Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's ridiculous how obsessed with a babies gender/sex ppl still seemingly are?

194 replies

Socksforxmas · 24/11/2023 19:55

I have my 20wk scan in a couple of days and will be finding out the sex if they're able to tell. DH and I already have twin boys aged 3 and know this will be our last baby. It might be silly on my end to be surprised by this but a shocking amount of ppl in my life seem to assume that I'm desperate for a girl and would be deeply saddened by another boy.

I know that every now and again some 'gender disappointment' threads pop up but i had assumed that overall ppl had come to the realization that it really doesn't matter much. I'm not going to raise them any differently or push any sort of gendered nonsense on them. I don't really understand what it'd be getting from one and not the other. Ultimately it's a baby. As long as its not a puppy or anything like that I'm happy.

A lot of the comments have been fairly innocent 'bet you want a wee girl this time' but some have been more (paraphrasing here) "oh God I bet you'll just die if they tell you it's another boy! I wouldn't be able to cope with that"

Idk. I just really don't care either way and am surprised by the amount of comments I've received from family and friends about it. Anyone else experience similar?

OP posts:
PiggyFlounce · 25/11/2023 09:06

scrunchie2 · 25/11/2023 09:05

I think people just want something to say rather than being overly bothered about what you're having/ want to have

This.

scrunchie2 · 25/11/2023 09:05

I think people just want something to say rather than being overly bothered about what you're having/ want to have

TheRealProfessorYaffle · 25/11/2023 09:03

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 08:42

I had a boy first, then a daughter. I’m very pleased to have one of each. I have found there is a difference in the natures of the two, that’s not to do with upbringing, but personality / sex. Both are equally lovely, but there are differences, and I’m pleased to have got the chance to parent both.

Most of my friends who only have sons, have confessed to me privately that they wished they could have had a girl. Ditto for the men I know who only have daughters. I think it’s natural to want a child the same sex as yourself; it’s the imagined future of shopping trips, weddings, spa days, girly trips for women and football, pub trips, golf for men. Of course your child may not like those things, but there’s a good chance they might, and I don’t think there’s anything wrong with that.

If my daughter asked for girly shopping trips and spas, I'd think she'd been taken by the aliens. We prefer gym or watching the football with her brothers.

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 08:42

I had a boy first, then a daughter. I’m very pleased to have one of each. I have found there is a difference in the natures of the two, that’s not to do with upbringing, but personality / sex. Both are equally lovely, but there are differences, and I’m pleased to have got the chance to parent both.

Most of my friends who only have sons, have confessed to me privately that they wished they could have had a girl. Ditto for the men I know who only have daughters. I think it’s natural to want a child the same sex as yourself; it’s the imagined future of shopping trips, weddings, spa days, girly trips for women and football, pub trips, golf for men. Of course your child may not like those things, but there’s a good chance they might, and I don’t think there’s anything wrong with that.

Wonderlot · 25/11/2023 08:38

Tamuchly · 25/11/2023 05:28

I already had 2 boys when I fell pregnant with twin boys and found it incredible how many people felt confident enough to be ‘sympathetic’ even though I was personally thrilled to bits! It seemed very few people understood that I just wanted healthy babies, their sex was unimportant. That said, I don’t think there was malice behind it, they were just conversing and I quite enjoyed putting them straight! By the time I had my DD years later, they were cooing over how I had finally got my girl which was pretty funny because we had thought she was a boy, were super happy with that and had a name picked out too.
Small talk is often weird, as OP is a twin mum I’m sure she’s experienced the total invasion of privacy involved with twins - are they identical? ”no” oh so which one is the girl? “they’re both boys” are you sure? “Um, yes, quite sure” well they don’t look identical to me “they’re not identical” so one of them must be a girl!?!? It might have been funny the first few times but it happened so often in the first year that I felt like carrying a printed information sheet about twins! People can be very silly.

Yes to the twin thing too, I’ve been asked several times by strangers if mine were conceived naturally!!

Wonderlot · 25/11/2023 08:31

I could have written this post a year ago! 3 year old twin boys, pregnant with 3rd. I actually got quite upset with the amount of comments I got, about how much I must be hoping for a girl. What’s wrong with my boys?? Actually we had decided to try for another baby not even considering what the sex might be, we just hoped for another healthy child. So yes mixed with my pregnancy hormones I did get quite upset, and thought, is everyone going to be disappointed for me now if I have a boy!? In the end I had a girl, and now of course get comments like ‘you’re done now of course’, ‘you’ve completed the set’ and even ‘thank goodness you had a girl, what a relief for you’. I’m sure these people must be projecting their own feelings here, because they aren’t mine!

PiggyFlounce · 25/11/2023 08:20

I kind of get why people want one of each. Best of both worlds, right?

Naptrappedmummy · 25/11/2023 08:18

Parker231 · 25/11/2023 05:42

It would be better that no one was told at the scans. Other than a very small number of medical conditions, no one needs to know until the birth.

I’ve seen threads where posters have said they need to know so that they can go shopping. Babies wear clothes - the colour is irrelevant!

I appreciate this is a little unusual but we needed to know because as I said we were in a 2 bed house. If it was a second girl we would’ve stayed put but it was a boy. Our first child was due to start school the following year so we put wheels in motion to move immediately as we couldn’t afford a local 3 bed and knew a move would mean a change of school. We thought it would be better to move in time for her to start school than it would after a few years when she was settled somewhere then have to pull her out.

3menandalittlelady · 25/11/2023 07:26

Your mistake was to assume that everyone thinks in the same way as you do. If you let go of that and accept that people will think in whichever sweet way they like, you'll find yourself less outraged by general life.

TheRealProfessorYaffle · 25/11/2023 07:08

Absolutely. Why get hung up on it when it's so easy to change their sex now after they're born?

EmpressaurusOfCats · 25/11/2023 07:05

Parker231 · 25/11/2023 05:42

It would be better that no one was told at the scans. Other than a very small number of medical conditions, no one needs to know until the birth.

I’ve seen threads where posters have said they need to know so that they can go shopping. Babies wear clothes - the colour is irrelevant!

Clothes are a big part of the whole gender nonsense though aren’t they? Social constructs built around sex stereotypes.

I suppose if someone’s asking about a baby’s gender you could have some fun with it though - tell them the baby is catgender or ambigender or any others from the various lists.

marshmallowfinder · 25/11/2023 06:31

A baby's sex/gender. Not a babies.

Ascubudr · 25/11/2023 06:29

Naptrappedmummy · 24/11/2023 20:10

I have 1 girl and 1 boy and the number of people who congratulated me on one of each was unreal. The thing is I actually wanted a second girl because I got very hung up on same sex siblings having a better bond. And also because we lived in a 2 bed house and i didn’t want to move. Wouldn’t change my little boy now for anything but it’s funny how people make assumptions and assume you want their idea of a perfect family.

This I would have loved a third (and probably a fourth too) I definitely decided head over heart. But the 2 comments that drove me made and still do now really 17 years later were " that's you done then" and " aren't you clever?" FFS. I am incredibly close to my DSis and woud have loved 2 of the same sex.

thelonemommabear · 25/11/2023 06:20

When I had boy girl twins the amount of strangers who said i had hit the jackpot having one of each and would never have to do it again was really off putting. Not least because my twins came after years of multiple miscarriages ectopics and tens of thousands spent on IVF. Obviously they weren't to know that but I find it odd that people strive to "have one of each" I actually prefer it when you have siblings that are the same

curaçao · 25/11/2023 05:47

Nobody but the parents and possibly the gps care, let alone are obsessed by, the sex of a baby.

Parker231 · 25/11/2023 05:42

It would be better that no one was told at the scans. Other than a very small number of medical conditions, no one needs to know until the birth.

I’ve seen threads where posters have said they need to know so that they can go shopping. Babies wear clothes - the colour is irrelevant!

Tamuchly · 25/11/2023 05:28

I already had 2 boys when I fell pregnant with twin boys and found it incredible how many people felt confident enough to be ‘sympathetic’ even though I was personally thrilled to bits! It seemed very few people understood that I just wanted healthy babies, their sex was unimportant. That said, I don’t think there was malice behind it, they were just conversing and I quite enjoyed putting them straight! By the time I had my DD years later, they were cooing over how I had finally got my girl which was pretty funny because we had thought she was a boy, were super happy with that and had a name picked out too.
Small talk is often weird, as OP is a twin mum I’m sure she’s experienced the total invasion of privacy involved with twins - are they identical? ”no” oh so which one is the girl? “they’re both boys” are you sure? “Um, yes, quite sure” well they don’t look identical to me “they’re not identical” so one of them must be a girl!?!? It might have been funny the first few times but it happened so often in the first year that I felt like carrying a printed information sheet about twins! People can be very silly.

Zanatdy · 25/11/2023 05:17

girlfriend44 · 24/11/2023 22:37

Wasn't it more important you had a baby born well and with no disabilities rather than a specific sex?😉😏

Well obviously, I didn’t say I wanted a girl over health

justanothermanicmonday1 · 25/11/2023 04:46

Yeah I agree.

When pregnant with my second DC everyone would say "oh i bet you're hoping for a boy now" no. I wasn't. Was thrilled that we were having another girl 🥰 wouldn't have it any other way.

It's the same with the babies weight and if you're FF or EBF. Don't see why it affects others.

Rightsraptor · 25/11/2023 04:06

The word is sex.

You're probably correct but that won't change anything. I still hear people say daft things, like boys continuing the family name (as though the family concerned has an unusual name and is an old-established dynasty when they aren't).

TealSapphire · 25/11/2023 03:34

I have four boys and I guess some people assumed we were trying for a girl but we weren't so their comments didn't bother me.

Mostly people are in awe and think it's amazing, how do I do it etc. I'll take it 😇 I mean at times it's busy but that's because there's four of them not because of their sex.

chappoi · 25/11/2023 02:12

@Socksforxmas I had 3 boys and the bravest part is putting up with peoples condolences and 'what a shame it would have been lovely to get a little girl' comments. Then 2 mins after you have the baby you will get asked when are you trying again for a girl?
Takes a while for it to stop being annoying because 3 boys is amazing, and becomes quite funny that people still think it's hell whatever you say

Smallonesaremorejuicy · 25/11/2023 02:07

We had identical twin girls & when I was pregnant with a singleton so so many people family & friends were convinced we wanted a boy . They really didn’t seem to believe us when we said we truly didn’t mind . We had another beautiful girl & our family is complete. Congratulations to you & hope everything goes well x

Ladyj84 · 25/11/2023 02:01

Hubby and I were never bothered by gender whatever we got we were over the moon. 2 boys and then twin girls. Hubby got pissed off at work colleagues when first was expected the amount that said bet your hoping for a boy and he was like I don't mind either way aslong as there healthy

FrozenGhost · 25/11/2023 01:48

Rude/weird comments aren't right, but surely the "interest" isn't such a mystery. It's an obvious question to ask about a baby, as you don't know anything else about them. Can't really ask what music they like or their opinion on politics.

Also, it isn't gendered nonsense to say that your sex is something that's defines your life. And it isn't about wearing pink or blue or what toys you play with, that obviously doesn't matter. But it will affect your life as an adult.

Swipe left for the next trending thread