Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask that my daughter be removed from a certain teachers lessons, but remain entered for a GCSE?

109 replies

LolaLouise · 23/11/2023 15:26

Not that im even sure that is possible?

My daughter has issues with a specific teacher at school. She is year 10 GCSE age. She has zero issues in any other lesson. She regularly gets the class award for most achievement points achieved that week, she got the house leader award for the half term, she is a student voice rep for her house, she has positive feedback, and is working at grade 7+ in every subject, including the lesson being discussed.

My daughter and this teacher had a "falling out" last school year when the teacher, accidentally, opened an email concerning my daughters private life onto the whiteboard for the whole class to see. My daughter was very upset and angry about this, and quite rightfully in my opinion, voiced this upset and asked that the teacher apologised. The teacher took the stance of "Im not apologising to a student" and for the remainder of the year my daughter did the bare minimum for this subject and work in lessons, and her homework was half arsed. This school year, after talking to my DD at length over summer about how sometimes you may feel you are owed an apology, but you wont always get it, sometimes you need to draw a line under events and start a fresh, my daughter tried just that. Her school book is very thorough, very neat, homework was taken seriously, and she is doing extra revision or pre reading as the focus of the lesson changes. However, the teacher has not done the same. She continues to pick my daughter up for anything, handing out detentions etc for minor situations, shouting and screaming at her (and the entire class by all accounts) for no reason. My daughter has come home in tears multiple times over how this teacher has treated her in the lesson. She posted negative feedback on the parent portal that is so unbelievably petty. The only negative behavioural points my daughter has had all school year are from this one teacher.

Despite this, as i said, my daughter does all her work in this subject, homework up to date, and high predicted grades. The teacher has now expressed she wants my daughter removed from this GCSE entirely subject (which i have been made aware of by the head of year) and placed on another she has no interest in at all, and is more vocational than academic, and also doesnt lead into what she wants to do at A level unlike this subject. I have stated categorically that my daughter is not to be removed from this subject against her wishes, when her grades are good, if they cant provide an alternative teacher - ill tutor her myself as it is a subject area i have an MSc in already. It is clear to me the relationship between her and this teacher is beyond repair, if it is causing this much upset for my daughter, and the teacher if she is requesting my daughter is removed from the course, surely having her remain entered, but privately tutored is a workable solution?

OP posts:
bellocchild · 23/11/2023 18:08

This is unprofessional. Formal complaint to head and then governors?

Nowherenew · 23/11/2023 18:00

and for the remainder of the year my daughter did the bare minimum for this subject and work in lessons, and her homework was half arsed.

Perhaps the teacher feels it’s too little, too late to catch up on the work she’s missed.

Is this a subject your DD actually wants to do?

Unfortunately it seems your only options are to carry on with this teacher or change options.

I would discuss with DD what she wants to do.

The opening the email was awful but sometimes technology can mess up and it would have been a complete accident.

If I was DD and I really wanted to do the subject, then I would carry on with it and just tell you if she thinks the teacher is treating her unfairly and you log it with the school every time.

EvilElsa · 23/11/2023 17:59

I had a teacher like that when I was at secondary in the 90s.
We fell out when she accused me of talking in form group -it absolutely wasn't me at all, and this was backed up by other people in the class but she really had a go at me. In my face shouting and calling me a liar. I saw red and told her (although I did not shout) that she was wrong and being rude.
After that she was out to get me at every opportunity. Luckily she was only my form tutor and I didn't have actual lessons with her but she made me life as difficult as she could manage. Accused me of inappropriate behaviour with a boy in an art room (we were both working separately on projects during lunch on tables completely the other side of the room to each other and barely knew each other) and then my mum had had enough and came into school and told her in a meeting to pack it in basically. She never spoke to me again, even during register.
Mrs Borton, if you are still out there, fuck you. I'm not the "mess" you said I was going to be-far from it actually.
I'm glad you are sticking up for your DD OP. There must be some way to negotiate this so she can do her exams.

SurelySmartie · 23/11/2023 17:53

It’s unfortunate and neither the teacher nor your daughter seem to be able to let it go. Worth having the meeting suggested and try to get a resolution one more time. Are you sure the teacher didn’t just say ‘oh sorry’ at the time and dd didn’t hear because she was upset? It’s very bad discourteous behaviour from a teacher if not. I don’t know why the head is happy with it.

OneTC · 23/11/2023 17:49

I wasn't allowed to attend lessons with a certain teacher but could still do the exam (and i passed)

PattyDukeAstin · 23/11/2023 17:47

How do you know your daughter is telling the truth? I think you must have doubts about this and her general behaviour. Why didn't you escalate the problem earlier and resolve it to everyone's satisfaction?

Soontobe60 · 23/11/2023 17:46

LolaLouise · 23/11/2023 17:24

I fully agree it was accidental, and probably easily done, but it was left up long enough for the class to read enough of the contents of the email to know what was happening.

I personally think that now, an apology for it would be worthless, too much time has passed and it would no longer be sincere. My daughter has also accepted that. This incident though is the catalyst to everything that has happened since, which is why i have mentioned it. Now the bigger issue is the relationship between my DD and the teacher is beyond repair, so its a case of looking for a solution as to how my DD can sit exams for the subjects she wants to sit only, and have a positive experience in these final years of school.

I totally understand that, but she has 2 choices. Stick with the lessons in order to get her GCSE or change subjects. There isn’t a choice to not attend lessons for a subject but still take the exam.
Im not sure if I’ve missed it, but when did this all happen?

Newtonianmechanics · 23/11/2023 17:44

Boomboom22 · 23/11/2023 17:43

If she can't go to student support can she sit in the back of a other subject and work quietly, with a teacher she gels with.

This is what my dd does or goes to a support room or even into the library.

Boomboom22 · 23/11/2023 17:43

If she can't go to student support can she sit in the back of a other subject and work quietly, with a teacher she gels with.

Justwondering36 · 23/11/2023 17:43

I think the reasoning is an important factor in how you deal with this going forward. If they try and say she’s not managing academically you’ll have more of an argument to get them to support her take the exam without in-school lessons. If they acknowledge the relationship breakdown is the issue then I think the onus is on them to provide the time for her to study and enter her into the exam.

Boomboom22 · 23/11/2023 17:42

It's extremely normal for all teachers of a student to receive an email like this so no idea what the pp is on about. Why else do parents contact the school to let them know if not for all of the teachers to be aware. I regularly get emails like this.
The teacher is presumably young and I'm very surprised she wasn't made to apologise by the hof or hoy and that she didn't immediately apologise.
I think double check with the hoy and exams officer as the teacher will confirm exam entries so as long as the exams officer and head ok it the teacher has no control over exam entries than confirming her class list.

Switchingoff · 23/11/2023 17:42

Ask for a meeting with head of year / house / whoever as others have said and take a factual chronological outline of what has happened (including number of behaviour points Vs other teachers etc). You should probably admit that your daughter wasn’t exactly a model student after it happened but that this year is different and she is being treated unfairly. Take her books to the meeting too and try to keep emotion out of it. Would classmates be willing to back her up?

Withnailandsigh · 23/11/2023 17:41

I don’t know how the structure is these days, but when I did my GCSE’s I missed most of the last two years and managed A’s and AB’s by self teaching using the text books and assignments. I then went hard on the revision just before the exams. If I could do that , I can’t see why your child couldn’t manage it with your support if you have a masters in that subject. Will the school allow it? Well, that’s the big question isn’t it? I bet they won’t want to, it’ll worry them that it’ll start a trend is my guess.

LolaLouise · 23/11/2023 17:39

Justwondering36 · 23/11/2023 17:35

Sorry if I missed it but what reason has the teacher given for wanting to remove your child? Presumably she can’t say she doesn’t want to teach her anymore.

I have asked for this but I'm yet to be given a reason. The message i got off the head of year when discussing how to progress after the last lesson when she came home in tears as she had be blamed for something another student had done and sent out of the class was "Mrs X feels it would be best for DD to withdraw from the subject and take Y subject instead".

OP posts:
Justwondering36 · 23/11/2023 17:35

Sorry if I missed it but what reason has the teacher given for wanting to remove your child? Presumably she can’t say she doesn’t want to teach her anymore.

Newtonianmechanics · 23/11/2023 17:35

My daughter had droppings 3 GCSEs die to mental health. She goes to several different rooms or even suts in another lesson working at the back on her Maths. They should be able to accommodate this.

LolaLouise · 23/11/2023 17:33

PattyDukeAstin · 23/11/2023 17:22

How did the teacher have this information and why did she open it when projected on the whiteboard? - is she her form teacher? This type of information would not be circulated in school emails and the email would need to be opened in class for everyone to see. Yes you are being unreasonable. Firstly because this happening is very unlikely. Secondly tell your daughter to concentrate on her GCSE, in class with everyone, whether the teacher is 'shouty' or not. Finally if this did all happen as your daughter describes then you are unreasonable for not sorting it sooner.

The email was sent to all individual class teachers stating what i have said, i dont know how it was worded, only that it contained enough information for students to ask my daughter about it, and that her relative had passed away. She opened it on the laptop that was connected to the whiteboard, it was mid lesson, so im guessing a powerpoint had been up or something and the teacher forgot her laptop was connected whilst the class was working and was checking her emails? I dont know the ins and outs, but i dont doubt it was a genuine mistake. Its how she has dealt with it afterwards that is the issue. I also dont condone my daughter half-arsing the subject for the last 2 months of the last school year, but i can see now she is putting the effort into the subject and wants to succeed. But the teacher is treating her as if she is still half-arsing and singling her out for punishments.

OP posts:
LolaLouise · 23/11/2023 17:24

Soontobe60 · 23/11/2023 17:17

I presumed this was an email sent TO the DD about the issues and why she should be allowed to leave the class - the teacher received it in class and inadvertently opened it whilst her laptop was connected to the whiteboard.

TBH, I can easily see that happening. But, I’m amazed that anyone even read the contents! It must have been left open as opposed to a quick flash before realising what had happened.
Perhaps (and this is not to excuse the teacher) the teacher thought your DD was over reacting if she only had the email up for a matter of seconds. Obviously the DD would have known about the contents, as it was about her, but the rest of the class not so much. The teacher may well have said sorry at the time, but as your DD was upset and left the room she may not have heard it. That’s the only reason why I can see the teacher hasn’t been disciplined about this, but then again if she had, you wouldn’t be told that information because, ironically, it’s confidential.

I fully agree it was accidental, and probably easily done, but it was left up long enough for the class to read enough of the contents of the email to know what was happening.

I personally think that now, an apology for it would be worthless, too much time has passed and it would no longer be sincere. My daughter has also accepted that. This incident though is the catalyst to everything that has happened since, which is why i have mentioned it. Now the bigger issue is the relationship between my DD and the teacher is beyond repair, so its a case of looking for a solution as to how my DD can sit exams for the subjects she wants to sit only, and have a positive experience in these final years of school.

OP posts:
Djimm · 23/11/2023 17:23

The sticking point is what they do with her during that lesson time if she does not do the other subject. Some schools can accommodate, some can't.

Definitely have the meeting but think what alternatives there might be. If any lessons are at the beginning or end of the day she might be able to arrive late or leave early. The problem is if she's on school property she needs to be supervised. It could be as simple as staying in the back of the other classroom, possibly with headphones, doing her own work, or if there's a desk outside a HoY's office she could go there.

In your position I think it would be worth the disruption for her to sit the GCSE elsewhere privately. It'll be two half days of your life and you'd be protecting her from dealing with this teacher around the exam itself.

I think you can make progress for your daughter's sake by escalating, but sitting the GCSE in school is not the hill to die on.

PattyDukeAstin · 23/11/2023 17:22

How did the teacher have this information and why did she open it when projected on the whiteboard? - is she her form teacher? This type of information would not be circulated in school emails and the email would need to be opened in class for everyone to see. Yes you are being unreasonable. Firstly because this happening is very unlikely. Secondly tell your daughter to concentrate on her GCSE, in class with everyone, whether the teacher is 'shouty' or not. Finally if this did all happen as your daughter describes then you are unreasonable for not sorting it sooner.

Soontobe60 · 23/11/2023 17:17

Zebedee55 · 23/11/2023 17:09

I was wondering that. How did a teacher access a students email account?🤔

I presumed this was an email sent TO the DD about the issues and why she should be allowed to leave the class - the teacher received it in class and inadvertently opened it whilst her laptop was connected to the whiteboard.

TBH, I can easily see that happening. But, I’m amazed that anyone even read the contents! It must have been left open as opposed to a quick flash before realising what had happened.
Perhaps (and this is not to excuse the teacher) the teacher thought your DD was over reacting if she only had the email up for a matter of seconds. Obviously the DD would have known about the contents, as it was about her, but the rest of the class not so much. The teacher may well have said sorry at the time, but as your DD was upset and left the room she may not have heard it. That’s the only reason why I can see the teacher hasn’t been disciplined about this, but then again if she had, you wouldn’t be told that information because, ironically, it’s confidential.

LolaLouise · 23/11/2023 17:12

Zebedee55 · 23/11/2023 17:09

I was wondering that. How did a teacher access a students email account?🤔

It was about a medical diagnosis and a death in the family that had happened on the same day, the head of year or house had sent an email to class teacher explaining both these things had happened and that my daughter could maybe be feeling extra sensitive or upset and was allowed to leave the classes to go to the office if she felt overwhelmed. It wasnt her email as such, just an email regarding private information she didnt want sharing with everyone in the class at the time.

OP posts:
TheLightSideOfTheMoon · 23/11/2023 17:10

The school is massively in breach of GDPR.

The teacher needs to be investigated. Your child is being bullied.

You need to get everything in writing.

Zebedee55 · 23/11/2023 17:09

Newtonianmechanics · 23/11/2023 16:46

Not the point of the thread but why did the teacher have private emails about your daughter?

I was wondering that. How did a teacher access a students email account?🤔

LlynTegid · 23/11/2023 17:04

I agree it is a GDPR issue, and should be raised as such, along with what I see as victimisation given the subsequent responses by the teacher.

Start with the head and the board of governors, and also if it can be done, make it clear in writing the parental objection to any detention given by the said teacher. Also consider a complaint to the Information Commissioner about the GDPR issue.