Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Europen governments need to respond to immigration?

564 replies

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 06:45

So the Netherlands is going to have a far right government.
Sweden has moved to the right.
Finland has shut its borders.
Countries that have traditionally been liberal are hardening and irrespective of the many issues listed its to do with immigration.

Ireland has seen violent protests last night following a series of stabbings.
In the UK we obviously had Brexit.

I think governments need to start responding to voters feelings on immigration as if they don't we will continue to see a general slide to the right in Europe, when actually these countries aren't right wing: it feels like a single issue is distorting the entire political landscape?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
Yetmorebeanstocount · 24/11/2023 14:32

Notonthestairs · 24/11/2023 08:55

Universities are one of our few success stories - worth £30 billion a year.

There is an economic benefit to current migration numbers that the Government knows from but will not openly discuss.

So we have a Government that tells voters one thing (migration is bad) whilst doing something completely different and then blaming everyone else.

Until the Government are honest about why they have liberalised the Visa system we will continue going around like this.

Worth £30 billion to whom? 'Economic benefit' to whom?

We don't all benefit equally from 'the economy'. This point is so often ignored or glossed over.
Migration that benefits the wealthy in this country can be of direct detriment to the poorer majority.

We are most definitely not 'all in this together'.

inamarina · 24/11/2023 14:02

Seymour5 · 24/11/2023 08:56

In some areas the negative views of immigration had nothing to do with the boats, it was after Tony Blair’s government in 2004 opened our borders to the A8 countries that some people’s lives started to really be affected. Only Sweden and Ireland did the same at that time, and so there was a huge influx to the UK.

For instance, one suburb in Sheffield is home to around 6000 Roma from Slovakia. It was a fairly diverse and deprived community, but there have been serious tensions since large numbers of Roma moved there. David Blunkett, who was the Labour MP for many years there was quoted ten years ago by the BBC expressing concerns about the lack of integration. The police took over a house there, and things appear to be quieter, but the impact on the existing community was widely reported, noisy gatherings, indiscriminate rubbish dumping, big groups fighting in the streets, and issues in the local schools. If the people in power had the same daily reality, they might not be so quick to call people racist?

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-24909979

Sounds like some areas in our town.
Large, noisy gatherings (of mostly men) in town centre, rubbish and old furniture piling up in front gardens, many incidents of shoplifting...
I’m an immigrant myself, and a remainer at heart, but I must say I can’t really blame the locals in our town who decided to vote pro Brexit.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/11/2023 13:16

AdamRyan · 24/11/2023 13:10

the letter states that families still have no explanation as to why French and British authorities failed the people onboard a sinking dinghy who repeatedly called for help.

It's ridiculous for families to ask why British and French authorities let their relatives drown, knowing they were in difficulty at sea?
Really? That seems pretty cold hearted

Yeah, I mean, it's insane for the families to expect that there might be a bit of basic decency... it's almost as if they think that their relatives should have been treated like real human beings. Ridiculous indeed.

Hmm
AdamRyan · 24/11/2023 13:10

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 12:32

the letter states that families still have no explanation as to why French and British authorities failed the people onboard a sinking dinghy who repeatedly called for help.

It's ridiculous for families to ask why British and French authorities let their relatives drown, knowing they were in difficulty at sea?
Really? That seems pretty cold hearted

Pregnant woman and three children among 27 drowned in Channel

Victims mostly Kurds from Iraq or Iran, say French authorities, as criminal investigation begins

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/nov/25/drowned-people-were-mostly-kurds-from-iraq-or-iran-says-france

londonmummy1966 · 24/11/2023 12:54

Notonthestairs · 24/11/2023 08:55

Universities are one of our few success stories - worth £30 billion a year.

There is an economic benefit to current migration numbers that the Government knows from but will not openly discuss.

So we have a Government that tells voters one thing (migration is bad) whilst doing something completely different and then blaming everyone else.

Until the Government are honest about why they have liberalised the Visa system we will continue going around like this.

In financial terms.... I'm not sure that it quite that straightforward in other terms. There are a lot of threads on here about DC with 4 A star at A level not being able to get onto top economics courses despite the fact that lots of foreign students are enrolled. There are quite a few threads (and I also know young people saying the same) that those who do get on those courses are then getting almost no small group tuition as the course is taught in vast lectures and a lot of the international students struggle with the language taking up big chunks of scarce seminar time as they ask the same questions week after week. Not exactly the best way to train our own talent for the financial services that are our no 1 source of revenue.

In smaller prestigious institutions like our conservatoires the course places are limited and the vast majority now go to international students despite there being more than enough UK students wanting to go (in some cases we are looking at 80 -90% international students on very in demand courses). Not exactly the best way to train our own talent for the arts that are our no 2 source of revenue.

CharlotteRumpling · 24/11/2023 12:45

It's very difficult to know what groups to cut. A lot of posters want to exclude men from certain communities. Much of our NHS is staffed by people from these communities.Not sure we can make a clear distinction between a good immigrant and a bad immigrant.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/11/2023 12:42

CharlotteRumpling · 24/11/2023 12:38

I think people are arguing that the benefit calculation is wrong

OK. So they don't really mean "uncontrolled immigration". They mean that they disagree with the approach to controlling it.

The interesting part for me is that, when people are asked about individual groups of immigrants - such as NHS workers, carers, students etc - they are generally happy for them to be here. It would be good to hear from people about which specific groups that they would want to cut, and what impact they believe that cutting that particular group might have.

CharlotteRumpling · 24/11/2023 12:38

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/11/2023 12:22

People talk a lot about "uncontrolled immigration". I'm really curious to know what people understand by this.

Now that FOM is no longer a thing, the vast majority of migration into this country is controlled - irregular arrivals only account for a very small percentage of total immigration figures, so the vast majority of immigrants have been granted visas to come here because our government has determined that there is a net benefit to the UK in allowing them to be here. Now, you can argue all you like that the benefit calculation may have been wrong, but I don't see where the perception comes in that it is uncontrolled.

Is it simply that, when people say "uncontrolled", they actually just mean "too high for my liking"? Or is it that they have bought into the government's narrative about the UK being invaded by small boats, and they assume that irregular arrivals account for most of the net migration figures?

I think people are arguing that the benefit calculation is wrong

MoonLife · 24/11/2023 12:33

For all of those who welcome mass immigration, where on earth do you live? I counter its not in the densely packed inner city areas where resources are stretched to breaking point and community tensions are at an all time high?

OP posts:
Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 12:30

The difference with being leered at by English builders is we don't actually have a choice regarding them

OP posts:
EasternStandard · 24/11/2023 12:29

The figure is a bit high, we need university students and other stuff but I’d try hard to get it down wherever it’s not needed

Aus is a good system for being pretty strict

On asylum I agree with @KnittedCardi the system won’t cope with climate pressure related mass migration

Myfabby · 24/11/2023 12:27

LickleLamb · 24/11/2023 12:26

Too high for my liking -we haven’t added to hospitals, roads, housing (adequately). , rail, nhs etc etc for decades, far too many for any sensible persons liking

and this is down to the immigrants right?

LickleLamb · 24/11/2023 12:26

Too high for my liking -we haven’t added to hospitals, roads, housing (adequately). , rail, nhs etc etc for decades, far too many for any sensible persons liking

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/11/2023 12:22

People talk a lot about "uncontrolled immigration". I'm really curious to know what people understand by this.

Now that FOM is no longer a thing, the vast majority of migration into this country is controlled - irregular arrivals only account for a very small percentage of total immigration figures, so the vast majority of immigrants have been granted visas to come here because our government has determined that there is a net benefit to the UK in allowing them to be here. Now, you can argue all you like that the benefit calculation may have been wrong, but I don't see where the perception comes in that it is uncontrolled.

Is it simply that, when people say "uncontrolled", they actually just mean "too high for my liking"? Or is it that they have bought into the government's narrative about the UK being invaded by small boats, and they assume that irregular arrivals account for most of the net migration figures?

inamarina · 24/11/2023 12:11

Elastica23 · 24/11/2023 12:01

And it's not like those from the Ukraine can really go home for the foreseeable is it? I don't blame them for making longer term plans.

As I said, I’m not blaming them either.
I just think it’s important to see how people actually behave in real life, instead of just assuming that after spending some time in places like the UK they just happily go back when no longer needed.

inamarina · 24/11/2023 12:08

KinS24 · 24/11/2023 07:42

I always think people need to declare if they think Britain’s colonial past renders it wrong to control immigration at all. That affects stances so much that further conversation can be pointless.
There was a BBC report that said around 60% of young Pakistani males planned to try and go abroad for work.
There are 700,000 people waiting in Libya to make a crossing to Europe.
Personally I think it is sensible for politicians to prioritise this issue.
The UK is entitled to have borders and act in the interests of its people. There is too much activity in the interests of businesses (including universities) and the impact on the nation is not considered holistically.

Solutions? Resource Border Force properly. Increase use of detention and removal. Update the asylum laws. Pursue offshore processing for illegal entrants. More money for proper assimilation measures for those already here. Prioritise women and children in refugee visa schemes.
Immigration is good and welcome but we need to accept tough measures to protect the welfare of Europeans. Welfare states and uncontrolled immigration are not compatible so take your pick.

Welfare states and uncontrolled immigration are not compatible so take your pick.

I think this is such an important point.

therealcookiemonster · 24/11/2023 12:04

what politicians need to do is to stop using immigration as an easy vote winner by egging on racist sentiments.

European countries need immigration, we need bigger workforces. the politicians need to admit this and work on meaningful positive policies that help immigrants settle into communities.

blaming immigrants is an easy out for failing social policies

Myfabby · 24/11/2023 12:04

BethDuttonsTwin · 24/11/2023 11:57

It’s this kind of shaming and pretending people are saying things they’re not that has allowed so much resentment and anger to fester, and only stymies sensible balanced debate.

In absolutely no other circumstance would the solution to social problems or any problems really, be “yeah it’s really bad so let’s add loads more strain to the problem that’s already there!”

Beth, that's unfair and inaccurate. I am not shaming anyone

My point is a cross section of any society- any will be flawed. There has to be balance in all things. All of the UK's problems are not caused by immigration.

Elastica23 · 24/11/2023 12:01

inamarina · 24/11/2023 12:00

That’s a good point. I think that’s generally a bit of an issue with people who would describe themselves as pro-immigration, but mainly see immigrants as work force to fill undesirable jobs.
I think it’s different with temporary work visa between countries with a similar standard of living - a friend of mine went to New Zealand on a work and travel visa during uni, with no aim to try and stay there.
On the other hand, I know several Ukrainians who are either planning to stay in the UK or have already moved on to places like the US.
Can’t blame them really - I just think it’s a bit naive to think that people from poorer countries just come over for a bit, work in jobs locals don’t want to do, and then happily go back home (and I realise that Ukrainians didn’t come over as economic migrants, but I think my point still stands).

Edited

And it's not like those from the Ukraine can really go home for the foreseeable is it? I don't blame them for making longer term plans.

inamarina · 24/11/2023 12:00

OhYouBadBadKitten · 24/11/2023 07:39

Let me get this right. You want only single women to come here, without allowing them family support, to fill our low paid jobs?

Great Britain - the saviour nation.

That’s a good point. I think that’s generally a bit of an issue with people who would describe themselves as pro-immigration, but mainly see immigrants as work force to fill undesirable jobs.
I think it’s different with temporary work visa between countries with a similar standard of living - a friend of mine went to New Zealand on a work and travel visa during uni, with no aim to try and stay there.
On the other hand, I know several Ukrainians who are either planning to stay in the UK or have already moved on to places like the US.
Can’t blame them really - I just think it’s a bit naive to think that people from poorer countries just come over for a bit, work in jobs locals don’t want to do, and then happily go back home (and I realise that Ukrainians didn’t come over as economic migrants, but I think my point still stands).

TempestTost · 24/11/2023 11:57

Regarding mass immigration in the past - yes, of course this happened everywhere. But not usually peacefully where there was already a population. It's an inherently destabilizing situation.

There were places like the Roman Empire where there was significant movement within the empire, but that had quite a lot of empire-building, including at the cultural level, involved. The Romans were not shy about what they considered the superiority of Roman values.

BethDuttonsTwin · 24/11/2023 11:57

Myfabby · 24/11/2023 11:49

Are you saying crime and ghettos are only from immigrants? I absolutely hope not as you are competely wrong

https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/immigration-and-crime-evidence-for-the-uk-and-other-countries/

And the number of white builders that have leered at me with some downright disgusting sexual language- these are people with non medieval or religious beliefs, what do we say that to that then?

It’s this kind of shaming and pretending people are saying things they’re not that has allowed so much resentment and anger to fester, and only stymies sensible balanced debate.

In absolutely no other circumstance would the solution to social problems or any problems really, be “yeah it’s really bad so let’s add loads more strain to the problem that’s already there!”

Libertyy · 24/11/2023 11:57

Who are we counting as immigrants here, people who haven’t naturalised or/and people who have naturalised but weren’t born here?

Myfabby · 24/11/2023 11:49

Bigcoatweather · 24/11/2023 11:44

I think most people are fine with immigrants who are productive and respectful. The issue is with when they see their home country or their own values disrespected.
Integration and cohesion are an afterthought to the government, that’s what causes the problems, particularly if you’re letting people with medieval religious or social beliefs into a country where eg. Our women have equal rights and we have (thankfully) left behind a time when religion was forced on others.
I’m all for immigration. I’m not for being tutted at and overhearing from a group of Muslim males in the same BP petrol station shop that I should ‘cover up’ because I was in gym leggings and a big t-shirt after going to the gym and nipping in for milk.

Many people are not enjoying being told by angry minorities that their way of life is incorrect. People aren’t liking the crime and the ghettos that are appearing. People are sad for their country. That’s not bigotry.

Are you saying crime and ghettos are only from immigrants? I absolutely hope not as you are competely wrong

https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/immigration-and-crime-evidence-for-the-uk-and-other-countries/

And the number of white builders that have leered at me with some downright disgusting sexual language- these are people with non medieval or religious beliefs, what do we say that to that then?

Immigration and Crime: The UK and beyond - Migration Observatory

This briefing discusses the impact of immigration on crime, both in the UK and in an international context and reflects on the role of the labour market in the relationship between immigration and crime.

https://migrationobservatory.ox.ac.uk/resources/briefings/immigration-and-crime-evidence-for-the-uk-and-other-countries