Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the student housing system would be much better if you didn’t have to decide who to live with until the end of the first year

109 replies

Ihaveseenitallbefore · 24/11/2023 13:53

The current system (especially in certain cities such as York, Manchester, Durham) requires 18 year olds living away from home for the first time to decide who they want to live with within only a few weeks/months of knowing them. Oftentimes the early stages of uni are a time of desperation with friendships where people won’t necessarily be being their authentic selves. It seems silly that in some cities students sign up in early November with a deposit and contact and then have to wait the entire rest of the academic year to see a different side/the true colours of their housemates. Obviously the situation is different for second years and/or in the rare situation where DC knew people from before uni to live with. Ainu to think it’s silly how early ‘housing season’ comes and that the system would be far better if it wasn’t until the end of the first year that deposits were put down on houses?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AlannaOfTrebond · 27/11/2023 10:16

You are not being unreasonable in that the first term is way to early.

I am a student landlord and over the past ten years the date students have been looking or accommodation has moved from late January to November in my city. This is despite the Uni running a campaign for students urging them to wait until the second semester before signing up for a house as there are plenty available.

I think it is a combination of factors driving it though. There is a big discrepancy in the standard of houses available and second year students who may have ended up in a house they aren't happy with are determined to find a better one for their third year, so start looking earlier. This creates a ripple effect and everyone starts looking earlier and earlier.

Some landlords would always jump the gun and start advertising early to get their houses let, which didn't help.

Last year I started getting enquiries in November, I thought this was way too early and also had other obligations to attend to during December, so stuck to my guns and waited until January to start advertising. When previously I would have been swamped with enquiries I got hardly any as most groups had already signed up for a house. When the uni online housing portal opened and I normally would have had 50 phone calls in a day, I had none for three days. All this is a long way of saying, that you can't entirely blame the landlords, it's a two way street.

I would be much happier if letting season happened in the summer term when students are more certain of their plans, even January as it was previously would be better. How to make this happen I don't know as the uni campaigns seem to fall of deaf ears.

BeyondMyWits · 27/11/2023 09:16

WheresMyLife · 26/11/2023 20:44

It’s all wrong. My daughter got into Cambridge and has accommodation for all 3 years and we have to pay for only 30 weeks.
I obviously wanted her to get in but a lot of my reasoning was this security.

Does that mean they have to leave during holiday periods? My Dds love their rented accommodation as they don't have to come home for all of the holidays, they are out at parties for Xmas, new year etc, so come home for a few days, but still have their shared house.

Elastica23 · 27/11/2023 08:08

I never got a place in halls and shared with strangers straight away.

coffeeaddict77 · 27/11/2023 08:07

mathanxiety · 27/11/2023 01:26

I can't imagine someone being so opposed to the room sharing even applying, true.

But for those who are motivated to apply but have misgivings about sharing, I wonder what they think of it all and how the process of getting used to it plays out. Bearing in mind that bathrooms are usually communal, with curtained shower cubicles - one per floor - and very few dorm rooms have an en suite.

Plenty of students in the UK share bathrooms too so I doubt that would be a problem. Very few UK students go to US univerities anyway. Those that do may well have gone to boarding schools so are used to room sharing.

Boomboom22 · 27/11/2023 07:17

mathanxiety · 27/11/2023 01:26

I can't imagine someone being so opposed to the room sharing even applying, true.

But for those who are motivated to apply but have misgivings about sharing, I wonder what they think of it all and how the process of getting used to it plays out. Bearing in mind that bathrooms are usually communal, with curtained shower cubicles - one per floor - and very few dorm rooms have an en suite.

Surely this is way out of date? Maybe 20 years ago, like we had more sharing then too.

mathanxiety · 27/11/2023 01:26

coffeeaddict77 · 26/11/2023 19:19

Presumably they wouldn't go to an American university if they didn't want to share a room.

I can't imagine someone being so opposed to the room sharing even applying, true.

But for those who are motivated to apply but have misgivings about sharing, I wonder what they think of it all and how the process of getting used to it plays out. Bearing in mind that bathrooms are usually communal, with curtained shower cubicles - one per floor - and very few dorm rooms have an en suite.

TizerorFizz · 26/11/2023 22:50

Well most cannot get the security so well done your DS for acing it. It pays to be extra smart in more ways than one.

In the meantime, the 1/4 million who don’t get to Oxbridge struggle on. I do know how difficult it is for many. We have to acknowledge wealthy unis have the endowments and substantial
income streams to provide accommodation BUT have continued to limit their intake to remain highly elite. It’s no coincidence numbers remain static so accommodation is available. Unfortunately most students don’t hit the jackpot and never get a chance of cheap halls for three years - however much we implore our dc to get it. To those that have the most brains, even more gets given it seems.

WheresMyLife · 26/11/2023 20:44

It’s all wrong. My daughter got into Cambridge and has accommodation for all 3 years and we have to pay for only 30 weeks.
I obviously wanted her to get in but a lot of my reasoning was this security.

coffeeaddict77 · 26/11/2023 20:07

closingdownsale · 26/11/2023 20:01

YANBU. it also makes finding a rental property for non-students too as so many properties are 'reserved' in advance, plus I think having to decide so early on creates the groups of 8 students looking to rent big family homes, because they feel obliged to find a house with their entire student halla flatmates.

I don't think they do feel obliged to look for houses for their entire hall flatmates!

closingdownsale · 26/11/2023 20:01

YANBU. it also makes finding a rental property for non-students too as so many properties are 'reserved' in advance, plus I think having to decide so early on creates the groups of 8 students looking to rent big family homes, because they feel obliged to find a house with their entire student halla flatmates.

bluebeck · 26/11/2023 19:56

My DS is currently studying at a US uni (Columbia) and doesn’t have to share, so I don’t think that’s a blanket situation.

coffeeaddict77 · 26/11/2023 19:19

mathanxiety · 26/11/2023 18:59

I wonder how British students manage when they go to an American university. It must be quite a shock Grin

Presumably they wouldn't go to an American university if they didn't want to share a room.

TizerorFizz · 26/11/2023 19:15

@mathanxiety So few go to the USA though! They clearly are ok with it. Plenty have been to boarding schools where sharing isn’t an issue for them. It’s what they are used to. Many many dc hate sharing though. That’s why we don’t have dorms any more. Do you know of any?

We have huge numbers of divorced people wanting two homes for their families. We have students from abroad who bring their families. We have students who won’t share. We have many areas of land we won’t build on and look at the price of land in London! It’s difficult to know where building can take place.

The loan for staying at home is generous when compared to renting accommodation. We perhaps do need to wean ourselves off going away to uni but commuting isn’t possible for everyone. Uni for thousands and thousands every year is hardly a housing triumph. Empty nests (larger houses) at home and nowhere to live at uni. We have limited resources but we just want more and more from it because DC wont share.

coffeeaddict77 · 26/11/2023 19:05

Islandgirl68 · 25/11/2023 19:00

That is nuts. How do they know they are not going to drop out or even fail 1st year and not go back. In Scotland as far as I know, they start looking for 2nd year flat in late spring. Landlords don't dictate like that. How do landlords know whether their flat will be free. The students might want to stay if they are happy. Or the kids might decide to come home and commute if possible. They don't really make that decision till towards the end if first year.

Given they don't know if they are going to fail until July and even then there are usually retakes during the summer, even if students waited until late spring to find a house they would be in the same position.

mathanxiety · 26/11/2023 19:03

Wrt flats for nine months a year - American universities often run summer programmes (sports, music, etc) and the dorms get used for accommodation and paid for by the people participating in the programmes.

mathanxiety · 26/11/2023 18:59

TizerorFizz · 25/11/2023 23:29

@mathanxiety The Brits have an aversion to sharing unless they have been to boarding school. It’s a class thing! Many students won’t even share a bathroom! That’s the reason there are no dorms!

I wonder how British students manage when they go to an American university. It must be quite a shock Grin

TizerorFizz · 26/11/2023 17:40

@Badbadbunny Thats not tied housing. Tied housing was rent free but often wages were altered forwards to pay for it. It’s gone because it wasn’t a good use of money. It only helped a few and some who didn’t need it. My mother had a room in a nurses block. It was standard procedure but wages were reduced to pay for it. Housing Associations and key worker housing have replaced it. Again though, not enough built. That’s the insurmountable problem.

tpa · 26/11/2023 17:29

my db ended up in a horrible house share, bullied and being made to pay for stuff he never used or touched

it is a shit situation, not sure of the answer though

Badbadbunny · 26/11/2023 15:24

@TizerorFizz

Who will pay for tied housing now?

It's an investment, not a cost. House prices have proved to rise in value over time faster than other forms of investments. If they're rented out to staff at market value, they should easy cover their costs. After all, we have millions of private landlords and lots of commercial/corporate landlords, all making profits on both rental income and capital gains, so not at all sure why organisations aren't jumping on the band wagon.

Look at all the pension schemes and institutional investors, and even local councils who've been shovelling money into commercial property portfolios for the last few decades. Residential property has the potential to out perform commercial, especially now that city centre offices/retail seem to be heading for a massive slump.

Shame that Brown bottled it and didn't go ahead with his plan to allow pension schemes to buy residential property really - that would have allowed pension schemes to complete with private landlords for residential properties.

PuttingDownRoots · 26/11/2023 15:05

Ask Military families for their opinions on their provided accommodation! (Which we do pay for, its not free).

TizerorFizz · 26/11/2023 14:57

Who will pay for tied housing now? We don’t have enough money for the services let alone perks worth thousands each year. Plus are other professions not worthy? We need care assistants, engineers, etc. What about them?

It’s no good keep saying build, build, build. Where??? We have restrictions. Families need accommodation first. Why do we need flats for 9 months occupancy? I’d rather we spent money on family housing. If you want unis to spend more, encourage foreign students or pay higher fees.

London is very different. Students are a smaller percentage of the population there and spread out very widely.

WrongSwanson · 26/11/2023 14:48

Agreed. I ended up anorexic and suicidal partly as a result of an entirely unsuitable house share. If I had till Easter (say) I don't think I would have ended up in that mess

BeyondMyWits · 26/11/2023 14:46

Badbadbunny · 26/11/2023 11:51

Employers should do the same. There was a time when there were nurses' accommodation blocks next to hospitals, or a floor of dorms on the top floor of police stations, ideal for "single" young nurses, policemen etc. Fire stations had "proper" flats too, sometimes big enough for families! Ideal for younger staff until they got enough cash together for deposits for their own homes, or for transient workers until they found their "niche" to settle down. Go back further and mill owners built entire streets of "2 up 2 down" for their workers to live in, and of course, farmers usually provided homes for their workers/labourers, etc.

It would massively help if employers would get back to doing that. My son has just started working at one of the UK's biggest insurance firms in a Northern city - some of his colleagues are living in hostels because they can't find flats to live in, it's not cost, they literally can't even get viewings as demand is so high! He'd got a job offer at a different firm, a more "old fashioned" one, who owned a number of properties which they let out to their new starters if needed - all market rates, not discounted, but they were in good locations for their head office and only available to staff. I can't understand why more big organisations don't do that - it's a valid investment if they're charging market rates for rent etc - it's a no brainer really. I think organisations have just lost sight of the severe problems facing younger staff these days - they're run typically by managers in their 50s who didn't face to same shortages we have today, so probably don't understand the problem!

Rose tinted glasses. When we lived in tied accommodation for my dad's job and he decided to leave my mum and move in with his other woman, we were made homeless. Just like that.

hellsBells246 · 26/11/2023 13:17

I totally agree! Dd has to do this in Nottingham and it seems ridiculous.

Badbadbunny · 26/11/2023 11:51

DuesToTheDirt · 26/11/2023 11:13

Yes, the universities should really step up here and make more provision for accommodation - buy or build some themselves, and retain control over it.

Employers should do the same. There was a time when there were nurses' accommodation blocks next to hospitals, or a floor of dorms on the top floor of police stations, ideal for "single" young nurses, policemen etc. Fire stations had "proper" flats too, sometimes big enough for families! Ideal for younger staff until they got enough cash together for deposits for their own homes, or for transient workers until they found their "niche" to settle down. Go back further and mill owners built entire streets of "2 up 2 down" for their workers to live in, and of course, farmers usually provided homes for their workers/labourers, etc.

It would massively help if employers would get back to doing that. My son has just started working at one of the UK's biggest insurance firms in a Northern city - some of his colleagues are living in hostels because they can't find flats to live in, it's not cost, they literally can't even get viewings as demand is so high! He'd got a job offer at a different firm, a more "old fashioned" one, who owned a number of properties which they let out to their new starters if needed - all market rates, not discounted, but they were in good locations for their head office and only available to staff. I can't understand why more big organisations don't do that - it's a valid investment if they're charging market rates for rent etc - it's a no brainer really. I think organisations have just lost sight of the severe problems facing younger staff these days - they're run typically by managers in their 50s who didn't face to same shortages we have today, so probably don't understand the problem!