Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To touch a strangers dog without permission then to be abusive when it barks

207 replies

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 24/11/2023 15:14

For context; we have a 4 year old female German Shepherd who is the softest, friendliest dog you can meet IF she knows you. She is not good with strangers, especially men, after some horrible experiences as a very young puppy. Typical of her breed she is loyal, loving and protective over us and our DC (6mo twins)- to note she is NEVER alone with or out of reach when around DC and has only ever been calm and affectionate towards them.

This morning I’m out walking her with a friend and have the twins in their pram, my friend pops into a shop so I’m stood outside with the pram in front of me and her sat calmly by my feet, next to the pram. Out of nowhere a young, quite big in build, man appears next to me and just lunges towards her and sticks his hand into her face. She instinctively sees this as a threat to her and us and immediately snaps at him/barks loudly. He backs off whilst quite angrily saying ‘not a friendly dog then eh?’.. so I said ‘actually she is but not with strangers and you should have asked before touching her!’ To which he raises his voice and starts saying ‘you shouldn’t have an effing dog on the streets if it isn’t effing friendly to strangers!’

At this point my friend comes out of the shop so this man storms off whilst shouting back more abuse about me being a ‘silly cow’ and having a ‘dangerous dog’..

Now I’m aware she’s a protective breed and can be intimidating to some, but I had a halter collar/lead on her and kept her by my feet/out of the way of people passing. She has zero issues around people as long as they don’t try touch her without warning. He PURPOSELY leaned across me to touch her with no warning!

AIBU to be annoyed at him? Or could I/should I have done more to avoid strangers touching her?

OP posts:
WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 25/11/2023 00:03

OCDmama · 24/11/2023 19:22

No one should be approaching strange dogs.

But, YABU having this dog in the first place, and say how she 'could be scary'.

The police use these dogs to attack adults. There's a little girl buried next to my great grandmother who was killed by the family German shepherds.

These are not family dogs, and people do not have any business having them.

I couldn’t disagree with you more, sadly plenty of people over the years have died as a result of dogs, not just GSD’s. So your argument seems to be aimed at all dogs, which isn’t helpful as we’re not all going to suddenly stop having dogs as pets. GSD’s can make amazing family pets, but I’m not here to try to convince you of that.

OP posts:
Ladybughello · 25/11/2023 00:02

Agree the man should have asked first. But what would be amazing would be if other people didn’t let their dog touch strangers without them (the owner) asking. Hopefully no overlap with the people on this thread who are enraged by a human touching a dog without asking and the large number of dog owners that think that’s absolutely fine / cute / the stranger should be delighted by the honour.

Loubelle70 · 24/11/2023 23:59

CurlewKate · 24/11/2023 15:22

If you can't be sure your dog won't bite then it should be muzzled. Bathe man was a dickhead. But even dickheads shouldn't be bitten.

This

BalthazarTheCamel · 24/11/2023 23:56

@XenoBitch
Oh yes, so lovely!

Could do without mine snoring, dreaming (involves kicking and little puffy barks) and her dogsbreath, but she loves cuddling and she’s so fluffy and warm on this cold night!

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 24/11/2023 23:55

BubbleBubbleBubbleBubblePop · 24/11/2023 17:38

This was my thought also. It sounds like he made a comment that the dog wasn't friendly and the you said what you said in a shitty tone (the ! at the end of what you said makes me think it was a bit of a shitty tone) and that's what set him off on his rant. Not getting snapped at by the dog.

Obviously he was in the wrong to have touched the dog without asking first but I'm guessing he would have just shrugged it off with "not a friendly dog then" if you hadn't have spoken in the condescending tone.

He said it in a shitty tone believe me, and I wasn’t amused (and why should I have been?) so yes I did say ‘and you should ask first’.. which surely is reasonable.. I’m actually very anti-confrontational and on the quieter side, so it wasn’t even in a raised voice.

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 24/11/2023 23:48

BalthazarTheCamel · 24/11/2023 23:38

@Catsmere 🙌👏 🐕♥️🐈♥️

Shout out to all the dogs, cats, rabbits, mice, snakes, birds, rodents etc who are keeping their owners company tonight, giving them cuddles, keeping them warm and safe. 🐾

My dog will be in bed with me soon. We keep each other warm. It is lovely.

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 24/11/2023 23:44

CurlewKate · 24/11/2023 18:12

@FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable "Doesn’t the grabby person bear any responsibility?"

Yes. Loads. But the bite has still happened.

She didn’t bite him!

OP posts:
WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 24/11/2023 23:43

BungleandGeorge · 24/11/2023 17:24

The law is clear it’s your responsibility to stop your dog from biting people. There is no justification that it’s ok because the parent didn’t ‘control’ their child. You can’t injure someone because they’ve got too close to you 😆
you say your dog snapped/ barked? Which was it?

By snapped I meant barked at him/‘snapped’ and reacted, apologies if this was misleading and gave the impression she bit. She did not and has never bit anyone. And whilst I agree it would ultimately have been ‘my fault’ if she had bitten this fool, my post wasn’t actually questioning her reaction it was asking if there is more I can do to avoid strangers touching her/am I being unreasonable by thinking HIS behaviour was out of order.

OP posts:
BalthazarTheCamel · 24/11/2023 23:38

@Catsmere 🙌👏 🐕♥️🐈♥️

Shout out to all the dogs, cats, rabbits, mice, snakes, birds, rodents etc who are keeping their owners company tonight, giving them cuddles, keeping them warm and safe. 🐾

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 24/11/2023 23:37

BalthazarTheCamel · 24/11/2023 23:11

@OCDmama

Scour the internet looking for German Shepherd ‘horror’ stories all you want🤷‍♀️ I’m sure I could equally find horror stories regarding other types of dogs, cats, spiders, fishes,ants whatever. As i I said in an earlier post, after a long lifetime around GSDs, the only dog that was ever out of control and bit me was a toy poodle.
I am well aware that some people are dog people /cat people / no pet at all people, and that’s fine, each to their own. However the blanket howling of “Muzzle it now” really annoys me, as does the criticism of the breed with little justification. If I am walking my dog on a lead in a permitted place, I am bothering no-one, but children will frequently rush up to her, trying to hug and kiss her… (she’s very fluffy) where are the parents in this situation? Allowing kids to run round doing whatever? Why is that my dogs problem?
I stand by my point… that this breed of dog is a guarding breed, a herding breed and a superb working dog for its work with all the services. They are used by the Forces, the Police, Prisons and Security primarily for their deterrent factor, with, if necessary, the speed and ability to chase and detain any offenders that escape. I see no problem with that, without them, what would happen in those situations? A human rarely catches up with another fleeing human who has a head start… the GSD can reach speeds over 20mph and will easily catch and hold the offender.
As regards out of control children, I will continue to dislike them, and sadly there’s far more of them😢

My comprehension? Aah,It’s Friday, I’m tired🤷‍♀️ Soon to be in bed, lovely dog sleeping next to me, I sleep well knowing she will protect me, guard me and look after me 100% til her very last breath. Yet to meet a human who’ll do that.

Thank you! My thoughts exactly 👏

OP posts:
WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 24/11/2023 23:36

Boomboom22 · 24/11/2023 22:31

You must be mad. How can you be so uncaring? You deliberately keep a large dangerous dog that you admit cannot be touched and is not safe. And you have baby twins. I do hope you see sense before they walk. Jesus.

How exactly am I being uncaring? By saying surely the parents have some responsibility for stopping their child approaching a stranger’s dog?

Not wanting to be touched by a stranger without warning does not make her dangerous. I have no issues with having her as a pet and having my children around, plenty (and I mean literally thousands) of families have GSD’s, so I have no time for your offensive insinuation I am somehow a bad parent.

OP posts:
Catsmere · 24/11/2023 23:33

I don’t like people who don’t like animals, simple as.

Couldn't agree more, @BalthazarTheCamel!

BalthazarTheCamel · 24/11/2023 23:21

@Boomboom22

Through my career, I have known some deeply unpleasant cruel and horrible individuals who will lie, cheat & steal their way through life. In my personal life I have also known some not-very-nice people of both sexes.
In the animal and domestic world, I have had the pleasure of knowing some wonderful pets, genuinely pleased to see you, good companions and not one liar, cheater or thief amongst them. If that makes me “odd” so be it. I don’t like people who don’t like animals, simple as.

Catsmere · 24/11/2023 23:14

I bet this loser wouldn't have lunged at her if a man had been holding her. This sounds like it's as much about sexist male entitlement as anything else.

BalthazarTheCamel · 24/11/2023 23:11

@OCDmama

Scour the internet looking for German Shepherd ‘horror’ stories all you want🤷‍♀️ I’m sure I could equally find horror stories regarding other types of dogs, cats, spiders, fishes,ants whatever. As i I said in an earlier post, after a long lifetime around GSDs, the only dog that was ever out of control and bit me was a toy poodle.
I am well aware that some people are dog people /cat people / no pet at all people, and that’s fine, each to their own. However the blanket howling of “Muzzle it now” really annoys me, as does the criticism of the breed with little justification. If I am walking my dog on a lead in a permitted place, I am bothering no-one, but children will frequently rush up to her, trying to hug and kiss her… (she’s very fluffy) where are the parents in this situation? Allowing kids to run round doing whatever? Why is that my dogs problem?
I stand by my point… that this breed of dog is a guarding breed, a herding breed and a superb working dog for its work with all the services. They are used by the Forces, the Police, Prisons and Security primarily for their deterrent factor, with, if necessary, the speed and ability to chase and detain any offenders that escape. I see no problem with that, without them, what would happen in those situations? A human rarely catches up with another fleeing human who has a head start… the GSD can reach speeds over 20mph and will easily catch and hold the offender.
As regards out of control children, I will continue to dislike them, and sadly there’s far more of them😢

My comprehension? Aah,It’s Friday, I’m tired🤷‍♀️ Soon to be in bed, lovely dog sleeping next to me, I sleep well knowing she will protect me, guard me and look after me 100% til her very last breath. Yet to meet a human who’ll do that.

whyamiawakestill · 24/11/2023 22:54

I feel your pain, I have a large breed dog that people always rush up too as he's fairly rare and very pretty.

But he's a guard breed, nervous and will do the animated air snapping if he's threatened.

I'm sick to death of idiots approaching us so I now put him in a car and drive out to countryside only for walks, no town or even village walks fit him.

We rarely meet anyone and if we do they are dog people and pop leads on or just smile and walk, it's been a great change but it's only due to humans being idiots around him.

Boomboom22 · 24/11/2023 22:47

Haha, well really humans shouldn't be exposed to these dangerous things at all but so many are selfish and just have no care.
The two usual who hate people and love dogs. Very very strange tbh. It's extremely worrying to hear people say they prefer dogs to humans and compare them to children. It really makes you worry.

vodkaredbullgirl · 24/11/2023 22:41

Lol 💥

James Bond Reaction GIF by comspace
XenoBitch · 24/11/2023 22:33

Oh, bingo card time gain. I see the usual suspect has arrived.

Boomboom22 · 24/11/2023 22:31

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 24/11/2023 15:57

As a parent I can agree I’d be mortified if my child was bitten, however ultimately it’s the parents responsibility to stop their children from approaching strangers dogs, I understand much harder if a child has special needs.

As even the most mild mannered dog with zero history of reactiveness could turn? By your logic should all dogs be muzzled all the time to avoid parents having to stop their children?

You must be mad. How can you be so uncaring? You deliberately keep a large dangerous dog that you admit cannot be touched and is not safe. And you have baby twins. I do hope you see sense before they walk. Jesus.

XenoBitch · 24/11/2023 22:28

ActDottie · 24/11/2023 21:58

We have a dog like this. She’s friendly to those she knows but will bark at those who she doesn’t.

I have her in a “nervous” harness now because I got so fed up of people assuming they could stroke her. Tbh even if I don’t have a nervous dog I’d be tempted to get one just to avoid all the repetitive small talk with people about my dogs! People just assume because I’m out with my dogs I’m happy to have long chats about them when normally it’s my work lunch break and I’m enjoying the silence!

There should be a 'nervous' vest or something for the owner to wear too. I could do with one. Grin

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 24/11/2023 22:27

Newestname002 · 24/11/2023 22:18

@BalthazarTheCamel

a woman who lived by us but never spoke to us, marched straight up to the pram and stuck both hands in to pick DS up!!!

Utterly moronic woman!

Good Dog! 🌹

I would have knocked her over. That's so scary.

Newestname002 · 24/11/2023 22:18

@BalthazarTheCamel

a woman who lived by us but never spoke to us, marched straight up to the pram and stuck both hands in to pick DS up!!!

Utterly moronic woman!

Good Dog! 🌹

ActDottie · 24/11/2023 21:58

We have a dog like this. She’s friendly to those she knows but will bark at those who she doesn’t.

I have her in a “nervous” harness now because I got so fed up of people assuming they could stroke her. Tbh even if I don’t have a nervous dog I’d be tempted to get one just to avoid all the repetitive small talk with people about my dogs! People just assume because I’m out with my dogs I’m happy to have long chats about them when normally it’s my work lunch break and I’m enjoying the silence!

Vettrianofan · 24/11/2023 21:55

CurlewKate · 24/11/2023 15:22

If you can't be sure your dog won't bite then it should be muzzled. Bathe man was a dickhead. But even dickheads shouldn't be bitten.

This. And I say that as someone who owns a giant breed dog. She just lies there and lets people pet her. Incredibly placid. The one German Shepherd I know is always barking aggressively at my dog. My own dog always looks around wondering what she's done wrong 🤣