Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP doesn't help with baby costs?

387 replies

wibblewobblequack · 23/11/2023 15:25

Hi

I've been with my DP for 8 years. He has a 13 year old DD from a previous relationship and we have one DS together and he is 2. He wasn't planned not sure if it's relevant.

We live together, his DD is with us 5 nights in every 14. He has been split up from DSD mum since she was 2 and rightly has always paid maintenance.

My AIBU is we now have a child together. The house we live in is DP name. He has a much better paying job than me, over 100k and I earn 30k.

I pay half of all bills and for food shopping but DP won't let me pay towards mortgage.

I pay for DS childcare so I can work, I have not a lot left over. Things are very tight.

DP pays maintenance above CMS level to DSD, and DSD also attends private school at a cost of 2.5k a month roughly which DP pays for. DSD mum had a similar job to me and earns similar from what I understand.

I think it's great that he does this for his DD and that he's in a position to, when we first met I thought it was so much more attractive then a man trying to dodge paying for the child.

But I can't help but feel our DS isn't being treated the same as DSD. It now feels like he's trying to dodge paying anything for OUR child. DP doesn't give me even a penny towards any activities, clothing, nursery etc for DS.

He says that he puts a roof over our head and that's enough, and that it's fair?

I've asked about if in his head he's planning to do the same with private school in future for our DS but he's quite vague.

AIBU to feel like my DS is being treated unfairly?

OP posts:
ReadingSoManyThreads · 23/11/2023 21:26

You're going to get deeper into CC debt unless you make some changes right now. Stop paying half of all the bills and for all of the food shopping. Pay say 30% towards both. If he kicks off with his "I'm putting a roof over your heads", reply, "yes, but you also earn 5 times what I do and I cannot afford to pay half anymore, you're already refusing to pay any of the childcare fees for our joint child". If changing to 30% gives you the opportunity to both save and get your CC debt paid off, then great, but I would also be pushing for him to be paying for 50% of the childcare.

Him failing to financially support you during maternity and refusing to pay at least half of the childcare fees for his own child when he earns 5 times what you do is absolutely sickening. Put that together with him using your home to cocklodge whilst he paid off his flat, then buying a £500K home, almost having it paid off and refusing to put you on the deeds or mortgage, oh my goodness, he's a total cunt.

He's done a right number on you. You really need to leave and claim CMS. You'll be able to get a mortgage to buy a small 2 bed house up north. Do you have a family member who could help you with a deposit? Then pay them back when you're back on track financially?

As things are right now, if they don't change, you'll never be able to afford to leave and you'll get deeper and deeper into debt just covering the basics for your joint child. This will get worse and worse unless changes are made now.

Please please please make a stand now, and also ask family if they are able to help. He's financially abusing you. This is so wrong.

Dixiechickonhols · 23/11/2023 21:26

You are in a horribly vulnerable position Op. CAB has a decent guide marriage v cohabitation.
You need to work through scenarios inc if he dies or you split.
If he dies who has he left his house to? Who left death in service or pension to?
If you split tomorrow, you are homeless and no claim on his house, what is your plan to house yourself and your child? - be nice to him and hope he doesn’t meet someone else or get bored isn’t a plan.
Another poster on here used phrase men pay for assets, women pay for donkey work this is exactly what you are doing - he’s paying for his house, lots into his pension,. You are paying childcare and food and clothes for child.
You split in 16 years. You are almost 60 and homeless. Depleted pension as you’ve been primary carer. No child maintenance payable. You are almost 60 - lots of women find themselves in poverty in this scenario.
He’s got a stunning house all paid for, large pension, can afford to buy teen gifts and holidays.

MargotBamborough · 23/11/2023 21:25

Puzzledandpissedoff · 23/11/2023 21:22

... you can start by deducting half the cost of nursery from your share of the bills and backdating this to when your child first started nursery

OP already addressed this, Margot, apparently she feels this would be a trigger for him to chuck her out, which as I just said he could do at any time anyway

Well then she might as well pull that trigger.

Or continue to live like this forever, getting deeper and deeper into debt and never having any kind of financial independence.

One thing is for sure, reading these responses on Mumsnet isn't going to make the bastard suddenly play fair. He's got the OP right where he wants her and it's deliberate.

Doodar · 23/11/2023 21:23

OP, cut your losses, he will never change, a miserable existence for you and your child. he's only keeping you around to care for his first child.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 23/11/2023 21:22

... you can start by deducting half the cost of nursery from your share of the bills and backdating this to when your child first started nursery

OP already addressed this, Margot, apparently she feels this would be a trigger for him to chuck her out, which as I just said he could do at any time anyway

MargotBamborough · 23/11/2023 21:21

Oh and by the way, it would be better for your child to be from a "broken home" than live in one where his father is financially abusing his mother, which is what this is.

ToniTTtopaz · 23/11/2023 21:21

Well didn't he learn what not to do from his ex.

He's paying her, paying private school and managing this by letting you and your child live in poverty.

You need to speak up now. Multiple posters on this thread have agreed that he is wrong so when he turns round and says you need to feel bad you tell him no.

MargotBamborough · 23/11/2023 21:19

wibblewobblequack · 23/11/2023 20:01

Leaving him is easier said than done, we've been together a long time. It's not simple to just walk?

I came from a broken home and I don't want the same for my son.

I think I do love DP, I don't think he's fundamentally a bad person. I made this post more to ask how I can help him see that this isn't right.

I'm just not sure I could/want to leave.

I do agree that I'm very vulnerable trust me I feel it and I should never have let it get to this point.

Well then you can start by deducting half the cost of nursery from your share of the bills and backdating this to when your child first started nursery.

What exactly is his justification for not paying half the nursery costs but letting you pay for half the bills??

Goldbar · 23/11/2023 21:17

I don't pity you, OP, I am outraged on your behalf.

Men like this get away with it because they simultaneously both undervalue and refuse to take responsibility for "caring" work - childcare is not "real work" so they don't recognise it as a contribution or want to pay for it, but equally it's too inconvenient for them to do it either. Men like this exploit women's unpaid and caring labour. This work is not optional. It's not a choice on your part to do it - someone has to. He has manoeuvred you into being the default carer so that what is a choice for him is obligatory for you.

Unequal relationships like this are essentially a form of servitude for women.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 23/11/2023 21:12

I'm just not sure I could/want to leave

Putting it bluntly, OP, you may not have a choice; as things stand he could ask you to leave at any point, though of course he'd be liable for child maintenance

On that subject is he self employed? Because if so you may well struggle to get anything for DS even if he's made you homeless

arethereanyleftatall · 23/11/2023 21:11

What I'm wondering is - does he think your son isn't his?

MrsKeats · 23/11/2023 21:09

So he pays 2.5k for his daughter's school and nothing for his other child's care?
Never heard the like.
He's on 150k in the north and you feel poor?
Madness.

therealcookiemonster · 23/11/2023 21:08

wibblewobblequack · 23/11/2023 20:56

@arethereanyleftatall he's only about 5 years older than me. I'm almost 40.

No one said not to do it. When we got together I thought he seemed like a great man like I said he was going over and above for the daughter.

If we went on say a night out or for a meal, he'd mostly pay. If we went out for drinks with friends he'd be the one buying drinks for everyone. He never seemed tight.

I guess being honest with myself it would feel like I'd let my son down leaving the "nice" house. And I do wonder what people would think, if they'd pity me.

my mum stayed in her toxic marriage because she wanted us siblings to benefit from our fathers money. it turned her totally psycho and then she ended up ruining our lives by taking her anger out on us.

no nice house is worth this.

Nicole1111 · 23/11/2023 21:05

Have you sat down together and looked at your individual incomings and outgoings, so you can say look I am paying x % of what I get and you are paying x % of what you’re getting. Have you asked specifically why he won’t support his child’s development by helping financially?

Imperfectp3rf3ction · 23/11/2023 21:04

Your name needs to be on the deeds ASAP fuck him and his guilt trip.

Tell him you'll stop paying half the bills and in their place use this money for d.s amd food shops as these seem to be the issues.

Or sit there and do individual budgets show him and tell him that while he lives lavish you and your son cannot he may need a snap back to reality with lower earnings.

Any chance he resents the private school fees ?

therealcookiemonster · 23/11/2023 21:04

@wibblewobblequack "you think you love him" " he is fundamentally a good person" "you don't want to leave" "you don't want your son to be from a broken home" "he will kick you and baby out if you say anything"

let me clear some things up for you. he absolutely without doubt does NOT love you. you are useful and convenient. he is giving more money to his Ex in child maintainance than to you. and you know he can kick you out at anytime I.e. he does not give two shits about you, forget love. when the time comes, do you think he will think twice before dropping you in an instant for someone else? then you won't have a choice, you'll have to go...

I've read countless threads on here by women dumped after many years, with nothing to show for it. emotionally and physically drained by low level continuous abuse. they give just enough and hold back the abuse just enough so the women don't leave. you are in that situation.

he is not a good person. he is total fucking cunt. please get that through your head. there is a saying judge someone by how they treat those who depend on them and those at socioeconomical disadvantage to them.

if not for yourself, do it for your son. he probably already picks up that his sister is preferred, this will only get worse and eventually cause him lifelong issues (seen it in practice with my own eyes).

don't think about leaving yet. just open your eyes and see him for who he is. that's the first step.

Concannon88 · 23/11/2023 21:04

You've said you dont want to leave him and just want advice on how to make him see this isnt fair. Surely you know by now people dont change? Please please ask yourself if you want your son to turn out like him and if not then why is he a suitable option for you?

WowOK · 23/11/2023 21:04

wibblewobblequack · 23/11/2023 20:56

@arethereanyleftatall he's only about 5 years older than me. I'm almost 40.

No one said not to do it. When we got together I thought he seemed like a great man like I said he was going over and above for the daughter.

If we went on say a night out or for a meal, he'd mostly pay. If we went out for drinks with friends he'd be the one buying drinks for everyone. He never seemed tight.

I guess being honest with myself it would feel like I'd let my son down leaving the "nice" house. And I do wonder what people would think, if they'd pity me.

He is showing everyone how great he is and how generous he is. Its all about presenting an image. I wonder if he'd want you to talk openly about your financial situation. I'm sure he wouldn't want people to know that he doesn't pay any childcare.

Honesty, fuck the nice house. I'd prefer to live in a shoe box on my own with my DC than with a man who keeps me skint.

Dacadactyl · 23/11/2023 21:03

God!

How can you bear to look at him?!!!!

I would hold him in absolute contempt and have no respect for him whatsoever.

LEAVE THIS GIT

Concannon88 · 23/11/2023 21:02

No her cm payment would be 1224 per month. They dont take into consideration children who do not live with them.

arethereanyleftatall · 23/11/2023 21:02

'I guess being honest with myself it would feel like I'd let my son down leaving the "nice" house. And I do wonder what people would think, if they'd pity me.'

This is great op - the honesty. I think kids a bit older love 'their home' whatever that looks like, within reason! They certainly don't care at 2 years old. But if you had a cosy home half the size of your current one, he wouldn't give a shiny shit.

People pity you now, ok we're strangers, but this thread is pulling at many heart strings. People would think you were absolutely fucking awesome if you get away from this vile man, raise a child and get a masters.

Mycatmax · 23/11/2023 21:02

I would be distraught if my DD was living like this.

He sounds bloody awful.

Mindyaownbeeswax · 23/11/2023 21:02

He has no intention of marrying you - then you'd be entitled to 50% of everything he's worked so hard and sneakily to squirrel away for himself.

He has no intention of putting you on the deeds and INSISTS you don't contribute to the mortgage because then when you split up you have NO CLAIM whatsoever - despite all you have paid for, it's all his legally.

He has no intention of selling the flat ever because it's an asset he's making money from.

I can't believe you let him get away with not supporting you and HIS child through maternity and now. It's a joke!!

mugofstew · 23/11/2023 21:01

I pity you now OP profoundly.
Which doesn't mean I'm looking down on you or judging you, just that I'm very sorry you are in this situation.
Leaving and rebuilding your and your dc's life shows strength and resilience.

Goldbar · 23/11/2023 21:01

OP, this is not a partnership of any worth. You are with a man who views it as "your choice" to do enriching activities with your son and won't take him to them or contribute to the cost.

If as a family you were on the breadline, then maybe these activities would be an extravagance. But let's just put it in context... your son has a parent earning £150k plus and you're worried about how to pay for stuff like forest days, music classes, swimming etc.! This is absolutely ridiculous!! I am speechless. What sort of man earning the kind of salary he does doesn't think that some of that money should go to providing a range of activities and experiences for his child?

In essence you have totally different priorities - your priority is your son, his is himself.

The question is- what do you want to do about this? If you choose to stay, do you think things will get better?

If ultimately you find that you can't live like this and you can't accept this for your son, then there is a lot of help available (including on these boards) to help you begin to chart a way out of this to a happier life.