Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask you not to take your frustrations out at the system failures of the NHS on the clinician?

141 replies

IncognitoPanda · 24/11/2023 09:50

It’s been a long week. I loved my job but honestly it’s got so tiring being moaned at about things I cannot control. I want to help you with your problem, that’s why I am here. But the sad truth is that in an over stretched service under immense pressure the limited time I have to help you is not best used with you complaining.
I know how many months you have waited for this appointment, I have your referral letter. I know you’re unhappy about it. I am too, I would much rather have seen you when it first occurred rather than you suffering and worrying until now.
I know how long you’ve sat in the waiting area, I can see your check in time. If we don’t have enough staff we will be delayed in seeing you. I will always apologise if the delay is excessive but please don’t delay me even further by spending ten minutes complaining about it.
I know you’re scared, I really do and I completely empathise. But if I tell you it’s a three month wait for a given test, it’s not because I want you to wait 3 months, it’s because that’s how long the queue is. Getting angry at me doesn’t help, and doesn’t give me any ability to speed up that time frame. I could be evasive and not give any clue as to how long your wait is but that wouldn’t help and would just put more pressure on my administrative colleagues when you are chasing for an appointment that they cannot provide.
I know you may have seen the last patient leave my room ten minutes before I call you through, that’s because I have had to complete their paperwork and take time to read your referral and relevant history. I look rude if I have my back to you to read my screens, so it’s important I take a few minutes to understand why you are here before I invite you through. The systems are so disjointed I may have to view multiple software platforms (all of which are slow to open due to the poor it infrastructure). Even doing this I won’t know your full history so please understand if I ask questions that you may have had to answer before.
I know you may have seen me disappear from clinic for 10 minutes. I can assure you I won’t have been off to the coffee shop. Instead I am probably addressing a critical issue that would further delay the clinic if not remedied.
I know you would like to see the clinician each visit. I get it, as I like to see the progress of patients. However if we all had individual waiting lists, the system would become even more unfair as the wait times would vary between clinician. We do talk, we do leave good notes for each other and you will be looked after. Sadly I cannot promise I will see you myself next time.

It’s the desire to help people that keeps most of us in the profession, it’s certainly not the salary or working conditions. Please believe me that I am just as fed up of the system as you.
YABU - it’s a British right to moan
YANBU- I get it

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 25/11/2023 18:20

‘In France everyone has medical insurance where they are seen much much quick than people on the nhs.

It also works out cheaper as there is more competition and gives people more of incentive to train to become medical professionals’

I used to live in France, and I am in regular contact with friends who are still there ( they are French). Recently they have been saying that there has been a serious decline in the availability of medical appointments, and in the standard of treatment. Of course this is anecdotal, but it is interesting.

When I lived there, the local hospital staff often had a banner up on the roundabout complaining about working hours and pay. I wonder whether healthcare in developed countries is just groaning under the sight of increased expectations, brought about by the continual development of more complex treatments for more complex conditions.

Zebedee55 · 25/11/2023 17:55

It's a case of taking the middle ground. The NHS is a shitstorm. It's broken, and we know that.

But, any complaints are best taken up with whoever is actually responsible for what's gone wrong.

It's pointless getting stroppy with the first person in front of you - they are often as powerless as the patient.

TheFeistyFeminist · 25/11/2023 17:45

@MadamWho no absolutely not. If they asked me what I do for a living it came up, otherwise I'm a faceless cog in the background. I've watched treatment given to others in the room and am in a what's app group with my patient cohort and my experience is exactly the same as the others.

KidsDr · 25/11/2023 17:33

OceanStorm · 25/11/2023 12:09

In France everyone has medical insurance where they are seen much much quick than people on the nhs.

It also works out cheaper as there is more competition and gives people more of incentive to train to become medical professionals

But this is the point. You've identified that the system works better in France because of there being more clinicians - because they have better incentives and presumably fewer or no perverse training bottlenecks.

Where I disagree with you (if I understand correctly) is that this is a result of the system in France being insurance funded. It is a result of political will. We could achieve the same in a publicly funded system, in my opinion, if the political will existed.

That said, I'm not opposed to a well regulated insurance funded system with safeguards for the most vulnerable. But it wouldn't fix the problems in UK healthcare unless accompanied by the political will and strategy to train and retain more staff.

What we are seeing currently with NHS services that are being privatised (they remain taxpayer funded but are contracted to private enterprise) broadly speaking is that they become more expensive, less effective and less safe. People largely don't understand that this is what is happening to their local NHS services because once privatised they are still using an NHS badge.

For the record France spends a little more on healthcare per capita than we do, their healthcare is not cheaper.

infor · 25/11/2023 15:01

MoserRothOrangeandAlmond · 25/11/2023 08:26

@Goatymum one off seizures they don't do anything about....apparently anyone can have 1 seizure. Once it's 2 then they do. That's when my husband was in hospital for a week with aspirate pneumonia.
(He didn't see a neurologist then just started on anti seizure drugs)
Then for us it was another 3 tonic clonic seizures (dislocating both shoulders each time) and daily focal seizures before seeing a neurologist 6 months later.
9 months down the line he's had an EEG but in the meantime another seizure had x2 surgeries on his shoulder because it didn't go back in place...and it's fractured.

I really hope you get seen too quicker!

For those affected by seizures, I recently learned from a seizure-prone relative that Camphor in Tiger Balm and some other 'warming' creams can cause seizures.
Many folks are also sensitive to essential oils which can have neurlogical side-effects.

OceanStorm · 25/11/2023 12:09

KidsDr · 25/11/2023 01:00

Consider for example, your BUPA insurance or whatever, that allows you to see a specialist of your choice within a few weeks. Why can you see them within a few weeks? Because other people don't have BUPA, don't want to or can't afford to spend privately, and so they wait much longer to be seen, probably by the same person, on the NHS at no personal cost.

Consider, then, if publicly funded healthcare were to cease to exist altogether. So that that option which has kept people off the private waiting lists, ceases to exist. There are still the same number of specialists, if nothing else changes - if the training bottlenecks and poor incentives remain in place - there will be no additional specialists. If the bottlenecks and incentives change, it still takes 10-15 years plus to train more (and also begs the question why the training bottlenecks and incentives can't just be improved within a publicly funded system).

So either:

A} You continue to pay for private health insurance or upfront for healthcare, but so does everybody else and it no longer gets you seen within a short time frame or gives you access to higher quality than average services. You are all now paying to wait around as long for a similar quality of care that used to be available in a cheaper, publicly funded system.

B) A competitive marketplace develops between insurers / providers, such that you can still be eg seen within a short time frame but you'll have to pay a hell of a lot more for it, seeing as healthcare at no personal cost is no longer part of the marketplace. Receiving high quality care on an urgent timescale becomes the domain of the super rich, and/or ordinary people have to bankrupt themselves to access it. Ordinary people have to limit the healthcare they receive to what is personally affordable.

C) Other people don't compete with you to be seen because they simply can't afford to do so. So maybe your waiting list doesn't increase as much but this is because large sections of society don't access healthcare at all.

D) Public, free at the point of care healthcare does exist in some capacity; but it is limited or means tested and/or delivers a poorer service. So that if you are lower income you can access second tier care, if you are middle or higher income, you can choose to pay a consistently high price in insurance or take on the risk of personal liability for healthcare costs - whilst accessing a higher tier healthcare that isn't much better, and is very possibly worse in terms of a higher proportion of treatments being inaccessible on cost grounds, to the previously existing publicly funded healthcare. And is delivered by the same people.

Or some combination of the above.

Does any of this sound maybe, familiar?

Edited

In France everyone has medical insurance where they are seen much much quick than people on the nhs.

It also works out cheaper as there is more competition and gives people more of incentive to train to become medical professionals

babbi · 25/11/2023 09:59

amoobaa · 24/11/2023 10:07

I work in the NHS and I’d never dream of telling my patients that it’s their responsibility to figure out, understand and accept the system that’s letting them down.

Our patients didn’t choose to be in need of care… We chose to work in the NHS, it’s part of our job to listen to patients concerns and feedback about the system we chose to be a part of.

I understand your post is helping to explain the problems you’re facing and I agree it’s good to be transparent and honest with patients… and you probably need to write it all down because you’re exhausted and frustrated. But it’s not the job of our patients to quietly accept the chronic lack of funding and catastrophic consequences this is having on the quality of Care.

If there’s one thing that should never be taken from our patients, it’s their right to speak up and advocate for themselves, especially when the system is letting them down and ESPECIALLY when (E.g. mental health services) they find themselves being retraumatised by a service that is meant to be supporting them with their trauma.

As someone else said, just because you’re managing to remain empathic and engaged… doesn’t mean all staff are. I’ve seen some outstanding care and people going far beyond the call of duty… but I have also seen horrific standards of care and people who simply shouldn’t be allowed anywhere near a service that provides care.

All that being said, I’m grateful you’re still in the system and I despair at the thought you may leave, along with many other excellent clinicians. It’s utterly depressing.

@amoobaa

Thank you for such an honest post , I applaud you for calling out what people are not saying .
its almost like patients are not allowed to criticise the “ Marvellous NHS “ as it sinks to completely unacceptable levels of care .

I have seen some truly despicable treatment of family members over the last 18 months and NOTHING excuses it .

One family member was being sent home to die as there was nothing could be done . I got involved, lost my cool , long story short they were then referred to a specialist unit and are doing extremely well .

I would urge all to be very much aware of how many patients are being fobbed off or list in the system and advocate for themselves or others .

CountryStore · 25/11/2023 09:19

I've never felt hatred towards a patient, though, and I don't think I've ever known a colleague to, either

CountryStore · 25/11/2023 09:18

I work in the NHS. I don't mind patients complaining to me, and I completely understand why they want/need to, but if they took that time to put in a formal complaint, or speak to PALS, or email the chief executive, then it might be more productive. But I also understand why they might not have the time and energy to do so 🤷‍♀️

MoserRothOrangeandAlmond · 25/11/2023 08:26

@Goatymum one off seizures they don't do anything about....apparently anyone can have 1 seizure. Once it's 2 then they do. That's when my husband was in hospital for a week with aspirate pneumonia.
(He didn't see a neurologist then just started on anti seizure drugs)
Then for us it was another 3 tonic clonic seizures (dislocating both shoulders each time) and daily focal seizures before seeing a neurologist 6 months later.
9 months down the line he's had an EEG but in the meantime another seizure had x2 surgeries on his shoulder because it didn't go back in place...and it's fractured.

I really hope you get seen too quicker!

crew2022 · 25/11/2023 05:07

Unfortunately there are some stuff in the NHS who are not empathetic or caring. Some staff are lazy. It's hardly surprising that in such a large organisation there are some staff who don't share the values and work ethic of others. And some have limited capability and perform poorly.
But overall it's a poorly designed system that is no longer fit for purpose and so everyone in it is impacted. Health care professionals, admin support, facilities and maintenance, managers and patients.
The strong performers who have support and a good manager will survive, same as patients with support and resources will probably negotiate it better.
Basically the government needs to get a grip of it. Then people like the OP will stay and patients will get a good service.

dumdededdumdum · 25/11/2023 04:42

Sorry - missed work that should say

dumdededdumdum · 25/11/2023 04:41

For patients, medical appointments are anxious time. Sick people are stressed and upset. Sickness is shit. Add missed word onto that. The system is incomprehensible and the clinician is the only person / conduit they have to discuss their thoughts on their care. You see a gp. They wash their hands of it/ have no time/ you get a letter with no information for the hospital then months later attend.

Clinicians, staff and patients all get institutionalised and not in the greatest ways.

metellaestinatrio · 25/11/2023 03:33

MadamWho · 24/11/2023 23:12

Do you think working for the NHS altered any way in which you were treated ?

I've heard many say it's a closed shop these days.

I've certainly seen preferencial treatment given to NHS staff who turn up at A and E, and day case surgery settings, I wonder of others have seen this.

Yes, absolutely. A good friend who is an NHS consultant (in a different medical specialism, nothing to do with gynae/babies) recently had her first baby. She told me that she got noticeably better treatment at antenatal appointments when she turned up straight from her own clinic wearing her badge and NHS lanyard than when she came in her “civvies”.

CremeEggSupremacy · 25/11/2023 01:06

I work in the NHS and I pay to go private for GP appointments now. I can deal with waiting. I can deal with seeing you disappear off somewhere for 10 minutes, because I'm not an idiot and know it's for something useful. I can deal with being told tests will take a while, because I know that's the system. But just as you'd like more empathetic patients and for us not to take our frustrations with the system out on you...clinicians need to be told the same, and GP receptionists in particular. I would rather pay £100 for a private GP appointment now than have to deal with a hideously rude and unhelpful receptionist and then a GP who is either also rude, dismissive, or refuses to properly investigate what I'm there for. And because I too work in the NHS I fully know that everyone is burnt out and it's awful for you too - but this kind of thing is give and take, and in the last few years I personally feel our staff are ruder than ever, lacking compassion, and often doing a half arsed job.

KidsDr · 25/11/2023 01:00

Consider for example, your BUPA insurance or whatever, that allows you to see a specialist of your choice within a few weeks. Why can you see them within a few weeks? Because other people don't have BUPA, don't want to or can't afford to spend privately, and so they wait much longer to be seen, probably by the same person, on the NHS at no personal cost.

Consider, then, if publicly funded healthcare were to cease to exist altogether. So that that option which has kept people off the private waiting lists, ceases to exist. There are still the same number of specialists, if nothing else changes - if the training bottlenecks and poor incentives remain in place - there will be no additional specialists. If the bottlenecks and incentives change, it still takes 10-15 years plus to train more (and also begs the question why the training bottlenecks and incentives can't just be improved within a publicly funded system).

So either:

A} You continue to pay for private health insurance or upfront for healthcare, but so does everybody else and it no longer gets you seen within a short time frame or gives you access to higher quality than average services. You are all now paying to wait around as long for a similar quality of care that used to be available in a cheaper, publicly funded system.

B) A competitive marketplace develops between insurers / providers, such that you can still be eg seen within a short time frame but you'll have to pay a hell of a lot more for it, seeing as healthcare at no personal cost is no longer part of the marketplace. Receiving high quality care on an urgent timescale becomes the domain of the super rich, and/or ordinary people have to bankrupt themselves to access it. Ordinary people have to limit the healthcare they receive to what is personally affordable.

C) Other people don't compete with you to be seen because they simply can't afford to do so. So maybe your waiting list doesn't increase as much but this is because large sections of society don't access healthcare at all.

D) Public, free at the point of care healthcare does exist in some capacity; but it is limited or means tested and/or delivers a poorer service. So that if you are lower income you can access second tier care, if you are middle or higher income, you can choose to pay a consistently high price in insurance or take on the risk of personal liability for healthcare costs - whilst accessing a higher tier healthcare that isn't much better, and is very possibly worse in terms of a higher proportion of treatments being inaccessible on cost grounds, to the previously existing publicly funded healthcare. And is delivered by the same people.

Or some combination of the above.

Does any of this sound maybe, familiar?

infor · 25/11/2023 00:58

@KidsDr Thank you for your comments. Across Europe, every country seems to have reduced its number of beds. Whether this is by mothballing establishments, or as we have done, selling off large parts of the estate, I don't know. I do know that the hospital my DC was born in (now flats), built as an isolation hospital for Scarlet Fever would have been very useful for Covid patients had it not already been flogged off.
As I understand it, Holland has a very low waste system, with a single, monopoly provider that negotiates a flat rate paid by all of the population based upon their income and which is scrutinised and approved in much the same way as DHSC gets its funding.
I was in a position to propose a Dutch approach to care homes to a large number of public sector leaders - they were not receptive. My experience came from seeing my father, a dementia patient in Holland treated exceptionally well in essentially an office block, seven floors, each with communal areas and thirty individual bedrooms. The grounds were adequate but far smaller than three private or six council-owned facilities would have been and in addition to 24/7 doctors and nurses on-site, it was within sight of the local general hospital.

infor · 25/11/2023 00:42

@JFT If anyone listened to me on arrival at A&E, I wouldn't have needed to be admitted at all on the last three occasions. Finally, someone has approved a significant stock of antibiotics, so that I can self-administer when a flare-up next occurs.
My work involves designing and implementing process flows to save money and avoid risk. It is very demoralising to find nobody interested in simple things that would keep patients safer and help shorten patient stays - particularly when the costs would be no more than £5-£10 per room or ward and would last for years and the savings could be enormous - in human and financial terms.
It seems bizarre that in Formula 1, yacht racing and professional cycling, enormous sums are invested to improve efficiency by tiny percentages toward a greater goal, but in an organisation with an initial budget this financial year amounting to £5,500 per second, it's not viewed as worthwhile.

JFT · 25/11/2023 00:35

Jumpingthruhoops · 25/11/2023 00:31

Agree. The one and only time I've needed the NHS, I encountered staff who frankly couldn't have given less of a shit. Without health insurance, I would have been totally fucked (that's an understatement!).

And I hear what you say about being 'retraumatised', I was thinking just today that I should have put in a complaint about one establishment (that I can't believe has the audacity to call itself a hospital!) But if I'm honest, I don't want to relive the experience.

If you're going to complain, do it quickly, and effectively to the correct body (usually a Stage 1 complaint to the complaints dept of the relevant hospital).

Reason I say this is because they will then either not reply -or- reply absolute garbage. At this point you can go up a stage to Stage 2, ditto. That leaves you free to approach the Ombudsman (who in the history of time to not uphold complaints, however they are obliged to log and record them, forever!). If you don't do all that within a reasonable time, your complaint is dismissed as being out of time.

Other idea is ring around no win no fee medical injury solicitors.

Jumpingthruhoops · 25/11/2023 00:31

amoobaa · 24/11/2023 10:07

I work in the NHS and I’d never dream of telling my patients that it’s their responsibility to figure out, understand and accept the system that’s letting them down.

Our patients didn’t choose to be in need of care… We chose to work in the NHS, it’s part of our job to listen to patients concerns and feedback about the system we chose to be a part of.

I understand your post is helping to explain the problems you’re facing and I agree it’s good to be transparent and honest with patients… and you probably need to write it all down because you’re exhausted and frustrated. But it’s not the job of our patients to quietly accept the chronic lack of funding and catastrophic consequences this is having on the quality of Care.

If there’s one thing that should never be taken from our patients, it’s their right to speak up and advocate for themselves, especially when the system is letting them down and ESPECIALLY when (E.g. mental health services) they find themselves being retraumatised by a service that is meant to be supporting them with their trauma.

As someone else said, just because you’re managing to remain empathic and engaged… doesn’t mean all staff are. I’ve seen some outstanding care and people going far beyond the call of duty… but I have also seen horrific standards of care and people who simply shouldn’t be allowed anywhere near a service that provides care.

All that being said, I’m grateful you’re still in the system and I despair at the thought you may leave, along with many other excellent clinicians. It’s utterly depressing.

Agree. The one and only time I've needed the NHS, I encountered staff who frankly couldn't have given less of a shit. Without health insurance, I would have been totally fucked (that's an understatement!).

And I hear what you say about being 'retraumatised', I was thinking just today that I should have put in a complaint about one establishment (that I can't believe has the audacity to call itself a hospital!) But if I'm honest, I don't want to relive the experience.

JFT · 25/11/2023 00:29

It's widely considered the Labour Party will win the next election and they've made no promises or commitments to 'save' the NHS so I guess we can be assured that it's going to be heavily deconstructed into different 'pay for' services at some point.

KidsDr · 25/11/2023 00:24

I think there is a real problem with the perception that private healthcare can step in and fix things as a viable alternative to the NHS.

There are not enough clinicians in this country. If the NHS was abolished tomorrow that wouldn't change, the pool of available clinicians (including the irresponsible, callous, rude, inept ones etc) would remain exactly the same.

The discrepancy between demand to see a given clinician or service and the capacity / availability of that clinician or service would remain more or less exactly the same. Waiting times on average, would remain exactly the same. Provision of emergency services, exactly the same. Additional qualified staff would not spring up from the earth the moment private finance was available to pay (presumably more) for them.

And that would be the case for the foreseeable long term. The difference would be solely as to the balance of funding from the public purse, insurers and private pockets.

Regardless of how you feel about public vs private, healthcare provision is in a state of precipitous decline with no quick solutions available.

The same is broadly true in many other nations because of the inflationary nature of social and healthcare costs. To address this adequately required long term planning and funding provision, not only within healthcare itself but much more broadly in public services and social care - which hasn't happened. This needed to start decades ago, and instead the reverse has happened (a shrinking of the social state, collapse of social care, rise in inequality, and long term attrition of qualified staff whilst demand has continued to rise).

Even the best government right now would have a very hard time fixing where we are, even over the course of decades. Attempts at top down reorganisation of the NHS to address it's many failures and inefficiencies have largely made things worse.

We're in a right state and I personally do not think a public funding structure is really the root cause nor would moving away from this solve much. I think we would have many of the same problems, of not worse problems with a privately funded healthcare service - only it would additionally cost a lot more per capita and this is bourne out both in 1) per capita comparisons of cost between the NHS and comparable private healthcare models and 2) comparisons of how NHS funded services perform and how much they cost before and after they are handed over to private enterprise (largely much worse and at greater expense - has happened to many NHS services including many ambulance services).

JFT · 25/11/2023 00:22

Floralsofa · 25/11/2023 00:18

This is the problem isn't it? I'm having major surgery next week. My surgeon did something horrific and unspeakable in her private clinic to the point she must have paid millions to settle the lawsuit. It's a sh*tshow whichever way up.

JFT · 25/11/2023 00:08

infor · 24/11/2023 23:50

@JFT @LemonPeonies
In my most recent stay as an in-patient, 'presenteeism' caused more problems than it fixed. Three staff (nurse and HCAs) were moaning loudly about wanting to take their break because they were 'starving'.
Ten feet away, a man in urgent need of an operation requiring general anaesthetic, who had spent three days in a chair in the Emergency Department and who had been 'nil by mouth' for more than 12 hours and was two hours overdue for his op, didn't appreciate the continual reminders of food - or the request to remain nil by mouth until the following day when the postponed op might be able to take place.
None of the three were doing anything, other than waiting for someone to send them on their break. They could have been collating details of the prescriptions for their dozen patients, they didn't with the consequence that we all received our meds late.

I hear you. A lot of the systems don't seem to work. If they can even be called systems.

One thing that could help is that the average person is keen to gain agency over their own healthcare and putting some systems in place that help people gain direct access to the care they need could probably save time / money, as opposed to being the most terrifying concept in the world according to GPs who are constantly gate-keeping us.