Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To touch a strangers dog without permission then to be abusive when it barks

207 replies

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 24/11/2023 15:14

For context; we have a 4 year old female German Shepherd who is the softest, friendliest dog you can meet IF she knows you. She is not good with strangers, especially men, after some horrible experiences as a very young puppy. Typical of her breed she is loyal, loving and protective over us and our DC (6mo twins)- to note she is NEVER alone with or out of reach when around DC and has only ever been calm and affectionate towards them.

This morning I’m out walking her with a friend and have the twins in their pram, my friend pops into a shop so I’m stood outside with the pram in front of me and her sat calmly by my feet, next to the pram. Out of nowhere a young, quite big in build, man appears next to me and just lunges towards her and sticks his hand into her face. She instinctively sees this as a threat to her and us and immediately snaps at him/barks loudly. He backs off whilst quite angrily saying ‘not a friendly dog then eh?’.. so I said ‘actually she is but not with strangers and you should have asked before touching her!’ To which he raises his voice and starts saying ‘you shouldn’t have an effing dog on the streets if it isn’t effing friendly to strangers!’

At this point my friend comes out of the shop so this man storms off whilst shouting back more abuse about me being a ‘silly cow’ and having a ‘dangerous dog’..

Now I’m aware she’s a protective breed and can be intimidating to some, but I had a halter collar/lead on her and kept her by my feet/out of the way of people passing. She has zero issues around people as long as they don’t try touch her without warning. He PURPOSELY leaned across me to touch her with no warning!

AIBU to be annoyed at him? Or could I/should I have done more to avoid strangers touching her?

OP posts:
TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 24/11/2023 19:31

Locallady2 · 24/11/2023 19:16

Children aren't capable of mauling people to death?

I’m honestly so embarrassed for people who make that comparison. Like do they think their smelly out of control mutt is the same as a human child? I worry for some people’s intelligence

OCDmama · 24/11/2023 19:22

No one should be approaching strange dogs.

But, YABU having this dog in the first place, and say how she 'could be scary'.

The police use these dogs to attack adults. There's a little girl buried next to my great grandmother who was killed by the family German shepherds.

These are not family dogs, and people do not have any business having them.

Yellowdaysaregood · 24/11/2023 19:19

Christ I know I'm old but fxcinell , how far have we come where we are so obsessed with will a dog bite or not if you invade it's space, when I was growing up the sole purpose of us having a dog was to bite folks if they came into our space IE. the garden. It's simple peeps don't invade the dogs space it won't bite you, I won't be muzzling my perfectly behaved lab who won't harm anyone UNLESS you get in his space and fuck him off.

Locallady2 · 24/11/2023 19:16

Hobbi · 24/11/2023 18:25

If people can't control their children, they should put them on reins for their own safety. If they are being over excited and making enough noise to upset other people and animals, they should be gagged or kept at home.

Children aren't capable of mauling people to death?

goababy · 24/11/2023 19:09

fitforflight · 24/11/2023 15:21

As a dog owner I know how annoying some strangers can be when you're out with the dog. Nobody should touch a dog without the owner's permission however if you know your dog is protective to the point he may bite if a stranger touched him I would muzzle him in public. It may not be what you want but if your dog did bite a stranger you could be in much more trouble and I'd not want to risk the backlash or being forced to put my dog down.

Agree with this 100%. I really feel for you, your dog is only trying to protect their family but people can be so funny about GSD and it would be awful if you were forced to PTS because some dickhead touched your pup without asking.

The benefit of a muzzle also is that it stops said dickheads even trying to touch your dog as they assume unfriendly. There are some brilliant guides online about how you can train muzzle wearing as a positive and ok thing for the dog.

I was recently told by a youngish vet that my dog had "an attitude problem" because she wasn't happy with the vet touching her. Sorry but I'd be a bit arsey as well if someone I didn't know stuck a thermometer up my bum!

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 24/11/2023 19:00

Thanks everyone, after reading through the comments I think I’ll invest in a ‘I’m nervous please do not touch’ vest or similar for her and avoid standing in places we could be surprised by random people trying to touch her. I want to avoid muzzling her at all costs and don’t want to be in situation that could mean I have to or worse. Just sad really some people can’t understand it’s not acceptable to touch animals without the owners consent ☹️

OP posts:
Fifteenth · 24/11/2023 18:49

Based on that exchange, it was probably your response he didn’t like, not your dog’s.

Only you know whether you spoke to him in a friendly tone or as a reprimand.

abcde124 · 24/11/2023 18:48

my children’s school have a talk every year as part of safety week. A professional comes from a dog charity and they educate children on dogs. My children came home, one Reception, one y4, and told me that you always ask to stroke the dog. They ask me first, then the owner.
I normally say no, unless we are in a setting/environment where a dog is close by for a while.
my son was bitten on the hand by a sausage dog(?!) that was off the lead. It wandered up to him and just bit his hand. So for my son to still want to stroke dogs, is a good thing!
you did the right thing having it on a lead and by you. The stranger shouldn’t have tried to stroke the dog.

Lucyintheskywithadiamond · 24/11/2023 18:47

YANBU and I can’t believe 10% have voted that YABU, they are probably just as stupid as the man who you unfortunately encountered!

louderthan · 24/11/2023 18:44

Yanbu. Same with horses. My mare looks like a unicorn from a fairy tale but she'll take a chunk out of you if you pat her in the wrong place.

bananablues · 24/11/2023 18:31

Your reactive dog should be muzzled in case people (especially children) don't ask.

to me a reactive dog is one which reacts aggressively to normal situations. She was sitting quietly by her owners side, not barking at passers by- that is not reactive. Only issue came when an idiot lunged at her without warning- sometimes people need to take responsibility for their own stupidity. A child would be far less threatening- the issue is with grown men.

P.s. I am the biggest advocate of getting out of control dogs off the street.

Hobbi · 24/11/2023 18:25

If people can't control their children, they should put them on reins for their own safety. If they are being over excited and making enough noise to upset other people and animals, they should be gagged or kept at home.

PoshHorseyBird · 24/11/2023 18:25

My German Shepherd can be very anxious with other dogs. I tend to walk him in isolated spacious areas as even if he does kick off on seeing another dog, people would still allow their dogs to come over declaring "ooohhh he just wants to say hello!" No he really fucking doesn't!!
So! I got him a large luminous yellow vest with the words 'space needed' on it. Also two lead attachments, one saying 'anxious dog may over react' and one saying ' unpredictable twat'. They actually work! Especially the vest. Maybe it would be worth trying something like that? Although the guy in question would probably be one of those 'oh dogs love me!' 🙄

farmfoodsqueen · 24/11/2023 18:19

Oh hun I completely understand the frustration... our old XL bully was amazing with my kids and would never hurt a fly but the amount of people that would try and touch her head was unreal... we were responsible owners so she was well trained etc but would snap and growl at strangers who would then have a go at us for owning an "aggressive" dog!! People are unbelievable hun, YANBU xx

Headshoulderscheeseontoast · 24/11/2023 18:17

Sorry op if your dog has potential to bite people you need to muzzle it in public, there will always be idiots around. You wouldn't want the heartbreak of having to pts if they bit someone.

Peacheroo · 24/11/2023 18:16

It's 50/50. You obviously rubbed him up the wrong way with your response which was a bit "know it all" for someone who allowed it to happen. I have an Akita who would react in the same way so I understand your feelings on this BUT that's why as soon as someone walks up, I tell them no. Eyes open!

Locallady2 · 24/11/2023 18:13

What about a dog coat that says nervous on it? Vaguely remember seeing a dog with something like that once, although it was smaller than a German Shepard. A muzzle also signals to others that they shouldn't touch your dog.
My dad had a German shepherd once and used to walk her for miles across fields but never took her into town where there was lots of people because he knew she wouldn't handle it well. It is your responsibility as a dog owner to make sure nothing bad could happen to others, even if they are stupid enough to touch a dog they don't know.

CurlewKate · 24/11/2023 18:12

@FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable "Doesn’t the grabby person bear any responsibility?"

Yes. Loads. But the bite has still happened.

daisybe · 24/11/2023 18:09

To be honest, my dog is absolutely fine with anyone and everyone, extremely submissive and won't even take a treat if another dog is there for fear it'll upset the other dog I guess! BUT I still wouldn't want anyone touching her without asking, it should be common knowledge to ask before touching regardless of how "cute" or "friendly" a dog looks. I hate it when people don't!

Mostly people do ask me and I'll say yes, situation depending but generally if I'm not keen on the vibe I won't. Or if i can see itchy hands, ill move, say on a train or bus etc. (Little kids who look excited & parents ask, elderly lady on the bus etc - makes their day.... intimidating bloke who looks dodgy.... err no, mate)

Mine has just had tplo surgery and we're limited to 15min walks and I'm too scared to even do that as when we went to the park, loose dogs ran up to her and I didn't want to risk re-injury or surgical failure if she jumped etc even though on lead SO, my point, to help stop this I bought her a lead thing that says "Anxious Dog Respect my space" it's yellow, which stands out.
It might help avoid such nasty individuals in the future. There's all sorts of other texts available, I just chose that because I simply wanted to keep people at a distance but equally i didn't want to give people the impression its because shes aggressive, I just want some space.

I'm sure you can also find places that do custom ones, too.
You're not being unreasonable BTW. Some people just feel like they're owed 😒

Anyway, that yellow sleeve is an option if you feel it might happen again. I plan to keep mine as I'm due soon and worried about having to keep an eye on two important beings at the same time!

Viviennemary · 24/11/2023 18:08

No the man shouldn't have touched the dog without permission. But next time it could be a child. If the dog can't be trusted not act aggressively then it's a problem and a danger in public places.

Cosyblankets · 24/11/2023 18:06

He should have asked
He shouldn't have been abusive
However i think you need to take some responsibility for your dog. You can get leads, collars and harnesses that say 'nervous'.

CaineRaine · 24/11/2023 18:00

fitforflight · 24/11/2023 15:21

As a dog owner I know how annoying some strangers can be when you're out with the dog. Nobody should touch a dog without the owner's permission however if you know your dog is protective to the point he may bite if a stranger touched him I would muzzle him in public. It may not be what you want but if your dog did bite a stranger you could be in much more trouble and I'd not want to risk the backlash or being forced to put my dog down.

I agree with this, the man sounds like an utter idiot but I’d think of the muzzle as a way of preventing any heartache if a complaint was made about your dog if they reacted more strongly next time.

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 24/11/2023 17:59

CurlewKate · 24/11/2023 17:35

@FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable Well, at the point where they take a dog they know will react badly to being touched out in public....

Doesn’t the grabby person bear any responsibility? Nobody should touch people or animals without consent. I wouldn’t be very friendly if someone lunged at me either.

rwalker · 24/11/2023 17:57

Can’t stand dogs but yes he was out of order and wrong

Atethehalloweenchocs · 24/11/2023 17:54

I occasionally will pat a dog before I get permission - but ONLY if they run up to me and their owners are too far away to shout across too (happens a fair bit where I walk my dogs). But I am careful about watching their body language and dont pat unless I am sure they are friendly. And I would never touch a dog which was attached to an owner without speaking to the owner first. Hes bonkers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread