Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Europen governments need to respond to immigration?

564 replies

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 06:45

So the Netherlands is going to have a far right government.
Sweden has moved to the right.
Finland has shut its borders.
Countries that have traditionally been liberal are hardening and irrespective of the many issues listed its to do with immigration.

Ireland has seen violent protests last night following a series of stabbings.
In the UK we obviously had Brexit.

I think governments need to start responding to voters feelings on immigration as if they don't we will continue to see a general slide to the right in Europe, when actually these countries aren't right wing: it feels like a single issue is distorting the entire political landscape?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
Yetmorebeanstocount · 24/11/2023 21:31

@MidnightOnceMore

The fact there are structural inequalities is a different issue.

I disagree. The structural inequalities pervade everything. Nothing is immune. Nothing is separate from effects of the gaping chasm between the the rich and the rest. Everything in public life, and in the fabric of our society, is poisoned by inequality.

The rich, and to a lesser extent the wealthy middle class, want migration because they want cheap labour. Cheaper employees in public services mean lower taxes, disproportionally benefiting the better off.
The rest are disadvantaged by undermined wage levels, competition for housing and services, and chronic insecurity.

bombastix · 24/11/2023 21:02

@SomeCatFromJapan - I think EU law effectively stated that welfare or benefits had to be received by EU nationals. You couldn't discriminate.

Since the UK is no longer a member, it could do something more like you describe, that is benefits or other systems prohibited, or no possible indefinite leave to remain or nationality application permitted. The UK is quite open on this, but it doesn't have to be.

Notonthestairs · 24/11/2023 20:37

British people tend to go to the Gulf states for the tax advantages don't they?
Is that what you are proposing?

SomeCatFromJapan · 24/11/2023 20:35

That's a shit system though! Immigrants deserve to be treated like, idk, proper humans? Lots of them are workers, and even those that are not deserve a base level of humanity

Can you explain how what I've described is not treating someone as a proper human? Bearing in mind people move there by choice due to better financial opportunities than are available in their home countries, including plently of British people.

Chickenkeev · 24/11/2023 20:26

SomeCatFromJapan · 24/11/2023 20:20

I wonder if how the UK/EU handle immigration needs to change?

Thinking of the Gulf countries like Dubai, Qatar etc, their citizens are vastly outnumbered by immigrant workers (across all stratas of society, I'm not just talking about labourers in construction), but they're pretty strict about not letting that change or negatively impact their society.

People are there strictly to work, or their dependents. If they lose their job and can't find another, or reach retirement age, they are expected to return to their original country. Nor to their children have a right to remain as adults unless they too get employment and visas in their own right.
Commit a crime and you get deported once you've completed your prison term.

There is no welfare available for immigrants.

Would this system be considered too harsh in Europe?

That's a shit system though! Immigrants deserve to be treated like, idk, proper humans? Lots of them are workers, and even those that are not deserve a base level of humanity.

SomeCatFromJapan · 24/11/2023 20:20

I wonder if how the UK/EU handle immigration needs to change?

Thinking of the Gulf countries like Dubai, Qatar etc, their citizens are vastly outnumbered by immigrant workers (across all stratas of society, I'm not just talking about labourers in construction), but they're pretty strict about not letting that change or negatively impact their society.

People are there strictly to work, or their dependents. If they lose their job and can't find another, or reach retirement age, they are expected to return to their original country. Nor to their children have a right to remain as adults unless they too get employment and visas in their own right.
Commit a crime and you get deported once you've completed your prison term.

There is no welfare available for immigrants.

Would this system be considered too harsh in Europe?

Mucholderlittlewiser · 24/11/2023 20:11

In both of your first two posts you have talked about what voters feel/want.

Has it escaped your notice that not all voters want the same thing?

MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 20:04

MoonLife · 24/11/2023 12:33

For all of those who welcome mass immigration, where on earth do you live? I counter its not in the densely packed inner city areas where resources are stretched to breaking point and community tensions are at an all time high?

Everywhere has resources stretched to breaking point. We've had 13 years of Tory underfunding.

I just haven't fallen for the age-old tactic of pointing at immigrants instead of pointing at the government.

Immigration does need to be thought through, but immigration is not the cause of, for example, lack of GP appointments. That is the result of an ageing population + underfunded NHS + GP resignations.

MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 19:51

Yetmorebeanstocount · 24/11/2023 14:32

Worth £30 billion to whom? 'Economic benefit' to whom?

We don't all benefit equally from 'the economy'. This point is so often ignored or glossed over.
Migration that benefits the wealthy in this country can be of direct detriment to the poorer majority.

We are most definitely not 'all in this together'.

For goodness' sake Hmm

Worth £30 Billion to the UK economy.

They employ staff, who pay taxes and spend their money with other businesses that pay taxes and employ staff who pay taxes.

The students spend their money with businesses that pay taxes and employ staff who pay taxes.

Universities don't benefit 'the wealthy' they benefit everyone in the UK, although of course that is concentrated around the universities themselves as that is where the direct spending happens.

I also personally quite appreciate the cancer research and the qualified people that come out of it.

The fact there are structural inequalities is a different issue.

Myfabby · 24/11/2023 19:48

Notonthestairs · 24/11/2023 19:23

The economic impact is spread across the entire UK, with international students making a £58m net economic contribution to the UK economy per parliamentary constituency across the duration of their studies. This is equivalent to £560 per member of the resident population.

https://londoneconomics.co.uk/blog/publication/the-benefits-and-costs-of-international-higher-education-students-to-the-uk-economy-analysis-for-the-2021-22-cohort-may-2023/

A lot more info in this-

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5b928cc1e5274a4242d1adf3/Impactintllstudentsreporttpublished_v1.1.pdf

They won't like this. The narrative of intl students taking their RG places whilst speaking very little english is much more palatable.

Notonthestairs · 24/11/2023 19:23

The economic impact is spread across the entire UK, with international students making a £58m net economic contribution to the UK economy per parliamentary constituency across the duration of their studies. This is equivalent to £560 per member of the resident population.

https://londoneconomics.co.uk/blog/publication/the-benefits-and-costs-of-international-higher-education-students-to-the-uk-economy-analysis-for-the-2021-22-cohort-may-2023/

A lot more info in this-

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5b928cc1e5274a4242d1adf3/Impactintllstudentsreporttpublished_v1.1.pdf

Yetmorebeanstocount · 24/11/2023 19:04

Notonthestairs · 24/11/2023 14:39

@Yetmorebeanstocount The Government benefits. How they choose to spend it is up to them.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/money/tax/record-immigration-paying-tory-tax-cuts-jeremy-hunt/

Surely the 30 billion for universities doesn't go to the government? Doesn't it stay in the university sector?

Libertyy · 24/11/2023 18:00

Sparthan · 24/11/2023 16:24

Sounds to me like they attempted to break the law and now the families are complaining that we didn’t save them from their own illegal actions. Maybe don’t invade other countries and you won’t die 🤷‍♀️

What like when masses of Europeans invaded Native American, First Nation people, the Aboriginal and maori people’s countries? It’s not invading when the only way you can claim asylum is to actually be present in the country.

Passepartoute · 24/11/2023 17:47

Sparthan · 24/11/2023 16:24

Sounds to me like they attempted to break the law and now the families are complaining that we didn’t save them from their own illegal actions. Maybe don’t invade other countries and you won’t die 🤷‍♀️

They were on a boat. They weren't invading anywhere.

Or perhaps you think we should shoot down the planes carrying the 1.2 million immigrants who "invade" the UK each year?

MrTiddlesTheCat · 24/11/2023 17:32

Sparthan · 24/11/2023 16:24

Sounds to me like they attempted to break the law and now the families are complaining that we didn’t save them from their own illegal actions. Maybe don’t invade other countries and you won’t die 🤷‍♀️

Bloody hell, that's abhorrent.

CharlotteRumpling · 24/11/2023 17:11

God, that's vile. @Sparthan "Invaders".Tory rhetoric has clearly worked. I hope no one here is ever in that position.

AdamRyan · 24/11/2023 17:07

Sparthan · 24/11/2023 16:24

Sounds to me like they attempted to break the law and now the families are complaining that we didn’t save them from their own illegal actions. Maybe don’t invade other countries and you won’t die 🤷‍♀️

Wow. 😮
A pregnant woman, her unborn baby and three other children were "invading"? And therefore deserve to drown?
That's shocking. Where is your humanity?

MoonLife · 24/11/2023 16:32

Myfabby · 24/11/2023 15:47

I wasn't hinting anything. I provided to you my experiences in an attempt to juxtapose against yours, so there is a more balanced, holistic view. I was willing to have a respectful debate with you until you tried to police my tone. Aggressive because I pointed out that one of the issues you have with immigrants I have suffered from many many times from white men??? What's aggressive is labelling immigrants as angry.

I still stand by what I said misogyny and sexual harrasment is not the exclusive preserve of immigrant (muslim) men.

Edited

I hope you reported their sexual harassment to their employers as there are stringent workplace codes of conduct in place nowadays

Sparthan · 24/11/2023 16:24

AdamRyan · 24/11/2023 13:10

the letter states that families still have no explanation as to why French and British authorities failed the people onboard a sinking dinghy who repeatedly called for help.

It's ridiculous for families to ask why British and French authorities let their relatives drown, knowing they were in difficulty at sea?
Really? That seems pretty cold hearted

Sounds to me like they attempted to break the law and now the families are complaining that we didn’t save them from their own illegal actions. Maybe don’t invade other countries and you won’t die 🤷‍♀️

Myfabby · 24/11/2023 15:47

Bigcoatweather · 24/11/2023 14:50

Oh yes you were trying to shame me - you’re hinting that I don’t know as much as you. I can’t be bothered to come back and argue my point as I’m at work, but if you weren’t intending to shame me, perhaps use a less aggressive tone. I said none of the things that you are implying I said and saying there are ghettos of immigrants clearly doesn’t negate other ghettos.
Very simply, without proper integration there will be problems stacked on top of the social problems we already have.

I wasn't hinting anything. I provided to you my experiences in an attempt to juxtapose against yours, so there is a more balanced, holistic view. I was willing to have a respectful debate with you until you tried to police my tone. Aggressive because I pointed out that one of the issues you have with immigrants I have suffered from many many times from white men??? What's aggressive is labelling immigrants as angry.

I still stand by what I said misogyny and sexual harrasment is not the exclusive preserve of immigrant (muslim) men.

AdamRyan · 24/11/2023 15:04

Yetmorebeanstocount · 24/11/2023 14:32

Worth £30 billion to whom? 'Economic benefit' to whom?

We don't all benefit equally from 'the economy'. This point is so often ignored or glossed over.
Migration that benefits the wealthy in this country can be of direct detriment to the poorer majority.

We are most definitely not 'all in this together'.

We all benefit from having enough staff for the NHS and social care services to function, and to get food from field to fork Confused

AdamRyan · 24/11/2023 15:02

Bigcoatweather · 24/11/2023 14:50

Oh yes you were trying to shame me - you’re hinting that I don’t know as much as you. I can’t be bothered to come back and argue my point as I’m at work, but if you weren’t intending to shame me, perhaps use a less aggressive tone. I said none of the things that you are implying I said and saying there are ghettos of immigrants clearly doesn’t negate other ghettos.
Very simply, without proper integration there will be problems stacked on top of the social problems we already have.

Maybe you should read the link she posted, which clearly demonstrates there aren't ghettos of immigrants.

Just because you believe something, doesn't make it true. And when someone provides the information to show it isn't true, they aren't "shaming" you. They are trying to help you.

Bigcoatweather · 24/11/2023 14:50

Myfabby · 24/11/2023 12:04

Beth, that's unfair and inaccurate. I am not shaming anyone

My point is a cross section of any society- any will be flawed. There has to be balance in all things. All of the UK's problems are not caused by immigration.

Oh yes you were trying to shame me - you’re hinting that I don’t know as much as you. I can’t be bothered to come back and argue my point as I’m at work, but if you weren’t intending to shame me, perhaps use a less aggressive tone. I said none of the things that you are implying I said and saying there are ghettos of immigrants clearly doesn’t negate other ghettos.
Very simply, without proper integration there will be problems stacked on top of the social problems we already have.

Verv · 24/11/2023 14:40

Countries do tend to move to the right in times of duress.
Theyre not going to look for the doves to protect them, they'll vote for the hawks.

Probably irrelevant to the evolving discussion, but the above^ always sticks in my mind.

Swipe left for the next trending thread