Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Europen governments need to respond to immigration?

564 replies

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 06:45

So the Netherlands is going to have a far right government.
Sweden has moved to the right.
Finland has shut its borders.
Countries that have traditionally been liberal are hardening and irrespective of the many issues listed its to do with immigration.

Ireland has seen violent protests last night following a series of stabbings.
In the UK we obviously had Brexit.

I think governments need to start responding to voters feelings on immigration as if they don't we will continue to see a general slide to the right in Europe, when actually these countries aren't right wing: it feels like a single issue is distorting the entire political landscape?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
GreyhpundGirl · 24/11/2023 08:41

littleblackcat27 · 24/11/2023 08:03

I've just watched the Gillian Duffy conversation with Gordon Brown - and yep - she's definitely bigoted and pretty aggressive in her tone with him right from the start.

Blaming Gordon Brown even partly for Brexit is hilarious.

Maybe it was David Cameron's ill judged plan to stop the Tories' in-fighting????

But the Labour government not putting controls on immigration from former Eastern Bloc countries, when most other EU members did led to a huge number of Polish people migrating here- that, and the migrant crisis as a result of the war in Syria was the fuel for UKIP et Al campaigning to.leave the EU.

Libertyy · 24/11/2023 08:40

I don’t get why the white British people who complain about the immigrants taking all the jobs can’t fill the vacancies for care homes and picking fruit etc?

GreyhpundGirl · 24/11/2023 08:37

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 07:14

@Pooooochi
I agree with your idea. Maybe we could remove people's ability to apply for their families to come over and join them as a starting point

That's what the government is mooting, especially for student visas.

lljkk · 24/11/2023 08:34

Truss wanted to lift many immigration caps to improve economic growth. Now, the labour shortage in UK remains high, especially social & health workers but science and finance too, jobs often met by imported skilled workers. UK Universities are kept afloat by overseas student fees. Political Fix podcast pointed out that when people are asked specifically which type of immigrants they don't want... the only specifics are irregular and bankers (both tiny % of total).

In meantime, many older adults living in big houses they needed when they had many children; now long grown up, still in their big houses, a practice defended robustly on a recent MN thread. So there's your choice. Let the old people stay in their big houses and their triple-lock pensions, while everyone gets under-staffed hospitals and care homes and patchy social-care, the financial sector which drives UK economy gets snubbed and economy gets throttled too, universities contract in size and run up huge debts. We get to have all that just so we can "keep immigration down". It's what voters want, I guess.

Braverman supported the Truss agenda.

bombastix · 24/11/2023 08:34

CharlotteRumpling · 24/11/2023 07:51

Well,Theresa May tried to abolish post study work visas. Unis went bust because they rely on foreign students. So they brought it back.

You put your finger on the issue. Our legal migration is driven by the needs of business, not the general population. You could cut the legal migration rate by refusing dependents (huge figure) and getting rid of the study visa. Post Brexit these have ballooned in size. A lot of the university sector is totally dependent on overseas fees.

As for asylum the debate annoys me. The figures are small but the backlog never really gets addressed. The government talks big on it but spends money in bizarre ways. It uses commercial flights to deport, over which it had next to no legal control. Our immigration and asylum system is still full of legal problems which are, politely, only problems because the government want to do this cheaply. If the UK wants tighter borders it must pay a lot more for them. If it wants fewer migrants it is going to have to tell business and universities to look at their financial base. It means shutting down "English schools" where no one ever turns up, it means shutting down restaurants that use illegal labour and not giving little fines but ones that absolutely penalise the owner. All of this stuff is not done but it could be.

Comedycook · 24/11/2023 08:34

MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 08:28

Immigrants use the NHS far less than the resident population, so their tax revenues are a net gain.

It is fine to talk about immigration but you have to start with facts and reality.

Your post is entirely fiction.

There's no fiction. Of course immigrants use the NHS... probably not as much as British people but that's probably because immigrants are younger and the biggest users of the NHS are the elderly. But of course immigrants use public services....schools, NHS etc. They also need a roof over their head. It's simple maths.

And what I really really hate about debating immigration is that if you express any concern you are immediately labelled as being anti immigration.

I am not anti immigration. We need it but there's a middle ground between zero immigration and hundreds of thousands every year.

Spendonsend · 24/11/2023 08:32

I hold my hand up to jamming my fingers in my ears

I think climate change is going to maje the situation worse in a fairly short timescale.

sanluca · 24/11/2023 08:30

*Midnightoncemore:

There is a difference between right wing and far right.

If you vote for a party that is racist, you are either also a racist or a fool.

If you vote regular right wing, that's different.*

It really does not help when anyone tries to encapsulate complex voting behaviour in a single one line that calls people names and focuses on an issue that is not even the main reason people voted for a party. It just smacks of sour grapes and an unwilligness to engage.

The real question is why do center and left wing parties not take people's concerns about lack of housing and healtchare seriously?

Notonthestairs · 24/11/2023 08:29

You can reduce migration - the increase has happened as a direct result of Government policy to liberalise migration after all.
But you will need to raise taxes to maintain public services.

MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 08:28

Comedycook · 24/11/2023 08:24

I don't oppose immigration. But the numbers are unsustainable. It's a pyramid scheme to some extent. Increase population...NHS needs more workers as do other sectors....so increase population some more, now more workers are needed, so we increase the population some more and on and on it goes. Richer on paper ie economic growth and GDP does not necessarily mean a higher standard of living for people

Immigrants use the NHS far less than the resident population, so their tax revenues are a net gain.

It is fine to talk about immigration but you have to start with facts and reality.

Your post is entirely fiction.

mollyfolk · 24/11/2023 08:28

Nomnomnom66 · 24/11/2023 07:10

@Chickenkeev I used to teach in one on the worst areas in Dublin. Some of these lads have been genuinely let down by the example of their parents etc... and could do better but there are a lot of out and out scumbags who use school as somewhere for their own amusement and terrorise students and teachers. One lad who later that year assaulted me, told me he was only there til it was time to go on the dole. I think sometimes the stick rather than the carrot is good. Why do these people get to live in Central Dublin in social housing - some of the most expensive real estate in Europe - yet behave like this? They're not grateful for anything, so maybe it should be given to people who actually deserve it.

That is a shocking view from a teacher. They aren’t just innately scumbags who were born bad - our society has created them. They get to live there because it’s their home. North Dublin central is hardly fancy. Yes these lads have been let down by their own parents but they are brought up surrounded by addiction, violence and chaos and often their parents have too in an never ending cycle of poverty and social exclusion. We need more targeted funding towards young people in these communities. The cost of living crisis and the housing crisis have only fuelled their discontent. And now they blame immigrants for everything. Those lads are a product of their environment and a product of a government who needs to do so much more to tackle social inequality.

Passepartoute · 24/11/2023 08:27

How does the recent Polish election result fit into your scenario?

Onand · 24/11/2023 08:27

Createausername1970 · 24/11/2023 08:23

This is true on a lot of forums. With the result that those who are broadly right of centre don't put their heads above the parapet as they know they will get verbally abused. So there is never a true representation of opinions in the wider community. Which is why Brexit and Tory's winning elections come as a surprise.

Let’s also not forget that a lot of forums (MN too) have users with strategic intentions (paid even?) so often the noise for one argument becomes very loud ie anti vaxxers, the Israel Palestine issue, Brexit. Regular posters could probably have reasonable debates and conversations but the extremists who push agendas will always go that extra mile and refuse engaging in any constructive dialogue.

MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 08:26

We have a FPTP system. Some voters are always ignored.

If we want more voters to be listened to, we need a proper democracy.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/11/2023 08:26

What would you have them do about it though?

Apparently the so-called "illegal migration" only accounts for around 3% of the overall immigration figures. Many of those will be genuine asylum seekers who are subsequently granted refugee status. Most people would support taking in genuine refugees. The number of economic migrants coming in via that route is actually quite small.

The rest of the migration figures are legal migration - NHS workers, carers, international students who keep our universities afloat etc. Someone did some research about people's attitudes towards the individual categories of migrants and apparently, most people were in favour of every category except bankers. And I don't think anyone would particularly make the argument that we're being overrun by foreign bankers, who probably contribute handsomely to the overall tax take.

We need to address the skills gaps in our own country in order to address this in the longer term, and we need to look at our healthcare system to see if we can provide better care that would enable people with long term illnesses to be well enough to get back to work. We also need to invest properly in our public services and housing infrastructure etc so that people don't feel that resources are so stretched, as concerns about immigration are more often than not concerns about access to resources.

But there are no easy answers. We can't just close the door to immigration without other significant impacts on our economy, our public services, our education system etc, so people need to be careful what they wish for.

Passepartoute · 24/11/2023 08:26

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 07:12

@JaneDSE9
What would our countries have to gain from such a visa scheme though?

One of the things I don't get is often immigration is championed as being needed "to support growth". But what if we just stopped growing? Wouldn't that also be better for the climate?

What we would have to gain is desperately needed workers. There is a major recruitment problem in the NHS, care industry, hospitality, farming, all over.

Comedycook · 24/11/2023 08:24

MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 08:14

How do you intend to raise the tax revenue we need to pay our pensions without immigration?

People who oppose immigration won't discuss the economic impact of restricting it.

Student immigration, for example, bring billions into our economy. Do you want to be poorer without that income?

I don't oppose immigration. But the numbers are unsustainable. It's a pyramid scheme to some extent. Increase population...NHS needs more workers as do other sectors....so increase population some more, now more workers are needed, so we increase the population some more and on and on it goes. Richer on paper ie economic growth and GDP does not necessarily mean a higher standard of living for people

Onand · 24/11/2023 08:23

I fear it’s only a matter of time before we start seeing what has happened in Dublin in cities in the UK.

Createausername1970 · 24/11/2023 08:23

BethDuttonsTwin · 24/11/2023 07:47

You’re absolutely right. But MNetters largely, firmly jam their fingers in their ears and say it’s racist to have any kind of concerns about it - gammons, bigots, red faced racists - that kind of thing. That said, the conversation is starting, even on here. There was only so long an essential conversation could be shut down with insults/slurs.

This is true on a lot of forums. With the result that those who are broadly right of centre don't put their heads above the parapet as they know they will get verbally abused. So there is never a true representation of opinions in the wider community. Which is why Brexit and Tory's winning elections come as a surprise.

ATerrorofLeftovers · 24/11/2023 08:22

littleblackcat27 · 24/11/2023 08:03

I've just watched the Gillian Duffy conversation with Gordon Brown - and yep - she's definitely bigoted and pretty aggressive in her tone with him right from the start.

Blaming Gordon Brown even partly for Brexit is hilarious.

Maybe it was David Cameron's ill judged plan to stop the Tories' in-fighting????

You’re missing the point entirely. Whether or not Gillian Duffy or others with concerns about immigration are bigots or not is one thing. But it’s when politicians close people down and write them off as someone not worth listening to that voters realise they’re not being heard and will turn to less savoury parties.

Had Gordon Brown taken the time to listen to Duffy to get to the root of the issue, he might have found there were legitimate hardships, like lack of decent accommodation, that need to be addressed. That she’s right to be concerned about, even if she’s attributed it to the wrong cause.

It’s no good simply shouting that it’s not the fault of immigrants and not tackling the real issues dr inf grievances. People need to feel heard and that politicians will address their hardships. If they don’t, they’ll look elsewhere and parties offering a simple solution will seem very attractive.

Libertyy · 24/11/2023 08:21

The boats wouldn’t come if you could apply for asylum OUTSIDE of the UK. They come because you can only claim asylum INSIDE of the UK

MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 08:21

littleblackcat27 · 24/11/2023 08:03

I've just watched the Gillian Duffy conversation with Gordon Brown - and yep - she's definitely bigoted and pretty aggressive in her tone with him right from the start.

Blaming Gordon Brown even partly for Brexit is hilarious.

Maybe it was David Cameron's ill judged plan to stop the Tories' in-fighting????

Yes she was aggressive from the outset. Amazingly she was a Labour member.

He should not have said what he said, but she's no hero.

Eleganz · 24/11/2023 08:20

MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 08:14

How do you intend to raise the tax revenue we need to pay our pensions without immigration?

People who oppose immigration won't discuss the economic impact of restricting it.

Student immigration, for example, bring billions into our economy. Do you want to be poorer without that income?

Very good point.

The Tories whip up anti-immigrant feeling to get votes, but as the figures show their actual policies can't ignore the economic necessity of much the immigration we are seeing now. I do agree with Yvette Cooper though that these levels are in part due to the failure to give long term investment into training and skills, even if I really disagree with the Labour party's current position on student immigration.

Of course the Tories have failed to invest everywhere and seem mystified why growth is so weak when their only solution is more cuts, imported labour and taking support off disabled people.

MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 08:18

Sarahconnor1 · 24/11/2023 08:06

No, though it's largely irrelevant whether I agree with her or not.

You agree Brown insulted her on mic rather than engage with her point.

What I am saying is this allowed people to hear what politicians really thought, made them realise that politicians were not open to engagement and this has influenced the way people have voted.

It's not difficult. If politicians refuse to listen or engage, on any subject, people make their voices heard at the ballot box.

Gillian Duffy wasn't engaging either.

The reality is, for example, student immigration brings in huge amounts of money and provides high paid jobs which raise taxes.

What category of immigration do you want to cut? What decline in GDP do you want to see?

MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 08:14

Comedycook · 24/11/2023 08:08

I agree the boats are irrelevant in the numbers...3/4 million people and it will be legal migration in the main. It beggars belief to increase the population by over 1% every year then wonder why we have a housing crisis.

How do you intend to raise the tax revenue we need to pay our pensions without immigration?

People who oppose immigration won't discuss the economic impact of restricting it.

Student immigration, for example, bring billions into our economy. Do you want to be poorer without that income?

Swipe left for the next trending thread