Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Europen governments need to respond to immigration?

564 replies

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 06:45

So the Netherlands is going to have a far right government.
Sweden has moved to the right.
Finland has shut its borders.
Countries that have traditionally been liberal are hardening and irrespective of the many issues listed its to do with immigration.

Ireland has seen violent protests last night following a series of stabbings.
In the UK we obviously had Brexit.

I think governments need to start responding to voters feelings on immigration as if they don't we will continue to see a general slide to the right in Europe, when actually these countries aren't right wing: it feels like a single issue is distorting the entire political landscape?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 08:16

WandaWonder · 25/11/2023 07:40

Shouldn't the leaders of the countries that are having people leave those countries because they have a shocking life actually get off their backsides and fix the issues and not be so incompetent and corrupt and stop leaving other countries to pick up the mess they are causing?

I think they are blameless on mn

But yes often funding stops at the top with corrupt states

MrTiddlesTheCat · 25/11/2023 08:14

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 06:54

I am one of these immigrants and really, really don't feel "dehumanised". It's my choice to live somewhere and that obviously comes with negatives as well as positives.
Everyone profits. The host country AND the workers who would not come if they didn't.

You are a part of the society you live in even without social financial benefits, or a citizenship. If you are not and behave in a way that is not good for the particular society you live in (crime, disrespect to their customs etc) than why would they want to keep you. Even more, why would you want to be there. Now mind me, there is a difference if you pay income tax and something like NIN. Then you should have right to stuff. But in the UAE etc, you don't pay. There is job loss insurance you pay now for yourself. FIY many in UK have no access to public funds too, even though they pay into the kitty.

Everyone knows the game of the country they move to. If you are on short term visa, you are on short term visa. If you are an adult, you need your visa. It's not like it's suddenly sprung on people at the end of their visa period with a week to sort it. This is the case of all non permanent visa everywhere.

You will never be in same position like you would in your native country anywhere, unless you gain citizenship. Which is not an automatic human right. If someone is unhappy with that, then they don't emigrate.

I emigrated 20 years ago. Thankfully I emigrated to a country that doesn't dehumanise immigrants. It sees us as equals. So when I became disabled they took care of me and my children. They didn't throw us out like a pair of worn out socks.

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 07:44

WandaWonder · 25/11/2023 07:40

Shouldn't the leaders of the countries that are having people leave those countries because they have a shocking life actually get off their backsides and fix the issues and not be so incompetent and corrupt and stop leaving other countries to pick up the mess they are causing?

Geography, politics and history not your strong areas?

WandaWonder · 25/11/2023 07:40

Shouldn't the leaders of the countries that are having people leave those countries because they have a shocking life actually get off their backsides and fix the issues and not be so incompetent and corrupt and stop leaving other countries to pick up the mess they are causing?

TheThingIsYeah · 25/11/2023 07:32

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 07:01

around 8000 people died building the world Cup stadiums in doha.

  1. 6500 in 10 years. Which is hella lot out of about 2mil, but it is not "8000 died building stadium". This is not to say Qatar is perfect before anyome jumps on it, it's not. Just correction of the misquoted "facts".

I'm sure the construction of infrastructure for the 2034 WC will be a beacon for Health & Safety.

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 07:29

Deathwillbebutapause · 25/11/2023 07:19

It's not quibbling to correct an exaggeration or a falsehood, though.

When you seek to downplay deaths, people will wonder about your motives.

Where does your figure come from, is it the Guardian's estimate? We have no reliable documentation to review. Their figure was only for nationals from five countries.

There are other figures - think the highest is 15,000 in the Amnesty Report.

A figure has never been accepted by Qatar (for obvious PR reasons they won't get into the numbers).

TheThingIsYeah · 25/11/2023 07:29

MoonLife · 24/11/2023 12:33

For all of those who welcome mass immigration, where on earth do you live? I counter its not in the densely packed inner city areas where resources are stretched to breaking point and community tensions are at an all time high?

Those who say how great multi-culturalism is do not live in multi-cultural areas.

You only have to look at what happened last year in the US to see the blatant hypocrisy of it. The governor of Florida flew 50 migrants up to Martha's Vineyard and the residents there couldn't get rid of them fast enough.

If you want a solution to the UK's housing/migrant crisis I suggest a building loads of HMOs in the likes of Henley or Richmond. That will focus the mind.

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 07:26

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 07:18

I think you misread, they said world Cup stadiums plural, which is a fair enough shorthand for 'construction of the buildings and infrastructure associated with hosting the world cup'.

Quibbling over the numbers is an odd approach - the treatment of migrant workers and the injuries/deaths were fucking disgraceful.

I'm not accepting that as a model for UK migrant workers.

No one is asking you to accept that as a model for UK migrant workers 🤷
6500 in 10 years was overall, not just on building stadia and infrastructure. That would be like claiming all worker deaths in UK between 5th July 2005 and 2012 starting ceremony were related to Olympics.
It's simply factually wrong. Correcting wrong facts is not downplaying issues. It's simply just correcting wrong facts. If you want to make it into something else, that's your prerogative.

Deathwillbebutapause · 25/11/2023 07:19

It's not quibbling to correct an exaggeration or a falsehood, though.

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 07:18

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 07:10

I am not downplaying it. Claiming that 8000 people died building the WC stadium is simply wrong

I think you misread, they said world Cup stadiums plural, which is a fair enough shorthand for 'construction of the buildings and infrastructure associated with hosting the world cup'.

Quibbling over the numbers is an odd approach - the treatment of migrant workers and the injuries/deaths were fucking disgraceful.

I'm not accepting that as a model for UK migrant workers.

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 07:10

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 07:08

The situation in Qatar was appalling, I don't understand why you're seeking to downplay it.

I am not downplaying it. Claiming that 8000 people died building the WC stadium is simply wrong

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 07:08

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 07:01

around 8000 people died building the world Cup stadiums in doha.

  1. 6500 in 10 years. Which is hella lot out of about 2mil, but it is not "8000 died building stadium". This is not to say Qatar is perfect before anyome jumps on it, it's not. Just correction of the misquoted "facts".

The situation in Qatar was appalling, I don't understand why you're seeking to downplay it.

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 07:01

around 8000 people died building the world Cup stadiums in doha.

  1. 6500 in 10 years. Which is hella lot out of about 2mil, but it is not "8000 died building stadium". This is not to say Qatar is perfect before anyome jumps on it, it's not. Just correction of the misquoted "facts".
Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 06:54

MrTiddlesTheCat · 24/11/2023 22:33

Because it 'others' people, which dehumanises them. It tells immigrants that they will never be part of society. They are lesser. They're only there for what can be squeezed out of them, with no care for their needs or well-being. As for sending their children away once they turn 18, well that's just evil.

I am one of these immigrants and really, really don't feel "dehumanised". It's my choice to live somewhere and that obviously comes with negatives as well as positives.
Everyone profits. The host country AND the workers who would not come if they didn't.

You are a part of the society you live in even without social financial benefits, or a citizenship. If you are not and behave in a way that is not good for the particular society you live in (crime, disrespect to their customs etc) than why would they want to keep you. Even more, why would you want to be there. Now mind me, there is a difference if you pay income tax and something like NIN. Then you should have right to stuff. But in the UAE etc, you don't pay. There is job loss insurance you pay now for yourself. FIY many in UK have no access to public funds too, even though they pay into the kitty.

Everyone knows the game of the country they move to. If you are on short term visa, you are on short term visa. If you are an adult, you need your visa. It's not like it's suddenly sprung on people at the end of their visa period with a week to sort it. This is the case of all non permanent visa everywhere.

You will never be in same position like you would in your native country anywhere, unless you gain citizenship. Which is not an automatic human right. If someone is unhappy with that, then they don't emigrate.

MidnightOnceMore · 25/11/2023 06:27

@MoonLife I can only refer you to my previous answer, which is the government should be a) processing claims quickly and b) providing the resources our public services need.

We all heard the attitude problem in parliament when Stockton was apparently called a 'shithole' by a government minister.

And then you start to get personal with this type of stuff: where do you actually live? Because it's all very well having principles but only if you can afford to. - this is not a culture war between you and me.

CharlotteRumpling · 25/11/2023 03:51

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/11/2023 00:04

So how exactly do you propose that we could determine which people have stone age attitudes and which don't? Which ones are violent, and have no respect for women etc etc. Or are you just going to work on the assumption that everyone from certain countries fits that stereotype?

I think that's what people are proposing. A sort of apartheid that allows only people from certain countries to enter. Course by that logic Sunak and half his cabinet would not be here.

therealcookiemonster · 25/11/2023 03:48

SomeCatFromJapan · 24/11/2023 20:20

I wonder if how the UK/EU handle immigration needs to change?

Thinking of the Gulf countries like Dubai, Qatar etc, their citizens are vastly outnumbered by immigrant workers (across all stratas of society, I'm not just talking about labourers in construction), but they're pretty strict about not letting that change or negatively impact their society.

People are there strictly to work, or their dependents. If they lose their job and can't find another, or reach retirement age, they are expected to return to their original country. Nor to their children have a right to remain as adults unless they too get employment and visas in their own right.
Commit a crime and you get deported once you've completed your prison term.

There is no welfare available for immigrants.

Would this system be considered too harsh in Europe?

yep, let's follow the example of autocratic governments with human rights violations coming out of their ears lol. that's the way forward.
would you also like us to start taking away immigrants' passports, make them work in unsafe conditions under duress and cover up their deaths? around 8000 people died building the world Cup stadiums in doha.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 25/11/2023 02:03

@MidnightOnceMore I agree.

MoonLife · 25/11/2023 01:05

MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 20:04

Everywhere has resources stretched to breaking point. We've had 13 years of Tory underfunding.

I just haven't fallen for the age-old tactic of pointing at immigrants instead of pointing at the government.

Immigration does need to be thought through, but immigration is not the cause of, for example, lack of GP appointments. That is the result of an ageing population + underfunded NHS + GP resignations.

I disagree and I'll tell you why. Firstly, I have never voted Tory in my life - never have and never will. I've seen the damage that party has inflicted on society. My parents are working class through and through but fortunately for them, they are of the baby boomer generation, where working extremely hard in factory jobs for decades enabled them to buy their own homes at a young age and work their way up the property ladder, progressing to bigger houses in better areas. They both came from abject poverty so to achieve what they have is remarkable and a point of pride imo. Now to my point. They are both retired and live in a beautiful semi rural very middle class village. Do they have problems with getting a gp appointment? Nope. Problems with anti social behaviour? No. Over subscribed schools? No. Lack of community cohesion? Again no. But for those of us who are not of their generation and are stuck in poor areas despite our best efforts to better ourselves, these are the realities we live with every day. The houses are hmos, crime is everywhere, the streets are litter strewn and filthy...It's dangerous. All around There is division. I don't see harmony and different communities mixing. No one knows their neighbours. The council might wheel out the annual mela as a display of the diversity in the area, but it's smoke and mirrors, it has zero impact on unifying people. There are too many people living in too small a place. And it's the poorest of society that suffer the most. That's why I asked the question - for those who welcome mass immigration, where do you actually live? Because it's all very well having principles but only if you can afford to.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/11/2023 00:04

JudgeJ · 24/11/2023 23:35

Very well said. It's also the case that their stone-age attitudes are brought with them and a large percentage of the guilt for the treatment of women brought illegally into the West lies with their fellow countrymen.
If you invited someone into your home and they abused your hospitality then you throw them out, the countries should do the same. If they are making the host country unsafe then they go back and face whatever turbulence they 'escaped' from.

So how exactly do you propose that we could determine which people have stone age attitudes and which don't? Which ones are violent, and have no respect for women etc etc. Or are you just going to work on the assumption that everyone from certain countries fits that stereotype?

JudgeJ · 24/11/2023 23:35

skyknight · 24/11/2023 10:46

I really hate the way anyone opposed to the importation of violent people from cultures that have no respect for women, other religions, minorities, homosexuals are always smeared as "far-right". Surely it is these ideologies that are "far-right", not the politicians or voters who are opposed to such things?

Very well said. It's also the case that their stone-age attitudes are brought with them and a large percentage of the guilt for the treatment of women brought illegally into the West lies with their fellow countrymen.
If you invited someone into your home and they abused your hospitality then you throw them out, the countries should do the same. If they are making the host country unsafe then they go back and face whatever turbulence they 'escaped' from.

MrTiddlesTheCat · 24/11/2023 22:33

SomeCatFromJapan · 24/11/2023 20:35

That's a shit system though! Immigrants deserve to be treated like, idk, proper humans? Lots of them are workers, and even those that are not deserve a base level of humanity

Can you explain how what I've described is not treating someone as a proper human? Bearing in mind people move there by choice due to better financial opportunities than are available in their home countries, including plently of British people.

Because it 'others' people, which dehumanises them. It tells immigrants that they will never be part of society. They are lesser. They're only there for what can be squeezed out of them, with no care for their needs or well-being. As for sending their children away once they turn 18, well that's just evil.

Yetmorebeanstocount · 24/11/2023 21:53

@MidnightOnceMore

Immigration doesn't cause inequality.
But inequality does dramatically affect how people respond to immigration, and how they vote as a result, which was the OP's topic.

When the economy shrinks it hits the poorest hardest - yes because the rich have more power to protect their own interests, i.e. protect their wealth and incomes. The poor have no protection, except the power of community and mutual help.

The answer it not to continually grow the economy via immigration, as that is just a pyramid scheme. (No to mention that it is impossible to have infinite growth on a finite planet).
The answer is to work towards a low-growth or no-growth economy coupled with widescale re-distribution of wealth via tax and benefits.
Can't see any politicians going for it though, as they are part of the problem.

MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 21:42

I should add @Yetmorebeanstocount I agree inequality poisons everything.

I just don't see immigration as the cause of inequality.

There are countries in Europe with higher immigration and lower inequality. That's a pure policy choice.

MidnightOnceMore · 24/11/2023 21:40

Yetmorebeanstocount · 24/11/2023 21:31

@MidnightOnceMore

The fact there are structural inequalities is a different issue.

I disagree. The structural inequalities pervade everything. Nothing is immune. Nothing is separate from effects of the gaping chasm between the the rich and the rest. Everything in public life, and in the fabric of our society, is poisoned by inequality.

The rich, and to a lesser extent the wealthy middle class, want migration because they want cheap labour. Cheaper employees in public services mean lower taxes, disproportionally benefiting the better off.
The rest are disadvantaged by undermined wage levels, competition for housing and services, and chronic insecurity.

This is incorrect.

You have the pie, then you have how the pie is sliced.

I want a fairer economy. But shrinking it first is a bad idea. Just look at Brexit. When you make the country poorer, it hits the poorest hardest.

A closed economy doesn't bring greater wealth, because it only matters what you can buy with your wages.