Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Europen governments need to respond to immigration?

564 replies

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 06:45

So the Netherlands is going to have a far right government.
Sweden has moved to the right.
Finland has shut its borders.
Countries that have traditionally been liberal are hardening and irrespective of the many issues listed its to do with immigration.

Ireland has seen violent protests last night following a series of stabbings.
In the UK we obviously had Brexit.

I think governments need to start responding to voters feelings on immigration as if they don't we will continue to see a general slide to the right in Europe, when actually these countries aren't right wing: it feels like a single issue is distorting the entire political landscape?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
Myfabby · 24/11/2023 10:49

IMustDoMoreExercise · 24/11/2023 10:48

I was talking about the last 100 years, not the middles ages.

People only care about recent history,

only ignorant people care about recent history. You can't pick and choose what suits your narrative.

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 10:49

What I don't get is why after decades and decades of huge emigration, the Internet, a more globalised world, countries outside Europe haven't started thinking "hmmm, maybe those guys have got something, maybe we should create secular democracies too".

I also don't buy that "the west" is responsible for financial and political instability that creates mass immigration outside Europe. Don't these countries have governments?

OP posts:
MrTiddlesTheCat · 24/11/2023 10:49

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 07:14

@Pooooochi
I agree with your idea. Maybe we could remove people's ability to apply for their families to come over and join them as a starting point

'We'll take your hard labour for the benefit of ourselves but your kids can fuck off.' What a way to attract the brightest and best to Global Britain.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 24/11/2023 10:48

AdamRyan · 24/11/2023 10:40

This is just not true.
Large parts of southern Europe were Muslim until the middle ages - that was what drove the Crusades
There has always been movement of people who are being persecuted e.g. the Jewish diaspora in Roman times
There has always been movement across empires from colonised countries
And in prehistory there were waves of migration that we can track in our genetics.

Humans are a species that move around, there's really no such thing as "indigenous" in Europe, its a fiction people tell themselves to justify their innate xenophobia

I was talking about the last 100 years, not the middles ages.

People only care about recent history,

cansu · 24/11/2023 10:46

I think our government need to stop spouting rubbish and should start recognising that we need immigration to staff our health and social care sector. My fs is cared for by people who have come into the country on visas like this. They are kind and hard working. They are badly needed by this sector. The government know this and yet here we have Robert Jenrick trying g to prevent these visas being issued. This shows they are using immigration as a political football rather than considering what our country needs.

skyknight · 24/11/2023 10:46

I really hate the way anyone opposed to the importation of violent people from cultures that have no respect for women, other religions, minorities, homosexuals are always smeared as "far-right". Surely it is these ideologies that are "far-right", not the politicians or voters who are opposed to such things?

Myfabby · 24/11/2023 10:46

Dbank · 24/11/2023 10:39

I think the OP is right, especially in the light of the 2022 net migration figures of 750K for the U.K.

While we may benefit from their cheaper labour costs, they still add to the pressure on housing, benefits, schooling, healthcare etc. Yes I know they pay taxes, but generally low amounts if at all.

I may be wrong, but I expect the conservatives to take a harder line, and will be rewarded for it in the next election, they seem better at reacting to the national sentiment, than how people think in North London.

You need to support your thinking with facts.

For one, The largest contributor to non-EU immigration (39%) was study. Students paying 3x as much as home fees. What benefits are they claiming? They in fact heavily subisidize home student fees.

No one chooses to read the entire report. The number of people emigrating out of the UK long term was 508,000 in the same period.

Dotjones · 24/11/2023 10:45

AdamRyan · 24/11/2023 10:40

This is just not true.
Large parts of southern Europe were Muslim until the middle ages - that was what drove the Crusades
There has always been movement of people who are being persecuted e.g. the Jewish diaspora in Roman times
There has always been movement across empires from colonised countries
And in prehistory there were waves of migration that we can track in our genetics.

Humans are a species that move around, there's really no such thing as "indigenous" in Europe, its a fiction people tell themselves to justify their innate xenophobia

See also the Mongols who conquered their way from the Far East to Europe.

The whole idea that Europe never faced mass immigration is ludicrous. I thought it was commonly accepted that human life began in Africa. Literally everyone in Europe is descended from someone who migrated here. That's why it's so important to stop it happening now.

bombastix · 24/11/2023 10:42

this government are actually in charge of the migration policy and 1.2 million people entered the U.K. legally in the last two years. That's not on a bunch of North Londoners who aren't in government, it's Tory policy.

Change it, okay. But don't give them credit if you think migration is an issue. It's never been greater.

EasternStandard · 24/11/2023 10:42

TempestTost · 24/11/2023 10:23

I think it's inevitable this will happen.

That being said, you really have to talk about the refugee system, and then other kinds of immigration.

Both are important but the refugee system is where there is a huge problem on the horizon that is not just up to individual countries to deal with, and the systems and many regulations are essentially international.But it's a system that was crafted at a very different time, and it's simply inadequate to manage what's coming. Part of the reason (not the only reason) it's those small countries that are responding first is that in such a small place it's clear that it would be possible to be overwhelmed very easily. No one can fool themselves that they can absorb so many people, either in terms of the infrastructure of social democracy, or in terms of maintaining a distinct social fabric.

The majority of people IMO see this and want to try and find solutions, but it's extremely difficult. My sense is that they are going to end up being an investment in creating stability in people's own places.But then I can't really see that as being adequately effective either.

But certain sections of the progressive left seem to want to make it impossible to even get to a place where such discussions can happen, because they are so convinced that the answer is just, let people go where they want, the west should support them anyway as a kind of penance. And that will end up with people moving more right, politically, in terms of voting choices. This is one of those areas where you get a funny historical blindness, as it was at one time widely understood that the kinds of infrastructure you find in social democracies requires a relatively small, stable population with controls on immigration.

The other issue of course is managing declining population. One thing that will have to happen is a better approach to getting our own workers into the jobs we need, when they maybe aren't considered the most glamorous (farm work for example), and also training people properly rather than relying on poaching trained people from other countries to work cheap (or not so cheap.). Mechanization may come into this somewhat, though my intuition is that will be a mixed blessing.

This is a good post, sums it up well

AdamRyan · 24/11/2023 10:40

IMustDoMoreExercise · 24/11/2023 10:07

Because Europe has never had mass immigration from non-white and non-Christian countries in the past.

Europe has been anti-semetic and so there is no reason why it can't be racist as well faced with mass non-white and non Christian immigration.

This is just not true.
Large parts of southern Europe were Muslim until the middle ages - that was what drove the Crusades
There has always been movement of people who are being persecuted e.g. the Jewish diaspora in Roman times
There has always been movement across empires from colonised countries
And in prehistory there were waves of migration that we can track in our genetics.

Humans are a species that move around, there's really no such thing as "indigenous" in Europe, its a fiction people tell themselves to justify their innate xenophobia

Myfabby · 24/11/2023 10:40

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 24/11/2023 10:36

I think governments need to start responding to voters feelings on immigration as if they don't we will continue to see a general slide to the right in Europe

Indeed, and they can start by focusing on something they have more control over....emigration.

Time for Europeans to put their money where their mouths are and ban all outward migration from their countries. If you don't want them coming here then you shouldn't want us going there.

However, I imagine any attempt at something like that would be met with outrage, seen as an attack on the human rights, and be political suicide.

This!

Imagine suggesting as some have that migration should be limited to women only, or young men only. So Tom can move to Spain, but has to leave his wife of 15 years behind? Hilarious thinking

Dbank · 24/11/2023 10:39

I think the OP is right, especially in the light of the 2022 net migration figures of 750K for the U.K.

While we may benefit from their cheaper labour costs, they still add to the pressure on housing, benefits, schooling, healthcare etc. Yes I know they pay taxes, but generally low amounts if at all.

I may be wrong, but I expect the conservatives to take a harder line, and will be rewarded for it in the next election, they seem better at reacting to the national sentiment, than how people think in North London.

shockeditellyou · 24/11/2023 10:39

I think the other uncomfortable truth is that since Brexit, wages have generally increased as there has been a significant staff shortage, compounded by the effects of the pandemic. So all of those tradesmen who were undercut by better quality Eastern Europeans saw their circumstances materially improve, which doesn't exactly hurt anti-immigration feeling.
https://www.reuters.com/world/uk/uk-sees-fastest-wage-rises-sectors-most-reliant-eu-workers-indeed-2022-02-25/

The City of London financial district is seen in London, Britain, October 22, 2021. REUTERS/Hannah McKay

UK sees fastest wage rises in sectors most reliant on EU workers - Indeed

British wages are rising fastest in low-paid sectors where employers previously relied on workers from the European Union, new analysis from recruitment agency Indeed showed on Friday.

https://www.reuters.com/world/uk/uk-sees-fastest-wage-rises-sectors-most-reliant-eu-workers-indeed-2022-02-25/

TempestTost · 24/11/2023 10:37

SailAwayOnSummerDays · 24/11/2023 09:27

I sometimes wonder if people especially on MN get worked up about immigration and want to be seen as very welcoming because of post imperialist guilt and colonial history. I’m not white though born here, my ancestors are from a Commonwealth country and fully integrated coming over in the late 1950’s. I even worked for the NHS for six years, what a stereotype of the sort of immigrant outcome people want.

When people mention cultural enrichment some cultures don’t bring anything that is enriching with their quite frankly medieval attitudes towards women.

I think there is some of this. THere is a regular poster here on MN who, when this is discussed, says straight out that the UK needs to accept whoever wants to come because they were historical oppressors and now need to pay their dues. I've certainly heard the same from other individuals as well.

But I think you are right overall. It's not just a matter of particular attitudes though, IMO. ANy time you have large numbers of newcomers, it strains the social fabric. IN fact this even happens due to citizens within the country moving around a lot for jobs, you just don't get the kinds of resilient, integrated communities that support individuals and families.

That being said, the UK has always been pretty good, comparatively, about accepting newcomers. (Though it's worth watching the film Trevor Phillips made about multiculturalsm a few years ago, he basically argues that contrary to his hopes when he was in government, even in places like London there isn't real integration.) But at a certain point you simply overwhelm the existing social fabric. Where I live now over 20% of the population now were not born here. That is a lot, it begins to look like they are not going to be integrated so much as transform the community into something quite new. And you kind of think, surely the people who live here already should have some kind of say in that?

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 24/11/2023 10:36

I think governments need to start responding to voters feelings on immigration as if they don't we will continue to see a general slide to the right in Europe

Indeed, and they can start by focusing on something they have more control over....emigration.

Time for Europeans to put their money where their mouths are and ban all outward migration from their countries. If you don't want them coming here then you shouldn't want us going there.

However, I imagine any attempt at something like that would be met with outrage, seen as an attack on the human rights, and be political suicide.

JellyMops · 24/11/2023 10:31

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 09:02

I think what European countries (or their electorate) are saying is that they don't care about the economic benefit.
Brexit showed us that people were willing to take a financial or economic hit in exchange for less immigration.
That is the shift that is happening. The economics no longer matter and can no longer be used as an argument.

I wouldn't say that. Brexiters said there would be no downsides, only upsides, the idea that people knew there would be an economic hit from Brexit wasn't mentioned until AFTER it started to become obvious. Most people voted for Brexit because austerity had made them poorer and Brexiters promised them higher wages and cheaper food and goods.

The economics DO still matter which is why all the European right wing political parties dialled back on their promises to leave the EU after Brexit.

TempestTost · 24/11/2023 10:23

I think it's inevitable this will happen.

That being said, you really have to talk about the refugee system, and then other kinds of immigration.

Both are important but the refugee system is where there is a huge problem on the horizon that is not just up to individual countries to deal with, and the systems and many regulations are essentially international.But it's a system that was crafted at a very different time, and it's simply inadequate to manage what's coming. Part of the reason (not the only reason) it's those small countries that are responding first is that in such a small place it's clear that it would be possible to be overwhelmed very easily. No one can fool themselves that they can absorb so many people, either in terms of the infrastructure of social democracy, or in terms of maintaining a distinct social fabric.

The majority of people IMO see this and want to try and find solutions, but it's extremely difficult. My sense is that they are going to end up being an investment in creating stability in people's own places.But then I can't really see that as being adequately effective either.

But certain sections of the progressive left seem to want to make it impossible to even get to a place where such discussions can happen, because they are so convinced that the answer is just, let people go where they want, the west should support them anyway as a kind of penance. And that will end up with people moving more right, politically, in terms of voting choices. This is one of those areas where you get a funny historical blindness, as it was at one time widely understood that the kinds of infrastructure you find in social democracies requires a relatively small, stable population with controls on immigration.

The other issue of course is managing declining population. One thing that will have to happen is a better approach to getting our own workers into the jobs we need, when they maybe aren't considered the most glamorous (farm work for example), and also training people properly rather than relying on poaching trained people from other countries to work cheap (or not so cheap.). Mechanization may come into this somewhat, though my intuition is that will be a mixed blessing.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 24/11/2023 10:21

EasternStandard · 24/11/2023 10:16

You can study economics all you like, it doesn’t mean controlled immigration isn’t a reasonable idea

Where that level of control is set will differ between people, even those with knowledge of economics will have a view of where that is

Yes, if you studied economics then you would see that uncontrolled immigration is a bad idea.

Luckily we voted for Brexit despite people not having studied economics but it was pure luck and close.

I was really referring to other issues where people think that we have unlimited resouces because they don't understand about the level of debt that all Western countries have.

EasternStandard · 24/11/2023 10:16

IMustDoMoreExercise · 24/11/2023 10:13

Unfortunately, most people who vote have never studied economics. A lot of people don't even have a basic graps of maths.

Unless you have to pass an economics exam before you can vote (and I think that you should), then people are going to vote with their hearts.

You just need to read the rubbish on here when people go on about us being the 5th richest country and totally ingnore the trillions of debt that we have ( just like most Western countries).

You can study economics all you like, it doesn’t mean controlled immigration isn’t a reasonable idea

Where that level of control is set will differ between people, even those with knowledge of economics will have a view of where that is

IMustDoMoreExercise · 24/11/2023 10:16

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 24/11/2023 09:47

No, but it showed the contempt that was felt for anyone who differed from the ‘right-thinking’ line that Plenty Of Immigration Is A Very Good Thing.

And we still don’t have anything like enough decent, affordable housing for those people who are already here.

Yes exactly this.

GB sowed the seeds of discontent. Why do you think people voted for a buffoon like Boris? Because GB looked down on them and called them racist. Boris didn't.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 24/11/2023 10:13

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/11/2023 09:49

People might think that the economics don't matter. I suspect they might feel rather differently about the reality.

Unfortunately, most people who vote have never studied economics. A lot of people don't even have a basic graps of maths.

Unless you have to pass an economics exam before you can vote (and I think that you should), then people are going to vote with their hearts.

You just need to read the rubbish on here when people go on about us being the 5th richest country and totally ingnore the trillions of debt that we have ( just like most Western countries).

IMustDoMoreExercise · 24/11/2023 10:07

NutellaEllaElla · 24/11/2023 07:07

Why would Europe be more ignorant and racist now than ever before in history? I think you're wrong on that one.

Because Europe has never had mass immigration from non-white and non-Christian countries in the past.

Europe has been anti-semetic and so there is no reason why it can't be racist as well faced with mass non-white and non Christian immigration.

Pooooochi · 24/11/2023 10:06

Governments are very focussed on size of the economy but distribution of the wealth generated matters as much and more, otherwise you can have a huge economy and only a tiny proportion of people within it benefitting. Capitalism concentrates wealth because it allocates too great a share of the overall growth/return of the economy to owners of capital, rather than to labour. The whole point of socialism is to to intervene to even it out.