Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask that my daughter be removed from a certain teachers lessons, but remain entered for a GCSE?

109 replies

LolaLouise · 23/11/2023 15:26

Not that im even sure that is possible?

My daughter has issues with a specific teacher at school. She is year 10 GCSE age. She has zero issues in any other lesson. She regularly gets the class award for most achievement points achieved that week, she got the house leader award for the half term, she is a student voice rep for her house, she has positive feedback, and is working at grade 7+ in every subject, including the lesson being discussed.

My daughter and this teacher had a "falling out" last school year when the teacher, accidentally, opened an email concerning my daughters private life onto the whiteboard for the whole class to see. My daughter was very upset and angry about this, and quite rightfully in my opinion, voiced this upset and asked that the teacher apologised. The teacher took the stance of "Im not apologising to a student" and for the remainder of the year my daughter did the bare minimum for this subject and work in lessons, and her homework was half arsed. This school year, after talking to my DD at length over summer about how sometimes you may feel you are owed an apology, but you wont always get it, sometimes you need to draw a line under events and start a fresh, my daughter tried just that. Her school book is very thorough, very neat, homework was taken seriously, and she is doing extra revision or pre reading as the focus of the lesson changes. However, the teacher has not done the same. She continues to pick my daughter up for anything, handing out detentions etc for minor situations, shouting and screaming at her (and the entire class by all accounts) for no reason. My daughter has come home in tears multiple times over how this teacher has treated her in the lesson. She posted negative feedback on the parent portal that is so unbelievably petty. The only negative behavioural points my daughter has had all school year are from this one teacher.

Despite this, as i said, my daughter does all her work in this subject, homework up to date, and high predicted grades. The teacher has now expressed she wants my daughter removed from this GCSE entirely subject (which i have been made aware of by the head of year) and placed on another she has no interest in at all, and is more vocational than academic, and also doesnt lead into what she wants to do at A level unlike this subject. I have stated categorically that my daughter is not to be removed from this subject against her wishes, when her grades are good, if they cant provide an alternative teacher - ill tutor her myself as it is a subject area i have an MSc in already. It is clear to me the relationship between her and this teacher is beyond repair, if it is causing this much upset for my daughter, and the teacher if she is requesting my daughter is removed from the course, surely having her remain entered, but privately tutored is a workable solution?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GuessItsANameChange · 24/11/2023 22:40

Direstraightsagain · 24/11/2023 20:52

It sounds like your daughter is at a really good school and is likely to do well.
She should have got an apology and didn’t
You only have one side of the story re what has happened since the mistake
Good grades don’t always go hand in hand with good behaviours.
Reporting the school for GDPR breach is questionable. I’d imagine putting the school through that process is self sabotage for your daughter and the good of the school. GDPR covers this but isn’t really meant for this scenario: more identity theft, financial crime etc.
reporting a teacher for inadvertently putting up a personal email is taking it quite far. And I don’t think you’ll get what you need to live on:
id make a complaint to the school to get a formal response: if the teacher was being unreasonable then I’d be surprised if the head of year would support the teacher so perhaps there are some poor behaviours going on you’re not aware of. A complaint will get to the bottom of this. And then if you’re not happy to can go to the LA

Based on the OP’s most recent post even another teacher and the Head of Year think the problem teacher is being unreasonable in at least some instances.

Its never prudent to go in all guns blazing on the assumption that everything related, by a parent to a child, is accurate but let’s be real - the teacher sounds like an enormous, entitled arsehole and a vindictive bully who is bad at their job. The OP, on the other hand, is being extremely reasonable.

Direstraightsagain · 24/11/2023 20:52

It sounds like your daughter is at a really good school and is likely to do well.
She should have got an apology and didn’t
You only have one side of the story re what has happened since the mistake
Good grades don’t always go hand in hand with good behaviours.
Reporting the school for GDPR breach is questionable. I’d imagine putting the school through that process is self sabotage for your daughter and the good of the school. GDPR covers this but isn’t really meant for this scenario: more identity theft, financial crime etc.
reporting a teacher for inadvertently putting up a personal email is taking it quite far. And I don’t think you’ll get what you need to live on:
id make a complaint to the school to get a formal response: if the teacher was being unreasonable then I’d be surprised if the head of year would support the teacher so perhaps there are some poor behaviours going on you’re not aware of. A complaint will get to the bottom of this. And then if you’re not happy to can go to the LA

Cosyblankets · 24/11/2023 15:33

You need a joint meeting with the teacher, your daughter, head of year or head of pastoral.
If you think her doing private study will be enough then insist that they enter her at the school. Yes you can be a private candidate but it's up to you to find a centre. They may not accept get because she then becomes part of their statistics in the league table and they don't know anything about her only that things were so bad she was removed from the lesson. Is the timetable done for next year yet? What if there is travel involved because there's, say this subject in the morning and maths in the afternoon?
She needs to sit the exam in her own school

LatteLady · 24/11/2023 15:24

And, for good measure, ask for a copy of their GDPR policy... as I would consider her accidental showing of the information, a breach.

LatteLady · 24/11/2023 15:22

OK, I am writing this in my capacity as a Chair of Governors and as such, when you have your meeting next week, you ask for a copy of the complaints policy. You have engaged with the teacher and their line mgr and therefore the complaint goes to the HT. Your complaint no longer centres on the lack of apology but on the behaviour of the staff member. No teacher, and yes their may be exceptions with regard to physical violence, gets to pick and chose who is in their set to teach. However you are a bit of a dream, as far as school complaints are concerned because you not only have the complaint but you also have a viable solution.

If the HT does not uphold your complaint and you do not agree with the reasoning, you have the option to then and only then refer it to a GB panel for investigation... and yes, you can appeal that to, but only on grounds of lack of due process. I hope that this is helpful.

LolaLouise · 24/11/2023 15:12

donquixotedelamancha · 24/11/2023 14:37

@LolaLouise Could you clarify what exactly makes you think this teacher is picking on your child? They are applying the behaviour policy and giving detentions- are you saying those incidents are made up?

You say this relationship can't be repaired but you haven't said why. Have you met with the teacher, your daughter and a senior teacher? Do you punish your daughter when she disrupts the class?

You talk a lot about this one incident last year- I think you need to focus on fixing the specific problems now. If your daughter is harming the education of others (whatever her reasons) it can't be allowed to continue.

It would be unusual to let a student opt out of lessons but still take a GCSE. The school would be quite within their rights to remove your daughter from the subject of she's persistently disruptive.

My DD is blamed for everything in class even if she wasnt involved, she has received multiple detentions, most recently, for saying "yo" to another student instead of yes when someone said her name, for kneeling on a chair, DD has a toilet pass for her medical condition, she was placed in detention for taking longer than 3 minutes when she had come on her period, flooded, and have to change her clothes and clean herself up, this was explained to the teacher and she insisted the detention still remained, there was another similar incodent when she was late to class as she was talking to another teacher after a lesson, the other teacher supported this that it wasnt my DD's fault she was late, but she was still given a detention. There was some other the head of year has now removed from her portal so the negative points no longer count. These have been backed up by friends of my DD who have agreed my DD is treated unfairly by the teacher. However i fully understand these are her friends so biased accounts also.

I have met and spoken with both this teacher and others repeatedly. My daughter is not disruptive, this has not been mentioned in any of the posts on the portal, nor in meetings. She argued she doesnt engage in the work. Whilst this was true last year, she did the work expected of her but to the minimal level, she didnt seek out additional learning if she didnt know a homework answer, and she stopped putting her hand up in class and contributing. She was not disruptive, or rude, or attitude filled though, thats just not my daughters personality. She is nerdy, into books and graphic novels, would spend a weekend watching anime or criminal minds etc, she quiet, reserved, but she has a strong sense of what is right and is stubborn and strong wiled when she wants to be. She has never been disrespectful to this teacher infront of a class, she just stopped trying and put in no extra effort. She now does, she makes her own revision cards and posters at home, she makes cornell notes for lessons after i taught her the method a while ago. She isnt an obnoxious loud personality. Shes never really been in trouble at school which is why this is upsetting her so much and affecting her when she gets home.

So no, i dont punish her for disrupting a class, because that isnt what she is doing.

I explained this incident seems to be the catalyst, prior to that where was no issues with this teacher, all parents meetings were positive about her attitude to learning and her natural ability in this subject. The only reason i can see for this is the teacher did not take kindly to being asked to apologise by a teenager. Its feels more like she is holding a grudge. And being the adult and person in power in this relationship, it also does fall on the teacher IMO to make some effort in repairing it, which she isnt showing any willingness to do, instead, she wants her out of the class (im guessing here, but i think it is because i have contacted the school regarding this numerous times, her solution to shutting me up is to no longer have my DD in her lesson, that is pure speculation however)

This also isnt me wanting to remove her from a lesson, the teacher has expressed this, i am asking if that happens, can i request that she stay entered into that subject, rather than be forced into another one, and i either help her learn the curriculum myself, or pay for private tutoring. A lot have said that maybe this is unreasonable, and i should consider entering her privately instead of asking the school to keep her entered, which is fair and i take that on board, and i will look into doing that.

OP posts:
NewShoes · 24/11/2023 14:48

Teacher here. Just to give my perspective, I would be disciplined for opening a confidential email about a student in front of other students, and I have no doubt that the Head would make me apologise to the student for doing so. Anything less is not acceptable, and as a parent I would be asking for a formal meeting to discuss, and if unresolved complaining to the governors.

donquixotedelamancha · 24/11/2023 14:37

@LolaLouise Could you clarify what exactly makes you think this teacher is picking on your child? They are applying the behaviour policy and giving detentions- are you saying those incidents are made up?

You say this relationship can't be repaired but you haven't said why. Have you met with the teacher, your daughter and a senior teacher? Do you punish your daughter when she disrupts the class?

You talk a lot about this one incident last year- I think you need to focus on fixing the specific problems now. If your daughter is harming the education of others (whatever her reasons) it can't be allowed to continue.

It would be unusual to let a student opt out of lessons but still take a GCSE. The school would be quite within their rights to remove your daughter from the subject of she's persistently disruptive.

VickyEadieofThigh · 24/11/2023 14:22

Headband · 24/11/2023 14:19

Same here

It wasn't the pupil's email account. RTFT.

Headband · 24/11/2023 14:19

Zebedee55 · 23/11/2023 17:09

I was wondering that. How did a teacher access a students email account?🤔

Same here

FrustratedCustom · 24/11/2023 14:14

Newbutoldfather · 24/11/2023 14:00

@FrustratedCustom ,

If you lack both the care not to display someone’s personal information on the whiteboard, or the social skills to apologise, I would suggest you shouldn’t be in teaching.

Mistakes happen. But a sincere and prompt apology can sort things out quickly.

Paperbagsaremine · 24/11/2023 14:12

It's a real shame that the school aren't providing leadership on this. If they sat down everyone and managed to repair the relationship - which is clearly at rock bottom now - THAT would be the most pro-education (and educational in itself) thing they could do.

A general problem I think is that a lot of teachers go from school to uni to school and aren't exposed to good professional and managerial behaviours that they can then emulate.
The carelessness with personal info, the distress caused, that merited a private apology that has not yet been forthcoming. And then the teacher failed to follow up on DD's change in work quality and address that by saying "we may have our differences but this work is for YOU not me." A good manager in one of the firms I worked in would have pulled people up on this sort of shit.

Tooshytoshine · 24/11/2023 14:10

This seems a very one eyed view of this situation.

The teacher made a mistake and your daughter held a grudge. You supported this grudge. Your daughter's work ethic and attitude deteriorated in this class. You supported this behaviour.

The teacher has to teach the whole class and not just your daughter, who I suspect is disrespectful and disrupts the learning of others in this subject so the teacher has asked that they be moved for the greater good of the class. The teacher will not be holding a grudge against your daughter. The teacher probably teaches over 150 kids per week and is not focussing upon your daughter.

The teacher has used the behaviour system, followed policy and tried to gain parental support but you support your daughter's misbehaviour and lack of effort in the subject.

This is main character syndrome and you are being massively unreasonable. You have created this situation and when you decided the teacher has been punished enough encouraged your daughter to work, then were surprised that the teacher didn't immediately rectify their 'bad' behaviour.

It's a lesson for your daughter - people's impression of you matters, especially if they are in a position of power and a valuable one for the workplace as my boss NEVER apologises to me but I don't throw a little baby tantrum and do shit work.

Newbutoldfather · 24/11/2023 14:00

@FrustratedCustom ,

If you lack both the care not to display someone’s personal information on the whiteboard, or the social skills to apologise, I would suggest you shouldn’t be in teaching.

FrustratedCustom · 24/11/2023 13:55

Being able to apologise is a social skill that not everyone has. People like my sibling.

I can’t imagine how the teacher wouldn’t instinctively apologise. There should then have been a quick meeting with all parties for a proper apology, explanation and that could have defused the situation. Instead it has now escalated.

if this happened to me as an NHS worker I would immediately apologise. The school head has not managed this properly. Very poor.

Icannoteven · 24/11/2023 13:26

Yanbu.

I was bullied by a cunty teacher at the same age so I know how stressful it can be and how much it can affect your grades. I went on being on track for an A* in my subject to getting a C.

Please consider also raising a formal grievance against the teacher. My mother did this for me (apparently we were not the first, she was already being dealt with u see school’s disciplinary process despite only working there a couple of months) and the teacher actually didn’t get her contract renewed the next year.

Newbutoldfather · 24/11/2023 12:57

This is a tricky one.

The teacher sounds horrendous. Yes, accidents do happen, although the teacher will have attended insets where this kind of GDPR risk will have been discussed and warned against.

However, doubling down after that and not offering your daughter a profuse apology (in private) is just not acceptable.

OTOH, you can’t ask to have your daughter opt out of a class. It sets an impossible precedent. Any pupil who has a problem with a teacher will be asking for the same.

So, you need to go through the formal complaints procedure. Talk to the head of year or head of pastoral and explain the outcome you want, which is a meaningful written apology from the school and a guarantee your daughter will be treated fairly from now on.

Mention GDPR breach, appeal to safeguarding governor and subject information access request.

Take this all the way until you get satisfaction,

GuessItsANameChange · 23/11/2023 23:22

FrasierReboot · 23/11/2023 22:48

Your daughter has openly admitted that she didn't do work in the lesson as she was annoyed at the teacher. Are you absolutely certain she isn't still misbehaving in the lesson and putting zero effort in?

Like some others have pointed out, you have only heard your daughters version of events.

Your daughter has openly admitted that she didn't do work in the lesson as she was annoyed at the teacher.
No she didn’t - try re-reading.

Keepingittogetherstepbystep · 23/11/2023 23:20

So your daughter whilst having received 2 sad pieces of news, was then humiliated further by her teacher, then picked on instead if receiving an apology.
She's then decided to work hard despite the relationship with the teacher as the subject is key to her future plans and now the teacher wants her out due to what the teacher believes are misdemeanours. Why should this teacher have such power over your daughter future. It's aborant behaviour by a teacher. She's a teenager who's had some difficulties recently but has tried to buckle down (by the sounds of it). In the meeting its probably best to express your dismay that this is being allowed to happen.

Reminds me of my physics teacher, I was I the first year of gcse, he told me I could only do the lower paper which meant max grade C I said I either do the higher or none, he told me I'd fail. I got a C on the higher paper as he relented, but would have got a lower grade had I taken the lower paper. He still insisted despite having the result he didn't think I'd get a C

Teachers need to own their mistakes and do their best to not to penalise students due to perceived personality clashes.

Mulligan1789 · 23/11/2023 22:53

Ask the school if they reported the GDPR breach.

FrasierReboot · 23/11/2023 22:48

Your daughter has openly admitted that she didn't do work in the lesson as she was annoyed at the teacher. Are you absolutely certain she isn't still misbehaving in the lesson and putting zero effort in?

Like some others have pointed out, you have only heard your daughters version of events.

GuessItsANameChange · 23/11/2023 22:48

Really, the teacher should be replaced with one who can actually do her job. Your proposed solution is more than fair, OP.

moggerhanger · 23/11/2023 22:41

I'd be tempted to complain to the Information Commissioner, about a breach of your daughter's personal data that caused her alarm and distress...

BritneyBookClubPresident · 23/11/2023 22:32

Just one thought is how long is It realistic that you teach her this subject? Ie if the school agree she can use the class times as study time for the whole of the GSCE window you cannot surely continue this into A Level too?

Newuser75 · 23/11/2023 21:45

PattyDukeAstin · 23/11/2023 17:22

How did the teacher have this information and why did she open it when projected on the whiteboard? - is she her form teacher? This type of information would not be circulated in school emails and the email would need to be opened in class for everyone to see. Yes you are being unreasonable. Firstly because this happening is very unlikely. Secondly tell your daughter to concentrate on her GCSE, in class with everyone, whether the teacher is 'shouty' or not. Finally if this did all happen as your daughter describes then you are unreasonable for not sorting it sooner.

The exact same thing happened to my son.

I had emailed his form teacher about a medical issue my son was having at the time and he opened the email in the class and it appeared on the whiteboard. Several of my sons classmates saw the email.

Swipe left for the next trending thread