Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Europen governments need to respond to immigration?

564 replies

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 06:45

So the Netherlands is going to have a far right government.
Sweden has moved to the right.
Finland has shut its borders.
Countries that have traditionally been liberal are hardening and irrespective of the many issues listed its to do with immigration.

Ireland has seen violent protests last night following a series of stabbings.
In the UK we obviously had Brexit.

I think governments need to start responding to voters feelings on immigration as if they don't we will continue to see a general slide to the right in Europe, when actually these countries aren't right wing: it feels like a single issue is distorting the entire political landscape?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
bombastix · 26/11/2023 09:30

36k after tax is not peanuts. Do people mean gross?

Anyway, I think the problems with universal credit and top up of wages are clear. It's a kind of capitalist social policy that means employers don't pay decent wages and many people who could be properly economic productive aren't.

There are some difficult truths out there. One is future employment at all given AI. The others are the growth of special educational needs and how these children will thrive as adults in a society that is older and sicker with less tax contributions than 25 years ago. All of this speaks of economic decline. It's the reason immigration continues as it does even if the Tory Party does not say it. It does explain the last 13 years better rather than wondering why they haven't done anything. They have; they have greatly expanded immigration because a lot of the UK population are not very productive.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 26/11/2023 09:12

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 07:12

@JaneDSE9
What would our countries have to gain from such a visa scheme though?

One of the things I don't get is often immigration is championed as being needed "to support growth". But what if we just stopped growing? Wouldn't that also be better for the climate?

The growth is a Ponzi scheme anyway, we all get older, presumably we’ll need exponential levels of immigration.

Pomonas · 26/11/2023 09:10

When you start reading people suggesting older people give up their hard earn houses and space for immigrants you must be terrified. Remember there would be politicians that would support this idea. Those who are always supporting conflicts in foreign lands like they were of our making. Expropriating has happened in other countries that have now been eroded as civilised places to totalitarianism. Be careful what you wish for.

DowningStreetParty · 26/11/2023 09:07

Very much agree with you about dangers of learning (university or not) being seen only as an economic tool. That’s highly relevant to immigration issues. Accessible learning is a key part of social cohesiveness, mutual understanding and social mobility and enabling better life chances and innovation. That positive spiral benefits everyone! culturally and financially.

The sneery anti intellectual culture of the Tories (like Michael Gove’s unendingly shocking ‘we’ve heard enough from experts’ over the accurate evidence for Remain over Brexit) keeps the UK locked into hostility, prejudice, lower productivity and lack of innovation. Less hope and joy and more division and poverty. It’s basically a Tory policy pledge now.

Flowers4me · 26/11/2023 08:51

Where I live the local adult education system has been decimated and college funding has been reduced so there just isn't the number of courses/training opportunities that there once was. I've had personal experience of this with my daughter who struggled to find any opportunities to get back to studies. And then when we did find something, they squeezed all the SEND students into one programme at college. They couldn't afford to run another class and there was nowhere else for these students to go. This had implications for the wellbeing of some of those students including my daughter. I've also worked in the sector and have witnessed the decline myself. Meanwhile the big city university has expanded its student accommodation to build deluxe suites for students from abroad and they're also rolling out an expansive redevelopment of their green spaces. It all looks very nice and I don't have an issue with students from abroad but I think it is unfair to not also have opportunities for local people who may not be university level but who could learn and achieve and contribute to society in other ways. In my experience community education brings people together, it has the potential to build bridges and improve wellbeing but sadly this government is too fixated on learning being an economic tool.

EasternStandard · 26/11/2023 08:35

The issues to do with increased migration are hitting many economies. As events in Dublin show, or politics in Sweden, Germany, the Netherlands, Italy, probably others

I can only see it getting more pronounced as numbers increase

Winter2020 · 26/11/2023 08:31

Another idea for care/hospitals/farming - why don't the government build some lovely housing estates that are subsidised/tied accommodation for those working full time in accredited jobs (and perhaps a year after they leave to find time to move on).

I live in a house built 100 years ago as accommodation for factory workers in the midlands and people walked (yes walked) from Wales for the house/job combo that it allowed them.

But if you do this for the private sector you are choosing to simply subsidise the unrealistic wages they are offering at the expense of the tax payer.

When it was difficult to get truckers in the pandemic they were offered 5k golder hellos and good wages, when programming skills are in high demand jobs are advertised 60k plus. When you can't get carers for 11 quid an hour the attitude is screw them - we'll ship them in from abroad.

Care (and hospitality/ and farming) needs to pay what it costs to find people willing to do the job and afford them a decent standard of living- and yes the days of a 20p cabbage on the back of exploited workers are rightly over.

Peablockfeathers · 26/11/2023 08:25

We are in a low wage economy, it's still beneficial for some to work here as there are more opportunities and due to the conversion rate, but as an example a junior doctor wouldn't qualify for a skilled worker visa as they don't earn enough (it's £40k I believe) which is ludicrous. Skilled jobs lag behind comparable countries even taking into account varying living costs, and having the government subsidise wages of staff of multi million pound companies as they don't pay enough to live off of would rightly be viewed as ludicrous elsewhere.

Edit to add workers should be paid more, not saying they shouldn't be topped up with the system as it currently is!

Walkaround · 26/11/2023 08:12

Sauerkrautsandwich · 26/11/2023 07:31

*If it's so bountiful why are so many families on minimum wage with kids on universal credit?
🤷 No idea but 36k income after tax isn't exactly "peanuts".

I agree about difficult shifts though.

36k after tax is peanuts if trying to compete for housing, fund transport costs for antisocial hours, pay childcare costs (if you can find available, affordable childcare), etc. It is extremely expensive to have a job that requires long, antisocial hours with little to no control over shifts and to have unpaid caring responsibilities of your own to juggle.

Winter2020 · 26/11/2023 08:11

Sauerkrautsandwich · 26/11/2023 07:31

*If it's so bountiful why are so many families on minimum wage with kids on universal credit?
🤷 No idea but 36k income after tax isn't exactly "peanuts".

I agree about difficult shifts though.

Let's be clear that the 36K income you are quoting is what you have calculated for 2 people working full time. Not one.

When they just announced the national insurance cut the average wage for one person was quoted as 35,400k

So you need two full time care workers to earn the average British wage. Yet you are trying to tell me that the wages are fine?

Seymour5 · 26/11/2023 08:09

Sauerkrautsandwich · 26/11/2023 06:53

It's like 21k - 18k after tax etc. Two adult household on FT NMW brings in 36k.
How is that peanuts?

It isn't. But fewer and fewer people live in two working adult households. As long as a woman can have a child and know that she will get priority for housing and extra benefits there's little incentive to find low paid work.

The cycle of children growing up in families with a poor work ethic continues. The resentment against everything and anything grows and we have scenes like the recent one in Dublin.

Sauerkrautsandwich · 26/11/2023 07:31

*If it's so bountiful why are so many families on minimum wage with kids on universal credit?
🤷 No idea but 36k income after tax isn't exactly "peanuts".

I agree about difficult shifts though.

Winter2020 · 26/11/2023 07:25

Sauerkrautsandwich · 26/11/2023 06:53

It's like 21k - 18k after tax etc. Two adult household on FT NMW brings in 36k.
How is that peanuts?

Yes minimum wage - the lowest amount you can earn. If it's so bountiful why are so many families on minimum wage with kids on universal credit?

As a care worker new in your workplace you will usually be expected to be available 24/7 or even on day shifts 7am-10pm for a rolling rota of shifts.

That doesn't exactly lend itself to two people working full time if you have kids. Even if you can afford childcare it is impossible to source for anti-social hours so you are unlikely to get two full timers when care jobs are involved if they have kids.

Retail/hospitality/education are much more likely to give you fixed, family friendly hours. Care needs to pay the premium that the workers deserve for the anti-social working hours and uncertainty of rotas. Or employers could try and be more open to mornings/afternoons/evenings or weekends only fixed rotas - so the pay would still be crap but at least the hours would be more compatible with family life.

You will clearly get enough care workers if you pay a decent rate deserving of the demands of the job but some people would rather say "oh it's impossible to recruit" (paying minimum wage) and get people to come over from abroad who don't have better options.

Winter2020 · 26/11/2023 06:54

lljkk · 24/11/2023 08:34

Truss wanted to lift many immigration caps to improve economic growth. Now, the labour shortage in UK remains high, especially social & health workers but science and finance too, jobs often met by imported skilled workers. UK Universities are kept afloat by overseas student fees. Political Fix podcast pointed out that when people are asked specifically which type of immigrants they don't want... the only specifics are irregular and bankers (both tiny % of total).

In meantime, many older adults living in big houses they needed when they had many children; now long grown up, still in their big houses, a practice defended robustly on a recent MN thread. So there's your choice. Let the old people stay in their big houses and their triple-lock pensions, while everyone gets under-staffed hospitals and care homes and patchy social-care, the financial sector which drives UK economy gets snubbed and economy gets throttled too, universities contract in size and run up huge debts. We get to have all that just so we can "keep immigration down". It's what voters want, I guess.

Braverman supported the Truss agenda.

"Let the old people stay in their big houses"...

In their houses that they own you mean?

So it's only immigrants and asylum seekers where "be kind" applies. If you are old we can confiscate your paid for assets? When you get down to the nitty gritty leftists are sometimes not as kind as they make out are they?

Sauerkrautsandwich · 26/11/2023 06:53

It's like 21k - 18k after tax etc. Two adult household on FT NMW brings in 36k.
How is that peanuts?

Winter2020 · 26/11/2023 06:45

Libertyy · 24/11/2023 08:40

I don’t get why the white British people who complain about the immigrants taking all the jobs can’t fill the vacancies for care homes and picking fruit etc?

Because it's often back breaking work for peanuts- and in the case of fruit picking you can be expected to live on-site in substandard accommodation.

Most people seem to agree that work should pay enough to live on. Most ageee that benefits should not be propping up underpayinng employers. I can guarantee the vast majority of single income full time care workers, if they have children, will be on universal credit.

If working in hospitals, care homes, hospitality or picking fruit paid enough to put a roof over your families head, feed them and keep them warm, get transport to work/school and have a bit left over for other essentials and a tiny amount for luxuries the jobs would be filled. Reality is the wage wouldn't touch the side of doing this and lots of people - with kids anyway - find themselves better off (in money and quality of life) working a few hours and topping up with universal credit or not working at all.

Sauerkrautsandwich · 26/11/2023 05:17

Rwanda plan as is wouldn't deter imo.
Gaddafi 2.0 would 🤷

I asked earlier if anyone knows what was holding the Med crossings of before.
Gaddafi et al🤷

TempestTost · 26/11/2023 02:34

BroccoliniFloret · 25/11/2023 23:46

These problems are to do with existing poverty and social inequality more than they are immigration IMHO

Yes and no?

Social democracies with a lot of socialist supports typically have small, relatively stable populations, and there is an expectation of almost everyone working. For example mums, there may be good leave arrangements but what you don't see, except among the few ultra wealthy, are women who stay home with their kids. High taxes require high productivity.

But once you start upping the portion of the population who can't work or need extra support, or erode social pressures that make people feel obligated to work, or create social divisions where people don't have a lot of trust for each other, you start to undermine that kind of system.I think it's really worth thinking about how you get a lot of social integration where there is a constant high population that is newcomers. Are there good examples of this anywhere historically?

It's worth watching Trevor Phillips film, where he addresses some of these questions. It was a number of years ago but I think it is in some ways looking ahead to these same issues. It used to be on youtube, but I can't seem to find it there now - I'll see if it's somewhere else.

EasternStandard · 26/11/2023 00:43

MidnightOnceMore · 26/11/2023 00:39

It isn't that you won't - you clearly can't.

Honestly it’s just you. You’re too off putting. I’m hoping you’ll get the message.. Google is that way ->

MidnightOnceMore · 26/11/2023 00:39

EasternStandard · 26/11/2023 00:32

Of course 🙌

All your solutions have been grand. Anyway stop getting so annoyed I won’t ’explain to you’ it’s worse than a child. Go be free… Learn from other reading

It isn't that you won't - you clearly can't.

EasternStandard · 26/11/2023 00:32

MidnightOnceMore · 26/11/2023 00:28

Grin I just wondered if you could explain how it would work. And you can't. And that's absolutely fine.

I have already read up on it enough to be able to tell you haven't a clue what you're talking about.

Of course 🙌

All your solutions have been grand. Anyway stop getting so annoyed I won’t ’explain to you’ it’s worse than a child. Go be free… Learn from other reading

MidnightOnceMore · 26/11/2023 00:28

EasternStandard · 26/11/2023 00:19

Oh ok that’s nice Confused I’m pleased for you

Really you can do it without me. You can learn by yourself. Google and read 😀

Big old internet there for you. Good luck.

Grin I just wondered if you could explain how it would work. And you can't. And that's absolutely fine.

I have already read up on it enough to be able to tell you haven't a clue what you're talking about.

EasternStandard · 26/11/2023 00:19

MidnightOnceMore · 26/11/2023 00:15

I love the way you post @EasternStandard , you're really funny Grin

Do I not know much? I can tell you know loads, it's a shame you're not going to tell us all. You could really educate people with all your knowledge.

Oh ok that’s nice Confused I’m pleased for you

Really you can do it without me. You can learn by yourself. Google and read 😀

Big old internet there for you. Good luck.

MidnightOnceMore · 26/11/2023 00:15

EasternStandard · 26/11/2023 00:05

Honestly you don’t know much, when it comes to other systems

Google instead of asking me over and over. Read away 🙌

I love the way you post @EasternStandard , you're really funny Grin

Do I not know much? I can tell you know loads, it's a shame you're not going to tell us all. You could really educate people with all your knowledge.

EasternStandard · 26/11/2023 00:05

MidnightOnceMore · 26/11/2023 00:03

You haven't, you know you haven't and I know you haven't Grin

There is no aggression, I have just pointed out that you can't explain how the Rwanda policy would work.

Honestly you don’t know much, when it comes to other systems

Google instead of asking me over and over. Read away 🙌