Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's ridiculous how obsessed with a babies gender/sex ppl still seemingly are?

194 replies

Socksforxmas · 24/11/2023 19:55

I have my 20wk scan in a couple of days and will be finding out the sex if they're able to tell. DH and I already have twin boys aged 3 and know this will be our last baby. It might be silly on my end to be surprised by this but a shocking amount of ppl in my life seem to assume that I'm desperate for a girl and would be deeply saddened by another boy.

I know that every now and again some 'gender disappointment' threads pop up but i had assumed that overall ppl had come to the realization that it really doesn't matter much. I'm not going to raise them any differently or push any sort of gendered nonsense on them. I don't really understand what it'd be getting from one and not the other. Ultimately it's a baby. As long as its not a puppy or anything like that I'm happy.

A lot of the comments have been fairly innocent 'bet you want a wee girl this time' but some have been more (paraphrasing here) "oh God I bet you'll just die if they tell you it's another boy! I wouldn't be able to cope with that"

Idk. I just really don't care either way and am surprised by the amount of comments I've received from family and friends about it. Anyone else experience similar?

OP posts:
Naptrappedmummy · 25/11/2023 13:27

Ok, but it’s still an option if you really really wanted not to find out, it could even be fun ‘were we right or wrong’

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/11/2023 13:27

Socksforxmas · 25/11/2023 13:23

@Naptrappedmummy tbh it was extremely obvious the first time I looked at the twins properly that one of them was a boy. I'd considered trying to keep the other one a secret but it just felt so pointless. And with all the constant correspondence with my medical team it was nice to just use male pronouns and not have to speak in code all the time with all the neutral language.

Idk with how messy the pregnancy was overall it was nice to be straightforward and to the point with at least that one aspect.

I think it's also very possible to not have a preference or not think it's particularly important but to find out anyway.

I'm not a surprise person, hate them so that was never something I was interested in anyway. I like knowing all of the information available to me.

Socksforxmas · 25/11/2023 13:23

@Naptrappedmummy tbh it was extremely obvious the first time I looked at the twins properly that one of them was a boy. I'd considered trying to keep the other one a secret but it just felt so pointless. And with all the constant correspondence with my medical team it was nice to just use male pronouns and not have to speak in code all the time with all the neutral language.

Idk with how messy the pregnancy was overall it was nice to be straightforward and to the point with at least that one aspect.

OP posts:
Socksforxmas · 25/11/2023 13:18

Honestly something I've really appreciated about twin boys has been being able to see in real time how two boys raised by the same people, in the same environment and treated no different have still ended up as completely different children with largely different personalities and interests.

OP posts:
Naptrappedmummy · 25/11/2023 13:17

You could always just look and think you have an idea of the sex without ultimately finding out. Unless you’re a sonographer you won’t be able to tell for certain. I know loads of people who thought they definitely knew from scans but baby popped out the other sex.

Socksforxmas · 25/11/2023 13:14

@Concannon88 I answered this already but tbf it's way back in the thread now so the short answer is that my pregnancy with the twins was a nightmare and I needed numerous scans and it got very tedious not being able to look at my children to avoid seeing the sex. This pregnancy is looking difficult too and I'd rather spoil the surprise and get to actually see them at the scans.

OP posts:
Terfosaurus · 25/11/2023 13:08

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 12:58

@Terfosaurus Where is the line between what is ‘biological’ and what is ‘gender stereotyping’. Sure, you can make the case for blue/pink and cars/dolls.

I would argue that females and males are quite different biologically. As a result we have completely different life experiences. Hence, girls mostly gravitate towards their mothers and boys their fathers. It’s the shared biological experiences that make it easier to relate to the same sex. For example, my mother and sister supported me throughout my pregnancy and the early years of my babies far more than the male members of my family. I don’t believe that’s due to sexism or gender stereotyping, but because the females in my life understand the trials and tribulations of pregnancy, post partum, breast feeding, early years of babyhood far better than their male counterparts. As a result, we have a closer bond and relationship than I have with say, my dad or uncles.

Of course there are biological differences. I haven't actually said there aren't.

In fact I specifically asked about differences in pre-puberty.

Boys growing up to like football and golf (as per the original comment I replied to) has got absolutely fuck all to do with biology.

forumstalk · 25/11/2023 13:01

If I had twin boys and added another boy, than I think that other boy might feel left out. At least a girl would balance it out imo

Concannon88 · 25/11/2023 13:00

If you really dont care why are you finding out?

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 12:58

@Terfosaurus Where is the line between what is ‘biological’ and what is ‘gender stereotyping’. Sure, you can make the case for blue/pink and cars/dolls.

I would argue that females and males are quite different biologically. As a result we have completely different life experiences. Hence, girls mostly gravitate towards their mothers and boys their fathers. It’s the shared biological experiences that make it easier to relate to the same sex. For example, my mother and sister supported me throughout my pregnancy and the early years of my babies far more than the male members of my family. I don’t believe that’s due to sexism or gender stereotyping, but because the females in my life understand the trials and tribulations of pregnancy, post partum, breast feeding, early years of babyhood far better than their male counterparts. As a result, we have a closer bond and relationship than I have with say, my dad or uncles.

Kwer · 25/11/2023 12:58

It is annoying, but be patient with it: it is understandable and they’re just trying to express empathy.

As a mum of boys, I am sad that I’ll never have a daughter, and in particular never be able to help a daughter with birth, breastfeeding a newborn baby etc. Sure I might have a daughter-in-law who wants me to help, but her own mum will be more involved than me, unless her relationship with her mum is awful which I very much hope it won’t be.

Also, so many times at theme parks etc I want to go see the animals / musical show and the boys and their dad just want to do thrill-seeking rides, and I do feel wistful that if I had a girl she’d maybe come with me.

That said if I had to choose between only having girls or only having boys, I’m so happy I got boys, they just adore me 🥰 I do wish my DH had got to experience having a “daddy’s girl” too.

Terfosaurus · 25/11/2023 12:55

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/11/2023 12:53

You can also parent gender neutrally as much as you like but it doesn't stop societies influence. Toddler groups, nursery, school etc.

Yes exactly.

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/11/2023 12:53

Terfosaurus · 25/11/2023 12:47

Just because some girls are more girly despite not having girly mums doesn't mean it's not mostly nurture.
Just as my slightly 'feminine' boys don't prove anything.

But I know far more people who claim their dcs differences are caused by sex, whilst denying they buy into stereotypes, than I do children who genuinely have like/dislikes despite gender neutral parenting.

And yes. Animals have different roles based on their sex. But that's biological. In most species females give birth. So males get food. Etc

You can also parent gender neutrally as much as you like but it doesn't stop societies influence. Toddler groups, nursery, school etc.

Terfosaurus · 25/11/2023 12:47

Just because some girls are more girly despite not having girly mums doesn't mean it's not mostly nurture.
Just as my slightly 'feminine' boys don't prove anything.

But I know far more people who claim their dcs differences are caused by sex, whilst denying they buy into stereotypes, than I do children who genuinely have like/dislikes despite gender neutral parenting.

And yes. Animals have different roles based on their sex. But that's biological. In most species females give birth. So males get food. Etc

Parker231 · 25/11/2023 12:44

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 12:07

@Socksforxmas I don’t care how people dress their children, to be honest.

This debates falls flat for me when people insist there is no difference in the sexes and having a preference is terrible. There clearly is a difference and to pretend otherwise is disingenuous.

When they are younger there are little differences - b/g twins- dressed in babygros or dungarees. Non uniform school so both wore jeans every day. Both did music lessons, went to STEM club, attended science holiday clubs and were fussy about what their hair and clothes looked like.

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/11/2023 12:42

ThomasinaLivesHere · 25/11/2023 12:38

We live in an incredibly sexist society, of course that is going to have a big influence

Are there any societies which are or haven’t met the definition of sexist if we accept that our society is incredibly sexist? Society is surely something that people form and not imposed on people by an outside force. So the fact that most (all?) societies have a distinction between men and women might suggest there’s something in it.

Or it just suggests that the world as a whole is sexist. Some societies more than others.

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 12:40

@ThomasinaLivesHere Agreed. Even in the animal kingdom there are different roles for male / female animals. Are they all sexist, misogynists?

forumstalk · 25/11/2023 12:39

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 12:37

@Terfosaurus I don’t know anyone who has told their child they can’t play with ‘x’ because of their sex. In fact, the person I know who has tried to persuade her boys (she has 3) to play with dolls, kitchens etc. has been unsuccessful. They’ve all naturally gravitated towards cars and trucks.

FWIW, my mum and sister aren’t particularly girly, but I am super stereotypically girly. That wasn’t encouraged by my mum or sister, at all. I have a close relationship with them due to shared interests and the shared female experience (periods, pregnancy, childbirth and rearing, relationships), which is not something males can understand the same.

Yes it's weird how some girls are "girly". My niece is like that and my sister (and I) aren't.

ThomasinaLivesHere · 25/11/2023 12:38

We live in an incredibly sexist society, of course that is going to have a big influence

Are there any societies which are or haven’t met the definition of sexist if we accept that our society is incredibly sexist? Society is surely something that people form and not imposed on people by an outside force. So the fact that most (all?) societies have a distinction between men and women might suggest there’s something in it.

BOOMBAL · 25/11/2023 12:37

@Terfosaurus I don’t know anyone who has told their child they can’t play with ‘x’ because of their sex. In fact, the person I know who has tried to persuade her boys (she has 3) to play with dolls, kitchens etc. has been unsuccessful. They’ve all naturally gravitated towards cars and trucks.

FWIW, my mum and sister aren’t particularly girly, but I am super stereotypically girly. That wasn’t encouraged by my mum or sister, at all. I have a close relationship with them due to shared interests and the shared female experience (periods, pregnancy, childbirth and rearing, relationships), which is not something males can understand the same.

EarringsandLipstick · 25/11/2023 12:36

electriclight · 25/11/2023 12:29

It's probably already been said because I haven't rtft but they are just making small talk because nobody, absolutely nobody, cares about your scan, your pregnancy or the sex if your baby.

You tell them you're pregnant, or about your scan, and they feel that they have to say something but don't know what.

My natural response would be 'oh' but I always feel like I've got to seem interested. Give us a list of polite responses and I'll adopt one.

Great post!

EarringsandLipstick · 25/11/2023 12:35

Moving back to OP's first post, a lot of this just comes under the heading of Stuff People Say Without Thinking - you seem to have had some extreme versions, but mostly people just want to make some comment & don't think too deeply.

Most people don't actually think there's anything terrible about having children of the same sex. There are casual passing thoughts of not having a daughter to share certain experiences with etc - a lot of it is based on what the person themselves has experienced - I have girls & boys, and so find it hard to imagine not having both.

When mine were little, I had 'enjoy them!' said to me many many times (often in a day), usually by older women, with a clutch of my elbow. It used to drive me crazy (tho I didn't let it show) as I'd maybe have been up half the night or wrestled a toddler, preschooler & newborn out the door for 830... now mine are all nearly teens, I can see why they say it - those early years seem like centuries, but when you get to this stage you realise how quickly the years go by & how little time where they have that utter dependence & connection with you remains. I don't say it but sometimes think it when I see a mum with an adorable baby or toddler.

forumstalk · 25/11/2023 12:34

Gender and sex or two different things....

FrenchToastLover · 25/11/2023 12:30

Interestly enough I have 2 daughters and nobody every felt sorry for me not having a boy. In fact a lot of ppl thought I'd be really pleased to have only girls. My partners the one taking all the unwanted comments sighs

And for what it's worth op the dresses and tights went out the window with my second. Very annoying compared to good ol trousers. Suppose that makes me the worst kind of specimen huh?

Definitely some on this thread who would do better sticking with their baby dolls and Barbies 😛

electriclight · 25/11/2023 12:29

It's probably already been said because I haven't rtft but they are just making small talk because nobody, absolutely nobody, cares about your scan, your pregnancy or the sex if your baby.

You tell them you're pregnant, or about your scan, and they feel that they have to say something but don't know what.

My natural response would be 'oh' but I always feel like I've got to seem interested. Give us a list of polite responses and I'll adopt one.