Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate it when people say 'name change obviously...' at the start of a post

35 replies

DodoTime · 23/11/2023 22:45

'NC as this could be a bit outing...'

Why do people say this? Do they actually think people care? Do they think others are following their every word and tracking their MN past. It always sounds so narcissistic to me. If you are changing your name to protect your identity, surely it would be less outing not to tell everyone that's what you've done.

I feel like I lose brain cells whenever I read NC...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Globules · 24/11/2023 07:51

So why does typing "NC for this...penis beaker..." make a person more trustworthy?!

Anyone can do that if they're determined to troll!

AngelAurora · 24/11/2023 07:50

Fully agree OP, like seriously anyone gives a shit or recognises them in real life. So dramatic. Just roll your eyes

Lougle · 24/11/2023 07:49

Totally agree. The trouble with name changes is that you have no idea who has been around for 15 years and knows how the site works and who is new and doesn't know.

Globules · 24/11/2023 07:48

I know some of the threads that you refer to @Lougle as i've been around for while too.

I find it's better to be guarded by choosing to not engage rather than by trying to investigate an anonymous poster on an anonymous website. Surely people have got better things to do with their time than try to catch someone out.

And even when trolls are caught out by MN "investigators" it gives them a buzz anyway and feeds them more.

Best to ignore.

Lougle · 24/11/2023 07:11

@Globules over the years there have been people with highly distressing circumstances and MNers have rallied, often giving their own experiences and sometimes, time in RL. Sadly, a proportion of those people have turned out to be trolls, copying and pasting pictures from the internet and representing them as their sick baby, etc., so the MN community became a bit more guarded and tend to want to check that they aren't feeding a troll.

Globules · 24/11/2023 07:07

Circumferences · 23/11/2023 23:08

Why would you bother wasting time researching the history of another poster?!

In highly sensitive political topics like the sex/gender debate or Palestine/Israel or Tory/Labour... You'll be amazed at the trolling that goes on, and therefore users need to check whether they're dealing with a genuine MN regular with opinions or wasting their time with a troll-bot. To be fair, even in parking threads sometimes people need to background check who they're talking to first!

This is what I don't understand.

If someone is being deliberately inflammatory, then why does it matter if they're a regular poster or not? Ignore their post and move on. I don't understand why people choose to waste their time "verifying" an unknown poster on an unknown website. Reply, or don't reply.

I have about 6 user names on the go. I switch between them. I started a thread and the first few posts were telling me I was a journalist.

A) if you think that, why bother wasting your time typing it out, as it's not going to change anything.

B) I ignored their posts and replied to the people who answered my question. When I began responding to those who were actually being helpful, the first few posters came back and started engaging, pretending nothing had ever happened 🤦

Ignoring the trolls is a far better response than trying to call them out as one. And much more time saving.

Lougle · 24/11/2023 07:07

People used to say "I've name-changed but penis beaker, cutted up ham, sistene chapel..." So you're getting off lightly with 'I've name-changed'.

If people didn't go around like Miss Marple and piece together the back story from 100 threads it wouldn't happen.

However, I rarely name change and just have a policy that I only post stuff I'd be happy for anyone to read over my shoulder as I type it, so I never have to say any of that.

lifeisbollux · 24/11/2023 07:03

I name change every few days, and I’ve re registered an embarrassing amount of times due to forgetting passwords and it just being easier to re reg.

I’ve had quite a few “interesting first post” comments in my time. I’ve been here since 2004.

Globules · 24/11/2023 06:57

XenoBitch · 23/11/2023 23:04

This has happened to me. Someone on a really innocent thread (about tech) decided that because I disagreed with them, they had to closely copy my username, do an AS of me to dig up posts, and make a new thread with "me" complaining about all sorts or weird and random stuff. They also sockpuppeted all over it to me look even worse.

Recently, someone AS me to find out where I live, and dragged that into another thread too.

It is sad. I use AS to find threads/topics I am interested in, never people. I personally think AS searching posters other than yourself should not be allowed... but that is a whole different thread.

Seriously?!

How better to show you have no actual life than to do this? I'm sorry that happened to you @XenoBitch What a sad life that person must lead. I can't understand what they were hoping to gain by it.

Starseeking · 24/11/2023 00:55

I've started my own post on MN perhaps up to 10 times, and always name-change for that. I also comment a lot on other threads.

On any given post I've started, the details are unremarkable. Put them together, and if you knew me, you'd be able to confirm it was me.

I always announce that I've name-changed at the start, because some of the things I've posted here people may think are so outrageous I've made them up for fun; though to be fair even I might think they were made up, if they hadn't happened to me/weren't my life.

SurvivorsInc · 24/11/2023 00:45

Flandango · 24/11/2023 00:37

They name change because their other half does a very niche activity. Like hit a small ball into a hole with a stick. Or ride a machine with only two wheels. There is only a handful of people that do these very rare 'hobbies'

I must admit it amuses me a bit when posters talk about "outing" hobbies, I find my brain is then trying to come up with all sorts of things, the more bizarre the better. I can compile quite a list of niche hobbies in my head!

SurvivorsInc · 24/11/2023 00:42

There are some posters who do have to be careful of people not tracing them, people who have left or are considering leaving domestic abuse for example, it could be they worry about being recognised by some small detail about themselves. Even if their post isn't about the abuse itself, but also especially if it is.

Flandango · 24/11/2023 00:37

They name change because their other half does a very niche activity. Like hit a small ball into a hole with a stick. Or ride a machine with only two wheels. There is only a handful of people that do these very rare 'hobbies'

FiveShelties · 24/11/2023 00:34

Perhaps they put that because they are a troll😁

ScattieHattie1 · 24/11/2023 00:17

narcissistic? Are you batshit?

sowhisper · 23/11/2023 23:39

Cos some individuals like to trawl back through old posts and try and outsmart you. If you’re wanting to rescue a dog, they’ll say, awww but how on earth can you provide for a pet when your DH is redundant/you work full time. That’s just a random example I made up but that’s what happens. It’s horrible if it happens to you, so best to name change really

WonderLife · 23/11/2023 23:20

Otherwise you get 10 'interesting first post' posts instead of answers to the question!

WrongSwanson · 23/11/2023 23:19

ColleenDonaghy · 23/11/2023 22:48

They say it to demonstrate they're a regular user even if advanced search only shows that post, because troll hunting is rampant.

They NC so that if someone recognises their description of the accident their DC had at school today, they can't also use advanced search to read their opinion of their MIL, their lazy DH's cycling addiction, their hatred of their job and the fact that they're ovulating so planning a shag tonight.

NCing is sensible and to be advised.

Exactly

NotInTheMoodForIt · 23/11/2023 23:14

UsingChangeofName · 23/11/2023 23:02

As per all the posts. Which doesn't make sense that the vote is almost 50:50

You can't vote in the app. I think that's sometimes why the poll results differ from the posts.

NotInTheMoodForIt · 23/11/2023 23:11

People often do go searching a posters history though, and when they find nothing they'll say "interesting first post OP" or "you signed up just to say that?"

So posters who tell people they've name changed are likely doing it for that reason.

I've seen many threads on here where someone goes through a posters history and then mentions irrelevant things on a different thread as some sort of GOTCHA too.

Circumferences · 23/11/2023 23:08

Why would you bother wasting time researching the history of another poster?!

In highly sensitive political topics like the sex/gender debate or Palestine/Israel or Tory/Labour... You'll be amazed at the trolling that goes on, and therefore users need to check whether they're dealing with a genuine MN regular with opinions or wasting their time with a troll-bot. To be fair, even in parking threads sometimes people need to background check who they're talking to first!

DodoTime · 23/11/2023 23:08

LadyMacB · 23/11/2023 22:58

I’ve name changed for this response.

It doesn’t bother me to be honest.

Except you haven't you rascally crumpet eater! 😝

Sorry I just wanted to see if the search function worked, I won't do it again.

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 23/11/2023 23:04

Globules · 23/11/2023 22:59

I understand.

That's because I feel sorry for the sad sacks on here who spend actual time searching through a posters history to try to gain some leverage on them.

This isn't real life. It's a website. Anyone can say anything and be anyone. What sort of person bothers wasting time researching the history of another poster?!

Edited

This has happened to me. Someone on a really innocent thread (about tech) decided that because I disagreed with them, they had to closely copy my username, do an AS of me to dig up posts, and make a new thread with "me" complaining about all sorts or weird and random stuff. They also sockpuppeted all over it to me look even worse.

Recently, someone AS me to find out where I live, and dragged that into another thread too.

It is sad. I use AS to find threads/topics I am interested in, never people. I personally think AS searching posters other than yourself should not be allowed... but that is a whole different thread.

UsingChangeofName · 23/11/2023 23:02

As per all the posts. Which doesn't make sense that the vote is almost 50:50

Globules · 23/11/2023 22:59

I understand.

That's because I feel sorry for the sad sacks on here who spend actual time searching through a posters history to try to gain some leverage on them.

This isn't real life. It's a website. Anyone can say anything and be anyone. What sort of person bothers wasting time researching the history of another poster?!