Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Europen governments need to respond to immigration?

564 replies

Finlesswonder · 24/11/2023 06:45

So the Netherlands is going to have a far right government.
Sweden has moved to the right.
Finland has shut its borders.
Countries that have traditionally been liberal are hardening and irrespective of the many issues listed its to do with immigration.

Ireland has seen violent protests last night following a series of stabbings.
In the UK we obviously had Brexit.

I think governments need to start responding to voters feelings on immigration as if they don't we will continue to see a general slide to the right in Europe, when actually these countries aren't right wing: it feels like a single issue is distorting the entire political landscape?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
jasflowers · 25/11/2023 15:56

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 12:55

Cleverly ‘"The mission is to stop the boats. That's the promise to the British people. Never lose sight of the mission.

"There are multiple methods. Don't fixate on the methods. Focus on the mission."

I look forward to hearing how he will do it. Aus has fewer than that in offshore as they’re reached the aim.

Decades ago and no party will touch it. Watching people tie themselves in knots over this is bizarre. Whatever Aus did it will be needed more as we progress into more climate issues.

A totally different narrative to Sunak and Braverman?

He wont do it because the only realistic why to stop is to physically turn the boats around in the channel & that wont happen, once here, the vast majority will stay.

This whole saga is due to leaving the EU and having little or no influence on the French/EU.

Australia had a large island grouping to send to and never had a million + migrants trying to or have got into Europe.

Finlesswonder · 25/11/2023 15:53

I grew up abroad and me and my brother weren't allowed to speak English together at school, in fact we got detention for it, the idea being that is was exclusionary to others and would only do us harm.
The school made us foreign kids go to intensive language classes while the other kids did their normal "own language" classes, there were no interpreters.
Our parents also had to go to language classes so they could communicate at a basic level with the teachers, otherwise they just got skipped at parent teacher evenings.

OP posts:
inamarina · 25/11/2023 15:51

Sloth66 · 25/11/2023 15:33

This is happening where I live. Some days I don’t hear English being spoken anywhere. I don’t feel there is much community cohesion any more. It’s more parallel communities each with their own resources and keeping to themselves

It’s more parallel communities each with their own resources and keeping to themselves

That’s exactly what it feels like where I live. Nothing exciting or vibrant about it at all, more cold and isolating.

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 15:44

inamarina · 25/11/2023 15:19

Yes, the self flagellation is odd.
By all means, be critical about some aspects of your history/ culture. But I’ve seen people on here describe the UK as a ‘total shit hole’ or ‘totally racist’ and I always wonder what perfect countries they’re comparing themselves to?

I agree mn is especially bad on this

Overall there’s so much handwringing and dicking around tbh

I don’t mind some need for skilled visas but it will fall due to AI

Why we prevaricate over sorting out irregular migration idk but mn again particularly glued to it as a good

Sloth66 · 25/11/2023 15:33

inamarina · 25/11/2023 13:52

Well said.

This is happening where I live. Some days I don’t hear English being spoken anywhere. I don’t feel there is much community cohesion any more. It’s more parallel communities each with their own resources and keeping to themselves

RamblingEclectic · 25/11/2023 15:23

I agree that society as a whole, and governments as an institute of society, need to be able to discuss the benefits and risks of migration openly, just like with everything else, but it seems groups tend to discuss one side or the other. We can't deal with the issues, if we can't discuss them without people jumping on about large scale economics.

We also need to recognize that there has hundred of changes to the migration system over the last couple of decades, many triumphed as a way to control immigration and ensure we get the right people, but really, a previous Chancellor said it best - the migration system in the UK is a for-profit system both for the government and the "private partners" migrants are required to use. They're never going to reduce it when their companies are making money off of it, and benefit from how it is now. They're going to keep making changes, many of them applying to immigrants who have been here decades who will have to shell out to 'private partners'. I mean, next December we have hundreds of thousands of biometric residency cards expiring, an issue known for years that no matter when applying they had that date, and all we have now is, 'we'll tell you what to do next in early 2024', and I would not be surprised if it's going to be another way for them to make money (nevermind how many lost their ability to work or access public services when BRPs became required and people who had had indefinite leave then had to prove years of residency - and women originally on spousal visas were particularly bad hit with many struggling to be able to provide that proof or have 'appropriate' reference).

There is also the issue that we are going to have to go through the population bulge. Migration can be part of that, but we can't be expecting to import and drain the people from other countries for us. That's...kinda creepy.

Student immigration, for example, bring billions into our economy. Do you want to be poorer without that income? Why do you want to reduce this income stream?

They bring income into the UK, sure, but what is the impact on the local area? Are people at the local level seeing that benefit? Or are they just seeing the downsides and handling the risks? Is enough brought in to outweigh the impacts on people?

Even without migration, there are issues when areas push far more towards students because they are "good for business", but ignore the impact that they don't pay council tax and the businesses they use aren't the same ones that the community that use. When you're in an area where everything that is being cut, the students are accessing at university, you get animosity between groups. You get the 'what is the point' when the only people who seem to benefit are those making money off of students, not the people living alongside them. Just having the additional resources means nothing.

People who oppose immigration won't discuss the economic impact of restricting it.
I oppose the government treating migrants as a 'for profit' measure for themselves, whether it's continuing to move the goalposts to immigrants have to keep being that economic benefit or that local communities don't see that benefit.
I oppose that my daughter, who is an inclusion teaching assistant apprentice, has been dropped into supporting literacy for dozens of children with little to no English, when she's had no training yet and is basically just supporting them use a computer. Neither the schools nor wider community here have seen the economic benefit to help with language and other things needed for community building. Schools and charities are working to get sponsorship deals to cover these desparate needs.
As a migrant, I oppose to being whittled down to my economic benefit. It's dehumanzing and I find putting us down to that only benefits people who make money off of us, not the communities we choose to live in nor does it get anyone to see us as people. Really, it just another way to rate who is a 'good' immigrant - the ones with high paying jobs and students who leave - from the bad immigrants: those who came on spousal visas and have largely worked in their communities unpaid, often legally barred from doing otherwise.

I live in area that's nationally noted to be deprived and have higher immigration - and where the Reform Party has strong control, even our mayor is Reform now. Most people aren't discussing 'economic impacts' because that's how professionals talk to each other (and I am beyond sick of professionals writing things they claim is for the community, when clearly it's just for other professionals), they're discussing difficulties talking with the receptionist at the GP surgery, they're discussing homes being bought by people who live out of country for the use of students and nothing happens when there is an issue, they're discussing how we've lost another community centre that's now been left to rot, but the university is getting council funding to take over another city centre building, it's discussing how Labour hasn't really learned its lesson yet about not insulting people that they want to vote for them and we're going to keep being stuck until they and other similar parties learn that, learn to deal with their in-fighting and get as tactical as the groups who spout anti-immigration rhetoics and focus only on the negatives - they can be awful ideologically, but great at tactics to get those votes and put off those who would have voted against them both from voting and in engaging in the wider community.

The landscape won't shift until those who want to support immigration actually discuss and be open to dealing with this issue, rather than chanting mantras and using cold language like 'economic impact' that make sense on a large-scale level, but means very little to most people who've been told how great it is for decades and seen none of the benefits and been dealing with the risks. We have to move past this idea that we can only discuss the benefits of immigration or we're hating on people fleeing the worst (which most immigrants aren't). We immigrants can discuss the issues with immigration and you born-Brits can do it too. You have to if things are going to improve.

*How many posters agree that it's fine to let universities collapse if they can't have 600k new foreign students each year?

Oh, I'm all for the crumbling Ivory Towers to face they're crumbling rather than continue propping them up with more human beings, many who won't get the promised benefits. It's not like that funding has benefited most of the people who work in them, the entire academic funding method has done little but incentivise the worst practice in the workplace, research, and teaching.

inamarina · 25/11/2023 15:19

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 14:48

Ah, it's the self flagellation, isn't it.

The only issue I have really with Britain is the class obsession somewhat and needed to put pelple in some box. Which doesn't work for immigrants! I grew up what would be WC in UK, lived in WC areas in UK, don't dress in brands etc, speak like my beak grew, drink lager(picky tho), but my fridge and pantry screams MC+++ (which it wouldn't in places DH and I come from. Poor-ish people's food!) 😂 It makes people sometimes bit uncomfortable.
I mean like wtf is MC on fermented cabbage and rice with chicken - kabsa🤷 (not together!).
DH had very much noted difference in how he was treated when he bought more expensive car and jacket.

Come to think of it, there is one more. And related to the topic!
Demands for diversity everywhere. "Our countryside is too British/white!" No shit Sherlock. Countryside in most countries is more native than big cities for obvious reasons - work. If not in all countries. It's not a bad thing, it's normal thing. Yet people moan about it as if it's something bad and unusual and needed to be corrected. How would one achieve diversity in villages somehow mirroring census numbers for demographics in England and Wales?
"So... Kingham needs some immigrants. We need you to move in there. They have about 1k population, few people from non White English groups, and we need couple of Arabs and White other. So we need you to move there, we will move one of the English families elswehere to level it there"
(Kingham was chosen in random, these are not real numbers).

It sounds ridiculous but sometimes this is how some people sound to me when they talk/write moan about this.

I hope it's clear not jumbled. Sorry

Yes, the self flagellation is odd.
By all means, be critical about some aspects of your history/ culture. But I’ve seen people on here describe the UK as a ‘total shit hole’ or ‘totally racist’ and I always wonder what perfect countries they’re comparing themselves to?

inamarina · 25/11/2023 14:59

TheThingIsYeah · 25/11/2023 14:46

@lljkk

There's a bench with gypsy-looking people always parked on it (colourful, cheerful) in the city centre. I look forward to seeing them.

Why do you look forward to seeing them?

They're not going to be growing the economy if they are sitting around on benches all day. What do they bring to the UK?

What do they bring to the UK?

They’re colourful and cheerful, that’s the contribution apparently.
Seriously though, I noticed that comment too, as it could have been describing our town.
Unlike PP though, I’m feeling less enthusiastic about it.
Fwiw, I quite like some of the international shops, but for every well stocked, welcoming Euroshop or Asian supermarket there are ten barber shops, odd cafes with groups of men hanging around outside blocking the pavement and ‘American candy’ shops selling vapes.
And that’s pretty much it. Most of the other shops have closed down due to lack of customers and high levels of shoplifting.

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 14:48

inamarina · 25/11/2023 13:44

DH and I are 1st gen and even we preferred more English areas. Not completely 100% English (encountered couple where we would NOT be welcome and couple which were quite shitholes with rubbish etc), but not ultra diverse.

I can totally relate to this.
I think there are diverse areas that feel vibrant and welcoming, while others might seem like an entirely different country - and not necessarily in a good way.
I have both English and immigrant friends. Interestingly, the immigrant ones have a much more positive outlook on the UK, its culture and traditions than some (presumably) English posters here on MN.

Ah, it's the self flagellation, isn't it.

The only issue I have really with Britain is the class obsession somewhat and needed to put pelple in some box. Which doesn't work for immigrants! I grew up what would be WC in UK, lived in WC areas in UK, don't dress in brands etc, speak like my beak grew, drink lager(picky tho), but my fridge and pantry screams MC+++ (which it wouldn't in places DH and I come from. Poor-ish people's food!) 😂 It makes people sometimes bit uncomfortable.
I mean like wtf is MC on fermented cabbage and rice with chicken - kabsa🤷 (not together!).
DH had very much noted difference in how he was treated when he bought more expensive car and jacket.

Come to think of it, there is one more. And related to the topic!
Demands for diversity everywhere. "Our countryside is too British/white!" No shit Sherlock. Countryside in most countries is more native than big cities for obvious reasons - work. If not in all countries. It's not a bad thing, it's normal thing. Yet people moan about it as if it's something bad and unusual and needed to be corrected. How would one achieve diversity in villages somehow mirroring census numbers for demographics in England and Wales?
"So... Kingham needs some immigrants. We need you to move in there. They have about 1k population, few people from non White English groups, and we need couple of Arabs and White other. So we need you to move there, we will move one of the English families elswehere to level it there"
(Kingham was chosen in random, these are not real numbers).

It sounds ridiculous but sometimes this is how some people sound to me when they talk/write moan about this.

I hope it's clear not jumbled. Sorry

TheThingIsYeah · 25/11/2023 14:46

@lljkk

There's a bench with gypsy-looking people always parked on it (colourful, cheerful) in the city centre. I look forward to seeing them.

Why do you look forward to seeing them?

They're not going to be growing the economy if they are sitting around on benches all day. What do they bring to the UK?

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 25/11/2023 14:43

‘I'm thinking of kids learning to get on with other cultures etc. ‘

Like in Leicester?

roarrfeckingroar · 25/11/2023 14:39

Most people don't want hoards of young men from v different cultures arriving here. Lack of integration is a real problem. However, governments don't listen. We're putting the success of western liberalism at serious risk and indigenous populations should object before it's too late,

Finlesswonder · 25/11/2023 14:38

@lljkk
Why do we need to grow the economy?

OP posts:
lljkk · 25/11/2023 14:36

ps: would we provide all those additional health care professional places under existing terms, so similar loan packages and last 2 years of a medical degree tuition funded, for instance? How much more would we the taxpayers need to pay to fund that?

Would additonal STEM degree places & apprenticeships be provided under existing terms, too, and how would that be funded? What would be the tax bill to create all those additional training opportunities, keeping in mind we're asking for lower qualifications at start point under these scenarios, so additional training time may be required.

Someone on radio says "more bursaries for nurses" : who wants to pay additional tax to fund that?

lljkk · 25/11/2023 14:30

How will the British economy grow without 150k skilled visa immigrants per year?

How many posters agree that it's fine to let universities collapse if they can't have 600k new foreign students each year?

If UK medical schools lower their entry requirements for domestic applicants, so supposing applicants could get onto a medical course with ABB at A-level, and clinical placements become very scarce or overcrowded or limited in duration, and annual medical school exams became easier, then UK could generate all of its own doctors. Are we all happy with medicine being a much easier degree for people to qualify for?

If medicine is much easier then I guess all the STEM courses could be easier to get onto & stay on, at Uni. Are the anti-immigrant folk all happy with that?

If the cascading down the system to make every job easier happens, who is going to be agricultural or social care worker ? Would we start importing lots of people for those purposes, maybe have Singapore style foreign worker dormitories for them?

inamarina · 25/11/2023 13:52

Dwappy · 25/11/2023 12:50

But the problem is some areas of start off diverse then one or more cultures becomes more prominent. Diversity and multi cultural doesn't always mean one shop per culture and the cultural split of residents is even. What often happens is a huge amount of one culture move to an area and a large number of the shops are for that culture and the people all speak their own language. And when this happens all the pro immigration people say "well of COURSE the immigrant people want to speak their own language and buy the food they're used to and celebrate their own religions and cultural things! Its important and essential they do this to keep their culture alive!" But yet if you are British you must not get upset that you are no longer able to speak English to your neighbours and your local shops are full of food you don't recognise. You're now meant to embrace the diversity or you're labelled racist or xenophobic.
The reason immigrants like being around people like themselves is the same reason British people like being around people like themselves. If you have no shared experiences it can become very isolating and you don't feel you are part of a community.

Well said.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 25/11/2023 13:45

Life changed and wages didn't rise with the cost of living, so people couldn't afford to work these jobs as they wouldn't cover even the rent on a 1 bed flat, let alone support a family.

What jobs are they doing? We have shortages of workers everywhere and we keep importing workers, so what better paid jobs are the the people who cannot afford to do 'immigrant' level paid jobs doing?

inamarina · 25/11/2023 13:44

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 12:40

DH and I are 1st gen and even we preferred more English areas. Not completely 100% English (encountered couple where we would NOT be welcome and couple which were quite shitholes with rubbish etc), but not ultra diverse. Where someone obviously recommend we should live, you know, cause we were immigrants. Lots of the very immigrant heavy areas look as bad as some pps described unfortunately.
Friendships groups were mainly immigrants though. Most lived in similar areas to us, slight mix, slight. It works better imho

DH and I are 1st gen and even we preferred more English areas. Not completely 100% English (encountered couple where we would NOT be welcome and couple which were quite shitholes with rubbish etc), but not ultra diverse.

I can totally relate to this.
I think there are diverse areas that feel vibrant and welcoming, while others might seem like an entirely different country - and not necessarily in a good way.
I have both English and immigrant friends. Interestingly, the immigrant ones have a much more positive outlook on the UK, its culture and traditions than some (presumably) English posters here on MN.

MoonLife · 25/11/2023 13:35

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 13:21

Please don't push the narrative that " people born here" don't want the jobs as they are lazy or selfish or uneducated or entitled.

When I worked in fast food I was laughed at for working there by some English lads who literally said they wouldn't do that job. These are the ones causing the narrative.

Yes, I don't disbelieve you - I can well imagine that happening . But you've missed my point, life wasn't always that way here - people used to work the crappy jobs because they paid a decent wage which could afford you your own home. Life changed and wages didn't rise with the cost of living, so people couldn't afford to work these jobs as they wouldn't cover even the rent on a 1 bed flat, let alone support a family. So cheap immigrant labour became a thing and HMOs sprung up, because the cost of rent and utilities could be spread across a group making life grim, but affordable. I take issue with the people are " lazy" here rhetoric and don't want to do these jobs because it's false and untrue largely. They simply can't afford to in many cases. I see exploitation on all levels.

bakebeans · 25/11/2023 13:31

@MoonLife I don't recall that I have referred to people born here as lazy and uneducated?
have you had a look at the care homes and wards in the hospital lately? Do you not recall during covid, fruit pickers and many low labour jobs had an impact as many immigrants had returned home.
Many trained GP's are leaving the NHS to go abroad for better pay and conditions. Nurses are leaving in droves.

like your father, my father, grandfather, would work for an honest living . my mother in the eighties worked 3 jobs whilst running a home. I have. worked 2 jobs whilst at university.
unfortunately, not everyone will.

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 13:21

Please don't push the narrative that " people born here" don't want the jobs as they are lazy or selfish or uneducated or entitled.

When I worked in fast food I was laughed at for working there by some English lads who literally said they wouldn't do that job. These are the ones causing the narrative.

Seymour5 · 25/11/2023 13:20

@bakebeans its sad, but he has exactly the same rights as a British citizen now. Lots of people of working age, with no major health issues or dependent children are homeless with no priority for housing. Hopefully the publicity might alert someone to offer him a room til he gets on his feet.

MoonLife · 25/11/2023 13:19

bakebeans · 25/11/2023 13:01

https://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greater-manchester-news/plight-of-journalist-living-in-28034594
not sure what the answer is. This gentleman is having to sleep in his Monclaer coat due threats as a Journalist in Qatar.

As some say , immigration have been the ones to step in to fill jobs as nurses, carers and fruit pickers. Probably because the people born here know they won't be getting paid enough so don't want to train or are leaving in droves.

It's not going to get better

Please don't push the narrative that " people born here" don't want the jobs as they are lazy or selfish or uneducated or entitled. People will do anything as long as they are paid fairly and can afford an adequate standard of living. My father, now in his eighties, worked on an assembly line all his life, largely on the night shift. Do you think he enjoyed his work or felt a sense of accomplishment at the end of a very long day in a windowless environment breathing toxic fumes? Did he hell. But back in those days, working hard paid off and lead to your own home and well fed children and money for an annual family holiday. My point being, pay people fairly and the working classes " born here" will work because who wouldn't aspire to a greater quality of life! But no, keep on pushing the propaganda as only immigrants will do these jobs because " our own" are too lazy and work shy.

Chickenkeev · 25/11/2023 13:09

inamarina · 25/11/2023 13:00

What about immigrants who are not particularly interested in learning about the ‘ways of being’ of the locals though? I’m not saying all immigrants are like this, but where I live I see plenty of examples where that seems to be the case.
Over all I also prefer living amongst people from different backgrounds and cultures, I’m an immigrant myself.
But there needs to be some kind of social cohesion, a sense of community.
That’s not always the case in areas with high numbers of immigrants, particularly when there are large groups from the same background who just stay among themselves.

I appreciate that is a problem. I supoose it shouldn't be allowed to happen that communities can develop where English isn't needed. How that's done, i don't know though.

EasternStandard · 25/11/2023 13:02

Sauerkrautsandwich · 25/11/2023 12:59

Climate issues is afaik still not recognised as aaylum claim internationally. Though it's being talked about since some islands are dissapearing and there is about to be few homeless nations. I think it's being sorted under disaster displacement atm

We’re so far removed from 1951 convention now, although huge industries both legal and illegal depend on the set up so it won’t change without challenge

Plus media narrative selling us a version that reinforces it

And it might survive with your average profiteering and trafficking but with climate and extra volatility on top I say no chance

Swipe left for the next trending thread