. He's outgrown his old one and tbh I haven't replaced it because I know he won't wear it so what's the point in spending money on one? I do worry about him but he doesn't go far on his bike, just round our estate and always where I can see him xx

He's 6, you are the parent. He puts on the helmet or doesn't ride his bike.
You don't have to be going far or even very fast to come off a bike. There doesn't even need to be any other vehicle involved. I know a family who's child came off his bike while not wearing a helmet and is now permanently brain damaged due to the way he hit his head on the kerb .

Tumbleweed101 · 25/11/2023 09:33

A child was hit crossing the road to our village shop. She’d been riding her bike so had a helmet on but had dismounted to cross. She was with parents. A car tried to squeeze around parked cars and hit her. Because she had her helmet on she didn’t sustain the head injury she might have had from the impact and was bruised and got a broken arm.

SilverBranchGoldenPears · 25/11/2023 09:26

There are some astoundingly stupid comments on this thread. I can’t believe how dumb people can be sometimes.
Parenting fails left right and centre. SMH

Nopenott0day · 25/11/2023 09:09

Show her a picture of rtc victim's who weren't wearing a helmet and the consequences.

As someone who used to work in a major trauma hospital helmets save lives.

ShowOfHands · 25/11/2023 09:09

@Allfur you've repeatedly talked about cars. Yes they're a problem. Yes they need tackling. But even if, as you say, cars are the majority issue, it doesn't mean we stop mitigating risks for minority situations. I've already pointed out that DH came off his bike at slow speed on a cycle path at center parcs and his helmet likely saved him from catastrophic issues or death. With it, he was seriously injured but treatable.

It's like saying smoking is responsible for more deaths than alcohol abuse and therefore we only need education in one direction.

ThePoetsWife · 25/11/2023 09:08

farmfoodsqueen · 24/11/2023 21:30

@Rogue1001MNer don't you dare suggest I don't parent my DS, he's my life and I never take my eyes off him for a second when he's riding outside. Worst case scenario and he breaks a bone, obviously it would be awful but at the same time boys will be boys and get into scrapes. It's part of growing up

Head injuries are often not fixable - you are being very silly and irresponsible

Theyvegotatrex · 25/11/2023 09:02

My kids don’t go on roads, this has nothing to do with cars. Smacking the back of your head on a slab or pavement will do some serious damage (and it’s a common occurrence when your scooter disappears from under you). Same with heading over your bike handle bars.

Personally I think parents are insane letting their young kids ride without helmets - they are too young to understand the risks so need rules. When they’re older, up to them but we do more extreme sports and so helmets are a part of life - why risk injury doing something as mundane as riding your bike/scooter down the pavement?

That said, my DC have done more damage to themselves at home hitting heads on walls, falling out of trees and falling upstairs (!). All resulting in hospital treatment.

Allfur · 25/11/2023 08:50

If there were no cars, would we all feel quite the same way about helmets. Vision Zero is a strategy implemented by lots of cities across the world to try and reduce traffic deaths and injuries on our roads to zero, which are nearly all caused by motor vehicles. The strategies involve reducing cars, better traffic management and separation of pedestrians, cyclists etc from motor vehicles. Helmets are not mentioned.