Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask that my daughter be removed from a certain teachers lessons, but remain entered for a GCSE?

109 replies

LolaLouise · 23/11/2023 15:26

Not that im even sure that is possible?

My daughter has issues with a specific teacher at school. She is year 10 GCSE age. She has zero issues in any other lesson. She regularly gets the class award for most achievement points achieved that week, she got the house leader award for the half term, she is a student voice rep for her house, she has positive feedback, and is working at grade 7+ in every subject, including the lesson being discussed.

My daughter and this teacher had a "falling out" last school year when the teacher, accidentally, opened an email concerning my daughters private life onto the whiteboard for the whole class to see. My daughter was very upset and angry about this, and quite rightfully in my opinion, voiced this upset and asked that the teacher apologised. The teacher took the stance of "Im not apologising to a student" and for the remainder of the year my daughter did the bare minimum for this subject and work in lessons, and her homework was half arsed. This school year, after talking to my DD at length over summer about how sometimes you may feel you are owed an apology, but you wont always get it, sometimes you need to draw a line under events and start a fresh, my daughter tried just that. Her school book is very thorough, very neat, homework was taken seriously, and she is doing extra revision or pre reading as the focus of the lesson changes. However, the teacher has not done the same. She continues to pick my daughter up for anything, handing out detentions etc for minor situations, shouting and screaming at her (and the entire class by all accounts) for no reason. My daughter has come home in tears multiple times over how this teacher has treated her in the lesson. She posted negative feedback on the parent portal that is so unbelievably petty. The only negative behavioural points my daughter has had all school year are from this one teacher.

Despite this, as i said, my daughter does all her work in this subject, homework up to date, and high predicted grades. The teacher has now expressed she wants my daughter removed from this GCSE entirely subject (which i have been made aware of by the head of year) and placed on another she has no interest in at all, and is more vocational than academic, and also doesnt lead into what she wants to do at A level unlike this subject. I have stated categorically that my daughter is not to be removed from this subject against her wishes, when her grades are good, if they cant provide an alternative teacher - ill tutor her myself as it is a subject area i have an MSc in already. It is clear to me the relationship between her and this teacher is beyond repair, if it is causing this much upset for my daughter, and the teacher if she is requesting my daughter is removed from the course, surely having her remain entered, but privately tutored is a workable solution?

OP posts:
napody · 23/11/2023 17:03

LolaLouise · 23/11/2023 17:01

I have requested another meeting with the house lead next week when im off work to see if we can solve it, im not against privately entering her into the GCSE, if that means she can sit the exam, I would also obviously prefer it was done via school for ease. But i also dont think she should be made to attend another subject, and be expected to do the associated work, that she has no interest in doing in its place.

Edited

Seems a very reasonable stance. Hope it gets resolved.

Igmum · 23/11/2023 17:02

I started reading this thinking that YABU but you're really not. I would escalate this. It sounds as though the teacher is carrying out a mini vendetta against your daughter and that is really not acceptable. Head teacher then governors. Good luck

LolaLouise · 23/11/2023 17:01

I have requested another meeting with the house lead next week when im off work to see if we can solve it, im not against privately entering her into the GCSE, if that means she can sit the exam, I would also obviously prefer it was done via school for ease. But i also dont think she should be made to attend another subject, and be expected to do the associated work, that she has no interest in doing in its place.

OP posts:
agent765 · 23/11/2023 16:59

I had a similar issue with a teacher decades ago.

It took a while before my mum believed me but when she did she gave me a small voice-activated recorder to put in my satchel.

My teacher was one of those types who wanted to be cool with the kids and had singled me out in several lessons, calling me a lesbian, asking me what it was like etc.

My mum was appalled and took the recorder to the head. I was allowed to do the 'O' level rather than be entered for a CSE but only if I sat in the corridor and got my lessons from another pupil.

Looking back now it seems incredible he was allowed to do that but revenge for me was getting an A in the subject despite a full year without lessons.

Can your DD record (without telling classmates) so you can take evidence to the head?

I remember how badly this bullying affected me so I hope you can get it sorted.

napody · 23/11/2023 16:56

TBH I don't believe in forced apologies.

BUT what kind of person would accidentally open a child's email and NOT automatically apologise in the moment?? Obvious power issues and really concerning subsequent behaviour. Agree with the suggestions for action above. Horrendous situation.

CocoC · 23/11/2023 16:55

Definitely a meeting with the teacher and the head. The incident awhile back is neither here nor there : the student has moved on and is working perfectly acceptably and teacher has no grounds to single her out and bully her, and even less to exclude her from the class!
Let's see what justification she can give to the head teacher...!

LolaLouise · 23/11/2023 16:51

CocoC · 23/11/2023 16:24

I don't think the teacher needed to grovel for something that was clearly an accident - and perhaps she felt the information shared wasn't that serious in the grand scheme of things?
I would have thought a quick' oh sorry about that' when shutting down the email would have sufficed... I may be wrong but sounds like your daughter expected something more grovelling, which may be OTT.

Anyway, it's equally clear that the teacher cannot bar a student from the classroom on spurious grounds, if the child is up to standard, delivering the work etc - this could impact her entire life, if it is a subject she needs to study later. So I would definitely have a meeting with the head and the teacher to try and clear the air and resolve the situation. It's always better to study in class than out of it. You may have an MSc but it doesn't mean you know the GCSE curriculum, or what exactly the teachers are looking for in particular answers on this topic. If you take her out, I would at least get a tutor who is very up to speed on this to teach her. (you can supplement and help with the revision).

When it happened my daughter immediately left the classroom upset. It was then a half term or bank holiday or something, so there was a few days when they weren't in school. On return from what i can gather my daughter spoke to the teacher and said it had upset her as she didnt want every one knowing her private information, the teacher replied "these things happen" or along those lines, this then made my daughter dig her heals in. The email was regarding a medical diagnosis my daughter received on the same day a close relative passed away, and that she may be a little bit more sensitive than normal and that she was allowed to leave lessons should she get overwhelmed, neither was information she wanted a class to know. At no point has she offered even a basic apology for it. Which is why i have no said to my daughter sometimes we just have to move on and accept that we wont get the result we want, and that not engaging in the lesson or doing the work is only going to affect her now she is at GCSE stage, and she has to put the effort into the subject. She has tried since September, but it seems the teacher has now labelled her and treats her with contempt.

OP posts:
PokeyLaFarge · 23/11/2023 16:51

G.D.P.R!!!!

I'd be playing merry hell about this op

What the hell are teacher e mails doing on a whiteboard?

What are the schools filtering and monitoring procedures?

(Ofsted is very hot on this atm)

Your dd is being bullied by this adult.

Time to get the Board of Govs involved

Mariposista · 23/11/2023 16:47

The teacher was wrong not to apologise but I would be very interested to see what attitude your daughter displayed when she asked for the apology. Was she gobby? Stroppy? Drawing a lot of attention to herself?
If she kept her head down and said politely 'Miss, I am really not happy that the whole class saw that', she is in the clear and the teacher is wrong. If she showed herself up throwing her weight around, believe me, teacher have zero patience with that. She is a teenager, not an equal.

Newtonianmechanics · 23/11/2023 16:46

Not the point of the thread but why did the teacher have private emails about your daughter?

Primproperpenny · 23/11/2023 16:41

If your account of events is factual and correct, the teacher should not be teaching. It sounds like she has singled your child out to be bullied, after she inadvertently (or on purpose?) breached GDPR guidelines to show her entire class an email containing personal information.

I would be going to the head and governors. Failing that, I would contact the LEA and Ofsted. The teacher is clearly failing against a number of the teaching standards. However, I would have also acted sooner and not allowed my child to be bullied like this. If the behavior points and detentions are all actually over the top, you have clear evidence that this teacher has carried out a sustained campaign of bullying against your child.

Baffledandalarmed · 23/11/2023 16:40

TBH I am amazed you didn’t make a formal complaint at the time the teacher opened that email.

Sorry but I don’t think that was an accident - teachers are taught the importance of confidentiality on these sorts of things and what she did WAS unforgivable. She should have said sorry and the fact she didn’t was disgusting. It’s the fact she refused to admit fault that makes me think it was deliberate.

YANBU and your daughter shouldn’t have to suffer through being taught by such a thoroughly unpleasant individual

JaniceJanice · 23/11/2023 16:39

Conkersinautumn · 23/11/2023 15:43

If its the entire class then your daughter is not being singled out and no, the school won't enter a student for an exam if they're not sitting lessons. But a teacher that won't ever apologise or own their mistakes is never going to be a decent role model.

@LolaLouise can enter her for the exam, pay the exam fee and tutor her herself.

The school could be petty and refuse to allow her to physically sit the exam at school but they can’t stop her sitting it at any other exam centre.

MrsMarzetti · 23/11/2023 16:34

You should never have allowed this to get this far. Demand a meeting with the Head and take it from there.

Saz12 · 23/11/2023 16:31

What reasoning has the teacher given? Because if Pupil A gets good grades, works hard, and wants to do the subject, theres got to be a strong justification to remove her from that subject - it wont be "I dont like her" from the teacher.

IMO you need to arrange a meeting with this teacher and HOY. Specific examples of whats been happening in class and what has been done about it up until now. Constant interruptions etc hamper others learning, even if DD is doing ok, so it may be that DD needs to be told to quit the eye-rolling grumpiness, poibtless questions, nitpicking etc. Or it could be that the teacher is the nitpicking one!

davidcameronsshed · 23/11/2023 16:31

I don't think the teacher needed to grovel for something that was clearly an accident - and perhaps she felt the information shared wasn't that serious in the grand scheme of things?
I would have thought a quick' oh sorry about that' when shutting down the email would have sufficed... I may be wrong but sounds like your daughter expected something more grovelling, which may be OTT.

Blimey, I hope you don't work with young people! They are very vulnerable and being humiliated in front of their peers will be a massively big deal, accident or not. A decent teacher (person) would accept responsibility and apologise wholeheartedly and sincerely for the error.

Nicole1111 · 23/11/2023 16:28

Have you approached the school governors?

CocoC · 23/11/2023 16:24

I don't think the teacher needed to grovel for something that was clearly an accident - and perhaps she felt the information shared wasn't that serious in the grand scheme of things?
I would have thought a quick' oh sorry about that' when shutting down the email would have sufficed... I may be wrong but sounds like your daughter expected something more grovelling, which may be OTT.

Anyway, it's equally clear that the teacher cannot bar a student from the classroom on spurious grounds, if the child is up to standard, delivering the work etc - this could impact her entire life, if it is a subject she needs to study later. So I would definitely have a meeting with the head and the teacher to try and clear the air and resolve the situation. It's always better to study in class than out of it. You may have an MSc but it doesn't mean you know the GCSE curriculum, or what exactly the teachers are looking for in particular answers on this topic. If you take her out, I would at least get a tutor who is very up to speed on this to teach her. (you can supplement and help with the revision).

GoingOffOnATangent · 23/11/2023 16:23

Wow!!
Teacher sounds ghastly and unprofessional.
Hitman? <constructive>
Solidarity, that's dreadful.

Schooldinner2 · 23/11/2023 16:22

Im sure they can as students can sit for languages etc.

One school has 1 child doing latin.
But they probably wont want to in this case as it would show the student did better than those having lessons.

Plus the teacher wouldnt be getting revenge by stopping the student studying it if they sit as an external candidate.
We had a slightly simiar situation where ds annoyed an out of school activity leader - minor things. But even though i told ds off he persisted. Ds ended up chucked out (and his brother wasnt allowed to do activity even though the leader didnt know him! )
DS1 one asd/adhd waitlist now and ironically this issue has actually helped a lot with that.

I can see why the teacher wouldnt apologise in that it obviously wouldnt have been intentional to show the email. And should have automatically apologised.
But alsio your dd probably cant see how easily stuff might happen if you have to share your laptop screen.

Nanny0gg · 23/11/2023 16:19

LolaLouise · 23/11/2023 15:42

Ive spoken to them alot regarding this issue, the short story is she is allowed to do as she choses as the teacher, as she has explained it was an accident, my daughter should just have accepted that. However i have always taught my children that even if you unintentionally hurt or upset someone, you should apologise. So my daughter felt very strongly she deserved an apology and stopped engaging with the teacher and subject as she is incredibly stubborn when she wants to be. However i can see she has put much more effort into it this year and has tried to move on from the email situation.

Then you need to raise it again as her behaviour is very unprofessional

TheFormidableMrsC · 23/11/2023 16:18

Rocksonabeach · 23/11/2023 16:16

You need a meeting with the Headteacher and teacher

This. I can't believe that hasn't happened. I couldn't stand by and watch my child be singled out this way day in and day out.

Rocksonabeach · 23/11/2023 16:16

You need a meeting with the Headteacher and teacher

noblegiraffe · 23/11/2023 16:13

Have you been in for a meeting with the teacher and perhaps head of dept or line manager to try to sort it out?

The problem with taking a kid out of a lesson is what does that kid do when they're meant to be in lessons? They can't be left unsupervised.

YireosDodeAver · 23/11/2023 15:58

Yanbu.

But you'll need to sort out the gcse entry independently (this is fine, and easy to do) - you can't expect the school to enter her for the GCSE when her success or otherwise aren't anything to do with them. But loads of independent candidates take gcses having self-taught, it won't be a problem.

Agree to her being removed from that lesson and insist that she is timetabled to spend those slots either in the library or in learning support rather than studying a different subject. You can teach her yourself at home and set her "homework" tasks to do at school in those slots.