Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Europen governments need to respond to immigration?

564 replies

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 06:45

So the Netherlands is going to have a far right government.
Sweden has moved to the right.
Finland has shut its borders.
Countries that have traditionally been liberal are hardening and irrespective of the many issues listed its to do with immigration.

Ireland has seen violent protests last night following a series of stabbings.
In the UK we obviously had Brexit.

I think governments need to start responding to voters feelings on immigration as if they don't we will continue to see a general slide to the right in Europe, when actually these countries aren't right wing: it feels like a single issue is distorting the entire political landscape?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
TempestTost · 26/11/2023 21:36

bombastix · 26/11/2023 20:57

There are other problems. A lot of people of working age are not in employment. The number one reason is long term sickness, then caring responsibilities and looking after family.

Something like 10 percent of the working age population of the U.K. are not working. And they are dominantly UK citizens, not immigrants.

There is a lot going on with this. The caring responsibilities issue is something that we have never really addressed with the rise over the past 50 years of women in the workforce. The fact is that all those women who left work when they married were not sitting home doing nothing, they were doing work that needs to be done. Childcare obviously, eldercare, community work, all that now has to be managed some other way. And some can't easily be monetized, evenif we want. Anyone with elder family members knows that even if they are in a good care placement, there are all kinds of time consuming things that require help. Banking, dealing with medical decisions, and also really just companionship.

And the issue of shit wages is real.

At the same time - I know people hate it when someone says there is a poor work ethic for local people, but unfortunately I think there is some truth to it. Poeple who come in to work from elsewhere often deal with conditions they shouldn't have to. But there are also things like like shared accommodations, or working shifts that aren't very nice, or jobs that involve a somewhat itinerant lifestyle. A lot more people used to work in these kinds of jobs, and now simply wont. Many people used to continue to work with health issues which they now take leave for.

Like a lot of things, you want protections for people who need it, but you also get this culture of entitlement that grows up. A lot of young people don't work, for example. My sister hires a lot of university grads, many have never had a job before! And it isn't that there are no jobs for young people where I live - they struggle to get indigenous students into jobs, places like MacDonalds seem to be staffed largely by immigrant teenagers. (And these jobs don't pay badly either, for a teenager or student situation. My library clerks, who are grown adults, make the same or even a bit less.)

bombastix · 26/11/2023 20:57

There are other problems. A lot of people of working age are not in employment. The number one reason is long term sickness, then caring responsibilities and looking after family.

Something like 10 percent of the working age population of the U.K. are not working. And they are dominantly UK citizens, not immigrants.

Livelovebehappy · 26/11/2023 20:31

I know it’s been said time and time again, but the simple answer is that the UK cannot accommodate any more immigrants. No housing - we having waiting lists of 2, 3, 4 years and more for people already living here. NHS on its knees - our health system cannot cope with the people we already have - it’s broken, absolutely crap. Schools - too many children, and not enough school places - class sizes having to be increased, where we then have one teacher teaching a class of 40. No wonder so many children are being failed by the current education system. The only area where we are lacking is in the job market - low skilled vacancies not being filled, but that’s because the Government are too slack with getting people into jobs - many are happy to stay on benefits indefinitely.

Winter2020 · 26/11/2023 19:34

bombastix · 26/11/2023 11:37

Gross or net. 36k after tax is not a bad income.

That was the after tax income quoted for 2 care workers working full time.

Recent publicity about national insurance quoted the average British wage as £35,400. I think that was pre-tax but safe to say a care worker (working full time) earns no where near an average wage.

Notanevillandlord · 26/11/2023 17:22

Winter2020 · 26/11/2023 08:31

Another idea for care/hospitals/farming - why don't the government build some lovely housing estates that are subsidised/tied accommodation for those working full time in accredited jobs (and perhaps a year after they leave to find time to move on).

I live in a house built 100 years ago as accommodation for factory workers in the midlands and people walked (yes walked) from Wales for the house/job combo that it allowed them.

But if you do this for the private sector you are choosing to simply subsidise the unrealistic wages they are offering at the expense of the tax payer.

When it was difficult to get truckers in the pandemic they were offered 5k golder hellos and good wages, when programming skills are in high demand jobs are advertised 60k plus. When you can't get carers for 11 quid an hour the attitude is screw them - we'll ship them in from abroad.

Care (and hospitality/ and farming) needs to pay what it costs to find people willing to do the job and afford them a decent standard of living- and yes the days of a 20p cabbage on the back of exploited workers are rightly over.

@Winter2020 You speak a lot of sense.

Employers, and the NHS, have all got drunk on cheap EU labour and rather than pay employees a decent living wage they're just importing people from 3rd world countries paying them a minimum wage which is too low for some jobs where evening work, shift work, weekend work etc is involved.

I have mixed feelings about minimum wage. On the one hand it ensures people aren't being paid "slave" wages but on the other hand employers don't want to pay more than the minimum wage.

I was looking on Indeed at jobs and employers are paying MW to retail staff, bar staff, care home staff, office work, warehouse staff. How come all these jobs pay the same hourly rate? There's no variation.

Anyway I digress. Greedy employers have a lot to answer for.

User135644 · 26/11/2023 15:50

The numbers are too high coming in but they're also too low going out. A lot more used to emigrate, Brexit has made that harder and we no longer have freedom of movement. That's what Brexiters thought would just mean low immigration.

Add to the fact that people live a lot longer now (and many of the millions who've poured in over recent decades will now be ageing themselves/no loner working) and it's a perfect storm. There's far too many in the UK as it is. Where does it stop? 80 million? 90 million? 100? We can't just concrete over the countryside indefinitely to build more housing estates or new towns.

Myfabby · 26/11/2023 15:33

Notaflippinclue · 26/11/2023 12:44

Also first hand - African nurse brought over shocked at cost of accommodation obviously not explained to her beforehand - then bring partner and children then get pregnant. How does this contribute to our NHS.

presumably she goes back to work after maternity like many mum's do?

Was she supposed to come, work her bones off, not have any more children and then be sent back at the age of retirement or at the hint of 'too many foreigners?. Not too far from slavery that scenario

Notanevillandlord · 26/11/2023 14:28

@RosaGallica yes I agree. It really is a double edged sword. People are saying we need more workers but this impacts housing/schools for the people already living here. But if we offer accommodation, not free, then yes it looks grossly unfair.

I don't think British people are lazy at all. I just wonder if they've lost out in the job market at the lower end of the scale due to not being able to/not wanting to work the required hours.

For eg.another real life one. I have a tenant from an EU country - not Eastern Europe - who works as a security guard. It's night work - so unsociable hours. My tenant lives here alone and their grown up family lives in their country of origin.

Most of my Polish and Romanian tenants have done really well for themselves here and have all bought their own properties. Not many of my 75 enquiries were from E Europe.

One thing UK people don't take into consideration is that some of the EU who have done well here don't want more arriving. My Polish tenant, who was a builder, wanted Brexit because they were already cheesed off that the Romanians were undercutting them and didn't want any more competition.

Immigration is a very complex issue.

Flowers4me · 26/11/2023 14:21

bombastix · 26/11/2023 09:30

36k after tax is not peanuts. Do people mean gross?

Anyway, I think the problems with universal credit and top up of wages are clear. It's a kind of capitalist social policy that means employers don't pay decent wages and many people who could be properly economic productive aren't.

There are some difficult truths out there. One is future employment at all given AI. The others are the growth of special educational needs and how these children will thrive as adults in a society that is older and sicker with less tax contributions than 25 years ago. All of this speaks of economic decline. It's the reason immigration continues as it does even if the Tory Party does not say it. It does explain the last 13 years better rather than wondering why they haven't done anything. They have; they have greatly expanded immigration because a lot of the UK population are not very productive.

The growth of SEND is in part due to improved accessibility to diagnostic services though in recent years that is becoming harder. In my day, there was limited understanding of the autism spectrum or ADHD for example but we still had people with SEND; we just didn't know about them. We should be proud that we have developed our understanding of these issues and that people can now have a better understanding of themselves. In the long run this can help prevent more serious problems developing. Unfortunately our education system is a one-size fits all and it fails many people particularly those who learn differently and in a non-academic way. And this fails us as a society. We need all types of people to function healthily and that's not happening. We're leaving too many people behind particularly those with SEND and disabilities and that causes us problems and extra costs as we try and deal with the inevitable mental health problems and social isolation that can result. The uncomfortable truth is the Britain is an ableist nation that does not give a stuff about its disabled citizens and in so doing deprives itself of a wide range of unique talent that could enhance our nation.

RosaGallica · 26/11/2023 13:12

Sauerkrautsandwich · 26/11/2023 06:53

It's like 21k - 18k after tax etc. Two adult household on FT NMW brings in 36k.
How is that peanuts?

The average house price is £291 k, that’s how. Plus if you want a family of your own, you also need to pay for the childcare that enables both of you to keep earning that wage (remembering that was the wage for both partners working full time, not one).

@Notanevillandlord if you provide accommodation for foreigners coming here while continuing to restrict the lives and opportunities of local people you will have big problems very quickly. Many of those ‘lazy uneducated boys’ who ‘don’t contribute’ referred to by pp already understand that only crime and drugs earns them a decent living in the U.K.

Notaflippinclue · 26/11/2023 12:44

Also first hand - African nurse brought over shocked at cost of accommodation obviously not explained to her beforehand - then bring partner and children then get pregnant. How does this contribute to our NHS.

Notanevillandlord · 26/11/2023 12:36

This is first hand experience. I'm a LL. Last year I had a 2 bed flat to rent. I received > 70 enquiries. Half being from people from Africa who had been invited here as hospital workers/nurses/carers.

They arrive here with job offers but with no credit history and no deposit. so finding a place to rent is very difficult. I think if we are going to invite workers here the Government should provide accommodation for at least for 6 months. Also care homes should provide accommodation too for the workers they recruit from abroad same with other employers who need workers from abroad. Employers want the cheap labour but don't want to help them with accommodation. They need to do more.

You may say well there is no accommodation. The flat is in a university town and the amount of uni accommodation that's been built in the last 10 - 15 years is phenomenal- so it can be done.

I was reading pp about the Dubai situation, if you get a job there as an engineer your employer usually gives you a housing allowance, or used to and you use private schools for the children if you bring them over. Hence not impacting the local schools.

However if you are a male Indian worker you are probably given accommodation - I imagine it'll be hideous but not impacting the locals and your family stays in India because they only want the worker and not the family. However I do know people whose dp worked in UAE whilst the family stayed in the UK.

I don't know the answers and I'm not advocating the Dubai way but as need more immigrants the government needs to decide do we just want the worker ie family get left behind or do we want them to bring their families and thus impacting schools and other services.

All I know is that they need to start providing accommodation for them. Expecting them to come here with no support on finding accommodation is inhumane and doesn't exactly say welcome to Britain. Securing accommodation is huge, harsh, expensive hurdle before they even start work.

EasternStandard · 26/11/2023 12:18

MeAndStuart1981 · 26/11/2023 09:45

I was listening to a large group at a nearby table in the pub last night and they blamed Angela Merkel's open door immigration policy, said it sent a dog whistle to the world to come to Europe and they have no border controls. Anyone can walk from country to country unstopped and end up in France, and does anyone remember the migrant camps. And has anyone been over to Paris lately to see them in the streets.

They were talking about a case where Tunisians snuck into Italy, went to Calais and got a boat to the UK and it took just days, they said it was filmed to show how easy it is and no one stops you as its open borders.

This kind of muttering I imagine happening over in Netherlands, Ireland, France, Sweden. Indigenous folk looking around and then starting to think...hang on...

Someone piped up about EU borders are being manned again to try and stem the tide, but the voice from last night was its too late.

This group were not what I would have called yobs or far right who run the streets to loot. And actually those who do that, like in Dublin, only get the media attention on them and not the real problem which is a man running around their streets with a knife stabbing women and children. That's where the outrage should be.

Merkel did exacerbate it. Then you have Putin pushing people movement for destabilising opportunities

Madness really, no wonder we’re seeing strain

User135644 · 26/11/2023 11:49

It's madness what Europe has allowed since the turn of the century. The population of EU and UK is over half a billion people and it doesn't cover that big a land mass. Russia itself is way bigger.

Chickenkeev · 26/11/2023 11:45

bombastix · 26/11/2023 11:37

Gross or net. 36k after tax is not a bad income.

It's not bad, but potentially not great. After housing and childcare. It all depends really.

bombastix · 26/11/2023 11:37

Gross or net. 36k after tax is not a bad income.

inamarina · 26/11/2023 11:37

Myfabby · 26/11/2023 10:17

Lol. Most immigrants get nationalised. They have a right to after living, serving, paying taxes. They are entitled to reproduce, just as you are.

In the same token, maybe the unemployed feral youth who choose not to be productive, or those who permanently stay on benefits shouldn't have children, because right now I as a tax payer are subsidizing them and my children as future tax payers will subsidize their offspring- using your logic!

PP didn’t say immigrants shouldn’t reproduce though.
They just asked what will happen when those people who are currently needed because of the demographic shift and the aging population in the UK get older themselves. Who will look after them?
What are the longterm consequences of a country using immigrant workers to prop up the local economy?
Do those immigrants only stay as long as they’re young, fit and ‘useful’, and then leave again to be replaced by the next wave of healthy, young workers?
Some people seem to think that’s the case.
But you say yourself that most immigrants get nationalised. That means they stay. So will more immigrants be needed to look after them when they get older?

Walkaround · 26/11/2023 11:04

bombastix · 26/11/2023 09:30

36k after tax is not peanuts. Do people mean gross?

Anyway, I think the problems with universal credit and top up of wages are clear. It's a kind of capitalist social policy that means employers don't pay decent wages and many people who could be properly economic productive aren't.

There are some difficult truths out there. One is future employment at all given AI. The others are the growth of special educational needs and how these children will thrive as adults in a society that is older and sicker with less tax contributions than 25 years ago. All of this speaks of economic decline. It's the reason immigration continues as it does even if the Tory Party does not say it. It does explain the last 13 years better rather than wondering why they haven't done anything. They have; they have greatly expanded immigration because a lot of the UK population are not very productive.

People mean two full time care workers, not one.

Myfabby · 26/11/2023 10:21

bombastix · 26/11/2023 09:40

The funding of the country is not looking good. It seems there are many local councils teetering on the edge of bankruptcy. And that is Labour and Conservative, in some nice parts of England where the narrative is not going to be "immigrants got the money". Give it six months.

You're absolutely correct. Woking is 83.6% white, 11.6% Asian descent and 2.4% mixed race. The council is in debt set to hit £2.6 billion. I'm sure with some of the warped thinking on this thread, that's down to funding immigrants. sigh

Myfabby · 26/11/2023 10:17

Notaflippinclue · 26/11/2023 09:44

Who cares for the immigrants and their dependants when they get older - more immigrants - then who cares for them & on & on

Lol. Most immigrants get nationalised. They have a right to after living, serving, paying taxes. They are entitled to reproduce, just as you are.

In the same token, maybe the unemployed feral youth who choose not to be productive, or those who permanently stay on benefits shouldn't have children, because right now I as a tax payer are subsidizing them and my children as future tax payers will subsidize their offspring- using your logic!

Comedycook · 26/11/2023 10:07

Notaflippinclue · 26/11/2023 09:44

Who cares for the immigrants and their dependants when they get older - more immigrants - then who cares for them & on & on

Of course...it's a massive pyramid scheme.

MeAndStuart1981 · 26/11/2023 09:45

I was listening to a large group at a nearby table in the pub last night and they blamed Angela Merkel's open door immigration policy, said it sent a dog whistle to the world to come to Europe and they have no border controls. Anyone can walk from country to country unstopped and end up in France, and does anyone remember the migrant camps. And has anyone been over to Paris lately to see them in the streets.

They were talking about a case where Tunisians snuck into Italy, went to Calais and got a boat to the UK and it took just days, they said it was filmed to show how easy it is and no one stops you as its open borders.

This kind of muttering I imagine happening over in Netherlands, Ireland, France, Sweden. Indigenous folk looking around and then starting to think...hang on...

Someone piped up about EU borders are being manned again to try and stem the tide, but the voice from last night was its too late.

This group were not what I would have called yobs or far right who run the streets to loot. And actually those who do that, like in Dublin, only get the media attention on them and not the real problem which is a man running around their streets with a knife stabbing women and children. That's where the outrage should be.

Notaflippinclue · 26/11/2023 09:44

Who cares for the immigrants and their dependants when they get older - more immigrants - then who cares for them & on & on

bombastix · 26/11/2023 09:40

The funding of the country is not looking good. It seems there are many local councils teetering on the edge of bankruptcy. And that is Labour and Conservative, in some nice parts of England where the narrative is not going to be "immigrants got the money". Give it six months.

SWSO · 26/11/2023 09:31

I can't blame people for wanting a better life where they will be housed , educated , have reasonable health care etc for the rest of their life , so much so that they will risk their lives to get it . The reality is that they end up at the mercy of trafficking gangs and end up owing lots of money . They become indentured slaves .

This government can't / won't take care of its own citizens properly who were born here and paid taxes . I'm a believer of take care of your own first then help others . We can't take in everyone who wants to come . We don't have the infrastructure or resources.

Saying that I despise these right wing groups who harass and bully migrants in their accommodation. Yes I understand there are vulnerable people born here living in the street but the right wingers argument is with the Government who has allowed this to happen.

Swipe left for the next trending thread