Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To touch a strangers dog without permission then to be abusive when it barks

207 replies

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 24/11/2023 15:14

For context; we have a 4 year old female German Shepherd who is the softest, friendliest dog you can meet IF she knows you. She is not good with strangers, especially men, after some horrible experiences as a very young puppy. Typical of her breed she is loyal, loving and protective over us and our DC (6mo twins)- to note she is NEVER alone with or out of reach when around DC and has only ever been calm and affectionate towards them.

This morning I’m out walking her with a friend and have the twins in their pram, my friend pops into a shop so I’m stood outside with the pram in front of me and her sat calmly by my feet, next to the pram. Out of nowhere a young, quite big in build, man appears next to me and just lunges towards her and sticks his hand into her face. She instinctively sees this as a threat to her and us and immediately snaps at him/barks loudly. He backs off whilst quite angrily saying ‘not a friendly dog then eh?’.. so I said ‘actually she is but not with strangers and you should have asked before touching her!’ To which he raises his voice and starts saying ‘you shouldn’t have an effing dog on the streets if it isn’t effing friendly to strangers!’

At this point my friend comes out of the shop so this man storms off whilst shouting back more abuse about me being a ‘silly cow’ and having a ‘dangerous dog’..

Now I’m aware she’s a protective breed and can be intimidating to some, but I had a halter collar/lead on her and kept her by my feet/out of the way of people passing. She has zero issues around people as long as they don’t try touch her without warning. He PURPOSELY leaned across me to touch her with no warning!

AIBU to be annoyed at him? Or could I/should I have done more to avoid strangers touching her?

OP posts:
Catsmere · 25/11/2023 03:26

@OCDmama OP's dog didn't attack anyone. She barked when a large man lunged at her, shoving his hand in her face. As is entirely reasonable.

Moro93 · 25/11/2023 03:25

I have a Lab and while she’s extremely friendly and would be delighted if anyone gave her attention, I do agree that people should ask permission before touching someone else’s dog. We teach our children to always ask first.

However, I also think that if your dog is likely to react aggressively then a muzzle may be needed. Just because she hasn’t bitten anyone so far doesn’t mean she won’t in future.

So yes, that man was a mannerless dickhead. But you’re also being unreasonable and I think your dog either needs some extra training/socialising or a muzzle.

OCDmama · 25/11/2023 02:55

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 25/11/2023 00:03

I couldn’t disagree with you more, sadly plenty of people over the years have died as a result of dogs, not just GSD’s. So your argument seems to be aimed at all dogs, which isn’t helpful as we’re not all going to suddenly stop having dogs as pets. GSD’s can make amazing family pets, but I’m not here to try to convince you of that.

My argument absolutely isn't aimed at all dogs. It's aimed at being realistic. There are breeds of dogs that are meant to react and do certain things - jack Russells to catch rats, hounds for hunting, etc.

They all have their place, but for what is clearly an attack and defence dog like a German shepherd, that's in a security capacity, not the family home.

German shepherds are up there in the stats for attacks and fatalities for a reason.

OCDmama · 25/11/2023 02:48

@BalthazarTheCamel

I'm not arguing the point of what these dogs should be used for. They are clearly attack and defence dogs, who should be used in these working capacities, not family pets. The article I sent is representative of the kind of damage these working dogs can do, because of their nature. Maybe you should look up some stats regarding dog bites, including fatalities. You might notice that German shepherds are up there.

So no recognition I didn't say that it's fine for anyone to touch strangers' dogs or to muzzle them? The slagging off my out-of-control children (who I teach to love dogs, and how to approach them safely with the blessing of the owner) was really uncalled for.

Your knee-jerk reaction and need to get personal makes you a really great ambassador for GSK dog owners everywhere.

BalthazarTheCamel · 25/11/2023 01:35

Aawww, your poor little pupper. She’ll settle down in time and the anxiety will go. Well done the EB for looking after her. They do grow strong bonds together especially if they’ve had a tough start in life.
Goid on you, taking them from rescue💐

Oldsu · 25/11/2023 00:58

I have 4 Pugs and an English Bulldog the EB and one of the Pugs were rescued together I don't know what they went though but the EB is very protective of her Pug 'brother' It took her 6 months before she let the Pug out of her sight and was happy when he played with the other Pugs, I cannot take them out together, she is fine on her own and if she is with one of the others, but I cannot take her out with her 'brother' she is not vicious, will not bite or growl but she gets terribly distressed to the point of trembling and weeing herself if a stranger approaches her Pug, the little Pug himself is very friendly ( a right little tart in fact) and loves people and obviously has not been as traumatised as the EB by whatever went on before they came to us, but I will not have my EB distressed if her Pug is approached by strangers so they are walked separately, I am thinking of an animal behaviourist soon as I want them all to come on holiday with me next year and they will have to be walked together, but for now I am letting her heal in her own time.

Catsmere · 25/11/2023 00:53

@BalthazarTheCamel Thank you!

shsh6 · 25/11/2023 00:50

Even my 4 year old asks if she can touch someone's dog, of course he was in the wrong!!

Not relevant here but I do agree with pp that it works both ways though. I don't think owners should let their dogs sniff inside prams etc.

BalthazarTheCamel · 25/11/2023 00:50

@Catsmere

100% agree with your last post👏

XenoBitch · 25/11/2023 00:34

Boomboom22 · 25/11/2023 00:28

Why would a decent owner let their animal anywhere close enough to touch people?
You have major problems with distinguishing between humans who have rights and dogs who are property and must be under control.
There is never a comparison, they are not comparable. One is human, one is not.

I have had small children try to climb over me recently. Another kid came up to me and put her hands in my drink. Where were the parents? They did either did not give a shit, or noticed too late (and I know some kids have SN, but their parents should still be watching them).

You have a major problem with dogs as pets.. and it is clear in all your posts on any dog thread.

If you want to make an honest comparison between dogs and humans... tell me who is fucking up the planet.

Catsmere · 25/11/2023 00:34

Boomboom22 · 25/11/2023 00:28

Why would a decent owner let their animal anywhere close enough to touch people?
You have major problems with distinguishing between humans who have rights and dogs who are property and must be under control.
There is never a comparison, they are not comparable. One is human, one is not.

You seem to have a problem seeing dogs as living beings with feelings and the right to be treated properly. Humans are animals, just as dogs, cats, all other species are. It's our responsibility to behave. Yes, of course dogs must be trained to behave in public, and socialised to be around others - same is true of humans.

LameBorzoi · 25/11/2023 00:30

The muzzle protects my dog because it keeps people out of her space (no one wants to touch the scary muzzled dog) and it protects her from the consequences of some idiot getting bitten.

Catsmere · 25/11/2023 00:29

Muchof · 25/11/2023 00:22

The man was in the wrong of course, but so are you. You know most dogs do not feel threatened or jump to protective mode when approached by a human being, your dog sound very reactive and you need to stop making excuses for her and muzzle her until you can get these reactions under control.

He didn't merely "approach her". Read OP's description again. "Out of nowhere a young, quite big in build, man appears next to me and just lunges towards her and sticks his hand into her face." Who wouldn't feel threatened by that, dog or human?

Boomboom22 · 25/11/2023 00:28

XenoBitch · 25/11/2023 00:05

My dog is not interested in people unless they actively make an effort to give her attention.
But on MN, a dog sniffing your hand when you least expect it is seen as akin to assault and the dog should be PTS, and the owner fined.

Why would a decent owner let their animal anywhere close enough to touch people?
You have major problems with distinguishing between humans who have rights and dogs who are property and must be under control.
There is never a comparison, they are not comparable. One is human, one is not.

LameBorzoi · 25/11/2023 00:27

Op, I know it's not the dog's fault, and that person was definitely in the wrong, but in this case, I would consider a muzzle.

I have a similar dog, and I tried the vests, but people still ignore it! It's crazy.

I know she's good at warning and not biting, but if she feels like that isn't respected, she might feel the need to take it to the next level.

If you introduce a muzzle properly, and it's comfortable, dogscan learn to love them. Mine gets very excited when I get the muzzle out; it's like getting a lead out.

The other upside of wearing a muzzle is that it's the only thing that I've ever found that will stop people randomly touching my dog!

XenoBitch · 25/11/2023 00:27

OP said her dog has suffered awful things as a pup, and struggles with men. That could be something benign, or something horrific that we can't even imagine. Dogs can't talk so can't tell. We gauge their reactions to things as some sort of indicator.

Loubelle70 · 25/11/2023 00:27

Muchof · 25/11/2023 00:22

The man was in the wrong of course, but so are you. You know most dogs do not feel threatened or jump to protective mode when approached by a human being, your dog sound very reactive and you need to stop making excuses for her and muzzle her until you can get these reactions under control.

Agree

Yellowdaysaregood · 25/11/2023 00:25

Christ almighty I do come on here for the batshits cos it's funny, but fuckinell it's a dog that barked and growled a bit cos a stupid man decided to come near it without asking. My dog barks and growls at strangers until told not to, he would never hurt anyone without my say so, but if I did beware.

Muchof · 25/11/2023 00:22

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 24/11/2023 15:42

Just to be clear, she has never bitten anyone before. If she feels threatened like in this instance, she snaps/barks quite animatedly, which I appreciate given her breed can be quite scary to some. I’m confident (as confident as you can be) she would not bite someone or I’d muzzle her when in public. In response to a question about how she is around children- she actually loves children and has shown zero anxiety around any, even when I’ve introduced her to new ones (family, friends children etc in a safe way).

Edited

The man was in the wrong of course, but so are you. You know most dogs do not feel threatened or jump to protective mode when approached by a human being, your dog sound very reactive and you need to stop making excuses for her and muzzle her until you can get these reactions under control.

Hippodogamus · 25/11/2023 00:20

Agree totally

My lovely sweet little doggie snaps at people when he tied up if they try to stroke him, because he feels vulnerable and scared.

You wouldn’t go up to strangers and pat them in the head would you?

Also, dogs are not public property - available for all an sundry to do what they wish, NOT why the dog wants.

Grapefruitsquash · 25/11/2023 00:19

CosyKnits · 24/11/2023 16:08

I think there is an argument for muzzling dogs in public, especially large breeds that could do considerable damage to or even kill a person.

Ideally nobody should approach a strange dog however there are plenty of vulnerable people who might do so, or could in some other way inadvertently cause a dog to react with a bite. I think the onus is always, always on the owner of the dog to make sure they minimise the risk as much as possible e.g. by muzzling, keeping on a short lead, ensuring perfect recall if off lead etc.

I'm sorry you had that experience though, it must have been very unpleasant.

Years ago I was walking our dog (a medium long haired breed) and a group of 20ish year olds got off a bus and were walking towards us. One started running up to us, waving his arms and making high pitched barking noises. Predictably my dog starting lunging and barking at him. He stopped dead and said I had a dangerous dog and he was going to report us. Some people are idiots.

Why should I have to keep him on a muzzle because yobs don't know how to behave. My dog completely ignores everyone we see on walks (unless it's someone he knows and then he'll roll onto his back and not move until he gets a tummy scratch 🙄).

Labradeedle · 25/11/2023 00:14

MamaGhina · 24/11/2023 15:46

Agree. My kids are being taught to ask but my youngest has special needs and if he sees a fluffy dog, he might try and touch it without asking. I’d be pretty upset incandescent with rage if he was bitten.

@MamaGhina looking after the safety of your own special needs child around dogs is no-one else's responsibility but yours. If your child was bitten because you were allowing dangerous behaviour or not paying sufficient attention, that's on you not the dog owner or the dog.

WeHaveChocIcesInTheFreezer · 25/11/2023 00:12

Conkersinautumn · 24/11/2023 21:45

Yes people should always ask before approaching at dog. But barking straight away at strangers is behaviour that needs addressing, most people are strangers to your dog and she's obviously feeling threatened and stressed regularly, not much of a life for the dog

Trust me she is living the dream, very much a happy and pampered pooch. She is fine being around strangers in general (I’ve taken her to parades, markets, stopped to chat in the street to people- she just sits at my feet as she can sense ‘ah mum is calm and ok with this situation so I am too’). She just doesn’t like complete strangers literally appearing from my behind me and trying to touch her without warning. She sees this as a threat. I think I’ll be getting some ‘I’m nervous’ ‘please don’t touch me’ vests to make it clear to others, and if needs be I’ll have to muzzle her but it will a sad day as I know she’ll be scared by it and that will make her stressed regularly.

OP posts:
Catsmere · 25/11/2023 00:09

BalthazarTheCamel · 24/11/2023 23:38

@Catsmere 🙌👏 🐕♥️🐈♥️

Shout out to all the dogs, cats, rabbits, mice, snakes, birds, rodents etc who are keeping their owners company tonight, giving them cuddles, keeping them warm and safe. 🐾

My younger kitty girl is curled up beside me as I type (we're keeping out of the sun, it's a nasty sticky day here in Oz). 😻

XenoBitch · 25/11/2023 00:05

Ladybughello · 25/11/2023 00:02

Agree the man should have asked first. But what would be amazing would be if other people didn’t let their dog touch strangers without them (the owner) asking. Hopefully no overlap with the people on this thread who are enraged by a human touching a dog without asking and the large number of dog owners that think that’s absolutely fine / cute / the stranger should be delighted by the honour.

My dog is not interested in people unless they actively make an effort to give her attention.
But on MN, a dog sniffing your hand when you least expect it is seen as akin to assault and the dog should be PTS, and the owner fined.