Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Europen governments need to respond to immigration?

564 replies

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 06:45

So the Netherlands is going to have a far right government.
Sweden has moved to the right.
Finland has shut its borders.
Countries that have traditionally been liberal are hardening and irrespective of the many issues listed its to do with immigration.

Ireland has seen violent protests last night following a series of stabbings.
In the UK we obviously had Brexit.

I think governments need to start responding to voters feelings on immigration as if they don't we will continue to see a general slide to the right in Europe, when actually these countries aren't right wing: it feels like a single issue is distorting the entire political landscape?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 09:05

I also think the debate post 2020 has moved beyond "They are stealing our jobs/taking our housing" and it is much more about identity and cultural aspects now, which again, economics cannot be used to debate

OP posts:
MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 09:03

sanluca · 24/11/2023 08:57

The mainstream right, the center and the mainstream left do take the issues seriously.

No, they don't. They actually makes things worse by stopping new build of housing for environmental reasons, clearly prioritising approved immigrants for social housing, building asylum centres in small villages in the countryside so that the asylum seekers outnumber the people living there and then sticking their fingers in their ears when people ask how to deal with all the issues that arise.

If you vote for a racist party (e.g. Wilders), either you support the racism (so you are also racist) or you overlook the racism (which I consider to be foolish).
A quarter of the voters of Wilders are first or second generation immigrants themselves. Are they racist too?
Wilders is actually a weird mix of right and left: right on immigration and diversity/multi cultural issues, left on housing, benefits, healthcare. This is why a lot of people vote for him, that weird mix.

*I do not understand what is wrong with saying this - am I supposed to pretend racism is reasonable?

If you vote for a racist party (e.g. Wilders), either you support the racism (so you are also racist) or you overlook the racism (which I consider to be foolish).*

You are not listening to what I am saying. People are voting for him for other reasons than racism because they deem those other reasons to be more important. Plus I know a lot of people know that he will have to form a coalition, probably with SNC, which will water down some of his more extreme ideas. Every government in the Netherlands ends up slightly right of slightly left of the middle because there is never a single ruling party.

I do not understand what is wrong with saying this - am I supposed to pretend racism is reasonable?

Missing the point again.

I'm not missing your point - I just don't agree with you.

My view is If you vote for a racist party (e.g. Wilders), either you support the racism (so you are also racist) or you overlook the racism (which I consider to be foolish).

You say: A quarter of the voters of Wilders are first or second generation immigrants themselves. Are they racist too? They may be racist or foolish, in my opinion.

I don't personally think his policies will benefit the Netherlands, therefore I think it is foolish to vote for him.

I am a liberal. I accept the right of voters to vote as they wish. I don't have to be supportive of their thought processes.

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 09:02

I think what European countries (or their electorate) are saying is that they don't care about the economic benefit.
Brexit showed us that people were willing to take a financial or economic hit in exchange for less immigration.
That is the shift that is happening. The economics no longer matter and can no longer be used as an argument.

OP posts:
MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 08:57

blackpear · 24/11/2023 08:53

Gordon Brown did engage with Gillian Duffy actually. He spoke to her pleasantly, but forgot his mike was on when expressing his views in private.

Yes this is my recollection.

It is difficult for politicians, they must be polite even if the questioner is aggressive.

If his mic had been off, it would have been quite unremarkable.

sanluca · 24/11/2023 08:57

The mainstream right, the center and the mainstream left do take the issues seriously.

No, they don't. They actually makes things worse by stopping new build of housing for environmental reasons, clearly prioritising approved immigrants for social housing, building asylum centres in small villages in the countryside so that the asylum seekers outnumber the people living there and then sticking their fingers in their ears when people ask how to deal with all the issues that arise.

If you vote for a racist party (e.g. Wilders), either you support the racism (so you are also racist) or you overlook the racism (which I consider to be foolish).
A quarter of the voters of Wilders are first or second generation immigrants themselves. Are they racist too?
Wilders is actually a weird mix of right and left: right on immigration and diversity/multi cultural issues, left on housing, benefits, healthcare. This is why a lot of people vote for him, that weird mix.

*I do not understand what is wrong with saying this - am I supposed to pretend racism is reasonable?

If you vote for a racist party (e.g. Wilders), either you support the racism (so you are also racist) or you overlook the racism (which I consider to be foolish).*

You are not listening to what I am saying. People are voting for him for other reasons than racism because they deem those other reasons to be more important. Plus I know a lot of people know that he will have to form a coalition, probably with SNC, which will water down some of his more extreme ideas. Every government in the Netherlands ends up slightly right of slightly left of the middle because there is never a single ruling party.

I do not understand what is wrong with saying this - am I supposed to pretend racism is reasonable?

Missing the point again.

Seymour5 · 24/11/2023 08:56

Sparthan · 24/11/2023 07:26

The lack of dealing with immigration is what caused Brexit. The vote was highly influenced by media stories at the time about crowds of young men in Calais. Remain totally refused to even address it, leading everyone with concerns to vote Leave. This is now happening on a wider scale.

Imo the main problem is not immigration per se, but immigration of men from countries which have non-Western attitudes to women. They arrive here and see women confidently walking around, wearing what they like and showing some skin. At best it leads to disrespect, at worst to sex crimes. I do have concerns about my own safety if the numbers of such men increase further.

In some areas the negative views of immigration had nothing to do with the boats, it was after Tony Blair’s government in 2004 opened our borders to the A8 countries that some people’s lives started to really be affected. Only Sweden and Ireland did the same at that time, and so there was a huge influx to the UK.

For instance, one suburb in Sheffield is home to around 6000 Roma from Slovakia. It was a fairly diverse and deprived community, but there have been serious tensions since large numbers of Roma moved there. David Blunkett, who was the Labour MP for many years there was quoted ten years ago by the BBC expressing concerns about the lack of integration. The police took over a house there, and things appear to be quieter, but the impact on the existing community was widely reported, noisy gatherings, indiscriminate rubbish dumping, big groups fighting in the streets, and issues in the local schools. If the people in power had the same daily reality, they might not be so quick to call people racist?

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-24909979

David Blunkett riot fear over Roma migrant tensions

Former Home Secretary David Blunkett says he fears riots unless the Roma migrant community make more of an effort to adapt to the British way of life.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-24909979

LickleLamb · 24/11/2023 08:55

The other thing about lots of people coming in in large numbers is that they aren;t processed properly and also there risks an increase to the black economy whilst people hang around waiting for visa or job. Our Justice system is broke - no one will be prosecuted for anything, This doesn't bode well for the UK in the future.

Notonthestairs · 24/11/2023 08:55

Universities are one of our few success stories - worth £30 billion a year.

There is an economic benefit to current migration numbers that the Government knows from but will not openly discuss.

So we have a Government that tells voters one thing (migration is bad) whilst doing something completely different and then blaming everyone else.

Until the Government are honest about why they have liberalised the Visa system we will continue going around like this.

MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 08:54

Sarahconnor1 · 24/11/2023 08:43

Honestly it's like banging my head against a brick wall.

It wasn't Gillian Duffy's job to engage, she asked a question. It was Gordon Brown's job to engage, he didn't, he just insulted her.

What category of immigration do you want to cut?

I haven't said I wanted immigration cut, read my posts back.

What I am saying for the fourth time is, If politicians refuse to listen or engage, on any subject, people make their voices heard at the ballot box.

Edited

Gillian Duffy didn't 'ask a question'. She started from an anti-inmigrant position.

Brown was wrong to say what he said, but correct in his assessment of her starting position.

PR-wise I agree, politicians would be wise to ignore the starting point of someone like Duffy and answer the questions in good faith.

But there are some (too many, sadly) who are bigoted and policy should never pander to that, even if presentation must accommodate it.

blackpear · 24/11/2023 08:53

Gordon Brown did engage with Gillian Duffy actually. He spoke to her pleasantly, but forgot his mike was on when expressing his views in private.

gannett · 24/11/2023 08:53

European governments need to respond to immigration by being bold enough to make the case for its economic necessity and cultural benefits, and the fact that it's an inherent part of human life.

They also need to respond by fixing the deep-rooted issues of economic deprivation and inequality in their societies, for which they currently blame immigration rather than cronyism and neoliberal capitalism.

As it is the same pattern keeps repeating itself. "Centrist" parties have no interest in changing the system, even though it doesn't work for so many people, and so they borrow the anti-immigrant rhetoric of the far right to manufacture a scapegoat. They do it in more polite language but the thing is, if you foment anti-immigrant feeling among voters, then voters will go to the real thing.

LickleLamb · 24/11/2023 08:52

Political Fix podcast pointed out that when people are asked specifically which type of immigrants they don't want... the only specifics are irregular and bankers (both tiny % of total).

@lljkk This is what made me think people are clueless when it comes to numbers - how can three quarters of a million incomers annually in a country with a population of 65 million not be an issue - other European countries do not have nearly this amount (discounting Ukrainians).
When DH worked in the USA he had a work visa - certainly not a residence visa and he had to be interviewed by an expert in his profession (Uni professor) to be allowed in at all.

lljkk · 24/11/2023 08:52

On Radio4 about 6:50am... Net Zero "train our own people" : does that mean all the people on long term sick benefits need to "get back to work" ? I just wondered what "our own people" are doing instead of working in UK right now.

I tried to figure out who the people are that should be taking UK jobs that new immigrants got. This list only adds up to 65.4 million, who have I missed? Which of these groups needs to provide workers to make up for 300k+ immigrants entering the UK workforce each year?

Retired people in UK: 11.9 million
Economically active, 27.8 million (not who NetZero meant)
(Unemployed, of the EA, about 4.2%) 1.1676 million
Economically inactive, most of them are long term sick, 9 million
Children (under age 17) 12 million
Students: 2.9 million (but some of them are also working...)

Comedycook · 24/11/2023 08:50

MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 08:48

A huge chunk of that is students. Plus Ukraine/HK. Plus health workers. Plus other workers replacing EU workers.

Which would you cut?

Students.

Let the universities collapse. Who cares.

Sourisblanche · 24/11/2023 08:50

I’m not saying I want to cut anything, I thought it would be useful to post some actual numbers. I’m married to an immigrant!

Kwer · 24/11/2023 08:49

In 2010, a voter called Gillian Duffy asked Gordon Brown what he was going to do about immigration. He dismissed her as a ‘bigoted woman’. That superior attitude where politicians ignored voters’ concerns ultimately led to the rise of Boris Johnson 🤮 and Brexit 😭

Net immigration to the UK is too high. And the whole concept of freedom of movement within the EU has failed. It’s a huge problem and yes, when liberal politicians ignore voters’ concerns, the voters fire those politicians and replace them with incompetent liars.

MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 08:48

Sourisblanche · 24/11/2023 08:46

This is post Brexit immigration:

A huge chunk of that is students. Plus Ukraine/HK. Plus health workers. Plus other workers replacing EU workers.

Which would you cut?

bombastix · 24/11/2023 08:47

Sourisblanche · 24/11/2023 08:44

Some immigration numbers from the FT:

In the YE June 2023, the top five non-EU nationalities for immigration flows into the UK were: Indian (253,000), Nigerian (141,000),
Chinese (89,000), Pakistani (55,000) and
Ukrainian (35,000).

Unless there is a substantial change in the policy of the UK you can expect these to grow. The UK is concluding trade deals with visa access; obviously the greater the economic disparity between countries then the more incentives to move. A post Brexit legacy.

Sourisblanche · 24/11/2023 08:46

This is post Brexit immigration:

To think Europen governments need to respond to immigration?
MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 08:45

GreyhpundGirl · 24/11/2023 08:37

That's what the government is mooting, especially for student visas.

This would reduce the numbers, but cut the income the UK receives from this stream.

Those who come are not supported by the state other than schooling. They have health insurance.

They spend money here, supporting businesses and paying VAT.

Why do you want to reduce this income stream?

What matters to you - the number, or the economic cost/benefit?

MintJulia · 24/11/2023 08:45

@CharlotteRumpling 'Some of this is already happening as the UK is now importing nurses from India and the Philippines to replace the Polish ones they threw out.'

That's completely inaccurate.

India and the Philippines have been the top sources for overseas nurses for decades. (I work in the sector). Nothing to do with Polish nurses at all. And no-one was 'thrown-out'. Anyone working here had the right to 'leave to remain'.

Sourisblanche · 24/11/2023 08:44

Some immigration numbers from the FT:

In the YE June 2023, the top five non-EU nationalities for immigration flows into the UK were: Indian (253,000), Nigerian (141,000),
Chinese (89,000), Pakistani (55,000) and
Ukrainian (35,000).

Sarahconnor1 · 24/11/2023 08:43

MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 08:18

Gillian Duffy wasn't engaging either.

The reality is, for example, student immigration brings in huge amounts of money and provides high paid jobs which raise taxes.

What category of immigration do you want to cut? What decline in GDP do you want to see?

Honestly it's like banging my head against a brick wall.

It wasn't Gillian Duffy's job to engage, she asked a question. It was Gordon Brown's job to engage, he didn't, he just insulted her.

What category of immigration do you want to cut?

I haven't said I wanted immigration cut, read my posts back.

What I am saying for the fourth time is, If politicians refuse to listen or engage, on any subject, people make their voices heard at the ballot box.

bombastix · 24/11/2023 08:43

The issue of dependency and visas for students is ridiculous. All this means is that in practice, an Article 8 claim under the ECHR is built up over time (right to a private life). That then ends up with other legal processes if a student overstays with their family. Likewise spousal visas.

This government is hypocritical. It could change this if it wanted. But it does not.

MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 08:42

sanluca · 24/11/2023 08:30

*Midnightoncemore:

There is a difference between right wing and far right.

If you vote for a party that is racist, you are either also a racist or a fool.

If you vote regular right wing, that's different.*

It really does not help when anyone tries to encapsulate complex voting behaviour in a single one line that calls people names and focuses on an issue that is not even the main reason people voted for a party. It just smacks of sour grapes and an unwilligness to engage.

The real question is why do center and left wing parties not take people's concerns about lack of housing and healtchare seriously?

The mainstream right, the center and the mainstream left do take the issues seriously.

If you vote for a racist party (e.g. Wilders), either you support the racism (so you are also racist) or you overlook the racism (which I consider to be foolish).

I do not understand what is wrong with saying this - am I supposed to pretend racism is reasonable?

Swipe left for the next trending thread