Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's ridiculous how obsessed with a babies gender/sex ppl still seemingly are?

194 replies

Socksforxmas · 24/11/2023 19:55

I have my 20wk scan in a couple of days and will be finding out the sex if they're able to tell. DH and I already have twin boys aged 3 and know this will be our last baby. It might be silly on my end to be surprised by this but a shocking amount of ppl in my life seem to assume that I'm desperate for a girl and would be deeply saddened by another boy.

I know that every now and again some 'gender disappointment' threads pop up but i had assumed that overall ppl had come to the realization that it really doesn't matter much. I'm not going to raise them any differently or push any sort of gendered nonsense on them. I don't really understand what it'd be getting from one and not the other. Ultimately it's a baby. As long as its not a puppy or anything like that I'm happy.

A lot of the comments have been fairly innocent 'bet you want a wee girl this time' but some have been more (paraphrasing here) "oh God I bet you'll just die if they tell you it's another boy! I wouldn't be able to cope with that"

Idk. I just really don't care either way and am surprised by the amount of comments I've received from family and friends about it. Anyone else experience similar?

OP posts:
forumstalk · 25/11/2023 12:29

You can't choose the sex of your baby so there will be some disappointment.....

I think people are just saying their thoughts.

My neighbours have all had boys.... 8 in total! Of course im going to mention something about their boys.

PlumpShady · 25/11/2023 12:29

We've got a daughter and are on the fence about having another one. Whenever we discuss it with friends/family, DH gets asked 'but don't you want a son?' And seem surprised that he isn't desperate for one.

Terfosaurus · 25/11/2023 12:27

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 12:00

On these threads, why is it always the ones acknowledging gender differences who get accused of wanting to play dress up or wanting dollies?

There are clear differences between males and females. Even more so as the children reach the teenage years and adulthood. I think it’s far more bizarre to insist there is no difference whatsoever!

What clear difference (other than genitals) are there in pre-pubescent children?

My brother insists there are differences and that I just don't understand them because I only have boys. The only difference between his children is that his son is always told he can't play with dolls/ toy kitchen etc because it's for girls. And the girls have been told they aren't allowed to do rugby because they are girls.

I think gender/sex differences are mainly nurture not nature. My own sons like mainly traditional female stuff (dance and theatre more than football and golf for eg) But they were raised mainly by me and my mum. Mind you none of the men in my immediate family like sports particularly so even more male influence might not have made a difference.

Parker231 · 25/11/2023 12:25

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 11:18

@Goodornot

Exactly. To argue there is no difference in the sexes is frankly ridiculous.

@Socksforxmas Really OP? So you won’t buy any girl gendered clothes? Cute pink onesies or floral bits etc?

Have twins - DS and DD - they wore whichever babygro I picked up first - sometimes DS wore pink and DD green and other days they both wore lilac. They just wore baby clothes - kept them in babygros until they were about nine months as it made the morning rush to nursery easier and they looked so cute!
Once they were walking they lived in dungarees of whatever colours came in a multiple pack.

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/11/2023 12:24

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 12:11

@BeardedIrises Yes, everyone is clearly sexist. The reason why girls (by and large) are closer to their mothers in adulthood than sons has nothing to do with their sex whatsoever... it’s all just gender stereotyping.

We live in an incredibly sexist society, of course that is going to have a big influence.

Studies have shown that people play with babies differently based on their sex. It starts from an incredibly young age and it's so ingrained, people don't even know they are doing it most of the time.

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/11/2023 12:21

MsCactus · 25/11/2023 10:12

I agree - but there's also something to having a shared biological experience I think.

My periods have always been difficult and it was something that made me different from my brothers growing up - when I went to a friend's house with three sisters, periods/women's health felt like the most natural thing in the world - their entire airing cupboard was stuffed with sanitary pads etc.

Now I've had a baby I really do feel like I have another shared experience with my mum that makes me feel closer to her/understand her more.

I've also experienced lots of sexism in the workplace - whenever I tell my brothers they're just gobsmacked people have said/acted like that to me, because they've never experienced anything remotely similar.

Those are the main things, off the top of my head. I think if I had a sister she'd probably have experienced similar things (maybe not childbirth etc, but the others)

I can understand that.

I have a sister and despite us having shared biological experiences and being close in age, we've never talked about women's health and it was still a very private thing when we were growing up. We aren't close at all so I would never tell her about any issues with sexism in the workplace, she's also a SAHM and believes that all women should be SAHM's so you can imagine how well that would go down.

We are just incredibly different people and if we weren't sisters, I doubt we would even talk to each other.

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 12:19

@Socksforxmas I know you didn’t, I’m referring to other posters who were insisting there is no difference between boys and girls. I’d even argue there are differences pre-puberty. It does become more obvious once they are older though.

Socksforxmas · 25/11/2023 12:17

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 12:07

@Socksforxmas I don’t care how people dress their children, to be honest.

This debates falls flat for me when people insist there is no difference in the sexes and having a preference is terrible. There clearly is a difference and to pretend otherwise is disingenuous.

The thing is I didn't say this? I said that I don't see the difference in a baby which I think is pretty fair. Obviously with teens and up sex matters but apparently I would be denying my daughter her femininity if I don't dress her in 'girly' clothes since birth. This is the only thing I've took issue with as I just think it's a ridiculous take.

And like I said on another post I'm sure I'm going to get lots of 'girly' things as gifts anyway. And frugality and practicality inspires a big part of my decision to just use hand me downs...

OP posts:
Naptrappedmummy · 25/11/2023 12:12

BeardedIrises · 25/11/2023 12:08

Sigh. Because they don’t seem to be making the connection between their own entrenched ideas about gender and the fact that they are likely to be teaching these to their children.

Hence it’s hardly surprising that a dimwitted ‘girlmom’ whose idea of a good time is ‘girly’ spa days and clothes shopping is likely to end up parenting a mini-me who wants a ‘pamper day’ for her fifth birthday party, while leaving her son to engage in football, grunting and roughhousing with his father.

But so many posts on here are by women whose mums wanted them to do those things but they don’t and have followed their own paths.

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 12:11

@BeardedIrises Yes, everyone is clearly sexist. The reason why girls (by and large) are closer to their mothers in adulthood than sons has nothing to do with their sex whatsoever... it’s all just gender stereotyping.

PinotViogner · 25/11/2023 12:09

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 12:00

On these threads, why is it always the ones acknowledging gender differences who get accused of wanting to play dress up or wanting dollies?

There are clear differences between males and females. Even more so as the children reach the teenage years and adulthood. I think it’s far more bizarre to insist there is no difference whatsoever!

They brought it up. Thread was fine with lots of differing but respectful opinions until op said she wouldn't be buying dresses for her newborn and all hell broke loose from the people who seem to think that clothing and sex are related in some grand and important way.

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 12:09

@Socksforxmas … though I do find it a little surprising that you wouldn’t want to buy anything gendered whatsoever for your baby. But horses for courses. Not my baby, not my business.

BeardedIrises · 25/11/2023 12:08

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 12:00

On these threads, why is it always the ones acknowledging gender differences who get accused of wanting to play dress up or wanting dollies?

There are clear differences between males and females. Even more so as the children reach the teenage years and adulthood. I think it’s far more bizarre to insist there is no difference whatsoever!

Sigh. Because they don’t seem to be making the connection between their own entrenched ideas about gender and the fact that they are likely to be teaching these to their children.

Hence it’s hardly surprising that a dimwitted ‘girlmom’ whose idea of a good time is ‘girly’ spa days and clothes shopping is likely to end up parenting a mini-me who wants a ‘pamper day’ for her fifth birthday party, while leaving her son to engage in football, grunting and roughhousing with his father.

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 12:07

@Socksforxmas I don’t care how people dress their children, to be honest.

This debates falls flat for me when people insist there is no difference in the sexes and having a preference is terrible. There clearly is a difference and to pretend otherwise is disingenuous.

Socksforxmas · 25/11/2023 12:04

@BOOMBAL there are differences between sexes but it has nothing to do with clothing.

You're allowed to point out the difference in adult men and women but the only thing I seem to be getting attacked for is the horrid crime of not putting my daughter in a dress.

Biological sex has nothing to do with fashion. Plain and simple.

OP posts:
PinotViogner · 25/11/2023 12:00

@Naptrappedmummy op didn't say anything like that...where did you pull that crap from?

It's terribly sad that you think not sticking a girl on a dress is so problematic in 2023

How about op does whatever she wants and if you like dresses and little girls so much you can get yourself a baby Annabelle or something?

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 12:00

On these threads, why is it always the ones acknowledging gender differences who get accused of wanting to play dress up or wanting dollies?

There are clear differences between males and females. Even more so as the children reach the teenage years and adulthood. I think it’s far more bizarre to insist there is no difference whatsoever!

Socksforxmas · 25/11/2023 11:57

Naptrappedmummy · 25/11/2023 11:51

This is where the argument falls down in my opinion. Op you say you hate girly items so must’ve dressed your sons in a fairly male gendered way. But you frown upon people doing the same with girls?

Can you show me where I said this?

I said that I hate dresses and such for me, and that I'm using hand me downs because they're there. How does this translate to 'frowning upon' other people dressing their kids however they like?

If anyone could show me where I said this that would be great 😂

OP posts:
Socksforxmas · 25/11/2023 11:54

Goodornot · 25/11/2023 11:46

I loved dollies and pink and dresses as a child. I still love dresses now. I also had whitewater kayaking as a hobby as a teen and young adult and frequently hike on all terrains in all weathers.

Wearing a dress doesn't make a girl into a simpering wreck. It doesn't make all girls love spa days- I hate them, never even done one.

Clothes don't make a personality. It's such an odd concept.

Everything your saying is based on projection and not what I actually said. Youre making the assumption that because I will be using hand me downs instead of buying new dresses and skirts for my child that I must somehow be stripping her of her femininity which is frankly nonsense. Especially considering that I've already made it clear that the minute she wants 'girly' things she can have them.

It honestly seems more like you have a problem with women who don't prescribe to traditional feminine rules.

Not to mention that my decision is also largely based on being practical and frugal. If I don't have to buy an entirely new 'girly' wardrobe for a baby that will be growing quickly (as they do) then why would I? I'm hardly a rich woman.

OP posts:
Naptrappedmummy · 25/11/2023 11:53

Doesn't basically everyone dress their children however they please until the kids are old enough to have their own opinions/sense of style?

Seems it’s only acceptable to do so if your style isn’t girly. Otherwise you’re accused of enforcing gender stereotypes. None of it makes sense!

Naptrappedmummy · 25/11/2023 11:51

This is where the argument falls down in my opinion. Op you say you hate girly items so must’ve dressed your sons in a fairly male gendered way. But you frown upon people doing the same with girls?

PinotViogner · 25/11/2023 11:48

This thread is really showing up all of the people who clearly only had children because they didn't grow out of playing with baby dolls 🙄

Apparently op is the height of abusive for not dressing her potential daughter in a dress now. Good grief go to therapy.

MsCactus · 25/11/2023 11:46

This thread is interesting to me - most posters are commenting on the differences between small children, but before puberty there's not v much difference IMO.

The experience of a man Vs a woman though in this world are v different - and that's what came into play with my gender preferences for my DC. I'm going to have adult children a lot longer than I have small children.

Goodornot · 25/11/2023 11:46

I loved dollies and pink and dresses as a child. I still love dresses now. I also had whitewater kayaking as a hobby as a teen and young adult and frequently hike on all terrains in all weathers.

Wearing a dress doesn't make a girl into a simpering wreck. It doesn't make all girls love spa days- I hate them, never even done one.

Clothes don't make a personality. It's such an odd concept.

Socksforxmas · 25/11/2023 11:43

Goodornot · 25/11/2023 11:35

But why would you make that decision for a daughter? I live in dresses and hate trousers unless it's leggings for hiking.

I have very outdoor hobbies and happen to dress in a traditionally feminine way when not doing these hobbies.

Why would you dress your daughter in boys clothes because you don't like dresses or anything remotely traditionally feminine.

If there's no difference I trust your sons wear dresses and skirts. No? Then there is a difference.

God it's so weird.

Edited

So you just didn't read any of what I said then...?

As soon as she asks for dresses and 'girly' clothes she'll get them. I'll be happy to oblige.

But in the meantime I'll be using the perfectly good clothes I already have saved up from my boys, most of which is very neutral anyway. Not to mention I'm sure family and friends will be provide a lot of the girly stuff in the form of gifts anyway...

My son's have never asked to wear dresses, and I have never wished for them to so no they haven't. Again, if they wanted to I would oblige.

Doesn't basically everyone dress their children however they please until the kids are old enough to have their own opinions/sense of style?

OP posts: