Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Europen governments need to respond to immigration?

564 replies

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 06:45

So the Netherlands is going to have a far right government.
Sweden has moved to the right.
Finland has shut its borders.
Countries that have traditionally been liberal are hardening and irrespective of the many issues listed its to do with immigration.

Ireland has seen violent protests last night following a series of stabbings.
In the UK we obviously had Brexit.

I think governments need to start responding to voters feelings on immigration as if they don't we will continue to see a general slide to the right in Europe, when actually these countries aren't right wing: it feels like a single issue is distorting the entire political landscape?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
inamarina · 30/11/2023 14:44

Walkaround · 30/11/2023 08:21

They gave thought to ensuring people were kept warm (too warm sometimes - centrally controlled….) and sheltered. No point comparing one completely different country with another. It’s not as if Russia ever had a good reputation for quality of life of its peasant population pre-revolution, because funnily enough, revolutions do not tend to happen when people feel they have something worthwhile to lose.

Many people were being kept ‘warm and sheltered’ sharing apartments with strangers, in old, crumbling buildings.
I had several classmates who lived like that - a family would get a room or two and share the kitchen and the bathroom with others.
My grandparents managed to get a newly built flat for themselves and their two kids - the flat had only one bedroom though. After my grandfather died, grandma lived there with my uncle, his wife and their child. Four people sharing one bedroom and a living room.

inamarina · 30/11/2023 14:27

MoonLife · 30/11/2023 01:51

I find your posts very odd. So you are blaming the housing crisis on people who are living in bigger properties than they strictly require? Houses that no doubt people have worked hard to buy? And who on earth would police this to ensure each person doesn't exceed their housing quota? Sounds like the start of some dystopian novel....

Sounds like the start of some dystopian novel....

Couldn’t agree more. My family used to live in a communist country where the state made sure nobody had ‘more house than needed’.
Definitely not the kind of place most people would like to live in.

MoonLife · 30/11/2023 13:10

@jasflowers agreed

jasflowers · 30/11/2023 13:04

MoonLife · 30/11/2023 12:57

So the majority agree that there is a housing crisis, but what I find interesting is the differing attitudes when identifying the reason for it and how it should be managed. I think it's absurd to even suggest that elderly people should give up their homes; the ones I know are not well off or from monied backgrounds - they just happened to be from the era when home ownership was attainable on blue collar incomes. It doesn't mean they're not struggling with the col and paying their energy bills! The real problem is addressing poor wages which suppresses people's ability to afford to buy a home and therefore, in effect vastly inflates the rental market. cheap imported labour only adds to the problem.

Well, if you increase wages too quickly, you feed inflation, making the problem even worse, increasing wages to give people more money, will also take many years.

As my mum used to say "there is nothing new under the sun" so after the war, we had a housing crisis, the Govt, both Tory and Lab, built council housing, cheap rents, more money in the local economy, better for the economy.

With improvements, we need to do the same but pointless if the Tories continue to let in 745k per year, we'll never keep up.

Agree, any attempt to requisition larger or even empty houses would be madness, though changes to taxation on 2nd homes is needed.

MoonLife · 30/11/2023 12:57

So the majority agree that there is a housing crisis, but what I find interesting is the differing attitudes when identifying the reason for it and how it should be managed. I think it's absurd to even suggest that elderly people should give up their homes; the ones I know are not well off or from monied backgrounds - they just happened to be from the era when home ownership was attainable on blue collar incomes. It doesn't mean they're not struggling with the col and paying their energy bills! The real problem is addressing poor wages which suppresses people's ability to afford to buy a home and therefore, in effect vastly inflates the rental market. cheap imported labour only adds to the problem.

jasflowers · 30/11/2023 12:51

How does leaving or amending the ECHR or any other treaty deal with migration, from war, climate or economic?

Do posters think a migrant escaping the Taliban, Assad, Putin or escaping starvation in Eritrea will be studying International law before making the move?

If you really do want to deter such people, then you'll have to go to a situation where we will treat them even worse.
Even Rwanda (increasingly looking like a non starter) will be preferable to many asylum seekers.

One reason Australia's policies worked is that they put people in camps that offered terrible living conditions, another is that the economies of SE Asia improved, there is a lesson for Europe here.

EasternStandard · 30/11/2023 12:00

Which is why I suggest looking at world news… we’re not going to be the only country not disturbed by this

We are not immune just because some favour Labour atm and they’d prefer to deflect

It’s not going away, it’ll only go in one direction. A system unable to cope and increased pressure for change.

@Sauerkrautsandwich yes an afternoon or two on mn threads ;

Sauerkrautsandwich · 30/11/2023 11:53

If you want to slow immigration, just promote mumsnet abroad... Some of the chat on here makes 3rd world countries sound rich compared to uk...

bombastix · 30/11/2023 11:52

For example, the Convention will stop me as say a border office from taking any property an asylum seeker brought with them. It means the asylum seeker cannot be locked up indefinitely without review, it means that, for example, the U.K. cannot design a system where it extracts gold from people's teeth on arrival (again, something that the Nazis did to Jews). I appreciate to some these ideas are extreme. But the Convention exists because there were no limits at all, and it is possible to say domestically, this the law only and we are within it. International law is a challenge to the idea that states are decent or will regulate themselves in a way that does not tyrannise people, take their property, lock them up, give no reason, or torture them.

It means I can't introduce a white only policy or racial purity law. Arguably that would remove migration problems overnight: anyone who could not show their heritage in the U.K. going back two hundred years could be expelled. That used to be the BNP line. And you could have a house consficated from those pesky immigrant interlopers.

The only disorder I have seen in the U.K. is the far right at the Cenotaph, and then seeing Tommy Robinson being pepper sprayed. That seems to be about the right approach to me, to deal with barbarians within rather than speculate as to the ones apparently outside.

Migration as a legal matter via visa can be more severely controlled. If people vote for it, then it can happen.

EasternStandard · 30/11/2023 11:38

It’s also designed for pre climate change and trafficking migration…

Do people not notice the world news? Look at what’s happening and project forward a bit

bombastix · 30/11/2023 11:35

AdamRyan · 30/11/2023 11:30

I think bomb was saying the ECHR protects us from house requisitions so we might want to keep it. Like insurance against a future we can't yet know.

I'd argue that advocating the removal of human rights as a way to deal with immigration is more bonkers than pointing out how the ECHR protects us all.

Lots of straw manning going on in this thread....

Yes of course. It is literally designed as a cohesive convention to prevent certain groups being picked off or identified as being less worthy.

EasternStandard · 30/11/2023 11:33

It won’t survive in current form. Countries will change it or exit

The asylum system as it was set up won’t cope with migration increase.

Voters will demand change or resort to public disorder- both have already started and will increase.

Aus is lucky it will be one of the few to work out approach within the law

AdamRyan · 30/11/2023 11:30

I think bomb was saying the ECHR protects us from house requisitions so we might want to keep it. Like insurance against a future we can't yet know.

I'd argue that advocating the removal of human rights as a way to deal with immigration is more bonkers than pointing out how the ECHR protects us all.

Lots of straw manning going on in this thread....

EasternStandard · 30/11/2023 11:24

bombastix · 30/11/2023 11:22

Relevantly, Aus is interesting but it's not a complete answer and it's not that useful. What it amounts to is saying another country does it differently, and one that has is geographically nearly completely distinct and indeed legally.

Yes and your idea that doing it differently will lead to house requisitions is bonkers

And lacks a decent look at what’s going on generally with increasing migration

bombastix · 30/11/2023 11:22

Relevantly, Aus is interesting but it's not a complete answer and it's not that useful. What it amounts to is saying another country does it differently, and one that has is geographically nearly completely distinct and indeed legally.

EasternStandard · 30/11/2023 11:18

bombastix · 30/11/2023 11:09

Well you can't show or demonstrate a source or seem unwilling. I say possible. Plausible is different

It’s not going to happen. It’s irrelevant.

What is actually plausible and increasingly so is voters showing they are not happy with the lack of ability for politicians to act due to a system created when pressures were different.

They will vote for those who listen, which is evident in increase for far right. There will also be growing public disorder.

Both are already happening.

AdamRyan · 30/11/2023 11:16

So maybe "what's sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander" and you should start paying additional council tax for each spare room you have, so the council can raise money to better house those in need. How would you feel about that?

I can guess - "I worked hard, I paid my taxes and I'm alright Jack"
But of course you will expect to keep your house should you need care. Because "I worked hard and paid my taxes"

Attitude absolutely sucks and I'm glad it's not representative of the country at large

AdamRyan · 30/11/2023 11:12

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 30/11/2023 09:32

So my house is fair game? I should move, change my whole way of life so someone can have it?

Funny, because I seem to recall the outcry when the so called "bedroom tax" was mooted, about how unfair it is to ask people to move or to pay extra for housing they have been allocated.

If you are looking for spare housing, then why not there?

What's sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.

Noone is saying that
Is it fair, when you look at the country as a whole, that older people can afford nicer houses alone than young families?
I think a lot of people think that isn't fair. And there is a tonne of stuff that could be done to even it out but this government won't because their voter/member base is rich retired people. Much easier to blame the housing crisis on immigrants.

Oh and FYI the bedroom tax was implemented, not "mooted", and is still in place. Which just goes to show how absolutely out of touch you are.

bombastix · 30/11/2023 11:09

Well you can't show or demonstrate a source or seem unwilling. I say possible. Plausible is different

EasternStandard · 30/11/2023 11:05

‘Not a lot to stop..’

Is scaremongering. Houses will not be requisitioned in Aus

They do have better ability to determine their own policies though, which will be increasingly beneficial as climate change puts pressure on post war institutions

bombastix · 30/11/2023 11:00

The point would be, there is not a lot to stop that in AUS already (some significant differences).

We have made that commitment in the ECHR, partly because removal of property was what the Nazis did to Jews, removing their assets. Property and the right to dispose of it is thus a human right in the ECHR

EasternStandard · 30/11/2023 10:46

I wonder how countries manage out of the ECHR

Aus and NZ seem to be ok for house owners 🤔

bombastix · 30/11/2023 10:14

Well, it's a minority who want rid of the ECHR but they get traction in government with ministers so why not this with Labour? Get rid of the ECHR and I can come to your house with an order to claim it for a family.

This is actually plausible policy for council housing

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 30/11/2023 10:03

bombastix · 30/11/2023 09:58

I'm bound to point out that this is not permitted under that pesky European Convention on Human Rights. That would be the same Convention that some posters are so keen to disapply for asylum seekers. You have to be very careful when you make new precedents in law because in democracy, you can never quite guarantee that the argument made for one set of people could not easily be extended to another. Domestically if the UK maintains it can override international law for domestic purposes such as asylum management there would not be a lot to say that you could not do similar for other domestic purposes such as a "housing crisis". And of course, were a party in power in the UK to advance this, you could claim it was "the will of the people".

The law of power is that in democracy, it may at some stage be used against you and your own interests. Tread carefully

I’m not saying it’s going to happen.
The voters have more sense than that.

I’m saying that some posters are positively salivating thinking about it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread