Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Europen governments need to respond to immigration?

564 replies

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 06:45

So the Netherlands is going to have a far right government.
Sweden has moved to the right.
Finland has shut its borders.
Countries that have traditionally been liberal are hardening and irrespective of the many issues listed its to do with immigration.

Ireland has seen violent protests last night following a series of stabbings.
In the UK we obviously had Brexit.

I think governments need to start responding to voters feelings on immigration as if they don't we will continue to see a general slide to the right in Europe, when actually these countries aren't right wing: it feels like a single issue is distorting the entire political landscape?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
bombastix · 25/11/2023 11:39

It's important also to realize that the UK has fallen behind its comparative competitors. We have very feeble growth, though we do have some, it's just that, compared to twenty years ago, it's not as good. If the UK were in a race, it would running at the same speed while other countries have got faster, improved their services and increased their investment in their society both in public and private sectors. We haven't done that and it shows. But getting in cheaper labour via immigration is a good sticking plaster. If you are a well off person who doesn't rely on public services, why do you care? It's not going to affect you. Brexit has just moved the source of migration, and arguably made greater incentives for people to stay.

All those who voted for the idea that there would be better pay and an implicit return to a kind of working class aristocracy have been thoroughly gripped. It's more competitive, not less.

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 11:16

Brexit was just immigration and borders

The UK may get to where Aus is but it’s a shift many will fight against

Pressure will increase in only one direction though. Towards more control. Look at politics in EU it’s already happening.

bombastix · 25/11/2023 11:14

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 11:12

Some rights @bombastix . Like voting was not one of them.

Quite. It was a perception but I think one that was important in terms of the result.

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 11:12

Some rights @bombastix . Like voting was not one of them.

bombastix · 25/11/2023 11:04

Or additionally, there were other voters who did not like the fact that EU citizens were given greater rights than say those coming from Commonwealth countries or parts of former colonies. I think that particular issue is yet to fully unwind.

Some of the thinking around Britain post Brexit is weird; the thinking of the 1940s, an "Anglosphere" (which is often code for white immigration from Canada or Australia or NZ).

It all ignores that actually most of what might be said to be the Anglosphere is better off than us in terms of living standards.

A better take is that the UK is that our population growth will come from India, Pakistan and the Philippines. If you look at the migration figures by country that will be there already.

inamarina · 25/11/2023 10:59

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 08:43

It’s interesting to hear how other countries set up. The guest part is different and as a kind of contract it works

Some people are attracted to low tax rates so they take the risks to earn

It doesn’t work as well for poorly paid

I don’t think we’ll switch to the same approach, not sure if even possible due to demographics

I don’t think we would (or should) switch to the same approach either.
I do wonder though - wouldn’t that approach actually be the other side of the ‘we need immigration to sustain our economy’ argument?
Because in that case it’s not just any immigrants you would need, but specifically economically active ones. So ideally qualified, young, healthy, without dependents.
What happens if someone loses their job though and struggles to find another? Or gets longterm sick? Or wants to bring their partner with them, even though the partner doesn’t have the right skillset for the local job market or wants to be a stay-at-home parent?
I mean, you either see people as human resources to prop up the local economy and send them away when they can’t contribute, or you take a more humane approach and end up with more workers, but also with their potentially economically inactive dependents.

bombastix · 25/11/2023 10:57

@Sauerkrautsandwich - oh yes for some it was the point. Britannia Unchained and all that.

There was a lot of care about more money for the NHS etc. When you looked at the people funding the leave campaign that seemed ridiculous as an idea.

TheThingIsYeah · 25/11/2023 10:41

@Dwappy Sounds depressingly familiar. Yet there'll be some people on MN who will still - with a straight face - say that somehow that situation was your parents fault.

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 10:22

AI and climate change

Immigration figures will go down for workers and up for non visa related

It’s worth considering next five years or ten when putting in place immigration policies now

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 10:19

bombastix · 25/11/2023 10:17

It's tough. People who wanted Brexit were probably not really aware of the political motivations behind it. If they had been they might have realised that the consequences were going to be migration increasing from non EU countries, and given the productivity issues, a decline in social provision.

Britain will be more diverse, not less, as a result.

Some people were aware and voted with that in mind

bombastix · 25/11/2023 10:17

It's tough. People who wanted Brexit were probably not really aware of the political motivations behind it. If they had been they might have realised that the consequences were going to be migration increasing from non EU countries, and given the productivity issues, a decline in social provision.

Britain will be more diverse, not less, as a result.

ChatBFP · 25/11/2023 10:08

@bombastix

Yes, agreed, and the expectation when they were born was that they wouldn't live as long as they did. My grandfather, born 1936, was a blue collar worker who had a pension from 50 because people were generally in very poor health if they had done 35 years on an assembly line in hot and dirty conditions. He would, when he began work, have been expected to live another 10 years. He actually lived until 73 and he died in an accident but was healthy at that point - his widow drew a pension until 90. It is hard to believe now that people accepted (had to accept) not so long ago that work might shorten their lives, perhaps considerably. It is a good thing that health outcomes have improved so much and that attitudes have changed BUT if we are expecting young people to start working full time a full 5 years later than that generation and to live 20 years younger we need to really think about how we make that work.

Immigration is not the blanket solution to that demographic issue long-term, because those people also get old too. And few will return to countries with a lesser safety net.

Dwappy · 25/11/2023 09:55

The houses are hmos, crime is everywhere, the streets are litter strewn and filthy...It's dangerous. All around There is division. I don't see harmony and different communities mixing. No one knows their neighbours. The council might wheel out the annual mela as a display of the diversity in the area, but it's smoke and mirrors, it has zero impact on unifying people.

My parents lived somewhere like that a few years ago. It never used to be though. It was a very typical terraced London street when my parents bought the house in the 70s. Over time they knew all their neighbours. Would chat to everyone in the street. People helped each other. The kids played out. People looked after their houses and gardens.
Fast forward 40 years and you wouldn't recognise it. They were one of the last long standing residents when they finally moved. They had 1 HMO directly next door, 2 across the road and 1 more 3 doors down. That one also had a "back garden shed" which more people lived in. And I'm sure many others did as well. At least one of the houses constantly burned builders waste in the garden causing huge amounts of fumes. The front garden of their direct neighbour was a total and utter shit tip. Mounds of rubbish and waste which would start spilling into my parents garden. Most of their neighbours didn't speak any English so they couldn't even talk to them about it. And the ones that did just either told them to fuck off or laughed. Even if my parents just wanted to chat, a group of young men drinking outside their house have no interest in having a chat with 2 elderly people. These men would also piss where they were gathered in the street. I was so glad when they finally moved.
But this is often the reality of high immigration numbers. My parents couldn't have cared less where someone was from. But the reality is a lot of the time people do not wish to integrate and especially when surrounded by people from their own culture they will socialise and mix with them only.
People will say HMOs are part of the problem as its horrible for the people living in them. Yes I agree. But there quite honestly isn't the housing or the space for every single local person and immigrant to have their own lovely 2 bedroom house in a nice area with good transport and shops etc.
And there's no point saying well flats are an option as well because they become the same as the HMOs. Where I live in London they built a lovely block of flats (only about 6 levels not a huge tower block). It started off with lovely flower beds along the walls outside etc. Beautifully painted gates to the entrance to the car park and bin area. It houses mainly families. Now I have no idea of the nationality of the people living there but they are definitely of mixed cultures. But the fact still is after 5 years its a total dump. The piles of rubbish and shopping trollies that line the street outside. The flower beds have been destroyed and are full of cigarette ends and rubbish. The nice gates are broken and smashed and are covered in graffiti. Even inside the main entrance and stairway there's piles of rubbish inside (it's glass so you can see inside).
Anyway my point is there is huge numbers of the population including immigrants that have zero interest in integrating and living in a nice community. And mass immigration does nothing to help things. Especially when you have a mix of cultures. It rarely works well.

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 09:47

I voted remain (and was incredibly pro it) but increased climate and migration pressures have become more of a factor and will continue to

An Aus system could be better matched due to changes that will happen

RiderofRohan · 25/11/2023 09:45

LickleLamb · 25/11/2023 08:52

Singapore pays less to its immigrant worker nurses than it does to its Singaporean nurses.
I doubt you could do that in the U.K. - human rights or something.
But it would be nice to pay more to our U.K. nurses if that’s what it meant.

The vast majority of nurses are amazing but as a doctor who spent many years on the wards, Filipino nurses were just phenomenal. The suggestion that they should be paid less because of their passport, nevermind the outstanding care and experience they provide, is unfair and just silly. These highly skilled individuals would just up and go to Canada or the States in the face of this sort of inequality.

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 09:41

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 08:51

@EasternStandard no, I don't think Europe will switch to that fully. It doesn't work everywhere. I think such systems have to be in use since the begining. Changing into it would be incredibly difficult without disadvantaging current immigrants. Unless it would be 100% done only for new ones, but even than change would be difficult to pass and implement. Same way like changing the other way round would be hard.

@SomeCatFromJapan I wanted to say expat, but didn't want to be accused of being "better than others Brit", even though I am not a Brit... Every is using that. Expat or resident.
And yup about the numbers. It's not to say, there are no massive issues (there absolutely are), it's just not factual claim.

@SomeCatFromJapan

Yes it’d have to be from the start

Ime Aus has a good set up for immigration. Citizens seem happy and neither party will change it now.

bombastix · 25/11/2023 09:38

It's never going to be lawful in the U.K. to have some sort of blanket "we don't take you if you are from x country" and nor will it be to have an unspoken rule that the UK doesn't accept people for visa applications from particular countries.

What would be, assuming you wanted to reduce the immigration rate is to change the amount required by means of a fee to apply to charge more, to insist on a declared amount in funds to meet medical costs by way of insurance, changing the point at which employers can seek visas so that lower paid jobs are excluded, dependents cannot come, age limits are imposed so you must be under 40, educational requirements are to UK standards, no recourse to benefits, and no route to citizenship.

All of these things are possible. They would make employers pretty unhappy. But they would also make the UK very unattractive for someone who had very little but wanted to work their way up.

The other half of the debate which is being discussed and I don't think that is a coincidence, is welfare and an ageing society. The migrant is younger, fitter, probably uses public services less than an ageing British person. The amount of investment this country would need to turn around its issue with sickness and long term economic activity hasn't been done. It's cheaper to get in people from overseas. And if you are a laissez faire Conservative who is already pretty well off then you will be happy with that.

And underlining that is something even worse; that most working Brits do not contribute tax unless they are paying higher rate tax. That is 10 percent of our working population.

I'm not pro immigration or against. But there does need to be a real discussion of the economic reality of why we have it, what our own problems are in terms of productivity and this feeble tax take we have, and then what can be actually afforded for public services. I hear people saying they want better services and living standards; good idea but it all rests on the people we have working harder, and more of them, and paying more tax. That is what the boomer generation did. They paid far more tax. They worked longer hours. They had lesser public services and they had housing subsidized by the state via social housing or tax relief for mortgages.

Peablockfeathers · 25/11/2023 08:58

The government need to address the decline in living standards and services in this country. You can see why when people can't afford to eat, can't access healthcare or school buildings that aren't crumbling there's more resentment to people coming over and getting the bare minimum. There is also a cultural aspect that people are loathe to mention for fear of being told they're racist or xenophobic; but realistically young men who have spent their formative years in countries where women are treated as less than property don't just shed that as they cross the channel. Of course I'm not saying that means all mistreat women, but large groups of these men in small communities is concerning for women and girls, and we shouldn't be scared to mention that. I agree with PPs a lot is well it doesn't affect me so I don't care also, move some over to these leafy affluent areas and I'm sure the mood would change.

What the government needs to address is how to increase and simplify safe channels to those who are truly vulnerable, and to treat everyone in society here better- be them native, immigrants or whoever by investing in public services and housing.

LickleLamb · 25/11/2023 08:52

Singapore pays less to its immigrant worker nurses than it does to its Singaporean nurses.
I doubt you could do that in the U.K. - human rights or something.
But it would be nice to pay more to our U.K. nurses if that’s what it meant.

inamarina · 25/11/2023 08:52

MoonLife · 25/11/2023 01:05

I disagree and I'll tell you why. Firstly, I have never voted Tory in my life - never have and never will. I've seen the damage that party has inflicted on society. My parents are working class through and through but fortunately for them, they are of the baby boomer generation, where working extremely hard in factory jobs for decades enabled them to buy their own homes at a young age and work their way up the property ladder, progressing to bigger houses in better areas. They both came from abject poverty so to achieve what they have is remarkable and a point of pride imo. Now to my point. They are both retired and live in a beautiful semi rural very middle class village. Do they have problems with getting a gp appointment? Nope. Problems with anti social behaviour? No. Over subscribed schools? No. Lack of community cohesion? Again no. But for those of us who are not of their generation and are stuck in poor areas despite our best efforts to better ourselves, these are the realities we live with every day. The houses are hmos, crime is everywhere, the streets are litter strewn and filthy...It's dangerous. All around There is division. I don't see harmony and different communities mixing. No one knows their neighbours. The council might wheel out the annual mela as a display of the diversity in the area, but it's smoke and mirrors, it has zero impact on unifying people. There are too many people living in too small a place. And it's the poorest of society that suffer the most. That's why I asked the question - for those who welcome mass immigration, where do you actually live? Because it's all very well having principles but only if you can afford to.

The houses are hmos, crime is everywhere, the streets are litter strewn and filthy...It's dangerous. All around There is division. I don't see harmony and different communities mixing. No one knows their neighbours. The council might wheel out the annual mela as a display of the diversity in the area, but it's smoke and mirrors, it has zero impact on unifying people.

Sounds like our town, sadly. Not much mixing between various groups, just some sort of parallel existence.

One of my kids has friends at school who are immigrants (as are we) and whose parents keep them from socialising outside school. Why? How are these kids supposed to integrate into this society if they’re not allowed to hang out with other local kids? They’re teenagers and will probably rebel at some point, but why keep them away from the society you chose to live in in the first place?

I used to live in a different place previously, in a very international neighbourhood of a big city.
Economically diverse to a certain extent, but over all more prosperous than the town I live in now. There was much more mixing between immigrants from different places and also the locals.

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 08:51

@EasternStandard no, I don't think Europe will switch to that fully. It doesn't work everywhere. I think such systems have to be in use since the begining. Changing into it would be incredibly difficult without disadvantaging current immigrants. Unless it would be 100% done only for new ones, but even than change would be difficult to pass and implement. Same way like changing the other way round would be hard.

@SomeCatFromJapan I wanted to say expat, but didn't want to be accused of being "better than others Brit", even though I am not a Brit... Every is using that. Expat or resident.
And yup about the numbers. It's not to say, there are no massive issues (there absolutely are), it's just not factual claim.

@SomeCatFromJapan

SomeCatFromJapan · 25/11/2023 08:50

I don’t think we’ll switch to the same approach, not sure if even possible due to demographics

Yes I agree, I wasn't really seriously suggesting that the UK or European countries should or could follow that approach, just throwing ideas out really.

Ultimately I think most people embrace immigrants who work and integrate, and resent those who receive benefits and do not. I appreciate that's a simplistic divide and the reality has more grey areas to it.
I also think asylum seekers are a particluarly thorny and divisive issue. The Gulf countries keep that one simple by not accepting any.

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 08:43

SomeCatFromJapan · 25/11/2023 08:26

Because it 'others' people, which dehumanises them. It tells immigrants that they will never be part of society. They are lesser. They're only there for what can be squeezed out of them, with no care for their needs or well-being. As for sending their children away once they turn 18, well that's just evil.

Everyone working there has made a choice to be there though. They are part of society while there but it's an understood agreement and there isn't a pathway to unrestricted permanent residency or citizenship.
Dependent children can remain until age 25 which allows time for tertially education and starting their own career.

Don't get me wrong, there is some less than ideal stuff that happens around the poorer paid and more vulnerable immigrants such as labourers and domestic staff, but I don't see the issue with the overall framework. You move to a country in the full knowledge that it will ultimately be temporary but that there are benefits to doing so.

As such no-one is really an immigrant there. I know that MN hates the term expat as they think it denotes British arrogance but that is how everyone is refered to. It keeps the distinction clear - you've not permanently immigrated to the country, you've come as a guest for a period of time to work and contribute.

Edited

It’s interesting to hear how other countries set up. The guest part is different and as a kind of contract it works

Some people are attracted to low tax rates so they take the risks to earn

It doesn’t work as well for poorly paid

I don’t think we’ll switch to the same approach, not sure if even possible due to demographics

SomeCatFromJapan · 25/11/2023 08:32

@Sauerkrautsandwich that Qatar worker death stat drives me insane! Wasn't the methodoly simply to look at all deaths of a specific nationality across a period of time (I think probably Indian nationals) and assume it was related to construction accidents?
So you could have been a surgeon who died in a car accident, or an accountant who had a heart attack, and have been included in the stats.

Plus most of the site construction is Western companies, including senior management, it's not like they're state-run. They sub-contract. You'll know this obviously but clearly many don't.

SomeCatFromJapan · 25/11/2023 08:26

Because it 'others' people, which dehumanises them. It tells immigrants that they will never be part of society. They are lesser. They're only there for what can be squeezed out of them, with no care for their needs or well-being. As for sending their children away once they turn 18, well that's just evil.

Everyone working there has made a choice to be there though. They are part of society while there but it's an understood agreement and there isn't a pathway to unrestricted permanent residency or citizenship.
Dependent children can remain until age 25 which allows time for tertially education and starting their own career.

Don't get me wrong, there is some less than ideal stuff that happens around the poorer paid and more vulnerable immigrants such as labourers and domestic staff, but I don't see the issue with the overall framework. You move to a country in the full knowledge that it will ultimately be temporary but that there are benefits to doing so.

As such no-one is really an immigrant there. I know that MN hates the term expat as they think it denotes British arrogance but that is how everyone is refered to. It keeps the distinction clear - you've not permanently immigrated to the country, you've come as a guest for a period of time to work and contribute.

Swipe left for the next trending thread