Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To touch a strangers dog without permission then to be abusive when it barks

207 replies

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 24/11/2023 15:14

For context; we have a 4 year old female German Shepherd who is the softest, friendliest dog you can meet IF she knows you. She is not good with strangers, especially men, after some horrible experiences as a very young puppy. Typical of her breed she is loyal, loving and protective over us and our DC (6mo twins)- to note she is NEVER alone with or out of reach when around DC and has only ever been calm and affectionate towards them.

This morning I’m out walking her with a friend and have the twins in their pram, my friend pops into a shop so I’m stood outside with the pram in front of me and her sat calmly by my feet, next to the pram. Out of nowhere a young, quite big in build, man appears next to me and just lunges towards her and sticks his hand into her face. She instinctively sees this as a threat to her and us and immediately snaps at him/barks loudly. He backs off whilst quite angrily saying ‘not a friendly dog then eh?’.. so I said ‘actually she is but not with strangers and you should have asked before touching her!’ To which he raises his voice and starts saying ‘you shouldn’t have an effing dog on the streets if it isn’t effing friendly to strangers!’

At this point my friend comes out of the shop so this man storms off whilst shouting back more abuse about me being a ‘silly cow’ and having a ‘dangerous dog’..

Now I’m aware she’s a protective breed and can be intimidating to some, but I had a halter collar/lead on her and kept her by my feet/out of the way of people passing. She has zero issues around people as long as they don’t try touch her without warning. He PURPOSELY leaned across me to touch her with no warning!

AIBU to be annoyed at him? Or could I/should I have done more to avoid strangers touching her?

OP posts:
BalthazarTheCamel · 24/11/2023 16:23

@Floatlikeafeather2

absolutely agree with you!! Why on earth to people feel they can just approach your dog and touch it without asking? Rude and idiotic!
I’m used to German Shepherds, but wouldn’t dream of just touching a strangers dog! Surely you chat to the owner first and they will tell you what they are like around people.
The idea that all dogs should be muzzled in public so strangers kids can do whatever to them is bizarre - I’ve met a few kids I’d love to muzzle if I’m honest!
I don’t touch your kids, so don’t touch my (on a lead, taking no notice of your kids) dog!

divinededacende · 24/11/2023 16:20

And I'm guessing that you posting it means it's the first time this has happened? A big man suddenly shoving his hand at a dogs face is asking for trouble and he deserved it.

I'm not a dog owner but I have a walking group with folk who mostly are; collies, collie/lab mix etc.

Seeing the crap they put up with, it absolutely astounds me how ignorant people are around dogs. Also, the wildly different thresholds people have for telling you a dog's "out of control".

BalthazarTheCamel · 24/11/2023 16:16

We had this when DS was in his pram… I’d popped into shop, DH outside with pram, and 2 yr old German Shepherd lolling on DHs feet as usual… a woman who lived by us but never spoke to us, marched straight up to the pram and stuck both hands in to pick DS up!!! Of course, the dog went nuts and she starts yelling about the Ddog being dangerous!!😡
Absolutely stupid thing to do, whatever the breed of dog, but especially with the ‘guarding’ breeds.
Its about 37 years ago, and I can still remember the awful noise outside when I was in the shop - I guessed what had happened.
Love, love, love German Shepherds, loved with them all my life, and known many others. My current one is gazing out of the window at seagulls at the moment.
I’ve only ever been bitten once by a dog… by a bloody ‘toy’ poodle!

MissingMoominMamma · 24/11/2023 16:15

I wonder what his reaction would be if a stranger lunged at his face…

Mrgrinch · 24/11/2023 16:15

MamaGhina · 24/11/2023 15:46

Agree. My kids are being taught to ask but my youngest has special needs and if he sees a fluffy dog, he might try and touch it without asking. I’d be pretty upset incandescent with rage if he was bitten.

Rage all you want but if any person, adult or child, puts their hand near a dog's mouth then they are at risk of being bitten. It's common sense and your job as a parent is to stop a child from doing it.

In fact, if a person shoved their hand in my face I think I'd be tempted to bite them too. Maybe I should wear a muzzle?

purpleme12 · 24/11/2023 16:12

I always ask if I can stroke a dog first

NoTouch · 24/11/2023 16:10

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 24/11/2023 15:57

As a parent I can agree I’d be mortified if my child was bitten, however ultimately it’s the parents responsibility to stop their children from approaching strangers dogs, I understand much harder if a child has special needs.

As even the most mild mannered dog with zero history of reactiveness could turn? By your logic should all dogs be muzzled all the time to avoid parents having to stop their children?

As even the most mild mannered dog with zero history of reactiveness could turn?

You need to assess the risk reasonably - you own a breed that is large and could do significant damage, it is a breed bred for its guarding instincts, and you have seen these instincts in action with reactiveness in the dog. Therefore common sense says it is a much higher risk than most dogs.

You are biased/blinkered to this because it is your dog, but really you should be responsible and muzzle him in busy public places.

Why do you think you shouldn't?

CosyKnits · 24/11/2023 16:08

I think there is an argument for muzzling dogs in public, especially large breeds that could do considerable damage to or even kill a person.

Ideally nobody should approach a strange dog however there are plenty of vulnerable people who might do so, or could in some other way inadvertently cause a dog to react with a bite. I think the onus is always, always on the owner of the dog to make sure they minimise the risk as much as possible e.g. by muzzling, keeping on a short lead, ensuring perfect recall if off lead etc.

I'm sorry you had that experience though, it must have been very unpleasant.

Deathwillbebutapause · 24/11/2023 16:06

He was totally in the wrong.

Another inadequate man screaming crap at a woman in public (with her babies there!). Yawn. All too common now.

Please try not to dwell on it and don't let it affect your routines.

Lovemycat2023 · 24/11/2023 16:06

You should always ask, and be polite if the owner says no. I was taught this as a small child. Some people have no manners

Yellowdaysaregood · 24/11/2023 16:05

Don't give it a second thought, as a pp said he objected to YOU not really the dog . The dog isn't a problem mine is the same, any one getting in his face without permission gets what they get, and before anyone comes for me he has never bitten,and is not left alone with children. But that's just common sense, people should not be near a strange dog without asking.

Floatlikeafeather2 · 24/11/2023 16:04

I don't understand at all why people seem to have a thing about touching other people's dogs. I think it's weird. When people approach us, even if they ask, I say that I'd rather they didn't. Why on earth should they? Get your own dog!

Nanny0gg · 24/11/2023 16:00

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 24/11/2023 15:35

I only realised as my dog was reacting, he was that quick and appeared from behind me. If anyone even looks to be thinking about approaching I usually give a ‘she’s not great with strangers/is nervous, please don’t touch her’.

She'd have been pretty useful if it had been you he'd been lunging for...

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 24/11/2023 15:59

He was a dick.

Who actually goes to stroke a dog face on without permission?!

An idiot, that’s who

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 24/11/2023 15:57

MamaGhina · 24/11/2023 15:46

Agree. My kids are being taught to ask but my youngest has special needs and if he sees a fluffy dog, he might try and touch it without asking. I’d be pretty upset incandescent with rage if he was bitten.

As a parent I can agree I’d be mortified if my child was bitten, however ultimately it’s the parents responsibility to stop their children from approaching strangers dogs, I understand much harder if a child has special needs.

As even the most mild mannered dog with zero history of reactiveness could turn? By your logic should all dogs be muzzled all the time to avoid parents having to stop their children?

OP posts:
NoTouch · 24/11/2023 15:56

If you have a large reactive dog it should be muzzled in busy public places where you can't always control interactions. Just because he hasn't bitten YET, doesn't mean he will never. It protects not only the people around you but also your dog.

As for his over reaction, assuming you never provoked it with the way you spoke to him about daring to touch your dog, of course it was wrong.

jlpth · 24/11/2023 15:51

People are very silly.

I have a cute dog. Very cute. He isn't friendly, unless he knows you, in which case he is extremely friendly. Woman stuck her hand in his face yesterday, despite being told that he was not friendly. He barked at her. She was actually shocked! I have a bright sleeve on the dog lead that says "do not touch". It's astonishing that people come and ask to touch.

MamaGhina · 24/11/2023 15:46

CurlewKate · 24/11/2023 15:22

If you can't be sure your dog won't bite then it should be muzzled. Bathe man was a dickhead. But even dickheads shouldn't be bitten.

Agree. My kids are being taught to ask but my youngest has special needs and if he sees a fluffy dog, he might try and touch it without asking. I’d be pretty upset incandescent with rage if he was bitten.

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 24/11/2023 15:42

Just to be clear, she has never bitten anyone before. If she feels threatened like in this instance, she snaps/barks quite animatedly, which I appreciate given her breed can be quite scary to some. I’m confident (as confident as you can be) she would not bite someone or I’d muzzle her when in public. In response to a question about how she is around children- she actually loves children and has shown zero anxiety around any, even when I’ve introduced her to new ones (family, friends children etc in a safe way).

OP posts:
WhileMyDishwasherGentlyWeeps · 24/11/2023 15:40

I find it amazing both that any person ever tries to touch a dog - why? what’s the attraction of a dog? - and that owners think it’s ‘normal’ or ‘reasonable’ for a dog to react aggressively.

If your dog reacts like that, muzzle it, as a pp has said. It’s clearly not fit to be in public otherwise.

NoCloudsAllowed · 24/11/2023 15:39

He was in the wrong.

But kids often do the same thing, could your dog be a risk to them?

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 24/11/2023 15:35

I only realised as my dog was reacting, he was that quick and appeared from behind me. If anyone even looks to be thinking about approaching I usually give a ‘she’s not great with strangers/is nervous, please don’t touch her’.

OP posts:
Catza · 24/11/2023 15:34

He was more likely being abusive because he took offence to you reminding him that he shouldn't touch a dog without permission. At least, from your account it seems that he didn't mind her barking as much as you talking.
Not saying that you or your dog did anything wrong just that you may want to avoid entering into conversation in the future to save your sanity.

alloalloallo · 24/11/2023 15:33

YANBU.

I have a springer, who is friendly and loves fuss and attention, but very much on her terms. She can be a little shy so is not keen on people grabbing at her without warning. She just backs away and hides behind me, which people seem to take offence to - she’s not a toy and I’m not going to force her.

I have actually asked people who do it how they would like it if I randomly started hugging them or stroking them without warning or permission and they get huffy.

I remember standing at some traffic lights with my old boy, on a lead, sitting nicely, waiting for the lights to change so we could cross over.

A child walking behind us, just kind of launched himself at my dog for a hug. My dog didn’t snap, or bark, but just kind of stood up in surprise so there was a clash of heads and the child fell towards the road before I grabbed him. The child’s Mum went absolutely nuts at me - ranting about my dangerous dog - I was like, maybe you should teach your child to ask permission before hugging random dogs.

HoneyBeatrice · 24/11/2023 15:29

Dont touch strangers dogs without asking. Its simple really