Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Europen governments need to respond to immigration?

564 replies

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 06:45

So the Netherlands is going to have a far right government.
Sweden has moved to the right.
Finland has shut its borders.
Countries that have traditionally been liberal are hardening and irrespective of the many issues listed its to do with immigration.

Ireland has seen violent protests last night following a series of stabbings.
In the UK we obviously had Brexit.

I think governments need to start responding to voters feelings on immigration as if they don't we will continue to see a general slide to the right in Europe, when actually these countries aren't right wing: it feels like a single issue is distorting the entire political landscape?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
bakebeans · 25/11/2023 13:01

https://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greater-manchester-news/plight-of-journalist-living-in-28034594
not sure what the answer is. This gentleman is having to sleep in his Monclaer coat due threats as a Journalist in Qatar.

As some say , immigration have been the ones to step in to fill jobs as nurses, carers and fruit pickers. Probably because the people born here know they won't be getting paid enough so don't want to train or are leaving in droves.

It's not going to get better

The man living in a tent with nowhere to go and nobody helping him find a home

Former Al Jazeera journalist Sohayb Farag saw his asylum application approved, but still has nowhere to live. He was told he does 'not have a priority need for accommodation'.

https://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greater-manchester-news/plight-of-journalist-living-in-28034594

inamarina · 25/11/2023 13:00

Chickenkeev · 25/11/2023 12:22

Of course it is! It absolutely is! There are so many benefits to being exposed to other cultures and beliefs, it broadens horizens and widens one perspective. I can't see any benefit whatsoever in having a closed society. It's limiting tbh. Everyone needs to learn about other ways of being, and to know that people can rub along with the other quite nicely. It's one of my favourite things about my childs school tbh, it not a religious one, so it gets lots of different people. I love that she gets that exposure, i think it's really important.

What about immigrants who are not particularly interested in learning about the ‘ways of being’ of the locals though? I’m not saying all immigrants are like this, but where I live I see plenty of examples where that seems to be the case.
Over all I also prefer living amongst people from different backgrounds and cultures, I’m an immigrant myself.
But there needs to be some kind of social cohesion, a sense of community.
That’s not always the case in areas with high numbers of immigrants, particularly when there are large groups from the same background who just stay among themselves.

bombastix · 25/11/2023 12:59

Also I am sorry but the fact is that immigration (depending on where it is and who) means a fair bit more competition for those affected. In the UK that has been typically those on lower incomes. I do not think you can tell them that a number of supermarkets or restaurants are enough to compensate. They see it absolutely differently and feel loss.

I don't think it makes them racists either. They just see it that way.

I say this as the kind of patronizing North London leftie champagne bibber who would be expected to be s diversity champion. But I see it affects people strongly who had relatively little to start, and for whom their community would have been strong if not all the compensation in the world for that. Wealth is not just money to some but people, comfort and predictability.

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 12:59

Climate issues is afaik still not recognised as aaylum claim internationally. Though it's being talked about since some islands are dissapearing and there is about to be few homeless nations. I think it's being sorted under disaster displacement atm

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 12:55

jasflowers · 25/11/2023 12:47

As i said on another thread, Cleverly now seems to be having reservations about its effectiveness.

How does a Aus style policy work for Europe, the numbers in N.Africa waiting to come across the Med are huge.

Where would we send them, Rwanda is geared up for 500 people.

Cleverly ‘"The mission is to stop the boats. That's the promise to the British people. Never lose sight of the mission.

"There are multiple methods. Don't fixate on the methods. Focus on the mission."

I look forward to hearing how he will do it. Aus has fewer than that in offshore as they’re reached the aim.

Decades ago and no party will touch it. Watching people tie themselves in knots over this is bizarre. Whatever Aus did it will be needed more as we progress into more climate issues.

Dwappy · 25/11/2023 12:50

Chickenkeev · 25/11/2023 12:22

Of course it is! It absolutely is! There are so many benefits to being exposed to other cultures and beliefs, it broadens horizens and widens one perspective. I can't see any benefit whatsoever in having a closed society. It's limiting tbh. Everyone needs to learn about other ways of being, and to know that people can rub along with the other quite nicely. It's one of my favourite things about my childs school tbh, it not a religious one, so it gets lots of different people. I love that she gets that exposure, i think it's really important.

But the problem is some areas of start off diverse then one or more cultures becomes more prominent. Diversity and multi cultural doesn't always mean one shop per culture and the cultural split of residents is even. What often happens is a huge amount of one culture move to an area and a large number of the shops are for that culture and the people all speak their own language. And when this happens all the pro immigration people say "well of COURSE the immigrant people want to speak their own language and buy the food they're used to and celebrate their own religions and cultural things! Its important and essential they do this to keep their culture alive!" But yet if you are British you must not get upset that you are no longer able to speak English to your neighbours and your local shops are full of food you don't recognise. You're now meant to embrace the diversity or you're labelled racist or xenophobic.
The reason immigrants like being around people like themselves is the same reason British people like being around people like themselves. If you have no shared experiences it can become very isolating and you don't feel you are part of a community.

bombastix · 25/11/2023 12:48

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 12:44

Interested point about some homogeneous countries being happy ones. I saw that stat somewhere. I wonder if that's countries that have very "heavy" culture as in, traditions and customs, ethics and etiquette being still very heavily used and demanded. If that makes sense?

Yes this is my point because England and other parts of the UK were manners culture. You needed less law as people self regulate by common implicit standards. This makes for a more stable society. Is it less dynamic, probably. But overall more stable.

jasflowers · 25/11/2023 12:47

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 12:23

We can be ‘’more like Aus’

It’s people working pretty hard not to get similar set up, god knows why

As i said on another thread, Cleverly now seems to be having reservations about its effectiveness.

How does a Aus style policy work for Europe, the numbers in N.Africa waiting to come across the Med are huge.

Where would we send them, Rwanda is geared up for 500 people.

bombastix · 25/11/2023 12:46

Well I am glad for this grown up thread and the diversity of views! But not much time for the shibboleth of diversity. It should be examined if we are to control borders as some want with positive choices being made as to who comes. This system, which replaced freedom of movement largely is going to value people and their backgrounds. It's innate to the result.

I have lived in London all my life. It is now more diverse than ever. Is it better? It is different.

SailAwayOnSummerDays · 25/11/2023 12:46

@TempestTost My grandparents escaped a war in which my Aunt died and they lost a lot of land, so they were most definitely oppressed. I had a student who was from that oppressing country and she said don’t you hate me, of course I did not. It is just ridiculous to have guilt for something you haven’t done and an ancestor did just like it would be crap of me to play the victim because the generation above me suffered. It’s very sad and the past needs to be acknowledged so the same mistakes are not made but instead everyone gets wrapped up in a tit for tat of who did what to who.

@MoonLife ah yes the leafy suburbs where some people think that by eating ethnic food it’s makes them better than others because they are so much more culturally sensitive.

I only ever lived in a very ethnically diverse place once and I didn’t like it. I had a white BF now DH and I remember being on a bus going down the Bristol road in Birmingham and a load of lads from my ethnic group were eyeing up DH really bad and I thought he was going to get a kicking for dating one of ‘their women’.

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 12:44

Interested point about some homogeneous countries being happy ones. I saw that stat somewhere. I wonder if that's countries that have very "heavy" culture as in, traditions and customs, ethics and etiquette being still very heavily used and demanded. If that makes sense?

Chickenkeev · 25/11/2023 12:42

Finlesswonder · 25/11/2023 12:30

I don't believe diversity where you live is always a good thing. We broaden our horizons and get fresh perspectives through travel.

Presumably when people visit Japan say, they go hoping not to eat at Italian restaurants or spend time in Irish pubs, right?

You're entitled to your opinion of course, but I personally would strongly disagree. I'm thinking of kids learning to get on with other cultures etc. They won't get that from a holiday.

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 12:40

DH and I are 1st gen and even we preferred more English areas. Not completely 100% English (encountered couple where we would NOT be welcome and couple which were quite shitholes with rubbish etc), but not ultra diverse. Where someone obviously recommend we should live, you know, cause we were immigrants. Lots of the very immigrant heavy areas look as bad as some pps described unfortunately.
Friendships groups were mainly immigrants though. Most lived in similar areas to us, slight mix, slight. It works better imho

Peablockfeathers · 25/11/2023 12:39

Chickenkeev · 25/11/2023 12:22

Of course it is! It absolutely is! There are so many benefits to being exposed to other cultures and beliefs, it broadens horizens and widens one perspective. I can't see any benefit whatsoever in having a closed society. It's limiting tbh. Everyone needs to learn about other ways of being, and to know that people can rub along with the other quite nicely. It's one of my favourite things about my childs school tbh, it not a religious one, so it gets lots of different people. I love that she gets that exposure, i think it's really important.

I don't know, some countries have laws and ideals that as a woman I find abhorrent, I don't find that as a virtue to try and integrate into our society. Definitely a balance though as I agree a balance of cultures does improve the country imo.

bombastix · 25/11/2023 12:38

@Chickenkeev - that is a personal preference. Diversity of opinions or thought may be useful to a society.

But simple diversity, without any thought as to what sort of society you might want? No. That is imo a fig leaf argument for business and migration overall.

MoonLife · 25/11/2023 12:38

lljkk · 25/11/2023 12:11

I live part time in a small city, in a neighbourhood that is about 40% 1st gentn immigrants (I'm guessing). There are countless Euro-supermarkets within walking distance, plus countless Turkish cafes, barbershops, Halal shops. there's a street of mostly Kurdish, I suspect. It's very noticeable when I actually hear English being spoken, and even then it's probably with a foreign accent. last week (for complicated reasons) I spoke to a lot of Polish people, plus some Lithuanians. There's a bench with gypsy-looking people always parked on it (colourful, cheerful) in the city centre. I look forward to seeing them.

I think I count as 'welcoming' mass immigration by the standards of this thread. I am an immigrant myself... I don't know about tensions. I'm not aware of any yet. It seems like the "White indigenous" people moved away, and this area so it became where the immigrants could afford to live. the little supermarkets thrive partly because the immigrants lack cars to get to out of town Asda. Everyone made their choices.

I'm not so blinkered to recognise that other people have different and far more pleasant experiences, for that would make me a hypocrite! But the devil may lie in the detail as they say. You say yours is a small city and you are only resident on a part time basis- I wonder if that has something to do with it? Just musing.

Finlesswonder · 25/11/2023 12:30

I don't believe diversity where you live is always a good thing. We broaden our horizons and get fresh perspectives through travel.

Presumably when people visit Japan say, they go hoping not to eat at Italian restaurants or spend time in Irish pubs, right?

OP posts:
EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 12:27

Personally I prefer diversity where I live, I’m not going to move anywhere else, I also know I have a pleasant experience and others may not which is valid

But I can still see where we’re headed and the lack of ability to look forward a few years is incredible, feels bizarre to me and will end up resulting in massive issues

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 12:23

jasflowers · 25/11/2023 12:15

25% in Holland voted for the far right Wilders, he may not even be in Govt if the other parties form their own coalition.

What i'd like to know is how countries in Europe should deal with 100s of '000s of migrants sailing across the Med?

Should we sink them? not rescue when boat sinks as we try to turn around? & send back to Libya/Tunisia

Should we tow back to France and risk an almost certain diplomatic incident, even possible conflict with French Navy.

People come out with the "we should be like Aus" totally ignoring the fact we don't have large empty Islands off our coastline, face far higher numbers.

We can be ‘’more like Aus’

It’s people working pretty hard not to get similar set up, god knows why

Chickenkeev · 25/11/2023 12:22

bombastix · 25/11/2023 12:01

Diversity in of itself isn't a virtue though people will tell you so. More homogenous societies tend to be happier and more stable.

Diversity is good for business. That is not necessarily the same as good for people.

Of course it is! It absolutely is! There are so many benefits to being exposed to other cultures and beliefs, it broadens horizens and widens one perspective. I can't see any benefit whatsoever in having a closed society. It's limiting tbh. Everyone needs to learn about other ways of being, and to know that people can rub along with the other quite nicely. It's one of my favourite things about my childs school tbh, it not a religious one, so it gets lots of different people. I love that she gets that exposure, i think it's really important.

jasflowers · 25/11/2023 12:15

25% in Holland voted for the far right Wilders, he may not even be in Govt if the other parties form their own coalition.

What i'd like to know is how countries in Europe should deal with 100s of '000s of migrants sailing across the Med?

Should we sink them? not rescue when boat sinks as we try to turn around? & send back to Libya/Tunisia

Should we tow back to France and risk an almost certain diplomatic incident, even possible conflict with French Navy.

People come out with the "we should be like Aus" totally ignoring the fact we don't have large empty Islands off our coastline, face far higher numbers.

lljkk · 25/11/2023 12:11

MoonLife · 24/11/2023 12:33

For all of those who welcome mass immigration, where on earth do you live? I counter its not in the densely packed inner city areas where resources are stretched to breaking point and community tensions are at an all time high?

I live part time in a small city, in a neighbourhood that is about 40% 1st gentn immigrants (I'm guessing). There are countless Euro-supermarkets within walking distance, plus countless Turkish cafes, barbershops, Halal shops. there's a street of mostly Kurdish, I suspect. It's very noticeable when I actually hear English being spoken, and even then it's probably with a foreign accent. last week (for complicated reasons) I spoke to a lot of Polish people, plus some Lithuanians. There's a bench with gypsy-looking people always parked on it (colourful, cheerful) in the city centre. I look forward to seeing them.

I think I count as 'welcoming' mass immigration by the standards of this thread. I am an immigrant myself... I don't know about tensions. I'm not aware of any yet. It seems like the "White indigenous" people moved away, and this area so it became where the immigrants could afford to live. the little supermarkets thrive partly because the immigrants lack cars to get to out of town Asda. Everyone made their choices.

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 12:02

Brexit was just immigration and borders
And many didn't even understand which immigration.

There were some unbelievable moments about this. One hour BBC has a guy on a street talking about how he will vote Brexit so less Asians come in, another hour there is South East Asian business owner talking about how he will vote for Brexit because it will mean more visa allowance for South East Asians.
Unbelievable times....
I don't know how that first reporter kept professionalism on like that.

bombastix · 25/11/2023 12:01

Diversity in of itself isn't a virtue though people will tell you so. More homogenous societies tend to be happier and more stable.

Diversity is good for business. That is not necessarily the same as good for people.

MoonLife · 25/11/2023 11:56

Dwappy · 25/11/2023 09:55

The houses are hmos, crime is everywhere, the streets are litter strewn and filthy...It's dangerous. All around There is division. I don't see harmony and different communities mixing. No one knows their neighbours. The council might wheel out the annual mela as a display of the diversity in the area, but it's smoke and mirrors, it has zero impact on unifying people.

My parents lived somewhere like that a few years ago. It never used to be though. It was a very typical terraced London street when my parents bought the house in the 70s. Over time they knew all their neighbours. Would chat to everyone in the street. People helped each other. The kids played out. People looked after their houses and gardens.
Fast forward 40 years and you wouldn't recognise it. They were one of the last long standing residents when they finally moved. They had 1 HMO directly next door, 2 across the road and 1 more 3 doors down. That one also had a "back garden shed" which more people lived in. And I'm sure many others did as well. At least one of the houses constantly burned builders waste in the garden causing huge amounts of fumes. The front garden of their direct neighbour was a total and utter shit tip. Mounds of rubbish and waste which would start spilling into my parents garden. Most of their neighbours didn't speak any English so they couldn't even talk to them about it. And the ones that did just either told them to fuck off or laughed. Even if my parents just wanted to chat, a group of young men drinking outside their house have no interest in having a chat with 2 elderly people. These men would also piss where they were gathered in the street. I was so glad when they finally moved.
But this is often the reality of high immigration numbers. My parents couldn't have cared less where someone was from. But the reality is a lot of the time people do not wish to integrate and especially when surrounded by people from their own culture they will socialise and mix with them only.
People will say HMOs are part of the problem as its horrible for the people living in them. Yes I agree. But there quite honestly isn't the housing or the space for every single local person and immigrant to have their own lovely 2 bedroom house in a nice area with good transport and shops etc.
And there's no point saying well flats are an option as well because they become the same as the HMOs. Where I live in London they built a lovely block of flats (only about 6 levels not a huge tower block). It started off with lovely flower beds along the walls outside etc. Beautifully painted gates to the entrance to the car park and bin area. It houses mainly families. Now I have no idea of the nationality of the people living there but they are definitely of mixed cultures. But the fact still is after 5 years its a total dump. The piles of rubbish and shopping trollies that line the street outside. The flower beds have been destroyed and are full of cigarette ends and rubbish. The nice gates are broken and smashed and are covered in graffiti. Even inside the main entrance and stairway there's piles of rubbish inside (it's glass so you can see inside).
Anyway my point is there is huge numbers of the population including immigrants that have zero interest in integrating and living in a nice community. And mass immigration does nothing to help things. Especially when you have a mix of cultures. It rarely works well.

Thank you for sharing your parents experience, I recognise it all. I don't know how else to get through to blinkered groups sat in their leafy suburbs that THIS is the reality of high immigration. It's laughable when I hear posters on here looking to move to ' diverse' areas and someone mentions an inner city suburb might be the answer where 50 odd cultures live cheek to jowl; oh no they couldn't possibly live there, the schools are not up to par or the nearest Waitrose is 10 miles away.!... I'm reality, they want a sanitised version of diversity minus all the gritty bits.