Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the student housing system would be much better if you didn’t have to decide who to live with until the end of the first year

109 replies

Ihaveseenitallbefore · 24/11/2023 13:53

The current system (especially in certain cities such as York, Manchester, Durham) requires 18 year olds living away from home for the first time to decide who they want to live with within only a few weeks/months of knowing them. Oftentimes the early stages of uni are a time of desperation with friendships where people won’t necessarily be being their authentic selves. It seems silly that in some cities students sign up in early November with a deposit and contact and then have to wait the entire rest of the academic year to see a different side/the true colours of their housemates. Obviously the situation is different for second years and/or in the rare situation where DC knew people from before uni to live with. Ainu to think it’s silly how early ‘housing season’ comes and that the system would be far better if it wasn’t until the end of the first year that deposits were put down on houses?

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 24/11/2023 19:30

It's not just Uni housing. It extends to "normal" housing in Uni towns like York. My son got a job in York and couldn't find a flat to rent and he started looking 6 months before his job started. Some of his colleagues are still living in hostels because there are no flats to rent, not even for workers, let alone students. That's why students have to get themselves signed up so early - there's such a shortage that they'll probably not find anywhere to live if they don't. In York, some junior doctors on work placements at the hospital are having to pay mega money to live in holiday flats because they can't find residential lettings. That's the reality of the housing shortage, not just a Uni housing shortage. I genuinely don't think people realise how bad our housing shortage really is - we've too many people and not enough homes!

Jux · 24/11/2023 19:27

The LL don't get interest on the deposit, and it seems the rentor doesn't either. Who on warth might get it then? The deposit scheme itself has costs to be covered, administrators and other staff. that's where the income from your child's money goes. Way to go Blair, a lovely layer of bureaucracy entirely paid for by the young people you forced into Uni, paying thousands for yhe privilege. And the vile Blair also ensured that your kid couldn't do a degree with the OU, by forcing them to put their prices up in line with all bricks and mortar Unis as too many poorer families were opting for the OU.

So here we are. poorer families beggaring themselves because degrees are universally expensive with accommodation and maintenance (eg food) on top, all because that man thought "50% of the population" should have degrees. Nevermind that he could have strengthened apprenticeships and other training instead, and achieved a more useful educated population that way. no, the silly man decided to completely devalue the degree so that to get a job you need post grad as well ....

Sorry, my contempt is showing

Atethehalloweenchocs · 24/11/2023 19:22

Yes the whole system is terrible. I was lucky enough that we were all encouraged to stay in halls all three years and it was great. No responsibility and cheaper than it would have been to rent a house. Which would not have been as nice as where we were.

youngones1 · 24/11/2023 19:18

When I was at uni you didn't have to decide until the summer term.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/11/2023 19:08

Godefroy · 24/11/2023 19:04

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves The private halls still have accommodation available in late spring so I would take their pressure tactics with a pinch of salt. They're awful.

Oh, I don't believe any of it. There are plenty of properties still available where we live, even in the summer. My own dc is pretty clued up about this stuff because we've talked it through, but lots of students do buy it and rush in to contracts with people that they have only just met.

Godefroy · 24/11/2023 19:04

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves The private halls still have accommodation available in late spring so I would take their pressure tactics with a pinch of salt. They're awful.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/11/2023 19:01

TizerorFizz · 24/11/2023 18:52

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves Never encountered that as DDs were not going near these halls for y2. Nor were they able to get their uni hall room for y2 and didn’t want to even if the room was available to them. Companies might well do it because they know student lets are difficult to secure? You don’t have to give your email to anyone. Best not to engage. Also try and get uni owned accommodation for y1. Then you won’t get pestered.

There is an oversupply of student properties where I live, hence the competition to sign them up.

And yes, students don't have to give their email addresses to anyone, but they do, in their droves.

I am not talking about my own dc's experience here. I used to work in the field and had many meetings with letting agents to try to persuade them to take a step back.

TizerorFizz · 24/11/2023 18:52

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves Never encountered that as DDs were not going near these halls for y2. Nor were they able to get their uni hall room for y2 and didn’t want to even if the room was available to them. Companies might well do it because they know student lets are difficult to secure? You don’t have to give your email to anyone. Best not to engage. Also try and get uni owned accommodation for y1. Then you won’t get pestered.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/11/2023 18:36

TizerorFizz · 24/11/2023 18:24

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves Students don’t have contact with landlords. All landlords do is advertise a property via an agent. How do landlords create fear? Cannot say I’ve seen this when DCs were at uni. It’s their business and their choice though. Generally the well located nice flats go first and the students know this. Party flats and those out of the desirable areas hang around. It wax always like this.

Do we really want to go back to 10% going to uni? Are we really saying 3/4 should nit go because it was better in the good old days? We do have too many unis and too many degrees but the grad tax is fair enough snd the worse off gef full loans and bursaries. Many single parents reduce working hours to 16 a week to ensure DC qualify.

I'm not really talking about small, individual landlords. Most of the student properties where I live are owned by companies that also act as letting agents. They proactively target students when they first arrive, typically offering freebies such as pizza etc during freshers' week. They used to offer free beer as well but I think most, if not all, have stopped that now after repeated complaints from the uni. In exchange for the freebies, they get students to provide their email addresses and/or follow them on social media etc, and then they start putting out messages that perpetuate the idea that all of the good properties will go very quickly. It's all very carefully orchestrated.

TizerorFizz · 24/11/2023 18:24

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves Students don’t have contact with landlords. All landlords do is advertise a property via an agent. How do landlords create fear? Cannot say I’ve seen this when DCs were at uni. It’s their business and their choice though. Generally the well located nice flats go first and the students know this. Party flats and those out of the desirable areas hang around. It wax always like this.

Do we really want to go back to 10% going to uni? Are we really saying 3/4 should nit go because it was better in the good old days? We do have too many unis and too many degrees but the grad tax is fair enough snd the worse off gef full loans and bursaries. Many single parents reduce working hours to 16 a week to ensure DC qualify.

Namechangedasouting987 · 24/11/2023 17:23

FrustratedCustom · 24/11/2023 16:50

We went through the Bristol hell last year. My son and his friends had slim pickings and finally got somewhere in the Jan. Much later than most. They were told that landlords preferred girls and stem students. It was hideous.

Indeed my DS is a mixed group but they are Art based courses (and one STEM) going into 2nd year (although the 2 boys are 3rd years as dis foundation years but elsewhere).
They are a quiet group, my DS is teetotal and their private halls flat is immaculately kept. But on paper they don't look like a good bet.
The covering letter he wrote was fabulous and so now he is sending it to each application he makes to see if it helps. Its so hard at 18/19 to go through. I am taking multiple calls a day to provide support and reassurance. It's hard work for them.

Rosecoffeecup · 24/11/2023 17:06

I started uni in 2008 and it was the same then - people started viewing in the January and it whips everyone else into a frenzy. I knew a few groups that ended up falling out after signing contracts, or someone dropping out etc

FWIW I found a random group to join up with in the March or April and we had no issues finding a house

exLtEveDallas · 24/11/2023 17:02

Yep, DD has signed up today.

Last week she was having a wobble about poss dropping out, this week has signed up for a house of 6, each paying a £100 retainer to be replaced with a £400 deposit in June.

crazy bloody early, and I'm not sure even sure if she's going to be around for it. But they were all to terrified to wait - the house is a good one, and they felt pressured to sign for it as the agent took two calls about it whilst they were in the shop!

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/11/2023 16:59

RainBow725 · 24/11/2023 13:56

Yes - it's ridiculous. The student unions or universities need to sort this out. It benefits no one except the landlords. Makes me furious!

What do you want them to do, exactly?

Lots of universities and student unions already have very proactive face to face and social media campaigns to try and discourage students from renting too early because they end up dealing with all of the problems when things fall apart. The problem is that a lot of landlords are very good at creating fear about all of the good properties going, and unfortunately, a lot of students themselves help to perpetuate this idea.

Universities and student unions can only campaign and advise. They can't actually prevent students from signing contracts with private landlords.

MrsCarson · 24/11/2023 16:57

Dd is waiting to get the date for booking next years halls (yr2). So I think her uni must wait till December She's hoping to get a studio next year, it's $600 a year more than the 8 room self catering flats in the same complex, so my fingers are crossed for her.
She's in catered this year in an 8 room flat and misses breakfast most days so money builds on her card and if she doesn't use it, it is lost. She'll be having lunch on campus often to use it up.

Almondmum · 24/11/2023 16:54

Yes it is crazy early to find housemates..my DD has signed up for halls in her 2nd year..her and some friends are going to be in the same flat in private halls. It makes sense to me as her campus is in the city and so are the halls and all the places she socialises. If she wanted to rent a house she'd have to move out of the city and bus in and out.

Boomboom22 · 24/11/2023 16:52

Tbf no way in hell would I ever consider letting to a group of 4 boys
Mixed or all girls fine.
I remember well the state of houses rented by 4 boys, often rat infested with no floor to be seen.

FrustratedCustom · 24/11/2023 16:50

Namechangedasouting987 · 24/11/2023 15:22

Ds is in Bristol and the market is crazy. 20 groups vying for each half decent house/ flat.
This week he had to fill in extensive forms with his and friends details and guarantor details and write a covering letter saying why his group should be considered to get a VIEWING on a house.
He is lucky that he has a solid group of 4 to live with next year but he has done nothing for 2 weeks but house hunt. He's lost out on countless properties and despairs of finding anything that isn't over £160ppw excluding bills without water running down the walls.
Some of the places he has seen are outrageous for the price.
But then Bristol does not have enough housing so its a LL dream.
Other DS at Birmingham has found it easier and cheaper.

We went through the Bristol hell last year. My son and his friends had slim pickings and finally got somewhere in the Jan. Much later than most. They were told that landlords preferred girls and stem students. It was hideous.

annielouisa · 24/11/2023 16:49

My DGD1 has been in purpose built but private student accommodation for all of her course at Uni. There was cheaper accommodation but hers is right beside her campus and has onsite security, a gym, dance studio and laundry and study lounge. She switched flats after her 1st year but still in the same building and this was a great introduction to life away from her rural home.

PriOn1 · 24/11/2023 16:45

I was horrified when my children went to university. When I attended, back in the 80s, all first years were guaranteed a place in halls if they wanted it. Almost all were single rooms. A cleaner came round daily. There was food provided on a half board basis. You left home, but were basically looked after, all for a price that was covered by the grant, leaving a bit over for buying books and a few extras. After first year, most people were in flats, which you rented out for the university year and didn’t pay for over the long summer break.

By the time my children went, there didn’t seem to be much accommodation available at all. They all had to rush round estate agents, looking for flats, which had to be rented for the entire year, even though there were three months when they were not needed.

And the degrees they got at the end were barely worth the paper they were written on. My daughter more or less gave up in her last year as people who made no effort were still passing and the whole thing seemed both demoralizing and pointless. Whoever thought it was a good idea to expand university attendance, remove grants for less well-off students and turn universities into businesses with customers has done nobody any favours at all.

coffeeaddict77 · 24/11/2023 16:44

I'm not sure that it has anything to do with landlords being greedy. They don't gain financially by renting early. They will fo it to secure their business for the following year. Who wouldn't? The students are necessarily panicking either. They are being pragmatic because they know that if they don't secure accommodation for the following year they may end up with something less nice.

LIZS · 24/11/2023 16:44

Goatymum · 24/11/2023 16:41

London is completely different and From friends with kids at London unis they do sign in the summer term.

Likewise in Scotland. Leases are not finite and only require 28 days' notice, so most accommodation becomes available towards the end of the academic year.

SgtJuneAckland · 24/11/2023 16:42

I went to Durham and we signed up in February, managed to get two houses next door to each other too in the city centre viaduct area, as there was a larger group of us wanting to live together. It was always expensive though

Goatymum · 24/11/2023 16:41

London is completely different and From friends with kids at London unis they do sign in the summer term.

Goatymum · 24/11/2023 16:37

Totally, it’s absolutely ridiculous!
dd started uni in covid times and a few of them cobbled together a house of 6 - so you had
dd and flatmate - good friends from the start
a friend of DD’s from home
a couple of others they vaguely knew and a randomer who came in when Simone later dropped out.
pretty rubbish!!
ds is in first year now - there seems to be 4 of them wanting to move in together - but ds having some major MH issues so not even sure what’s going to happen but still needs to secure a house! They haven’t viewed any & im urging him to get in with it as it’s in a v popular uni city!! They do say up to Feb is ok, but that’s still early.
In ‘my day’ it was definitely at end of spring term and friendships were cemented a bit more. I lived with 2 halls friends and one of their friends.
To me it’s greedy landlords and panicking students, the unis have no say in it.