Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Europen governments need to respond to immigration?

564 replies

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 06:45

So the Netherlands is going to have a far right government.
Sweden has moved to the right.
Finland has shut its borders.
Countries that have traditionally been liberal are hardening and irrespective of the many issues listed its to do with immigration.

Ireland has seen violent protests last night following a series of stabbings.
In the UK we obviously had Brexit.

I think governments need to start responding to voters feelings on immigration as if they don't we will continue to see a general slide to the right in Europe, when actually these countries aren't right wing: it feels like a single issue is distorting the entire political landscape?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
Pomonas · 30/11/2023 09:58

Some will be shock when the numbers of people are unmanageable. The radical solutions that would have to be done to accommodate the population.

bombastix · 30/11/2023 09:58

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 30/11/2023 08:10

It's what the USSR did.

They expropriated the available housing and used it to increase population density. They also built new slums flats with no thought for anything but how many they could squeeze there.

Some posters here are having wet dreams about this, it seems.

Edited

I'm bound to point out that this is not permitted under that pesky European Convention on Human Rights. That would be the same Convention that some posters are so keen to disapply for asylum seekers. You have to be very careful when you make new precedents in law because in democracy, you can never quite guarantee that the argument made for one set of people could not easily be extended to another. Domestically if the UK maintains it can override international law for domestic purposes such as asylum management there would not be a lot to say that you could not do similar for other domestic purposes such as a "housing crisis". And of course, were a party in power in the UK to advance this, you could claim it was "the will of the people".

The law of power is that in democracy, it may at some stage be used against you and your own interests. Tread carefully

EasternStandard · 30/11/2023 09:38

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 30/11/2023 09:32

So my house is fair game? I should move, change my whole way of life so someone can have it?

Funny, because I seem to recall the outcry when the so called "bedroom tax" was mooted, about how unfair it is to ask people to move or to pay extra for housing they have been allocated.

If you are looking for spare housing, then why not there?

What's sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.

There’s a couple of give up your property pp on various threads. They could lead by example and start with their own.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 30/11/2023 09:32

So my house is fair game? I should move, change my whole way of life so someone can have it?

Funny, because I seem to recall the outcry when the so called "bedroom tax" was mooted, about how unfair it is to ask people to move or to pay extra for housing they have been allocated.

If you are looking for spare housing, then why not there?

What's sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.

AdamRyan · 30/11/2023 09:21

You obviously.

And the bit about the posted being galling was referring to this:
I have £750k from the sale of my family home and I want a home with social and outdoor space in the location of my choice.

I also have enough in my pension to have freedom of choice, so I am actually quite impossible to boss around.

Complete lack of empathy for people trying to raise a family in 2023, just this kind of pervasive attitude that its their own fault they can't afford a house.

Whereas the reality is she is rich enough to do what she likes because she was lucky enough to be born in an era where houses were affordable and has made a killing from the rise in house prices.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 30/11/2023 09:06

AdamRyan · 30/11/2023 09:03

OK. Well if your answer to housing inequality is "stop immigration" I think you are going to be disappointed on lots of levels.

It is a bit galling to hear a poster who clearly lives very comfortably in a big house being "I'm alright Jack" about everyone else's living circumstances.

Who's your post addressed to?

AdamRyan · 30/11/2023 09:03

OK. Well if your answer to housing inequality is "stop immigration" I think you are going to be disappointed on lots of levels.

It is a bit galling to hear a poster who clearly lives very comfortably in a big house being "I'm alright Jack" about everyone else's living circumstances.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 30/11/2023 08:27

AdamRyan · 30/11/2023 08:16

Oh my god you bunch of weirdos, clearly she is not saying that.
She's talking about the fact historically you could buy a relatively nice house on a modest income and so today a lot of the bigger,nicer houses are being lived in by older single people who couldn't hope to live there if they were born today.

And that is nothing to do with immigrants and everything to do with the fact the housing market is distorted by successive government policies.

She's not saying that.

She's saying when you're one of the people with an excessive amount of house for your needs. Excessive as in above "your needs", and we all know where "according to their needs" comes from, and that the cuddly old uncle Karl.

Also, how can you claim the he market is not distorted by immigration, especially in the light of the new numbers? These are all people who need housing, right now.

Walkaround · 30/11/2023 08:21

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 30/11/2023 08:10

It's what the USSR did.

They expropriated the available housing and used it to increase population density. They also built new slums flats with no thought for anything but how many they could squeeze there.

Some posters here are having wet dreams about this, it seems.

Edited

They gave thought to ensuring people were kept warm (too warm sometimes - centrally controlled….) and sheltered. No point comparing one completely different country with another. It’s not as if Russia ever had a good reputation for quality of life of its peasant population pre-revolution, because funnily enough, revolutions do not tend to happen when people feel they have something worthwhile to lose.

AdamRyan · 30/11/2023 08:16

Oh my god you bunch of weirdos, clearly she is not saying that.
She's talking about the fact historically you could buy a relatively nice house on a modest income and so today a lot of the bigger,nicer houses are being lived in by older single people who couldn't hope to live there if they were born today.

And that is nothing to do with immigrants and everything to do with the fact the housing market is distorted by successive government policies.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 30/11/2023 08:10

It's what the USSR did.

They expropriated the available housing and used it to increase population density. They also built new slums flats with no thought for anything but how many they could squeeze there.

Some posters here are having wet dreams about this, it seems.

SomeCatFromJapan · 30/11/2023 07:41

So people should all live in the smallest homes possible to make space for more immigrants?
That should play well with voters 😂

Triptastico · 30/11/2023 07:13

@lljkk you're deluded. Confused

MoonLife · 30/11/2023 01:51

lljkk · 29/11/2023 21:45

long thread I don't want to search... fine, Papy, fine, really, do as you please,, just don't complain about "immigrants causing a housing shortage!" when you're one of the people with an excessive amount of house for your needs.

I find your posts very odd. So you are blaming the housing crisis on people who are living in bigger properties than they strictly require? Houses that no doubt people have worked hard to buy? And who on earth would police this to ensure each person doesn't exceed their housing quota? Sounds like the start of some dystopian novel....

SandySan · 29/11/2023 22:46

lljkk · 29/11/2023 21:45

long thread I don't want to search... fine, Papy, fine, really, do as you please,, just don't complain about "immigrants causing a housing shortage!" when you're one of the people with an excessive amount of house for your needs.

I'm not old but have "more house than I need".
My partner and I bought a 3 bedroom house a few years ago while TTC. Hoped to have at least one child. But after a few years and a few failed rounds of IVF it's looking like it isn't going to happen for us. So what now? Should we sell the house we only bought 3 years ago and have spent thousands doing up and move back to a small flat? We love our house. We love having a garden now and no noise from people stomping on our celling. Why should we move out of it (and lose thousands in the process) because we have been unlucky enough to be infertile?
By moving out of our small flat, we allowed a younger couple to get on the property ladder. So if all older/infertile/single people move into the small flats how on earth is anyone young going to get on the property ladder in the first place?
All these people with more house than they need will eventually die/ go into care and these houses will become available then.

lljkk · 29/11/2023 21:45

long thread I don't want to search... fine, Papy, fine, really, do as you please,, just don't complain about "immigrants causing a housing shortage!" when you're one of the people with an excessive amount of house for your needs.

Papyrophile · 29/11/2023 20:47

@lljkk I hear what you are saying about older people not leaving their family houses, but where would you like us to move?

I am not going to move into a one bed rabbit hutch or a two bed retirement complex with difficult re-sale prospects, because I have £750k from the sale of my family home and I want a home with social and outdoor space in the location of my choice.

I also have enough in my pension to have freedom of choice, so I am actually quite impossible to boss around.

I can leave the UK totally and pay my tax to another country, even within the EU. Retirement and non-lucrative visas are fairly universal, plus health insurance. All completely legally, on legally earned money, taxes paid.

Noicant · 29/11/2023 18:23

On a serious note I am worried about hoe many people are put of work in the UK and what happens if we do start adopting more AI. People who have moved to fill low skilled jobs may struggle. I know the driverless cabs thing is very very far away but what happens to a bunch of people whos jobs were to drive cabs. We need to move towards higher skilled higher paid work. The reality is easy labour supply discourages business from investing in technology to become more efficient and productive. UK productivity is shit because there is no need to make the effort to find an alternative to cheap labour.

Noicant · 29/11/2023 18:19

CasaAmarela · 29/11/2023 15:41

Agree with posters re: the ack of integration. There are immigrants employed at my local train/bus stations and they all stand speaking foreign languages together. It doesn't make them very approachable imo. There's a block of council houses filled with African/Asian immigrants that has just been built across from my house and we've sold up because of the unbearable noise - dozens of children screaming in the street and playing in the road. I'm not saying they're bad people but there are obviously some cultural differences. I want to run away to the countryside for some peace and quiet.

That’s interesting, I was desperate to move out of an estate I lived in because the white kids kept jamming fireworks through the doors of the black people that lived there and the unbearable noise of a bloody car being set alight behind my flat, they also spoke in the most incomprehensible babble. I guess it’s just different cultures…

Myfabby · 29/11/2023 16:41

CasaAmarela · 29/11/2023 15:41

Agree with posters re: the ack of integration. There are immigrants employed at my local train/bus stations and they all stand speaking foreign languages together. It doesn't make them very approachable imo. There's a block of council houses filled with African/Asian immigrants that has just been built across from my house and we've sold up because of the unbearable noise - dozens of children screaming in the street and playing in the road. I'm not saying they're bad people but there are obviously some cultural differences. I want to run away to the countryside for some peace and quiet.

Oh English children don't play on the roads? Very interesting.

CasaAmarela · 29/11/2023 15:41

Agree with posters re: the ack of integration. There are immigrants employed at my local train/bus stations and they all stand speaking foreign languages together. It doesn't make them very approachable imo. There's a block of council houses filled with African/Asian immigrants that has just been built across from my house and we've sold up because of the unbearable noise - dozens of children screaming in the street and playing in the road. I'm not saying they're bad people but there are obviously some cultural differences. I want to run away to the countryside for some peace and quiet.

jasflowers · 27/11/2023 09:07

I was listening to a large group at a nearby table in the pub last night and they blamed Angela Merkel's open door immigration policy, said it sent a dog whistle to the world to come to Europe and they have no border controls

Well, they are talking rubbish.
The wars in Iraq, Libya and Syria caused migration into Europe i.e wars we caused and even started!!
Merkel had a one off policy of allowing in 1m migrants to reduce pressures in Turkey and Greece, they were heading towards Europe regardless.

The bombing of Libya, turning it into a failed criminal state, is an open gateway to the Europe, a war stated by the British (Cameron) and the French, Gadaffi was a nasty piece of work but what has replaced him is far worse both for the Libyans and for Europe.

The vast majority of displaced people stay near their own areas & in any case, the EU does have a strong external border, as the queues we see in Dover or Turkey or Finland etc proves.

The majority of migrants now cross into Italy, should poor old Italy be the only European country to deal with these numbers?

AdamRyan · 27/11/2023 08:38

Google definition (bolding mine):
)of people) inhabiting or existing in a land from the earliest times or from before the arrival of colonists.
"she wants the territorial government to speak with Indigenous people before implementing a programme"

I would use the word British, or local.

TempestTost · 27/11/2023 00:05

AdamRyan · 26/11/2023 22:20

Can we stop going on about "indigenous". There is no such thing in the UK and it implies we are being invaded or pushed out.

The McDonalds where I live is almost exclusively staffed by the local teens, it pays well and is flexible so attracts a lot of them.

What word would you use? And why do you think it suggests invasion?

It's not a word that means that the people there were necessarily always there, didn't move around, or maybe even replace others. There's always a certain amount of fudge because unless you come from some pretty specific parts of Africa. no one's ancestors came from where their descendants are now. (And even if you do come from that part of Africa it is highly unlikely your people didn't move around.)

AdamRyan · 26/11/2023 22:20

Can we stop going on about "indigenous". There is no such thing in the UK and it implies we are being invaded or pushed out.

The McDonalds where I live is almost exclusively staffed by the local teens, it pays well and is flexible so attracts a lot of them.