Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Europen governments need to respond to immigration?

564 replies

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 06:45

So the Netherlands is going to have a far right government.
Sweden has moved to the right.
Finland has shut its borders.
Countries that have traditionally been liberal are hardening and irrespective of the many issues listed its to do with immigration.

Ireland has seen violent protests last night following a series of stabbings.
In the UK we obviously had Brexit.

I think governments need to start responding to voters feelings on immigration as if they don't we will continue to see a general slide to the right in Europe, when actually these countries aren't right wing: it feels like a single issue is distorting the entire political landscape?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
MidnightOnceMore · 26/11/2023 00:03

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 23:54

I have but it’s also the snide aggression so 🤷‍♂️ read up on what successful countries do instead.

I would understand more if you had a plan you were keen on and could tell us all about it but no it’s just head in the sand.

You haven't, you know you haven't and I know you haven't Grin

There is no aggression, I have just pointed out that you can't explain how the Rwanda policy would work.

bombastix · 25/11/2023 23:59

BroccoliniFloret · 25/11/2023 23:46

These problems are to do with existing poverty and social inequality more than they are immigration IMHO

Yea. And if we don't address it we will have our own Geert Wilders and all these distinctions we draw about migration will get down to more basic ideas like skin colour and religion.

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 23:54

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 23:51

You haven't explained anything.

If you had an explanation you would just explain it to me. It is not that you are not interested in explaining it to me, it is that you can't.

I have but it’s also the snide aggression so 🤷‍♂️ read up on what successful countries do instead.

I would understand more if you had a plan you were keen on and could tell us all about it but no it’s just head in the sand.

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 23:51

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 23:44

Bloody hell it’s just too frustrating reading these posts continuously so I’m not that interested in explaining to you over and over

I know you feel great with it all but you won’t avoid migration pressures with insults and carry on.

It’s a reality. Some countries will be better placed others not.

Edited

You haven't explained anything.

If you had an explanation you would just explain it to me. It is not that you are not interested in explaining it to me, it is that you can't.

Citylady88 · 25/11/2023 23:46

Ireland had a handful, less than 200, right wing 'protestors' and about three times that many scumbags who looted, robbed & burned the capital. The only thing we need to do with that lot is send them to prison. Why do you think UK, Belgium, Netherlands etc have people from other countries ? Because the Brits, the Belgians, the Dutch, the French etc went there first. Europe is built on the wealth extracted from other nations. The people who are here now are much kinder than we were when invaded their countries

BroccoliniFloret · 25/11/2023 23:46

These problems are to do with existing poverty and social inequality more than they are immigration IMHO

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 23:44

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 23:41

There is just no detail in what you say.

I understand you want to believe in the simple stories this snake oil government is selling, but there is no credibility unless a plan can be explained.

Bloody hell it’s just too frustrating reading these posts continuously so I’m not that interested in explaining to you over and over

I know you feel great with it all but you won’t avoid migration pressures with insults and carry on.

It’s a reality. Some countries will be better placed others not.

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 23:41

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 23:39

An alternative location is the only real option within current international law but we may well see a change to that as more countries face the same migration pressures

There is just no detail in what you say.

I understand you want to believe in the simple stories this snake oil government is selling, but there is no credibility unless a plan can be explained.

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 23:39

An alternative location is the only real option within current international law but we may well see a change to that as more countries face the same migration pressures

bombastix · 25/11/2023 23:38

The big issue is poverty, and the inequality the UK has. The Conservatives do not address it. Labour must to address the tensions of when people feel they cannot live well. I do remember real overt racists, the National Front, violent anti semitism (not just a few marches) and they always do better when times are difficult economically. Braverman I heartily disliked because she is an excellent example of someone who thinks, quite incorrectly, that her position protects her from these issues. Or that throwing asylum seekers under the bus will mean the wider population will not notice much larger legal migration. They will.

The UK has imo told itself self congratulatory fibs about its multicultural and diversity as a neutral thing. It's not all Paddington 2 in the UK.

But actually, look at terrorism and it is the white far right you need to worry about in the UK. Okay yes, you tell yourself they are racist nutters who are not mainstream. But racist nutters are frequently desperate to be that.

Eventually, unless we do address living standards a really palatable suit wearing, suitably well educated white racialist will come and capture a lot of people. We see it in France and the Netherlands, those sort of voters would not put a fag papers difference between an immigrant or a person who has been resident in their country legally and arrived many years ago.

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 23:38

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 23:35

I already have. I’m not repeating it again.

It doesn’t need to be there anyway, and probably can’t be, but another location can be done legally.

It’s not ‘mysterious’ maybe have a read up on what other countries do successfully.

You really haven't. You have said nothing about how the scheme would deter. You have simply said it will deter.

If you don't understand how the scheme would work, how can you have such faith in it?

And which are these other countries you claim have it sorted and, importantly, how do they compare to the UK situation?

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 23:35

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 23:31

I see, you can't explain how the Rwanda scheme - affecting just 0.01% of those coming via the channel - would have worked.

So you have now changed the subject to what 'has worked' in some mysterious place. Although whatever that is presumably has significant differences to the UK context.

It feels like, when pushed, that you know the Rwanda scheme was hot air and nothing more.

I already have. I’m not repeating it again.

It doesn’t need to be there anyway, and probably can’t be, but another location can be done legally.

It’s not ‘mysterious’ maybe have a read up on what other countries do successfully.

TempestTost · 25/11/2023 23:35

I don't quite understand your reasons with that either, Eastern?

People are more likely to die in the boat crossing than be sent to Rwanda, so I can't see it being a deterent in any direct way. If someone is willing to risk drowning they aren't going to balk at a small chance of being sent to Rwanda.

In any case Rwanda is a corrupt country, or rather, the government is corrupt.

Perhaps some other scheme to take people elsewhere would work. Though I hate really to say "work" because it is likely to be pretty much what we see already in long term refugee camps in other places, which is not a pretty sight. Especially when they exist as generational communities.

But ultimately, there are many shit places in the world, and no nation is really in a position to either fix that, or to take all those people in.

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 23:31

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 23:26

I know what has worked. Do you?

I don’t care what it is but I do know that most people are incredibly head in the sand over it all.

You can’t answer and if you think about what countries will face you’d probably want to.

I see, you can't explain how the Rwanda scheme - affecting just 0.01% of those coming via the channel - would have worked.

So you have now changed the subject to what 'has worked' in some mysterious place. Although whatever that is presumably has significant differences to the UK context.

It feels like, when pushed, that you know the Rwanda scheme was hot air and nothing more.

TempestTost · 25/11/2023 23:26

AdamRyan · 25/11/2023 22:59

I've said on lots of threads.
I think Rwanda is a bonkers waste of money. I'd build closer relationships with Europe and tackle the traffickers instead.
But the real issue for me is legal migration. And that basically requires some investment to reduce e.g the government could start paying universities rather than making them dependent on overseas students to exist. This government won't do that. So we need a change of government.

Universities are fucked because of the push for them to accept such a large proportion of the population. They increased their size, and particularly their infrastructure, so they require a large number of students to continue to attend to pay for it.

But population decline factors into that, but maybe more the reality that we don't need 50% of people to be university educated, and in fact it's a waste of money and productivity to be parking them in university for four years. Plus it's caused degree inflation and negatively affected teaching content.

I think students who really belong in universities should be fully funded, but it needs to be far fewer than it is now. They are probably going to have to shrink which will be hard.

That being said, universities are one area where a lot of international movement is common and probably important to their functioning.

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 23:26

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 23:22

And you can't answer the questions about how the Rwanda policy would work.

You have a deep personal faith in it, I can see. But faith is not an explanation.

Only 0.01% of those crossing the channel would have even got sent to Rwanda. How would that deter people? The traffickers will simply say 'The British have a pointless scheme to send a tiny number to Rwanda, but 99.9% of you won't be affected.'

I know what has worked. Do you?

I don’t care what it is but I do know that most people are incredibly head in the sand over it all.

You can’t answer and if you think about what countries will face you’d probably want to.

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 23:22

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 23:15

I bet you are. You can’t answer

Like I said I’m used to another immigration policy not just the U.K., and what has been implemented works so well not even Labor will touch it. It’s bi partisan.

All this handwringing decades after they did it is bizarre. Especially when most know what is incoming

And you can't answer the questions about how the Rwanda policy would work.

You have a deep personal faith in it, I can see. But faith is not an explanation.

Only 0.01% of those crossing the channel would have even got sent to Rwanda. How would that deter people? The traffickers will simply say 'The British have a pointless scheme to send a tiny number to Rwanda, but 99.9% of you won't be affected.'

Livelovebehappy · 25/11/2023 23:21

jemenfous37 · 24/11/2023 07:01

it is not just immigration that is causing the rise of the far right. What a simplistc view
Add ignornce, racism and a myriad of other economic and social reasons, then come back.
What do you suggesr those fleeing death and destruction do while all your right-wing governments are closing their borders

And quotes like this are the reason people feel that they can’t voice their concerns about immigration. Not everyone who thinks uncontrolled immigration is a bad thing is racist. You’re the one trying to be simplistic by putting everyone in the same box, because it suits your narrative, and is lazy thinking. Fortunately more people are now finding their voice.

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 23:15

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 23:12

Oh, I'm ignoring that. I'd rather talk about why the Rwanda scheme is total bollocks.

You are so certain it will work, which I find unusual - you seem to really believe in this government.

I bet you are. You can’t answer

Like I said I’m used to another immigration policy not just the U.K., and what has been implemented works so well not even Labor will touch it. It’s bi partisan.

All this handwringing decades after they did it is bizarre. Especially when most know what is incoming

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 23:12

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 23:09

Any idea what you want to see yet?

Oh, I'm ignoring that. I'd rather talk about why the Rwanda scheme is total bollocks.

You are so certain it will work, which I find unusual - you seem to really believe in this government.

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 23:11

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 22:26

The stories part is traffickers informing people what to say btw. Your attempt at superiority is grating for sure but you still will lag behind countries that have sorted it.

That will get harder as migration pressures get greater, there’s no getting around that.

You didn’t answer, what is it you actually want to see?

What does this the stories part is traffickers informing people what to say btw mean please? I am trying but struggling to follow what you are posting.

Why do you think, given all you say about increased migration to come, that a tiny scheme like Rwanda will make any difference?

The two halves of what you say don't seem to fit together 1) this is a massive and growing issue 2) a tiny intervention like Rwanda will fix it.

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 23:09

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 23:07

You have just explained why the Rwanda scheme is a fairy story for the gullible: There’s a constant supply of people ready to pick up that profitable business and it will get greater

Any idea what you want to see yet?

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 23:08

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 23:07

You have just explained why the Rwanda scheme is a fairy story for the gullible: There’s a constant supply of people ready to pick up that profitable business and it will get greater

And yet other countries have managed it….

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 23:07

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 23:02

I'd build closer relationships with Europe and tackle the traffickers instead

What does this actually mean in practise? I think you’ll find it very hard to ‘tackle the traffickers’

If it were that easy the Med crossing wouldn’t be an increasing issue either

There’s a constant supply of people ready to pick up that profitable business and it will get greater

You have just explained why the Rwanda scheme is a fairy story for the gullible: There’s a constant supply of people ready to pick up that profitable business and it will get greater

Pomonas · 25/11/2023 23:06

Agree. Numbers are rising sharply and some people are still on denial on the serious consequences of unsustainable number of immigrants would be bringing to Europe. Funny that the same people also want excellent services, NHS for all and social housing for all. They may need to be reminded that land is finite. More people need to be net tax payers to keep services going and diversity of skills and experience is needed when considering immigration.